Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think my sister has little reason to be upset that Dad left everything to me?

1000 replies

GentleKhakiFox · 02/11/2026 11:34

My dad passed away at the end of last year, aged 102. He had a wonderful long life, and whilst obviously I miss him, I feel incredibly lucky to have had him for so long.

A bit of background. My mum passed away a few years ago, and I was very involved in looking after her. I have an older sister, who is in her 50s (I'm not 40 until next year), so there's a 15 year age gap between us. We also have different mothers. We're in touch occasionally but have never been particularly close but never any animosity, we did not grow up together and I suppose never had a sisterly bond. No ones fault really, maybe our parents aha but I do not blame her and I don't think she blames me.

When my mother passed away, my husband and I made the decision to move him into our home rather than put him into a care home. His house was rented by a family, so that it wasn't sitting there empty. He had more than enough money to fund private care, but I really didn't want him to spend his final years in a care home if we could manage things ourselves. It wasn't always easy, particularly but we managed. At the time I was working three days a week alongside caring for him. I've since gone back to four days a week, as our youngest is only three and I like having one day a week just for the two of us.
Looking back, I'm actually so glad we made that decision. The children got to spend so much time with their grandad, particularly before his health deteriorated. They won't remember all that much when they're older, which is a shame, but we have lots of photographs and memories to share with them.

My sister, on the other hand, was never particularly involved in Dad's life or his care. She lives alone and never offered to have him stay with her or help with his day to day care. In fact, I have text messages going back to 2018 where I've actively asked her to come and spend time with him, visit him and make an effort and her response was generally that she was too busy.
This is despite Dad having done a great deal for her over the years. He paid school fees for her children, helped her financially when her marriage broke down and even gave her a deposit towards a house after her marriage ended.

Anyway, Dad's will has now been dealt with, and he left everything to me. His house, investments, savings etc. He also made provision for his grandchildren, with money held in trusts for them. To give an idea of the sums involved, Dad had been investing since his 30s and one of his Hargreaves Lansdown investment accounts alone had over £2m in it. Obviously, this is invested money rather than cash sitting in a bank account, but you get the picture. There are other assets as well and everything has now been transferred into my name.
I won't pretend it's not a substantial inheritance. It is, and I'm incredibly grateful. It is also quite overwhelming to suddenly be responsible for managing everything.

However, my sister is now upset that she hasn't inherited anything, and I'm honestly not sure what to say to her. Part of me feels that Dad was perfectly entitled to leave his money to whoever he wanted. He knew both of us, he knew who had been there for him, and he made his decision. I didn't ask him to leave me everything, nor did I expect it.

I also feel that it's slightly unfair for her to be upset about not inheriting when she made so little effort to spend time with him, particularly towards the end, when he could have really done with some company and support.
I appreciate that inheritance isn't necessarily payment for caring for someone, and I didn't look after Dad because I expected to receive anything. I would have done exactly the same regardless.

But AIBU to feel that my sister has little grounds to be upset? Should I just leave her to feel how she feels or is there something I ought to say to her? She wants me to share 'half' I don't want to and its not as though I have grand plans for it, more so for my children albeit they have their own inheritance, you can never have too much. My husband and I aren't big spenders, we share the family car, etc. We paid off our mortgage before I even had the inheritance etc, we just know the value of money and have always made sure to plan ahead for our futures. We miss out on personal treats so that we can take our children abroad on holiday 3-4 times a year because we value that.
I don't want this to turn into a family argument, but equally I don't feel I should have to justify my dad's decisions.

Just a bit more information: Dad sorted out his will etc when he was 86, no new changes, this was done before he moved in with my husband and I. I have always spent time with my parents, even before all of this, I would visit my parents every week, at least once a week sometimes more depending on the occasion, help them with ordering this food shop etc, my sister and I both live within the same county, Surrey, much of a much distance from our parents. My husband and I moved out of London to surrey to be closer to my parents, my older sister has always live here. I am not saying she hasn't seen our father but she never really was interested in helping him out, maybe even taking them out for food etc, her children, in their mid to late 20s, would come to see him on their own accord, without her.

OP posts:
millymollymoomoo · 02/11/2026 11:52

I think you’re totally selfish to be honest.
but enjoy your millions and justify it how you see fit

PillsBox · 02/11/2026 11:52

Horrible thing to do to his daughter.

It's not her fault he split up with her mother and got your mother pregnant.

These things are rarely uncomplicated but this was a final kick in the teeth from him.

