Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dd to learn in an automatic from the start?

164 replies

makemineadecaf · 01/11/2026 11:46

Dd will be 17 next year and is already nagging me about lessons for her birthday. My husband and I both drive autos (but both drive manuals for donkeys before). Now I’m in an automatic, I’ll literally never go back. And isn’t it the sign of the times for manuals to become redundant?

OP posts:
Twogonksandapencil · 02/11/2026 09:37

OffTheMap · 01/11/2026 12:30

Hire cars in Europe are almost all manual, If you want to book an automatic for your holiday reserve one early and expect to pay more.

We have found this too. In our experience, which is mainly in Greece and Italy, the hire cars seem to be nearly all manuals. Whenever we have tried to book an automatic they rarely have one available, plus the automatics are always more expensive to hire. So I would say it's best to learn in a manual.

mugglewump · 02/11/2026 09:41

Car insurance is higher for drivers with only automatic licences, and at 17 insurance is going to be astronomical anyway. We both have automatics, but DS learned to drive in a manual. He just had lessons, no additional practice, and passed first time. Since passing his test, he has been driving my automatic, but is glad he learned on a manual.

Scarcityvarcity · 02/11/2026 09:58

mugglewump · 02/11/2026 09:41

Car insurance is higher for drivers with only automatic licences, and at 17 insurance is going to be astronomical anyway. We both have automatics, but DS learned to drive in a manual. He just had lessons, no additional practice, and passed first time. Since passing his test, he has been driving my automatic, but is glad he learned on a manual.

I am not sure that is true. I can only drive an automatic nowadays due to a left foot injury and my insurance cost is very low. I can't even remember being asked if I have an automatic or manual license

DoloresDelEriba · 02/11/2026 09:59

Jeschara · 01/11/2026 11:52

Learn in a Manuel. She can then drive both. She will be at a disadvantage if she learns only auto.

Olé!

HatethedarknightsQW · 02/11/2026 10:13

I learnt in a manual (a million years ago) I'd honestly learn in a manual if I was starting again - it's so handy for e.g. quickly borrowing a car - or swapping who is driving home from somewhere - or if someone has got tired on a long drive and you need to swap drivers. I don't understand why someone wouldn't learn in a manual. The number of times I've driven a mate's car (with insurance) as that's been the handy thing to do.

Also hire cars etc.

I've got an automatic car now and wouldn't buy a manual - but I'm really glad I know how to drive one.

fdsllp · 02/11/2026 10:22

Insurance for newly qualified teens is horrendously expensive and the cheapest option is for them to get an older second hand manual car with a small engine.

Learn in a manual!

sashh · 02/11/2026 10:42

One thing to consider is if she wants other licences in the future.

If she wants to drive an HGV a manual car licence is useful as it means she can learn in an auto LGV.

Or a motorbike, automatic bikes do exist but for now 80% are manual.

VanCleefArpels · 02/11/2026 10:48

Both mine have only ever driven automatic, no problems with insurance or renting cars on holiday (many renters have many more automatics available these days). More automatic cars purchased than manual fur the past few years. Manual will become the exception .

330ml · 02/11/2026 10:54

Offherrockingchair · 01/11/2026 12:17

There is no logic to learning to drive a car that is harder to drive. It’s totally unnecessary. No idea why people cling to the gears are better mantra. Look at the US. Autos everywhere, dirt cheap. No one looks down on them for not knowing how to use a clutch.

When I was in the US I seemed to receive a lot of kudos for being able to drive stick. As they called it.

Scarcityvarcity · 02/11/2026 11:26

sashh · 02/11/2026 10:42

One thing to consider is if she wants other licences in the future.

If she wants to drive an HGV a manual car licence is useful as it means she can learn in an auto LGV.

Or a motorbike, automatic bikes do exist but for now 80% are manual.

But given you need a separate license to drive an HGV then people can easily get a manual license at the same time.

Scarcityvarcity · 02/11/2026 11:27

330ml · 02/11/2026 10:54

When I was in the US I seemed to receive a lot of kudos for being able to drive stick. As they called it.

You would probably get kudos for being able to touch type on a typewriter too. Doesn't mean it is useful.

AltitudeCheck · 02/11/2026 11:34

Manual from the start. It's harder to convert from automatic to manual once you've learned to drive as you have to unlearn what you currently do and pay for lessons and a test all over again!

Being able to drive a manual gives her the most flexibility and independence.

Hiring cars overseas, removal vans, driving a works vehicle, borrowing a partners car in future... I can think of so many potential limitations if she can only drive automatic. Especially as a young woman, why stack the odds towards her being seen as less capable/ employable/ independent than her peers.

TaptheCap · 02/11/2026 12:08

I agree that most cars will auto very soon BUT hire cars are often manual and auto ones are more expensive to hire when they are available. Manual will also do her better if she wants to learn other types of vehicles.

Allmarbleslost · 02/11/2026 12:33

My DD is currently learning in a manual. I tried to sway her towards automatic mainly because my car is automatic and I thought it would be better for her to be able to get some practice in between lessons. Her thinking is that she'll be more able to buy an older affordable car if it's manual.

MigGril · 02/11/2026 12:37

Scarcityvarcity · 02/11/2026 11:27

You would probably get kudos for being able to touch type on a typewriter too. Doesn't mean it is useful.

That's an odd comparison because being able to touch type is still extremely useful when using a laptop or computer.

