Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think my sister has little reason to be upset that Dad left everything to me?

1000 replies

GentleKhakiFox · 02/11/2026 11:34

My dad passed away at the end of last year, aged 102. He had a wonderful long life, and whilst obviously I miss him, I feel incredibly lucky to have had him for so long.

A bit of background. My mum passed away a few years ago, and I was very involved in looking after her. I have an older sister, who is in her 50s (I'm not 40 until next year), so there's a 15 year age gap between us. We also have different mothers. We're in touch occasionally but have never been particularly close but never any animosity, we did not grow up together and I suppose never had a sisterly bond. No ones fault really, maybe our parents aha but I do not blame her and I don't think she blames me.

When my mother passed away, my husband and I made the decision to move him into our home rather than put him into a care home. His house was rented by a family, so that it wasn't sitting there empty. He had more than enough money to fund private care, but I really didn't want him to spend his final years in a care home if we could manage things ourselves. It wasn't always easy, particularly but we managed. At the time I was working three days a week alongside caring for him. I've since gone back to four days a week, as our youngest is only three and I like having one day a week just for the two of us.
Looking back, I'm actually so glad we made that decision. The children got to spend so much time with their grandad, particularly before his health deteriorated. They won't remember all that much when they're older, which is a shame, but we have lots of photographs and memories to share with them.

My sister, on the other hand, was never particularly involved in Dad's life or his care. She lives alone and never offered to have him stay with her or help with his day to day care. In fact, I have text messages going back to 2018 where I've actively asked her to come and spend time with him, visit him and make an effort and her response was generally that she was too busy.
This is despite Dad having done a great deal for her over the years. He paid school fees for her children, helped her financially when her marriage broke down and even gave her a deposit towards a house after her marriage ended.

Anyway, Dad's will has now been dealt with, and he left everything to me. His house, investments, savings etc. He also made provision for his grandchildren, with money held in trusts for them. To give an idea of the sums involved, Dad had been investing since his 30s and one of his Hargreaves Lansdown investment accounts alone had over £2m in it. Obviously, this is invested money rather than cash sitting in a bank account, but you get the picture. There are other assets as well and everything has now been transferred into my name.
I won't pretend it's not a substantial inheritance. It is, and I'm incredibly grateful. It is also quite overwhelming to suddenly be responsible for managing everything.

However, my sister is now upset that she hasn't inherited anything, and I'm honestly not sure what to say to her. Part of me feels that Dad was perfectly entitled to leave his money to whoever he wanted. He knew both of us, he knew who had been there for him, and he made his decision. I didn't ask him to leave me everything, nor did I expect it.

I also feel that it's slightly unfair for her to be upset about not inheriting when she made so little effort to spend time with him, particularly towards the end, when he could have really done with some company and support.
I appreciate that inheritance isn't necessarily payment for caring for someone, and I didn't look after Dad because I expected to receive anything. I would have done exactly the same regardless.

But AIBU to feel that my sister has little grounds to be upset? Should I just leave her to feel how she feels or is there something I ought to say to her? She wants me to share 'half' I don't want to and its not as though I have grand plans for it, more so for my children albeit they have their own inheritance, you can never have too much. My husband and I aren't big spenders, we share the family car, etc. We paid off our mortgage before I even had the inheritance etc, we just know the value of money and have always made sure to plan ahead for our futures. We miss out on personal treats so that we can take our children abroad on holiday 3-4 times a year because we value that.
I don't want this to turn into a family argument, but equally I don't feel I should have to justify my dad's decisions.

Just a bit more information: Dad sorted out his will etc when he was 86, no new changes, this was done before he moved in with my husband and I. I have always spent time with my parents, even before all of this, I would visit my parents every week, at least once a week sometimes more depending on the occasion, help them with ordering this food shop etc, my sister and I both live within the same county, Surrey, much of a much distance from our parents. My husband and I moved out of London to surrey to be closer to my parents, my older sister has always live here. I am not saying she hasn't seen our father but she never really was interested in helping him out, maybe even taking them out for food etc, her children, in their mid to late 20s, would come to see him on their own accord, without her.

OP posts:
Jamlighter · 02/11/2026 16:54

@BermudaRhombus dad knew what he had done and had 20 years to change it, it doesn't matter whether its proportionate or not, its his money to do as he wishes. No-one is owed an inheritance.

Gall10 · 02/11/2026 16:55

FableAndFern · 02/11/2026 13:01

Yes. Very easily. In fact wills should be written in this way to avoid having to rewrite them every time a family member is born. Or to avoid unintentionally missing someone out.

E.g. '£25,000 to each of my grandchildren living at the time of my death'.

