Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think my sister has little reason to be upset that Dad left everything to me?

1000 replies

GentleKhakiFox · 02/11/2026 11:34

My dad passed away at the end of last year, aged 102. He had a wonderful long life, and whilst obviously I miss him, I feel incredibly lucky to have had him for so long.

A bit of background. My mum passed away a few years ago, and I was very involved in looking after her. I have an older sister, who is in her 50s (I'm not 40 until next year), so there's a 15 year age gap between us. We also have different mothers. We're in touch occasionally but have never been particularly close but never any animosity, we did not grow up together and I suppose never had a sisterly bond. No ones fault really, maybe our parents aha but I do not blame her and I don't think she blames me.

When my mother passed away, my husband and I made the decision to move him into our home rather than put him into a care home. His house was rented by a family, so that it wasn't sitting there empty. He had more than enough money to fund private care, but I really didn't want him to spend his final years in a care home if we could manage things ourselves. It wasn't always easy, particularly but we managed. At the time I was working three days a week alongside caring for him. I've since gone back to four days a week, as our youngest is only three and I like having one day a week just for the two of us.
Looking back, I'm actually so glad we made that decision. The children got to spend so much time with their grandad, particularly before his health deteriorated. They won't remember all that much when they're older, which is a shame, but we have lots of photographs and memories to share with them.

My sister, on the other hand, was never particularly involved in Dad's life or his care. She lives alone and never offered to have him stay with her or help with his day to day care. In fact, I have text messages going back to 2018 where I've actively asked her to come and spend time with him, visit him and make an effort and her response was generally that she was too busy.
This is despite Dad having done a great deal for her over the years. He paid school fees for her children, helped her financially when her marriage broke down and even gave her a deposit towards a house after her marriage ended.

Anyway, Dad's will has now been dealt with, and he left everything to me. His house, investments, savings etc. He also made provision for his grandchildren, with money held in trusts for them. To give an idea of the sums involved, Dad had been investing since his 30s and one of his Hargreaves Lansdown investment accounts alone had over £2m in it. Obviously, this is invested money rather than cash sitting in a bank account, but you get the picture. There are other assets as well and everything has now been transferred into my name.
I won't pretend it's not a substantial inheritance. It is, and I'm incredibly grateful. It is also quite overwhelming to suddenly be responsible for managing everything.

However, my sister is now upset that she hasn't inherited anything, and I'm honestly not sure what to say to her. Part of me feels that Dad was perfectly entitled to leave his money to whoever he wanted. He knew both of us, he knew who had been there for him, and he made his decision. I didn't ask him to leave me everything, nor did I expect it.

I also feel that it's slightly unfair for her to be upset about not inheriting when she made so little effort to spend time with him, particularly towards the end, when he could have really done with some company and support.
I appreciate that inheritance isn't necessarily payment for caring for someone, and I didn't look after Dad because I expected to receive anything. I would have done exactly the same regardless.

But AIBU to feel that my sister has little grounds to be upset? Should I just leave her to feel how she feels or is there something I ought to say to her? She wants me to share 'half' I don't want to and its not as though I have grand plans for it, more so for my children albeit they have their own inheritance, you can never have too much. My husband and I aren't big spenders, we share the family car, etc. We paid off our mortgage before I even had the inheritance etc, we just know the value of money and have always made sure to plan ahead for our futures. We miss out on personal treats so that we can take our children abroad on holiday 3-4 times a year because we value that.
I don't want this to turn into a family argument, but equally I don't feel I should have to justify my dad's decisions.

Just a bit more information: Dad sorted out his will etc when he was 86, no new changes, this was done before he moved in with my husband and I. I have always spent time with my parents, even before all of this, I would visit my parents every week, at least once a week sometimes more depending on the occasion, help them with ordering this food shop etc, my sister and I both live within the same county, Surrey, much of a much distance from our parents. My husband and I moved out of London to surrey to be closer to my parents, my older sister has always live here. I am not saying she hasn't seen our father but she never really was interested in helping him out, maybe even taking them out for food etc, her children, in their mid to late 20s, would come to see him on their own accord, without her.

