Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think influencers aren’t as happy as they seem?

83 replies

MildlyUnhingedMe · 31/10/2026 12:59

A page came up in my Instagram feed last night called “at home with Amy and H” I’ve never followed her or seen her page before. The video was of her replacing her entirely grey home, with beige things. She replaced her bed, flooring, kitchen, you name it.
I commented (albeit with clumsy wording) “more money than sense”
she then replied “lovely comment, unhinged” - so I replied saying I just meant a lot of the stuff looked in perfectly good condition, but I assumed she had gifted or sold things. And that Mrs Hinch has a lot to answer for (meaning she influenced a lot of the grey era)

she then went on to say I’m a very sad person, with a sad little life, her money is her own - a full on personal attack really. I apologised for my initial comment but said I just feel it’s very wasteful and the trend Mrs Hinch influenced caused a lot of people to probably do the same (and now with beige)

This woman’s page is full of holidays to Dubai, her lovely house, her ironing buisness etc - don’t you think if she was as happy as it seems she’d have spent her Friday arguing with a stranger?

OP posts:
GrapeBaby · 31/10/2026 14:23

MildlyUnhingedMe · 31/10/2026 13:07

@ThatCyanCat True. I did apologise for my initial comment and explained what I meant but she continued with personal insults. You would think she would be more prepared for answers like that eg saying she does gift/sell things etc but she just carried on calling me sad 😅

But it’s not hard not to leave a bitchy comment on someone else’s generic Instagram about home decor.

Apotofrealcoffee · 31/10/2026 14:26

GrapeBaby · 31/10/2026 14:23

But it’s not hard not to leave a bitchy comment on someone else’s generic Instagram about home decor.

The entire world of ‘content creating’ is bitchy AF and relies on other people feeling inferior and following their accounts for more masochistic ‘inspiration’. Glass houses and stones come to mind!

chirrupybird · 31/10/2026 14:29

Laughing all the way to the bank, she has to keep her followers happy by interacting and defending herself.

2214todsy · 31/10/2026 14:30

Tbh they need the ‘bad’ comments as much as the good ones as it’s all ‘engagement’ and most of them need to show a high level of engagement to prospective employers - companies hiring them for ads etc.

WiddlinDiddlin · 31/10/2026 14:30

Probably but what was the point of your comment - would you have said that to her face? If not, why would you say it to her online.

You'd likely think my channel shows I have 'more money than sense' - as I often buy products to try them out and if you have zero interest in them, you'd see no value at all in what I do, nor have any of the relevant context (I buy products for me to try out, that I use for my work, so reviewing/testing for YT is secondary).

I see a few 'influencers/content creators' broadly in the same category as me, who spend thousands on mystery boxes and advent calendars, only to be frequently disappointed with the contents, (the other day someone opened a box from an advent calendar that contained ONE paperclip!)...

I would never make a rude comment though - if they're wasting money or making themselves miserable, that's for them to deal with and unasked for advice or comments have never in the history of humans, been known to actually help.

Also, you realise that commenting and then engaging in a comment-fight with her is just earning her more money... right? So she's getting paid to argue with you on insta... and you're wasting your time for free, who exactly is the fool here?

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · 31/10/2026 14:31

It's just a self employed marketing job now. Obviously they seem happy, people generally don't want to buy from miserable people. Just if the actress in a tooth paste advert looked miserable it wouldn't help sell the tooth paste.

There is no more ability to conclude whether the influencer is happy than you can conclude where the tooth paste sales actress is happy.

Lostmyself3 · 31/10/2026 14:32

The more interaction she has the more money she makes, doesn’t matter if that is positive or negative.

ThatCyanCat · 31/10/2026 14:32

Thepeopleversuswork · 31/10/2026 14:20

I don’t disagree: I don’t look at any of this shite.

But the OP could just have gone without and ignored it.

This is what this woman does, its her job ot hobby or hustle. If the OP was really as nauseated with the whole circus she could have just graciously scrolled on by or unfollowed.

Instead of which, she chose to be nasty about it.

You can’t have this both ways. If you truly believe this stuff is rubbish don’t look at it. If you participate you can’t really set yourself up in judgement. Just come off it and find something more interesting and constructive to do.

I don't see why people who find social media so morally contemptible use it or scroll it! "I am looking for content on social media and anyone who provides it is shallow and narcissistic and evil!"

Of course loads of content producers suck, just as loads of people used to use Facebook to boast, which is what these threads were all once about. Not new and not surprising. At the same time, if you hate it, the best thing to do is ignore it because engagement is what keeps stuff going - this isn't new or surprising either!

And anyway, as far as moral collapses go, you really could do a whole lot worse than posting pictures of your living room. One might even argue that scrolling through Insta for visual content, and then making moral judgements and rude comments when the free content provided doesn't please you, is worse...

