Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think school reports should tell parents which topics their child is actually losing marks on?

40 replies

RedPenAndTea · 30/10/2026 10:23

I'm a teacher and I see this every year around mocks. A parent gets a report saying their child is "working at a 5" in Maths and has no idea what that means in practice. Is it algebra? Fractions? Running out of time in the exam? The report doesn't say, so the kid revises whatever they feel like, which is usually the stuff they're already good at.

Most of the time the information exists. It's sitting in a markbook or on a marked mock paper that never makes it home in a form anyone can use.

So I'd like to know what it's like from your side. If your child is in Year 10 or 11, do you know which topics they're dropping marks on? If you do, how did you find out?

And for those whose teens have already done their GCSEs, what made the difference in the end?

To be upfront, I'm involved in building a GCSE revision site because of this, so I'm partly asking to understand how parents deal with it. No links. I just want to hear how it goes in real homes.

OP posts:
mynamesnotsam · 30/10/2026 10:34

It surely depends whether you plan to micromanage your child's revision. DD says she gets plenty of feedback from school but I'm not sure I need to know.

Another76543 · 30/10/2026 10:37

mynamesnotsam · 30/10/2026 10:34

It surely depends whether you plan to micromanage your child's revision. DD says she gets plenty of feedback from school but I'm not sure I need to know.

This. Pupils are, presumably, getting any test papers returned so they can see where they’ve dropped marks. Ours get taught revision techniques so they know which areas they should be concentrating on.

JoderTia · 30/10/2026 10:38

mynamesnotsam · 30/10/2026 10:34

It surely depends whether you plan to micromanage your child's revision. DD says she gets plenty of feedback from school but I'm not sure I need to know.

Totally agree. My parents would not have known the ins and outs of things like this when I was mid teens but I certainly did and then focused on those topics accordingly.

Littletreefrog · 30/10/2026 10:40

Surely as a teacher you give that information directly to the students?

Another76543 · 30/10/2026 10:44

To add, the school reports sent to parents also mention which areas need focussing on to pick up extra marks. The pupils have already been made aware though.

Littlecrake · 30/10/2026 10:49

Actual real, useful, info from parents evening and reports is like hen’s teeth. Teachers seem hugely reluctant to say anything negative, presumable because it’s socially awkward and can be confrontational and will lead to pathetic complaining. They are also quite busy so you need to be stand out awful to get special mention. Every so often you get one who is more truthful/rigourous and gives you something you can work with. I expect by y10 they are well aware that they are bad at fractions but good at algebra and can work on that but it is human nature to be “right, I’m going to do 20 minutes of maths now….I’ll do some algebra” or more likely “I’m going to do some homework now…I’ll do English because it’s my favourite and I find it easy” and bar the teacher setting individualised revision plans it’s difficult to do. In my house I can say “Mrs McCkuskey says you are shit at fractions so I want you to focus on that to try and drag your mark up” and I’ll be treated to a 20 minute lament about how Mrs McCluskey doesn’t know anything and that was only one test and she says everyone is awful at fractions and she said that Stanley was bad at fractions whereas Stanley actually won a trophy for fractions and he couldn’t do well in fractions on that test because he could see a dog out of the window and they were given the wrong paper anyway and he can’t believe Mrs McCkuskey could say anything so scandalous and anyway he’s better at maths than most people and most people don’t even try at all.

MigGril · 30/10/2026 10:52

I get sent enough information directly to me from school without adding this in as well. DS gets feedback from school on what areas he needs to do more work on and that is his responsibility. Unless your child has SEN I would expect them to be able to manage this themselves by GCSE's.

Our science department produces sheets for each individual student on what they need to focus on, after year 11 mocks. It's a lot of paper work and half the students never even bother to take them home let alone look at them. So yes the data is there and used from a staff point of view but not always the students. The saying 'you can take a horse to water, but can't make it drink' comes to mind on this one.

RedPenAndTea · 30/10/2026 10:56

Littletreefrog · 30/10/2026 10:40

Surely as a teacher you give that information directly to the students?