BoredZelda · 02/11/2026 12:52

OffTheMap · 01/11/2026 12:30

Hire cars in Europe are almost all manual, If you want to book an automatic for your holiday reserve one early and expect to pay more.

The most cursory of checks says this is rubbish. Marbella, pick up on the 5th November, availability - 114 automatic cars 59 manual. Both types pretty much the same price for the same sized car. Paris CDG, 290 automatic 141 manual. Same price for similar cars. Berlin 802 v 315.

BoredZelda · 02/11/2026 12:52

MigGril · 02/11/2026 12:37

That's an odd comparison because being able to touch type is still extremely useful when using a laptop or computer.

They are two very different machines though.

BoredZelda · 02/11/2026 12:56

AltitudeCheck · 02/11/2026 11:34

Manual from the start. It's harder to convert from automatic to manual once you've learned to drive as you have to unlearn what you currently do and pay for lessons and a test all over again!

Being able to drive a manual gives her the most flexibility and independence.

Hiring cars overseas, removal vans, driving a works vehicle, borrowing a partners car in future... I can think of so many potential limitations if she can only drive automatic. Especially as a young woman, why stack the odds towards her being seen as less capable/ employable/ independent than her peers.

It isn’t hard at all. People talk about learning in a manual takes a monumental effort. It doesn’t. It’s a bit of clutch control. The vast majority of learning to drive is vehicle position and handling, road awareness etc. The mechanics of changing gear is really minimal in the scheme of things. I switch between the two a lot and sure, every once in a while, I stall at the first roundabout I come to because I forgot I was in a manual, but once you are on your way it is not a problem.

TaptheCap · 02/11/2026 12:58

Scarcityvarcity · 02/11/2026 11:27

You would probably get kudos for being able to touch type on a typewriter too. Doesn't mean it is useful.

But driving a manual IS useful.

We recently needed to hire a car whilst ours was out of action. We did order an auto but when we arrived they didn't have one available and only had manuals. We needed the hire car. We could have spent time looking for other hire companies and extra money in Ubers to get to them or, we could take the compensation and drive the manual.

Last time we moved house, the removal van broke down on its way to us and they had to send a smaller one. They were very apologetic and paid for us to hire a van as well so we could move it in one lot - the only ones available at short notice were manual.

In Spain last year, we got to the hire desk, no autos available.

Day out with a friend who sprained her ankle on our walk - we were in her car, I drove it to the hospital - it was manual.

Some people can't drive manual due to physical limitations, I get that. But if you can, why would you limit yourself?

Maybe in 10 or 15 years, there will be no manual cars left, but we aren't there yet.

Scarcityvarcity · 02/11/2026 12:59

MigGril · 02/11/2026 12:37

That's an odd comparison because being able to touch type is still extremely useful when using a laptop or computer.

I don't think so. I can type as fast as I can think on a computer and spellcheck quickly sorts out errors. A couple of colleagues can Touch Type after doing RSA courses in the 80s and 90s and they aren't getting reports done any quicker because of it nowadays.

TaptheCap · 02/11/2026 13:00

BoredZelda · 02/11/2026 12:56

It isn’t hard at all. People talk about learning in a manual takes a monumental effort. It doesn’t. It’s a bit of clutch control. The vast majority of learning to drive is vehicle position and handling, road awareness etc. The mechanics of changing gear is really minimal in the scheme of things. I switch between the two a lot and sure, every once in a while, I stall at the first roundabout I come to because I forgot I was in a manual, but once you are on your way it is not a problem.

I think this poster means if DD learns and passes her test in an auto, it will be hard (time and money as well as the learning process) to redo it in a manual in the future.

Watchoutfortheslowaraf · 02/11/2026 13:03

I’d say she’s old enough to decide herself. When she rings around or messages different instructors she could ask their opinions/ what car they have etc and just let her book whichever one she feels is best for her. I really don’t think it’s parental choice.

Scarcityvarcity · 02/11/2026 13:03

TaptheCap · 02/11/2026 12:58

But driving a manual IS useful.

We recently needed to hire a car whilst ours was out of action. We did order an auto but when we arrived they didn't have one available and only had manuals. We needed the hire car. We could have spent time looking for other hire companies and extra money in Ubers to get to them or, we could take the compensation and drive the manual.

Last time we moved house, the removal van broke down on its way to us and they had to send a smaller one. They were very apologetic and paid for us to hire a van as well so we could move it in one lot - the only ones available at short notice were manual.

In Spain last year, we got to the hire desk, no autos available.

Day out with a friend who sprained her ankle on our walk - we were in her car, I drove it to the hospital - it was manual.

Some people can't drive manual due to physical limitations, I get that. But if you can, why would you limit yourself?

Maybe in 10 or 15 years, there will be no manual cars left, but we aren't there yet.

Strange how there are so many instances where being able to drive a manual has been so essential for you. There have been absolutely no inconveniences for me.

RingsLikeTinnitis · 02/11/2026 13:05

My 19yo learnt manual and has failed her test 3 times, in hindsight maybe auto would have been better for her. We have three younger daughters and I think they'll probably learn automatic because manuals are being phased out anyway. There won't be any disadvantage nowadays.

Scarcityvarcity · 02/11/2026 13:05

TaptheCap · 02/11/2026 13:00

I think this poster means if DD learns and passes her test in an auto, it will be hard (time and money as well as the learning process) to redo it in a manual in the future.

How do they know it will be hard though if they have never done it?