What if there isn’t £25k left…by the time the will is ‘read’ there might not be anything left in the estate?

FirmSnake · 02/11/2026 16:55

GentleKhakiFox · 02/11/2026 16:53

At the end of the day it’s his choice. She contested the will, they went back and forth with solicitors etc I wasn’t involved I was willing to listen to the law if the law required the assets to be shared equally after contesting I would have obliged but that’s not what the law says. The testator wrote the will and those were the requirements written under all the expected conditions.

Your dilemma was not whether or not you should share. It was whether or not she should be upset. You maintain that it came out of nowhere, she owed him nothing and he was liked by all. You were all shocked, but you think she shouldn't be upset?
What you mean is that you think she should stop talking about it because it makes you feel guilty.

GentleKhakiFox · 02/11/2026 16:56

I think people here think you’re owned an inheritance and that’s how the law works. It’s not, what’s written in the will is what the testator wanted and that’s what the law will go by. This was contested by my sister, I had no issues with that which is why it’s taken this long even her adult children were upset at how long things were taking. I am not in the legal field so I let them handle everything.

OP posts:
MrsBananaman · 02/11/2026 16:56

Could it be that your sister is set to inherit well from her mother, and so your father knew that felt it was his duty to leave everything to you, as you’re adopted?

Dontrinsemince · 02/11/2026 16:57

GentleKhakiFox · 02/11/2026 16:43

That’s why it has taken so long to sort everything out because she contested but my father was in the legal field he knew what words to use in his will and had assistance from others in the legal field. It was devised in laymen terms essentially what is his is his and he decides what to do. Legally you’re not just entitled to something because you’re related or it’s your mother or father that’s not how it works. A will is the written instruction and the executor has to follow what the will says and it was done when he was sound of mind. It’s not as though he wrote the will the day he passed.

He clearly knew what he was doing.
Posters here are making up scenarios to justify their points of view, but the only person who really knows why sister is excluded was Op's dad. Even Op doesn't know. One thing is clear, that is that he did not want to leave anything to Op's sister.
Here's why I think that Dad's wishes should be followed. I am the only person who knows that my friend's mum has left everything to him, excluding his older sister completely. Her mum confided in me once when we'd both had a bit too much to drink at my friend's wedding! Mum told me that my friend had always been a great support to her, never asked for anything, just got on with life. His sister was constantly complaining about lack of money. This ended up with her being given a house deposit, being bailed out of debt several times and having some missed mortgage payments paid - all by her parents. After their dad died their mum made a will leaving 100% of her estate and her house to my mate. She said his sister had been given quite enough already, and never been particularly appreciative. She knows everything will go postal when this comes to light, but there is a paragraph in the will explaining this, so the sister will not be able to contest the will. I suspect that situations like this are more common than we think.

BermudaRhombus · 02/11/2026 16:58

Jamlighter · 02/11/2026 16:54

@BermudaRhombus dad knew what he had done and had 20 years to change it, it doesn't matter whether its proportionate or not, its his money to do as he wishes. No-one is owed an inheritance.

Thank you. I’d like to think I wouldn’t be hurt in this situation, but I think I would. Especially if there was no explanation at all from my parents.

GentleKhakiFox · 02/11/2026 16:58

FirmSnake · 02/11/2026 16:55

Your dilemma was not whether or not you should share. It was whether or not she should be upset. You maintain that it came out of nowhere, she owed him nothing and he was liked by all. You were all shocked, but you think she shouldn't be upset?
What you mean is that you think she should stop talking about it because it makes you feel guilty.

I am still confused why is upset after she contested. Dad tired his hardest as I said even when he was alive he’d tell me to check in on my sister because she isn’t answering the phone. Then when she needed something she’d go see him or call him. She would never just call him just to see how he was doing. He always helped her when he could have said no it’s not as though he never gave her anything

OP posts:
SnowflakeSmasher86 · 02/11/2026 16:59

GentleKhakiFox · 02/11/2026 16:09

At least not at HL, there is a limit to how much you can withdraw, if you want to withdraw over a certain amount it has to be a written instruction, I also think its like a month because they have other people trying to withdraw too. Its not a simple process as you think, depends on the amount though. Maybe AJ bell is different but I think they are pretty similar in their processes

I imagine your sister would be happy to wait a month to receive her half of her fathers estate don’t worry.

