Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think influencers aren’t as happy as they seem?

83 replies

MildlyUnhingedMe · 31/10/2026 12:59

A page came up in my Instagram feed last night called “at home with Amy and H” I’ve never followed her or seen her page before. The video was of her replacing her entirely grey home, with beige things. She replaced her bed, flooring, kitchen, you name it.
I commented (albeit with clumsy wording) “more money than sense”
she then replied “lovely comment, unhinged” - so I replied saying I just meant a lot of the stuff looked in perfectly good condition, but I assumed she had gifted or sold things. And that Mrs Hinch has a lot to answer for (meaning she influenced a lot of the grey era)

she then went on to say I’m a very sad person, with a sad little life, her money is her own - a full on personal attack really. I apologised for my initial comment but said I just feel it’s very wasteful and the trend Mrs Hinch influenced caused a lot of people to probably do the same (and now with beige)

This woman’s page is full of holidays to Dubai, her lovely house, her ironing buisness etc - don’t you think if she was as happy as it seems she’d have spent her Friday arguing with a stranger?

OP posts:
ThatCyanCat · 31/10/2026 15:47

CaimanCrown · 31/10/2026 15:43

Just classic projection. She wouldn’t have left a comment like that on somebody’s instagram post unless she was trying to make them feel bad about themselves, so she assumed that’s what you were doing too, hence why she reacted saying that it was unhinged to want to say things like that to people.

What was your reason for your initial comment? I’m struggling to understand what your genuine intention was although I appreciate “to make her feel bad” probably wasn’t it.

Why would you tell someone that they are derivative with no sense, if you were not trying to make them feel bad?

CaimanCrown · 31/10/2026 15:49

ThatCyanCat · 31/10/2026 15:47

Why would you tell someone that they are derivative with no sense, if you were not trying to make them feel bad?

Well exactly, that’s why i asked the question! I genuinely want to know i’m not implying a subtext.

latetothefisting · 31/10/2026 15:52

don’t you think if she was as happy as it seems she’d have spent her Friday arguing with a stranger?

it's funny that you don't seem to see the irony here! I don't agree with either influencing in general or her design choices as you've described them, but at least she is getting something out of them - if she has quite a lot of followers, presumably her refit could be earning her a tidy package. Even if she doesn't at least she has a home she (presumably) likes, even if not to her taste. Even you commenting negatively on there actually helps her as it boosts engagement - most influencers would prefer one negative comment from a 'real' account (e.g. not a bot) than 100 likes because that's what advertisers/sponsors care about.

Whereas you are the one who are spending your friday night first commenting on her post, and then creating a whole thread out of it on a different social media platform. What actual benefit do you get from doing that? Isn't there literally anything more productive or enjoyable you could be doing with your time?

I don't think any influencers pretend their lives are 100% constant happiness, just that they only show you the good bits, and if the audience have half a brain they also understand that.

Carinissima · 31/10/2026 15:53

Apotofrealcoffee · 31/10/2026 14:11

I mean I’m not going to say there wasn’t slight provocation on your part, but actually, given the sheer toxicity of these ‘content creators’ and how little they add to the country other than extra landfillcore and making everyone else feel like a bag of shite, I’m not going to knock you down for it.

YANBU. Imagine actually selling your entire life - your home, your bedroom, your kids, your crying fits, your personal news, your highs and lows - on the internet for ‘content’. Anyone who does this is inherently narcissistic and nihilistic IMO. Nothing is sacred to them.

And the dripping sarcasm, passive aggression and outrage at one fairly innocuous comment proves it.

I love your comment. Exactly the way I feel about these but better articulated.

MildlyUnhingedMe · 31/10/2026 16:22

@BlueBlueBerriesIt was just my photo, name and year of birth - yes. I have changed it now.
did you see the original post on the thread?

OP posts:
Pallisers · 31/10/2026 16:26

Nobody on social media is as happy as they seem. It isn't real.

TorroFerney · 31/10/2026 16:27

MildlyUnhingedMe · 31/10/2026 13:09

@tomorrowfollowstoday true - lesson learnt! I still think it’s wasteful though. It’s just over consumption just to follow faddy trends to post on social media. When there are families who can’t even afford heating or a sofa.

I can understand your thinking but to be honest she was never going to say “yes you are right” . You did it because it felt good to berate her that’s how social media works of course it sends you things you like or things you hate, it just wants engagement. She gets money whether her views are positive or negative interactions. Social media gives us insights into lives that are very at odds with our own and it’s jarring.

Meadowfinch · 31/10/2026 16:28

Imagine spending your entire professional life worrying about what people think of you, because that is what pays your bills.

Tht's enough to make anyone miserable.

TorroFerney · 31/10/2026 16:29

ThatCyanCat · 31/10/2026 15:47

Why would you tell someone that they are derivative with no sense, if you were not trying to make them feel bad?

To make yourself feel good, it gives you a dopamine hit. You can’t make another person feel bad so it’s only ever for ourself. It’s like when we think of a witty retort or put down ten minutes too late , we are irritated we didn’t think of it in the moment as it would have made us feel good.

feaalo · 31/10/2026 16:32

if she was as happy as it seems she’d have spent her Friday arguing with a stranger?
it’s her essentially contributing to the success of her business, its engagement. You’re spending your weekend not just bitching on her page, but also mumsnet about her.

ThatCyanCat · 31/10/2026 16:33

TorroFerney · 31/10/2026 16:29

To make yourself feel good, it gives you a dopamine hit. You can’t make another person feel bad so it’s only ever for ourself. It’s like when we think of a witty retort or put down ten minutes too late , we are irritated we didn’t think of it in the moment as it would have made us feel good.