OP posts:
Notanotherrestructure · 02/11/2026 13:02

It’s not as if the sister hadn’t had anything. She’s had school fees paid for her kids and a house practically paid for by the sound of it plus her own children have inherited. If you have inherited £2 million plus though, I’d be inclined to gift her £100k.

queenofthebongo · 02/11/2026 13:02

Maybe remind her about her house and then give her a token amount say 100k. It would make a huge difference to her and not much to you. She doesn’t know how much you have inherited.

FireEngine25 · 02/11/2026 13:02

Skippythemagnificent · 02/11/2026 12:51

When your mother died, did you inherit from her or did it all go to your dad?

It really sounds like he sees the money and assets as “theirs” - your mum’s and his, so he’s left it all to you. He didn’t see it as something for his first born because it was assets he held with his new wife, and should go to her child.

I cannot stress enough how common this is with men who have a new family. They cut out the first kids, create a new wealth of assets with the new wife and leave it all to the new kids.

It’s up to the new kids to make it right, if they have the morals.

Completely agree.

In my case, I am the first wife. I supported his career. I did ALL the childcare. He left when I was menopausal and traded me in for someone much younger. Naff. He's got a new family now with the younger woman. He's early 50s, stupid old fool. He has not been to one single parent-teacher meeting for my kids. He doesn't take them to any of their afterschool activities, not least because he chose to live just far away enough that it makes it not easily doable. He takes his toddler to nursery and their activities (according to my kids). No doubt he will go to parent teacher meetings with his new family, he's learned his mistakes from his time with me. His new children will reap the rewards of this. Mine on the other hand see him every other weekend, in a home that hasn't been made to feel like theirs, and his focus is on his new family. Mine don't much want to visit as the other woman makes them uncomfortable. I am sure this will lead to even more of a gap in their relationship as they get older (secondary school age now. My eldest is around the same age OP's sister was when OP was born. He HATES that his father has this second family. There are no holidays geared towards my children's ages as the new woman directs things to be geared at HER family's needs and the ex does nothing to make things better for my kids). It's only going to get worse. So if OP's father is anything like my children's father, I can see how his new kids might think he is a good father, whilst my kids' experience is vastly different, and they likely won't want to be wiping his arse when he's 96. And then he'll leave all his money to his younger kids for the final kick in the teeth.

Slightyamusedandsilly · 02/11/2026 13:03

I'd give her some money. Maybe not half, but some. You're not obliged to. And if you're as thoughtful a person as you've implied you are, you'd do it without thought.

Your choice though.

BermudaRhombus · 02/11/2026 13:03

Has OP confirmed if she received similar value gifts to her sister whilst their dad was alive? Because that kind of settles one of the issues

Gloriia · 02/11/2026 13:03

Limeandfigs · 02/11/2026 12:55

You're making quite a big assumption there that each account was worth millions. It's not uncommon for people to have one investment portfolio (worth lots) with much smaller cash accounts elsewhere

Whatever he had was clearly substantial. Much more than school fees and a house deposit that the eldest got.

The older dd may have had issues from her childhood as is often the case when parents go on to have more dc with other people.

The op graciously inviting her to spend time with the df may well have stuck in the older dd's craw. The Dad should been contacting her not his most recent wife's dc.

Witchyhoures · 02/11/2026 13:03

Also having written it so long ago its before your kids so much say x to all grand kids. But also potentially you were early 20s maybe still felt responsible for you. But also your mum since died too so he added her money or that went straight down to you. A tricky thing is if your mum did loads to help him have so much money whereas he felt the previous wife so kid already got whatever from divorce.

Perhaps its something decided with your mum beforehand

FireEngine25 · 02/11/2026 13:04

GentleKhakiFox · 02/11/2026 13:02

I don't think he lost that much intrest considering they were friends and my mother and my sister mum became good friends. Dad included my sister mum in the will. Sometimes marriages end doesn't mean he abandoned them considering it was her choice to end the marriage not his.