BermudaRhombus · 02/11/2026 16:59

Dontrinsemince · 02/11/2026 16:57

He clearly knew what he was doing.
Posters here are making up scenarios to justify their points of view, but the only person who really knows why sister is excluded was Op's dad. Even Op doesn't know. One thing is clear, that is that he did not want to leave anything to Op's sister.
Here's why I think that Dad's wishes should be followed. I am the only person who knows that my friend's mum has left everything to him, excluding his older sister completely. Her mum confided in me once when we'd both had a bit too much to drink at my friend's wedding! Mum told me that my friend had always been a great support to her, never asked for anything, just got on with life. His sister was constantly complaining about lack of money. This ended up with her being given a house deposit, being bailed out of debt several times and having some missed mortgage payments paid - all by her parents. After their dad died their mum made a will leaving 100% of her estate and her house to my mate. She said his sister had been given quite enough already, and never been particularly appreciative. She knows everything will go postal when this comes to light, but there is a paragraph in the will explaining this, so the sister will not be able to contest the will. I suspect that situations like this are more common than we think.

I think it’s preferable if there’s an explanation. In OPs case there is nothing, so no idea whether it’s an error (the balancing point) or intentional.

FirmSnake · 02/11/2026 17:00

GentleKhakiFox · 02/11/2026 16:58

I am still confused why is upset after she contested. Dad tired his hardest as I said even when he was alive he’d tell me to check in on my sister because she isn’t answering the phone. Then when she needed something she’d go see him or call him. She would never just call him just to see how he was doing. He always helped her when he could have said no it’s not as though he never gave her anything

You're not confused as to why she is upset. Why did you think her feelings would change after unsuccessfully contesting?
That is your perception of their relationship. She may feel differently. Either way he should have addressed it when he was alove rather than leaving you both with this mess.

GentleKhakiFox · 02/11/2026 17:01

BermudaRhombus · 02/11/2026 16:59

I think it’s preferable if there’s an explanation. In OPs case there is nothing, so no idea whether it’s an error (the balancing point) or intentional.

We thought it was an error first but turns out he’d thought everything out careful nothing in his will can be contested. He did plan that I will always wonder why I have tried to find out all I can think of is the fact that she never gave him the time of day. This didn’t just start just because he moved in with me it started a long time ago

OP posts:
ImNotAmOnlyFan · 02/11/2026 17:02

The only question you have to answer @GentleKhakiFox is if you would do this to your children, sit with your answer and then make it right for your sister

ReleaseTheDucksOfWar · 02/11/2026 17:03

You've got millions and she's got nothing?

Millions?

I think it's awful if you don't give her something, and I don't mean 5k.

Sure, she hasn't helped much with him and she got help in the past. But to leave nothing to her when your dad had literally millions is shitty, shitty behaviour.

80% to you, 20% to her, some sort of proportion would have been reasonable. To leave nothing is a curse on her, and curse on you.

You're acting in a horrendously selfish, self-righteous way and she's envious.

Your dad really messed up here and did badly by you both. I don't mean the money, I mean what he did to you both and your interactions.

BermudaRhombus · 02/11/2026 17:03

GentleKhakiFox · 02/11/2026 17:01

We thought it was an error first but turns out he’d thought everything out careful nothing in his will can be contested. He did plan that I will always wonder why I have tried to find out all I can think of is the fact that she never gave him the time of day. This didn’t just start just because he moved in with me it started a long time ago

You misunderstand. His error was in thinking the estate value would balance out (at least roughly) with the lifetime gifts to your sister. In the end you got vastly more which likely isn’t what he intended

Sealedbidswoes · 02/11/2026 17:04

GentleKhakiFox · 02/11/2026 16:51

I agree which is why I asked my sisters mum and she maintain a positive look on our father. She can’t have hated him that much considering she befriended my mother and they’d do stuff together all the time when I was growing up. They were all friends. As I said sometimes marriages don’t work out doesn’t mean there has to be a villain in every story albeit what my father has done with his will isn’t great but whilst he was alive he always helped my sister even she says that and regrets not seeing him more. He didn’t abandon her he tried she even says in hindsight looking back he was a great father to her. Unless she’s just lying but we spoke for hours and hours when our father passed not sure she’d lie but that’s her choice to I was willing to listen and share memories and look through photos laughing etc

It’s not your sister’s mum’s experience that matters here, it’s your sister’s. You are not close, so I wouldn’t necessarily expect her to confide anything to you even if you were to ask her outright, but you need to consider that you sister may have cause to resent your father for reasons that you can’t comprehend. The immediate aftermath of grief is hardly the moment when she is likely to open up about this.

MatronPomfrey · 02/11/2026 17:04

Maybe he considers the help he gave to buy her house and private school fees as her inheritance. I will receive more than my siblings when our parents die because they have had part of theirs in advance.

theresnolimits · 02/11/2026 17:04

blondeseaside · 02/11/2026 16:52

One other possibility, is that he had spent around £1m on the sister (house deposit and school fees), and at the time of writing his will in 2010, his investments were worth around the same sum. He probably never expected to live until 102, probably thought that he was near the end of life at age 86, and left the investments to Op, to even the score.