Thepeopleversuswork · 31/10/2026 14:34

Apotofrealcoffee · 31/10/2026 14:22

Actually I’m glad some people are challenging this absolute shite. Content creation has an overall net negative on people, particularly women, with their unachievable houses and fillered lips. It’s not as ‘harmless’ as they make it out to be. It’s contributing to the buying of landfill tat, people feeling insecure about their looks and parenting.

Why should they get to make this easy money without a little bit of pushback sometimes?

But the OP isn’t challenging it! She’s feeding it!

Instagram influencers depend on “engagement” whether positive or negative.

If the OP had really wanted to challenge it she wouldn’t have been doomscrolling it in the first place. And she could have posted something critiquing the medium as opposed to being bitchy to one specific individual and speculating about whether she was happy.

Just don’t engage with it if you think its bullshit.

SharkyBait · 31/10/2026 14:38

This is why I’ve stopped using Instagram. The “influencers” made the whole app unbearable. And I don’t understand why they’re called “influencers” anyway as there isn’t an ounce of originality between them. They all promote the same things and jump on the same boring bandwagons. Boring people, with boring lives, pretending they’re something special.

Thepeopleversuswork · 31/10/2026 14:38

ThatCyanCat · 31/10/2026 14:32

I don't see why people who find social media so morally contemptible use it or scroll it! "I am looking for content on social media and anyone who provides it is shallow and narcissistic and evil!"

Of course loads of content producers suck, just as loads of people used to use Facebook to boast, which is what these threads were all once about. Not new and not surprising. At the same time, if you hate it, the best thing to do is ignore it because engagement is what keeps stuff going - this isn't new or surprising either!

And anyway, as far as moral collapses go, you really could do a whole lot worse than posting pictures of your living room. One might even argue that scrolling through Insta for visual content, and then making moral judgements and rude comments when the free content provided doesn't please you, is worse...

I mean I personally find most of it to be brainrottingly boring, self indulgent shite. But I also recognise that some people enjoy it and that others should be free to engage with it if they want to.

But you can’t set yourself up as some moral crusader against the evils of Instagram influencers if you’re scrolling through it and posting on it.

If you really hate it, take yourself off it and challenge it at a systemic level. Don’t just be a twat to one particular person doing it.

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · 31/10/2026 14:39

Apotofrealcoffee · 31/10/2026 14:22

Actually I’m glad some people are challenging this absolute shite. Content creation has an overall net negative on people, particularly women, with their unachievable houses and fillered lips. It’s not as ‘harmless’ as they make it out to be. It’s contributing to the buying of landfill tat, people feeling insecure about their looks and parenting.

Why should they get to make this easy money without a little bit of pushback sometimes?

I think that is nonsense - content creators today are no different from the glossy magazines of the past. There are just less gatekeepers in terms of whose fake "perfect" life is showcased.

PumpkinPrincessx · 31/10/2026 14:42

On you’re definitely not wrong with thinking influencers aren’t as happy as they appear online. Most people aren’t. We only show the world what we want them to see, not the dark times. Social media is fake.

However, if I saw someone commenting “more money than sense” to someone else I’d assume the commenter is quite bitter about their own life and probably jealous at someone else’s money or lifestyle.

So the pair of you don’t come across good. You and the influencer probably need to spend less time online and touch some grass.

Doeaddeer · 31/10/2026 14:43

They're all AI generated. YABU to engage with them.

ThatCyanCat · 31/10/2026 14:45

Thepeopleversuswork · 31/10/2026 14:38

I mean I personally find most of it to be brainrottingly boring, self indulgent shite. But I also recognise that some people enjoy it and that others should be free to engage with it if they want to.

But you can’t set yourself up as some moral crusader against the evils of Instagram influencers if you’re scrolling through it and posting on it.

If you really hate it, take yourself off it and challenge it at a systemic level. Don’t just be a twat to one particular person doing it.

Absolutely.

And anyway, being boring and unoriginal and derivative with bad taste in sofas, and sharing this with the world, isn't actually a moral failing.

user293948849167 · 31/10/2026 14:46

Of course they don’t have as perfect a life as they’d like you to believe, and I agree that this sounds ridiculous.
However I just don’t watch nonsense like that and you could argue that you should have not wasted your life watching her channel in the first place or arguing with a stranger on a Friday night

AddictedToBooks · 31/10/2026 15:05

We have an influencer living next door.
On her media, you'd think she's stunning looking and living in a luxury house and is always laughing and travelling abroad and eating healthily and hitting the gym.

In real life, although she IS very pretty, she cakes the makeup on so thickly that in real life, she's actually detracting from her natural good looks.
She doesn't have a job, she doesn't engage with ANYONE on the street or even open her door to couriers (she talks to them through Ring and makes them leave the package), she lives on takeaways and seems to lead a very lonely life - she has no partner, no friends or family visit her and no pets and she's practically indoors 24/7.
I only know this because I was forced to take retirement on ill health grounds and because of my condition, I'm home 24/7 and we live in the attached semi to her.