My ex tells people it was my choice to end the marriage. Like it gets him some sympathy and they can understand why he had to move on with a new woman. It was not.

MyGirlJ · 02/11/2026 13:04

It's not for us to judge what your Father wrote in his will. Ultimately, it's HIS last will and testament. Therefore, as executor, you need to respect and carry out his wishes. He would have had his reasons, and you may never fully understand what they were, but they were your Father's wishes.
I say this as someone who has been cut out of a grandparents will, when all of my cousins inherited.
Nobody is automatically entitled to anything in life. That may not seem fair, but it's the way of life.

Monty36 · 02/11/2026 13:05

I feel sorry for her.

Slightyamusedandsilly · 02/11/2026 13:05

Pretty sure this is just rage bait.

HowNowBrownCow33 · 02/11/2026 13:05

BermudaRhombus · 02/11/2026 13:03

Has OP confirmed if she received similar value gifts to her sister whilst their dad was alive? Because that kind of settles one of the issues

Given OP has steadfastly ignored this question and paid off her mortgage before 40 Im going to take a wild stab in the dark and say she has

LuckyHazelFox · 02/11/2026 13:05

GentleKhakiFox · 02/11/2026 13:02

I don't think he lost that much intrest considering they were friends and my mother and my sister mum became good friends. Dad included my sister mum in the will. Sometimes marriages end doesn't mean he abandoned them considering it was her choice to end the marriage not his.

Are you expecting her to challenge the will? Sorry if this has already been discussed.

BermudaRhombus · 02/11/2026 13:06

MyGirlJ · 02/11/2026 13:04

It's not for us to judge what your Father wrote in his will. Ultimately, it's HIS last will and testament. Therefore, as executor, you need to respect and carry out his wishes. He would have had his reasons, and you may never fully understand what they were, but they were your Father's wishes.
I say this as someone who has been cut out of a grandparents will, when all of my cousins inherited.
Nobody is automatically entitled to anything in life. That may not seem fair, but it's the way of life.

Nonsense, OP has agency and free will and can do what she pleases with the money. Hopefully that means sharing!

Toodarktooearly · 02/11/2026 13:06

It was a horrible thing for him to do but if it sits ok with you it sits ok with you

BermudaRhombus · 02/11/2026 13:07

HowNowBrownCow33 · 02/11/2026 13:05

Given OP has steadfastly ignored this question and paid off her mortgage before 40 Im going to take a wild stab in the dark and say she has

If so, that’s a major point in the question of what’s fair!

KaplanCarr · 02/11/2026 13:07

MrsJPBP · 02/11/2026 12:58

Legally you don’t owe your sister anything.

However, she will likely have had her reasons for not being involved in his care, or “only contacting him when she wants something”. As other posters have said, she will have had a very different father to the one you had.

I suspect my father might do this to me, as I very much keep him at arms length. He was horribly emotionally abusive to me, and even physically once when I was pregnant. I hate the man. However mercenary it is, he is well off and I do feel he “owes” me for the shit he put me through in my life. I won’t be taking care of him any time soon. Not saying that’s the issue here but I can see why your sister is upset and if it was me, I would share something with her (but probably not half). You can afford it. Your children are provided for. Otherwise you will likely lose that relationship too.

I’ve just posted and then read yours and I absolutely agree with everything you’ve written. This is what my dad will likely do, because I kept him at arms length for the same reasons as you and he can’t understand so that would be his final fuck off to me.

He’d talk about his will all the time and I’d be in it as the main one then I’d be removed etc… and he’d happily tell me that. I see now that it was him trying to manipulate and control me for his own gain. I stopped contacting him as he was so hard work, aggressive and really awful so I’m sure that’s what will happen. It will just prove my point that he was a narcissistic horror and I’ll be pleased I didn’t have anything to do with him. Good parents wouldn’t do that.

anyolddinosaur · 02/11/2026 13:08

You are very unreasonable to suggest that your half sister has little reason to be upset. He left money to an ex-wife, his grandchildren, to you - but left his other daughter out completely. If he had put in a comment that she had her inheritance early in the form of school fees for her children, help financially on divorce and a contribution to a house it would be more understandable. You've said different things about that house contribution so not clear if it was a deposit rather than buying her a house. You also carefully dont respond to questions about whether he helped you to buy a house big enough for you, your children and him to live in.