But if all OP needed for that dopamine hit of superiority was to feel superior, she wouldn't have left the rude message. She would just have seen the content, felt superior and been happy with that. The only reason to leave the message was to get the woman involved in the superior feeling, by making her feel inferior... something OP is continuing now by starting an all new thread about it elsewhere the next day trying to convince herself and us that this woman must be miserable really.

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · 31/10/2026 16:45

Thepeopleversuswork · 31/10/2026 15:35

In fairness I don’t think their lives are any worse than most of us on this front. Most people in most walks of life have to be approved by someone, whether it’s their boss, their customers or their partner.

I would hate to be an influencer but they have become this moral lightning rod for society at the moment and I think its a bit daft.

They are just people trying to make a living like the rest of us and there are positives and negatives to the way they earn a living. I suspect its quite stressful and insecure as a job, but I don’t particularly see it as some moral failing.

Exactly they are just playing a role to sell stuff. There are many jobs in life where people pretend to be happy all the time but act differently when they aren't being paid to smily. The shop assistant trying to sell you clothes doesn't actually care if you have had a nice day or not, they just say that stuff so that you buy stuff.

Influencing is just affiliate marketing dressed up a bit. The influencers know that.

TorroFerney · 01/11/2026 16:14

ThatCyanCat · 31/10/2026 16:33

But if all OP needed for that dopamine hit of superiority was to feel superior, she wouldn't have left the rude message. She would just have seen the content, felt superior and been happy with that. The only reason to leave the message was to get the woman involved in the superior feeling, by making her feel inferior... something OP is continuing now by starting an all new thread about it elsewhere the next day trying to convince herself and us that this woman must be miserable really.

Perhaps but you can’t actually make anyone feel anything so that’s a gamble. You get much more satisfaction saying a thing than thinking it! But yes I agree it’s a bit of both I feel good by trying to make you feel bad.

ThatCyanCat · 01/11/2026 17:03

TorroFerney · 01/11/2026 16:14

Perhaps but you can’t actually make anyone feel anything so that’s a gamble. You get much more satisfaction saying a thing than thinking it! But yes I agree it’s a bit of both I feel good by trying to make you feel bad.

Of course you can't make anyone feel something, but there's a clear intent. Why else would you say it?

I'd say perhaps OP would be satisfied by knowing she's needled the woman but she seems more needled herself.

RiskAssessments · 01/11/2026 17:28

I think I used to work with her about a million years ago! How funny.

ThatCyanCat · 01/11/2026 19:30

I'm bored so I just checked out the channel. Can't see anything that suggests she's claiming to be incredibly happy or perfect or whatever. It's a home improvement channel and she shares content about doing DIY and redecoration, which she clearly enjoys doing. Seems pretty inoffensive to me.

Was this a clever ploy to drive traffic?

XenaSharples · 01/11/2026 19:54

It's a very average house. Not worth commenting on.

greenmacchiato · 02/11/2026 05:33

Just because someone else can't afford something other people want and can have, doesn't mean they shouldn't have it. Following a short-living trend or not, people are allowed to make whatever renovations in their places and get rid of things they don't want or need however they see fit. I'd even say people might be quite happy with what they have even if the trend they are following is ugly.

If you post stuff online, however, you've got to remember there will be different opinions on what you're doing, so either suck it up or turn off commenting.
I think you were both in the wrong here, you for stopping by something you didn't like and her for attacking you for a harmless opinion.

Zanatdy · 02/11/2026 05:40

just looked at her page and seems she gives as good as she gets re what she deems as negative comments. She isn’t the only person having to replace the grey! It’s definitely had its day.

Mumtoabillion · 02/11/2026 06:37

Id probably have done the same as you OP. and be worrying about it later. I'm glad I mainly waste time here and don't have Instagram..Now I get the feeling it's a bit like this place. Try not to let it get to you.

DrWhosJazzyScarf · 02/11/2026 06:43

I actually think you’re the one in the wrong here. Why post something sniffy? Just move on and unfollow her.

Sartre · 02/11/2026 06:44

I’m not sure we can call him an influencer because he was obviously a big deal back in the day and I’ve always personally been a fan but I’ve been watching a lot of Michael Barrymore’s content lately. I find him really soothing to watch, even though he doesn’t do anything remotely exciting but I think that’s the point. Also always thought he was a decent bloke. Anyway, I get the overwhelming feeling he’s incredibly lonely. He gains a lot from the attention members of the public give him but lives alone with his dog and doesn’t seem to include friends or family in any of his videos, just random strangers who approach him.

I find it really sad in ways. I think lots of “influencers” are similar. Lonely, sad, not much going on.

ClaredeBear · 02/11/2026 06:49

TY78910 · 31/10/2026 14:03

Influencers monetise on making content. You’ve just attacked her for making such content. Weird.

And also provided more engagement. It often doesn’t matter whether engagement is “good” or “bad”, it all helps the algorithm.

butternutsquashed82 · 02/11/2026 06:51

I totally agree with you OP. There are some great down to earth influencers, but a lot of the lifestyle influencers are pushing over consuming. I also think the point you make about ‘aren’t as happy as they seem’ is totally valid. I much prefer the influencers who share a bit of their real life and when things aren’t rosy! Times are tough and it’s much easier to relate to these influencers! I also know a couple of lifestyle influencers personally and what you see online and the reality are two different things! And changing your grey house to beige is ridiculous - defo more money than sense! Saying that doesn’t make you ‘unhinged’!

butternutsquashed82 · 02/11/2026 06:53

@greenmacchiatobur it’s also totally unrealistic to change everything in your house all the time. We’ve got so used to over consuming, that people think it’s normal to change their interiors every year or so!

Swipe left for the next trending thread