The hiccup being of course, that he lived another 16 years, and now that £1m has grown to £2m, possibly without him even realising....I mean, at 100 are we really thinking he is logging into Apps and checking investments?

In that case, I would say the onus is on the Op to ask her sister how much she's had so far (for deposit and school fees), take out the same sum for herself, and split the rest in half. It's not okay really to just say "Hard Cheese Sis".

I think this is exactly right. The stock market has had enormous growth over the last ten years and his investments have probably rocketed. When he made the will I expect the school fees and the house added up to a similar amount.

If he left all the grandchildren a similar amount, it doesn’t feel like favouritism. In addition, had he gone into a care home for the last 5/7 years of his life that could have run into £250,000 plus, so OP has protected those assets too.

DSis is looking at the will, not at the lifelong help she has had. Let’s remember Dad did not leave her and the fact that ex wife has remained close suggests he didn’t abandon her. OP has won out, DSis has lost out. That happens in life sometimes.

fivepastmidnight · 02/11/2026 17:04

Maybe your father felt that your sister had her
'inheritance' whilst he was alive: A house/ private schooling for more than one child for several years as well as several cash payments and you are now receiving your inheritance after his death. It would have been good if perhaps he'd made that clear in his will. I however would point it out to her. What if he had split everything equally between the two of you? She's already had a house several £1000 worth of school fees, so it wouldn't have been equal, would it?

I think he could have left her something but said your sister gets the rest because of the fact that you've already had lots of money up front and she hasn't had anything.

Rtttoppp · 02/11/2026 17:04

GentleKhakiFox · 02/11/2026 16:39

My father did not explain anything to me I have said this many times on here. I was shocked too, both of us knew I would be the executor of his will that wasn’t a secret my sister and I both discussed that and were always under the assumptions we get equal amounts. My father did not discuss the will with either of us while he was alive he just said it’s sorted when I asked him if he’d written a will. When I first found got the news that I pretty much would be inheriting everything else minus the grandchildren,and my sisters mother I was shocked I even spoke to my sister mother and she was confused too. We don’t know what happened all we knew is when the will was written it’s not as though they’d fallen out or anything of that sort.

Oh, so you were shocked at the will? Why, then, do you not think your sister has any call to be upset?

BermudaRhombus · 02/11/2026 17:04

ImNotAmOnlyFan · 02/11/2026 17:02

The only question you have to answer @GentleKhakiFox is if you would do this to your children, sit with your answer and then make it right for your sister

She’s already said she absolutely wouldn’t!

GentleKhakiFox · 02/11/2026 17:04

ImNotAmOnlyFan · 02/11/2026 17:02

The only question you have to answer @GentleKhakiFox is if you would do this to your children, sit with your answer and then make it right for your sister

I’ve written my will and my children are equal. I’ve mentioned this a few times.

OP posts:
MrsBananaman · 02/11/2026 17:04

OP I don’t really think giving your sister part of your inheritance will actually make her feel any better now.
Surely being excluded from a will by your own father is a horrible feeling, and although she may be sore about the money, her kids have been looked after and any amount given by you won’t make that wound any better.
She’s not unreasonable to be upset and you’re not unreasonable to not give her anything.

BMW6 · 02/11/2026 17:05

Dontrinsemince · 02/11/2026 16:57

He clearly knew what he was doing.
Posters here are making up scenarios to justify their points of view, but the only person who really knows why sister is excluded was Op's dad. Even Op doesn't know. One thing is clear, that is that he did not want to leave anything to Op's sister.
Here's why I think that Dad's wishes should be followed. I am the only person who knows that my friend's mum has left everything to him, excluding his older sister completely. Her mum confided in me once when we'd both had a bit too much to drink at my friend's wedding! Mum told me that my friend had always been a great support to her, never asked for anything, just got on with life. His sister was constantly complaining about lack of money. This ended up with her being given a house deposit, being bailed out of debt several times and having some missed mortgage payments paid - all by her parents. After their dad died their mum made a will leaving 100% of her estate and her house to my mate. She said his sister had been given quite enough already, and never been particularly appreciative. She knows everything will go postal when this comes to light, but there is a paragraph in the will explaining this, so the sister will not be able to contest the will. I suspect that situations like this are more common than we think.

Your friend's Mum has done exactly the right thing by leaving a written explanation for her decisions in her Will.

I applaud her

Bogofftosomewherehot · 02/11/2026 17:06

IronicBonds · 02/11/2026 11:44

He also made provision for his grandchildren,
is that just your children or also her children?

I was wondering the samething

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.