Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that I should be the one buying my secretary presents, not the other way around?

30 replies

GravyFairy · 01/11/2026 19:50

I work in the public sector and I am fortunate to have had a brilliant secretary since changing to a new job last year. She is amazing and we get on great. As is standard everywhere I've worked before, I bought her a nice Christmas present last year as a thank you for her hard work and support and wrote a card saying the same.

She bought me one back, not just a token but quite expensive. I said thank you but you shouldn't have. She said, but you bought me one? And seemed confused.

The same thing happened for our birthdays (mine was first and she bought me a generous present, so I then bought an even more expensive one back for her, and she said she felt bad as I had spent more 😐).

I earn about 4 times as much as her and I feel terrible that she is spending her salary on buying me gifts. It is lovely of her, but bottom line, the present is supposed to be a thank you gift, not an exchange. I just don't know how to get this across without sounding like Lady Bountiful or hurting her feelings. But I fear another John Lewis voucher arms race is coming this Christmas if I don't say something.

OP posts:
GiveMeOodlesofPoodles · 01/11/2026 19:55

EA here. You're right.

I have always been the receiver of birthday/xmas gifts. Never the giver. It's just the unspoken dynamic.

But never ever perfume, flowers or jewellery. Those are items you buy for your wife not your PA. That's another unspoken dynamic.

LeopardOnEverything · 01/11/2026 19:56

If you're in the public sector just say there's a policy against it or it's not appropriate or something.

XenaSharples · 01/11/2026 20:02

If you spend more than she can afford you might be embarrassing her.

GravyFairy · 01/11/2026 20:02

GiveMeOodlesofPoodles · 01/11/2026 19:55

EA here. You're right.

I have always been the receiver of birthday/xmas gifts. Never the giver. It's just the unspoken dynamic.

But never ever perfume, flowers or jewellery. Those are items you buy for your wife not your PA. That's another unspoken dynamic.

Edited

Thank you. Yes that's exactly it, the unspoken dynamic. I'm not sure how to get the message across without speaking it!! I've never had to before as everyone just knew.

She knows there isn't a policy against it, she has worked there for a long time. If I say it's not appropriate she will ask why, if I'm giving her one? She isn't making a deliberate point, I think she is just a bit socially unaware.

OP posts:
GravyFairy · 01/11/2026 20:05

XenaSharples · 01/11/2026 20:02

If you spend more than she can afford you might be embarrassing her.

But that's the thing, she shouldn't be getting me anything in return. I have worked in this role for years, previously in a large department where there were a number of people in the same role. We all bought our secretaries a Christmas gift. They just said thank you, and possibly gave us a card in return. None of them ever bought a reciprocal gift.

OP posts:
SereneGoose · 01/11/2026 20:07

Could there be a different way of expressing gratitude and appreciation without an overt monetary attachment? I don't know what/how ...so not really really helpful but....hmm it's kind of a "good problem".. good luck x

Fieldday26 · 01/11/2026 20:09

EA here and generally that is the dynamic and I would never feel that I needed to buy something back but I’ve had a couple of execs that I genuinely felt like a friend to and have bought them gifts in return, especially for their special birthdays etc. I’ve never felt an expectation to do that or to spend a particular amount. I’m not sure you can address this without sounding like you think you are above her.

PurpleThistle7 · 01/11/2026 20:09

My boss gives me a gift and I get a gift for my team. It always flows ‘down’ like that. Last year my team clubbed together and got me a gift as well which was probably 1/3 what I spent on them and I was a bit embarrassed about it. I don’t want them spending their money on me - I make almost twice their average salary.

Wonderingmummy · 01/11/2026 20:09

“I just want to say, I know you usually get me a Christmas gift, but please don’t feel you need to this year. I buy you one for all your hard work you do in the year to show you how much I appreciate you - please don’t spend your money on me”

GiveMeOodlesofPoodles · 01/11/2026 20:10

Wonderingmummy · 01/11/2026 20:09

“I just want to say, I know you usually get me a Christmas gift, but please don’t feel you need to this year. I buy you one for all your hard work you do in the year to show you how much I appreciate you - please don’t spend your money on me”

This is perfect.

Bitzee · 01/11/2026 20:12

I know you say you earn 4 times as much as her but any chance she has a high earning DH and/or family money so it isn’t actually a big deal for her to spend however much it is to match the value of your gift? But I would agree with PP that an EA gift isn’t something that is normally reciprocated in that way…

Doctordoolittle · 01/11/2026 20:18

I buy gifts for my secretary - she is my friend too, but I would buy for her to say thank you even if she weren’t. She does buy back for me but it’s absolutely not something I would ever expect her to (she says she likes to).