So if I were you I'd cut her some slack.

Pumpkinsaregrowingnicely · 02/11/2026 11:52

Ultimately your df's wishes outweigh dsis and her hurt feelings.

Tough shit imo..

IronicBonds · 02/11/2026 11:52

Probably Whatever you give will not be enough.
How much came through your mother's family? Did you inherit anything when she died or did it just pass to your dad?
How much did he give her for deposit etc and did he help you the same?

dairydebris · 02/11/2026 11:53

GentleKhakiFox · 02/11/2026 11:51

Yes her children have access to their inheritance now. There was a lot of things to sort out so it wasn't an immediate access, it has taken almost a year. They are very happy last I checked which was 2 or so weeks ago.

The texts were just an example. I do not think there was favouritism if we ignore the will, our father did try very hard, it would have been nice for my sister to offer to have dad live with her considering she lives on her own and works part time. He gave her enough to buy her house pretty much cash, her house is fully paid for.

The will shows clear favoritism.

You know if there's good reason for that.

Your sister knows too.

So it's your choice.

Octavia64 · 02/11/2026 11:53

If he’s also left specific money to all the grandchildren (yours and hers) I personally would consider that as leaving it to my “side” as it were.

so it’s a personal kick in the teeth to your half sister but her kids have inherited.

HowNowBrownCow33 · 02/11/2026 11:53

GentleKhakiFox · 02/11/2026 11:51

Yes her children have access to their inheritance now. There was a lot of things to sort out so it wasn't an immediate access, it has taken almost a year. They are very happy last I checked which was 2 or so weeks ago.

The texts were just an example. I do not think there was favouritism if we ignore the will, our father did try very hard, it would have been nice for my sister to offer to have dad live with her considering she lives on her own and works part time. He gave her enough to buy her house pretty much cash, her house is fully paid for.

But thats irrelevant as he'd already decided she wasnt inheriting before he moved in with you. And I dont think she needed to have him live with her, given he had more than enough to pay for care. Thats a huge sacrifice to expect someone to make, and whilst it was lovely you did it, I dont believe its something that should be expected of children

Hugasaurusrex · 02/11/2026 11:54

A family member left inheritance to his siblings and nieces and nephews. The estate was divided unevenly. I was happy to put what we got into the pot and divide evenly but other family members were not.

I don’t know money isn’t everything in life and wills create so many problems.

In your shoes I would definitely be giving your sister a share but I would expense out the care you provided which was an enormously generous thing for you to have done.

Sadvetatcrossroads · 02/11/2026 11:54

stripesandspotsanddots · 02/11/2026 11:49

So your sister's parents split up or her mum died, and then her dad remarried and had another family that she was barely involved in. And now her dad has left millions to her sister from his second family and nothing to her. That's hardly "little reason to be upset"!

Not saying you should do anything different to what you are doing, but surely you can understand what a difficult situation this must be for her. Imagine if you died/got divorced - how would your kids feel if your DH remarried and cut them out of his will?

This

millymollymoomoo · 02/11/2026 11:54

Basically a case of abandoning your first children in favour of your second family - all so often we see on here about deadbeat dads doing that / your dad was awful to do this! Your sister is justified in her upset - another kick in the teeth - and you are selfish for not even considering her feelings

Greenfinch7 · 02/11/2026 11:55

In the OP it is clear that dad paid for the sister's house and sister's kids' private schools. He has also left sister's kids substantial sums, enabling them to buy houses.

I think the father was close to OP and depended on her, and that is reflected in the will. It would have been nice if he clarified his thoughts and left the sister something meaningful in his will, but apparently he didn't.

GentleKhakiFox · 02/11/2026 11:55

My father never explained any of this to me. I was shocked, he never wanted to discuss his will with me or anyone only qualified professionals as he put it, so I had no idea till he passed. I knew I was going to be the executer and the trustee of his will but that was all, I didn't really know the ins and outs, I just thought it would be split equally and with his house, we would sell it and split but those were not the written instructions I received when I located the will

OP posts:
millymollymoomoo · 02/11/2026 11:56

Then share it with your sister …. Simple

OtterlyAstounding · 02/11/2026 11:56

What kind of man cuts one of his children entirely out of his will, leaving one literally millions and the other nothing, simply because she doesn't visit him as often? (Given the will was written twenty years ago, long before he needed care). Differing sums would perhaps be fair, but cutting one out altogether?

If this is real then he was a nasty prick, frankly.