He left the money to you, you looked after him so prevented a fair part of the inheritance going in care fees. You have no obligation to split it and it's unlikely that anything you gave your half sister would be enough. But if you dont wish to give her anything the least you can do is acknowledge that he did a shitty things and she has every right to be upset.

Notonthestairs · 02/11/2026 13:09

GentleKhakiFox · 02/11/2026 13:02

I don't think he lost that much intrest considering they were friends and my mother and my sister mum became good friends. Dad included my sister mum in the will. Sometimes marriages end doesn't mean he abandoned them considering it was her choice to end the marriage not his.

The choice to end a marriage will happen for all sorts of reasons and doesn’t mean the party instigating the divorce is at fault.

How much did you receive?
How much did your sister receive?

Pipsquiggle · 02/11/2026 13:10

Urgh - it sounds really badly managed by your DF.

He really should have talked to both of you beforehand. I would feel annoyed if I was your DSis. It's like a big 'fuck you' from beyond the grave, although I can understand why your DF did what he did.

Why oh why couldn't he just added a sentence in the will saying something like:
DD1 I bought you a house and funded your DC through their education, I have also given you substantial sums of money when you have asked for it, therefore I have decided to distribute my estate like this .......

Would you be inclined to give her some money? e.g. £20k?

BermudaRhombus · 02/11/2026 13:11

Pipsquiggle · 02/11/2026 13:10

Urgh - it sounds really badly managed by your DF.

He really should have talked to both of you beforehand. I would feel annoyed if I was your DSis. It's like a big 'fuck you' from beyond the grave, although I can understand why your DF did what he did.

Why oh why couldn't he just added a sentence in the will saying something like:
DD1 I bought you a house and funded your DC through their education, I have also given you substantial sums of money when you have asked for it, therefore I have decided to distribute my estate like this .......

Would you be inclined to give her some money? e.g. £20k?

This changes completely if OP in fact received the same sort of assistance. Unfortunately OP isn’t willing to reveal this.

notspringingback · 02/11/2026 13:11

Are you really surprised that she is upset? She was totally excluded from his will with no prior conversation and even her Mum (his ex-wife who left him) received something? You can say what you like about the assistance he provided to her in life and her willingness to put herself out for him but of course she is upset.

Obviously you have done nothing wrong and I am not even saying you should give her anything but yes, you are absolutely unreasonable to think she has little reason to be upset about it.

Pipsquiggle · 02/11/2026 13:14

BermudaRhombus · 02/11/2026 13:11

This changes completely if OP in fact received the same sort of assistance. Unfortunately OP isn’t willing to reveal this.

@BermudaRhombus - yes you are right.

@GentleKhakiFox did your DF contribute / buy your house? Has he give you money for your DC's education?

This is really key.

Wildfairy · 02/11/2026 13:14

GentleKhakiFox · 02/11/2026 13:02

I don't think he lost that much intrest considering they were friends and my mother and my sister mum became good friends. Dad included my sister mum in the will. Sometimes marriages end doesn't mean he abandoned them considering it was her choice to end the marriage not his.

And yet he cut his child out his will and only her over 20 years ago and still you proclaim him to be a loving father,

look you don’t need to give her money, I suspect he knew you wouldn’t, you get to keep it congrats, enjoy, but stop pretending this man was father of the year to your sister,

GentleKhakiFox · 02/11/2026 13:15

There is a 6 year age gap between my parents. My mother was in her 50s when she met my father and no she was not the other woman, my sister's mother is actually younger and still alive. My mother passed away before my father but regardless he didn't just go out to find a 'younger wife' as some are assuming, not sure why? I was adopted as a baby, from a family member on my father's side who died during child birth. My mother was not able to have children even in her 20s so it all worked.

OP posts:
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.