Yes, they get their papers back with the marks on and we go through them in class. Where it falls down for a lot of them is the next step. They look at the grade, put the paper in their bag, and that's the last anyone sees of it. Do yours actually go back over their marked papers at home?

OP posts:
pinotnow · 30/10/2026 10:57

As a teacher and parent of teens who've done their GCSEs I agree with PPs that this information needs to be shared directly with students (and I'm sure it is in the vast majority of cases) rather than parents being expected to manage this for them. It should be communicated to parents that students have been informed of the areas they need to focus on so that kids can't get away with saying they don't know. Also, surely parents' evening would normally closely follow mocks and this would be another opportunity to share the info in more detail with parents.

RedPenAndTea · 30/10/2026 11:00

mynamesnotsam · 30/10/2026 10:34

It surely depends whether you plan to micromanage your child's revision. DD says she gets plenty of feedback from school but I'm not sure I need to know.

That's fair, and if your DD is on top of it then I'd leave her to it too. The ones I worry about aren't the organised ones. It's the ones who say "it's fine" at home and then turn up to the real exam having never gone back to the topics they dropped marks on. How would you know which one yours was?

OP posts:
mumoronegirl · 30/10/2026 11:02

Surely your students know where to focus their efforts from your feedback to them in class? By GCSE students need to be managing their own revision even as most parents don't have up to date GCSE knowledge of every subject.

RedPenAndTea · 30/10/2026 11:04

Littlecrake · 30/10/2026 10:49

Actual real, useful, info from parents evening and reports is like hen’s teeth. Teachers seem hugely reluctant to say anything negative, presumable because it’s socially awkward and can be confrontational and will lead to pathetic complaining. They are also quite busy so you need to be stand out awful to get special mention. Every so often you get one who is more truthful/rigourous and gives you something you can work with. I expect by y10 they are well aware that they are bad at fractions but good at algebra and can work on that but it is human nature to be “right, I’m going to do 20 minutes of maths now….I’ll do some algebra” or more likely “I’m going to do some homework now…I’ll do English because it’s my favourite and I find it easy” and bar the teacher setting individualised revision plans it’s difficult to do. In my house I can say “Mrs McCkuskey says you are shit at fractions so I want you to focus on that to try and drag your mark up” and I’ll be treated to a 20 minute lament about how Mrs McCluskey doesn’t know anything and that was only one test and she says everyone is awful at fractions and she said that Stanley was bad at fractions whereas Stanley actually won a trophy for fractions and he couldn’t do well in fractions on that test because he could see a dog out of the window and they were given the wrong paper anyway and he can’t believe Mrs McCkuskey could say anything so scandalous and anyway he’s better at maths than most people and most people don’t even try at all.

This is exactly what I see. Most of them know they're weak at fractions. Knowing it doesn't make them want to sit down and do fractions on a Sunday night when they could do the topic they like. Did anything ever work with yours to get them onto the boring stuff?

OP posts:
Littletreefrog · 30/10/2026 11:06

RedPenAndTea · 30/10/2026 10:56

Yes, they get their papers back with the marks on and we go through them in class. Where it falls down for a lot of them is the next step. They look at the grade, put the paper in their bag, and that's the last anyone sees of it. Do yours actually go back over their marked papers at home?

I didn't with either of my kids but then I didn't get involved in revision at all apart from providing the resources, time and space. Their teachers gave them feedback and they attended all extra revision classes provided by the school. I trusted them to know what areas they needed to revise and to ask their teachers if they didn't. My kids are very different, have very different academic abilities and also one is autistic but I don't feel micromanaging either of them would have helped and would probably have been counter productive. However all kids are different.

SummerInSun · 30/10/2026 11:08

My DC are only year 5 and year 9, but we get this detail in the parents evening chat. Actually for our son in Year 5 it can go too far the other way. His English teacher gave us a list “good vocabulary and spelling, not using punctuation enough, needs more adjectives”, etc, so we came away with a long list of what he needs to work on, but no real understanding of whether he was doing ok or well or poorly!

RedPenAndTea · 30/10/2026 11:12

Thanks all, this has been useful. Sounds like most of you think it's on the student by Year 11, which is fair.