When she bought the house next door, she bought all of the IKEA furniture that was used to "dress" the house and she literally moved in with one suitcase.

I actually feel really sorry for her as she doesn't seem to let anyone engage with her at all unless it's online fans - it just seems such a sad way to live.

She does also look down on me (but I'm not offended) because she sees an overweight, short, old woman who doesn't seem to do anything and I wish I could tell her to embrace her life now whilst she can.
I too, used to be slim with a 24 inch waist and long blonde hair and I was attractive just like her and I lived life - then I got sick and old and my looks faded and so did my confidence and my medication and sickness (and occasional poor dietary choices) expanded my body to "Cuddly Granny" as my nephews call me and then the condition took away my mobility and my long-held career.

I feel my neighbour puts so much pressure on herself and restricts herself from so much and it makes me sad. She seems to hate being seen in "real life"

itstoolateforsnacks · 31/10/2026 15:07

Of course influencers aren’t happy! They are saying ‘please approve of me’ for a living. What a tense and sad life.

ThatCyanCat · 31/10/2026 15:14

itstoolateforsnacks · 31/10/2026 15:07

Of course influencers aren’t happy! They are saying ‘please approve of me’ for a living. What a tense and sad life.

Well, some of them are saying "tell me I suck and get really angry; it's been proven that anger drives more engagement than any other emotion and if you interact with my content then I get paid whether you like it or hate it".

BlueBlueBerries · 31/10/2026 15:20

MildlyUnhingedMe · 31/10/2026 12:59

A page came up in my Instagram feed last night called “at home with Amy and H” I’ve never followed her or seen her page before. The video was of her replacing her entirely grey home, with beige things. She replaced her bed, flooring, kitchen, you name it.
I commented (albeit with clumsy wording) “more money than sense”
she then replied “lovely comment, unhinged” - so I replied saying I just meant a lot of the stuff looked in perfectly good condition, but I assumed she had gifted or sold things. And that Mrs Hinch has a lot to answer for (meaning she influenced a lot of the grey era)

she then went on to say I’m a very sad person, with a sad little life, her money is her own - a full on personal attack really. I apologised for my initial comment but said I just feel it’s very wasteful and the trend Mrs Hinch influenced caused a lot of people to probably do the same (and now with beige)

This woman’s page is full of holidays to Dubai, her lovely house, her ironing buisness etc - don’t you think if she was as happy as it seems she’d have spent her Friday arguing with a stranger?

You do know you’re identifiable now from this post? Your profile might be private but still has a full face picture of you as well as your name and year of birth. Just a warning of how much of your own information is out there.

twocrumpets · 31/10/2026 15:24

You are a bit sad for commenting that 😂

JustAnotherWhinger · 31/10/2026 15:27

Saying “more money than sense” isn’t clumsy wording, it’s just bloody rude.

I don’t think any higher of people who go around being needlessly rude to folks they don’t know than you think of influencers.

And by engaging them in the way you did you likely helped make them money anyway, which seems a bit daft given your position.

GellerYeller · 31/10/2026 15:29

I just see influencers as adverts and scroll on without engaging.
I worked with someone whose partner was a low level influencer.
The working partner was propping up a monetised hobby by:
Being permanently photo ready and not allowed to leave anything on any surface.
Driving to the arse end of nowhere to collect ‘curated’ items from Facebook marketplace.
Constantly replacing their sinks/lighting/tiles/cupboards/fittings and ebaying the old ones.
Explaining to the likes of me that a few free knickknacks and the odd gifted sweatshirt don’t pay for the big shop or electric bill!

Thepeopleversuswork · 31/10/2026 15:35

itstoolateforsnacks · 31/10/2026 15:07

Of course influencers aren’t happy! They are saying ‘please approve of me’ for a living. What a tense and sad life.

In fairness I don’t think their lives are any worse than most of us on this front. Most people in most walks of life have to be approved by someone, whether it’s their boss, their customers or their partner.

I would hate to be an influencer but they have become this moral lightning rod for society at the moment and I think its a bit daft.

They are just people trying to make a living like the rest of us and there are positives and negatives to the way they earn a living. I suspect its quite stressful and insecure as a job, but I don’t particularly see it as some moral failing.

CaimanCrown · 31/10/2026 15:43

Just classic projection. She wouldn’t have left a comment like that on somebody’s instagram post unless she was trying to make them feel bad about themselves, so she assumed that’s what you were doing too, hence why she reacted saying that it was unhinged to want to say things like that to people.

What was your reason for your initial comment? I’m struggling to understand what your genuine intention was although I appreciate “to make her feel bad” probably wasn’t it.