Edit: I mean, could you imagine doing that to your own children, OP??

IwouldlikeanewTV · 02/11/2026 11:56

So your dad lived with your mum. Don’t you think that it was difficult for your sister seeing this and visiting your mums house? Sounds like she was excluded as soon as your dad met your mum. Hopefully she will challenge the will as it is more than enough to split between the grandchildren.

Banjas · 02/11/2026 11:57

kaparo · 02/11/2026 11:49

I don't know why you are posting here TBH. If you want to gift her something do it. If you don't, then don't.

Justifying not sharing a small part of it shows me that you are unsure, but want validation for being that stingy sister!

The vast majority of people would make some gesture to a sister from an inheritance of millions. So there you are.

I absolutely agree.
Was your sister the daughter of the first marriage ?
Did your Dad leave her Mum for yours ?
If so, could there be long term hurt there

because of this, which affected her relationship with her Dad ?
It seems very unjust not to have left her something.

TFImBackIn · 02/11/2026 11:57

So he gave her a lot of money while he was alive. Did he give you a similar sum at the same time?

IwouldlikeanewTV · 02/11/2026 11:57

Also your dad sounds bloody awful ignoring his grandchildren. I think you should share it. £2m is too much for one family.

kaparo · 02/11/2026 11:57

A deed of variation is not that complicated OP. If you want to give anything to your sister that is.

You strike me as desperate to justify keeping it all. So do that. Going into all the permutations of this and that achieve nothing if you are not willing.

Maybeitllneverhappen · 02/11/2026 11:57

I feel there is a lot more back story that we need before concluding anything. What were the circumstances of the first marriage breakdown?

PillsBox · 02/11/2026 11:59

millymollymoomoo · 02/11/2026 11:54

Basically a case of abandoning your first children in favour of your second family - all so often we see on here about deadbeat dads doing that / your dad was awful to do this! Your sister is justified in her upset - another kick in the teeth - and you are selfish for not even considering her feelings

This is exactly it.

A very familiar story that we read on MN all the time, where children get replaced by the new squeeze and subsequent children.

Arbourimage · 02/11/2026 11:59

It sounds like their relationship broke down long before any of this transpired. I imagine he didn’t foster his relationship with his daughter properly when he started a new family and had a new daughter.
I do think unless there’s a huge falling out over something very serious it’s always going to cause upset when you completely leave one of your children out of your will, your father must not have cared about how that would look for whatever reason.

mousehousey · 02/11/2026 11:59

I'm surprised by some of the replies on this thread. Makes me wonder about the kind of world we live in.

A man disinherits his daughter from his first marriage, before the care arrangements were never made? That's horrible behaviour IMO. She was his child, just as you were. Of course she has every right to be upset.

And IMO you should give her something, if you want to feel that you are behaving better than your father did. You've already stated you don't need all the money, so why wouldn't you? She is your sister?? People have become extremely selfish it seems, even within their own families.

Ethelspagetti · 02/11/2026 12:00

It’s okay for her to be upset and it’s also fine that he left money to you and not your sister. Your sister does benefit as in her children can now buy homes thanks to grandad. My dad has changed his will and left me the majority share of his house, because my siblings have seen him twice in 20 years and haven’t actually spoken to him in 2 years. He made a recording explaining why he’s giving me the most with the will writer, and it’s to be sent to the siblings upon his death. I don’t care if they’re upset, they don’t consider that our father is upset to never hear from them or see them.

Ionlymakejokestodistractmyself · 02/11/2026 12:00

stripesandspotsanddots · 02/11/2026 11:49

So your sister's parents split up or her mum died, and then her dad remarried and had another family that she was barely involved in. And now her dad has left millions to her sister from his second family and nothing to her. That's hardly "little reason to be upset"!

Not saying you should do anything different to what you are doing, but surely you can understand what a difficult situation this must be for her. Imagine if you died/got divorced - how would your kids feel if your DH remarried and cut them out of his will?

I think this is a great point. He by the sounds of it abandoned her and her mum for another woman and started a new family when she was a young teen, such a vulnerable time. She might still have been struggling with those feelings of abandonment. Yet she ensured her own children had a good relationship with him.

It feels pretty awful that he cut her out completely because she didn't visit as much, given he wrote the will before he even moved in with you. I feel this has more to do with who your mothers are.

Personally given how much it all is worth and you and your kids don't need the money, I'd give her a substantial amount (£250-500k) to help ensure she has enough to live on in old age as a divorced woman.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.