A different question for anyone who's paid for a tutor. How did the tutor find out what your child was struggling with at school? Did you email the school for mock results, did your child take their books and marked papers along, or did the tutor work it out over the first few sessions?

And would it help if your child, you and the tutor could all see the same marks and weak topics in one place, so nobody has to chase the school or dig out old papers? Or is that more monitoring than a teenager needs?

OP posts:
Soontobe60 · 30/10/2026 11:15

When my DDs did any exams secondary school they got their paper back in class so could easily see where they’d gone wrong. At GCSE age, the student should be able to revise based on their errors without it having to be pointed out to them.

gravitarse · 30/10/2026 11:23

Ours do at gcse maths. Analyses the bits of the mock they failed then hyperlinks to the Sparks units

MrAlyakhin · 30/10/2026 11:29

I think you're overestimating the involvement of the vast majority of parents in their children's education.

Very few parents by year 11 are getting involved in their children's revision. A lot of them can't because they don't have the skills needed.

I also think it's difficult to say a specific topic because how an exam question is written changes how challenging it is. Some students lack basic knowledge others struggle with application. Generally the best revision is past papers but a lot of students don't bother because they find it difficult.

FourEyesGood · 30/10/2026 11:46

RedPenAndTea · 30/10/2026 11:12

Thanks all, this has been useful. Sounds like most of you think it's on the student by Year 11, which is fair.

A different question for anyone who's paid for a tutor. How did the tutor find out what your child was struggling with at school? Did you email the school for mock results, did your child take their books and marked papers along, or did the tutor work it out over the first few sessions?

And would it help if your child, you and the tutor could all see the same marks and weak topics in one place, so nobody has to chase the school or dig out old papers? Or is that more monitoring than a teenager needs?

A tutor should not be increasing schoolteachers’ workloads by asking for information. They should do a baseline assessment themselves (e.g. a past paper) to identify key areas to work on with the student.

patooties · 30/10/2026 11:47

Do they not do parents evening? Ask then. Then make a list. There’s usually a load of online resources too

tomorrowfollowstoday · 30/10/2026 11:50

Schools don't provide enough info in reports. I think they should give more to the student in written format, then the parents can see it if wanted or needed.

movinghomeadvice · 30/10/2026 12:06

RedPenAndTea · 30/10/2026 11:12

Thanks all, this has been useful. Sounds like most of you think it's on the student by Year 11, which is fair.

A different question for anyone who's paid for a tutor. How did the tutor find out what your child was struggling with at school? Did you email the school for mock results, did your child take their books and marked papers along, or did the tutor work it out over the first few sessions?

And would it help if your child, you and the tutor could all see the same marks and weak topics in one place, so nobody has to chase the school or dig out old papers? Or is that more monitoring than a teenager needs?

I was tutored as a student, and now tutor as a teacher, and the expectation is that students will bring their school work, books, past papers, revision etc. to tutoring sessions. A good tutor will work out within the first sessions or two which areas to focus on. I have occasionally been passed on work from the school for the student to complete with me, but that tends to be more elite private schools.

Another76543 · 30/10/2026 12:24

tomorrowfollowstoday · 30/10/2026 11:50

Schools don't provide enough info in reports. I think they should give more to the student in written format, then the parents can see it if wanted or needed.

Edited

I think it probably depends on the school. We get plenty of info on the reports, and the pupils also get regular written feedback from subject teachers via a tutor. If parents would like any further information or guidance, the teachers are always happy to provide it.

Octavia64 · 30/10/2026 12:29

Ex teacher

in maths doing red/amber/green sheets that give detailed feedback to students is the norm in year 11 certainly in my county.

it does take a bit of work - each teacher has to input the marks for each question into an excel spreadsheet which then generates the red amber green sheet for students.

my school then makes students write down the three topics they should focus on to improve.

dr frost maths will generate these automatically if students do a paper online. So top and middle set students get these sheets about once a month.

this model works much less well for subjects like English lit where you need to write an essay.

ACynicalDad · 30/10/2026 12:31

If you want more detail, then ask; many parents would find it inaccessible.