Maybe she actually is a millionaire and does the job for fun 😂

GravyFairy · 01/11/2026 20:28

Thanks all, your replies have been really helpful and I appreciate you taking the time to reply.

@Wonderingmummy that wording is perfect and exactly what I was hoping someone could come up with - thank you!

@Fieldday26 yes that's what I'm afraid of, sounding like I think I'm above her which I absolutely do not. I just want to thank her as she works so hard. We are friendly and I know her circumstances, she is single and does not have masses of independent wealth. I hope she wins the lottery though as no-one deserves it more than her.

OP posts:
SylvanMoon · 01/11/2026 20:30

GravyFairy · 01/11/2026 20:05

But that's the thing, she shouldn't be getting me anything in return. I have worked in this role for years, previously in a large department where there were a number of people in the same role. We all bought our secretaries a Christmas gift. They just said thank you, and possibly gave us a card in return. None of them ever bought a reciprocal gift.

If she hasn't understood the social conventions within the organisation, perhaps one of the other secretaries could tell her rather than you?

Nonnegotiables · 01/11/2026 20:34

In most jobs where I have been the manager it has definitely been managers buying for team not vice versa but I did have one job where the team also bought for me. I think we had quite an equal vibe as we were often delivering work together. No one was overly extravagant and it was very kind tokens of appreciation at Christmas and birthdays. I think if your EA wants to buy for you it would be churlish to try and change that and might really impact your working relationship!

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 01/11/2026 20:57

Wonderingmummy · 01/11/2026 20:09

“I just want to say, I know you usually get me a Christmas gift, but please don’t feel you need to this year. I buy you one for all your hard work you do in the year to show you how much I appreciate you - please don’t spend your money on me”

I think this sounds good

chirrupybird · 01/11/2026 21:02

She's thinking of you as a friend, not a boss when buying presents, nothing you can do about it. Apart from saying thank you.

AttitudeAdjuster · 01/11/2026 21:16

Why does it matter though? Surely it's up to her who she gets a gift for. I think you'll damage your relationship by pulling rank like that. Sounds a really patronising place, I've never worked anywhere where you can't reciprocate a gift if someone's more senior than you. If you don't want her gift why don't you stop it by tell her you're not doing gifts anymore.

Bubblewrap100 · 01/11/2026 21:38

Wonderingmummy · 01/11/2026 20:09

“I just want to say, I know you usually get me a Christmas gift, but please don’t feel you need to this year. I buy you one for all your hard work you do in the year to show you how much I appreciate you - please don’t spend your money on me”

I’m an EA, this is good wording, though possibly leave off the last few words about the money.

It is generally one-way gifting in companies. My current manager though I sometimes get him a present too, as I regard him as a friend. I don’t feel obliged though, it’s just if I think of something he would like that year. He always pays for lunches and drinks though on the few occasions we go out, I wouldn’t be splitting the bill with him. Private sector.

Goldengirl123 · 02/11/2026 09:14

Just have a chat with her. Tell her that you buy her these gifts as you appreciate all of her hard work and you would really rather she didn’t buy you one back as that defeats the object

travailtotravel · 02/11/2026 09:55

Could you take them for lunch and say this is on me, my thank you and we should stop with the gifts and just get them a card for Xmas/Birthday or neutral token like biscuits fir the office or similar?

BoredZelda · 02/11/2026 10:05

Wonderingmummy · 01/11/2026 20:09

“I just want to say, I know you usually get me a Christmas gift, but please don’t feel you need to this year. I buy you one for all your hard work you do in the year to show you how much I appreciate you - please don’t spend your money on me”

No it isn’t. “Oh you poor, poor peasant, don’t spend money on me”

Giving a gift is giving an obligation. You can say “oh don’t get me anything” but when women have been socialised to return in kind for centuries, it makes no difference.

The right thing to do here (other than never having started this nonsense) is give a token gift, and if she wants to return in kind, she can. Her salary is her rewards for doing her job.

Eviebeans · 02/11/2026 10:09

I have been the person receiving the gift -usually cash in a card with a lovely message- and realised that there was no expectation of a gift in return

Dancingsquirrels · 02/11/2026 10:18

"bottom line, the present is supposed to be a thank you gift, not an exchange"

"she shouldn't be getting me anything in return"

But who are you to say that? Clearly that's not how she wants it to be. Perhaps she wants to feel that you're giving each other gifts out of friendship, or doesn't wish to receive more than she gives. And you should respect that, even if it's not your way of thinking

If you're uncomfortable about her feeling she should spend ££, perhaps you could suggest you agree to limit your gifts to a set amount

Ophy83 · 02/11/2026 12:50

Maybe she doesn't have many other people to buy for, or wants to show her appreciation to you for being a good boss, or simply enjoys giving gifts. You have already said there is no need to get a gift, so I wouldn't raise it again