Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think school reports should tell parents which topics their child is actually losing marks on?

40 replies

RedPenAndTea · 30/10/2026 10:23

I'm a teacher and I see this every year around mocks. A parent gets a report saying their child is "working at a 5" in Maths and has no idea what that means in practice. Is it algebra? Fractions? Running out of time in the exam? The report doesn't say, so the kid revises whatever they feel like, which is usually the stuff they're already good at.

Most of the time the information exists. It's sitting in a markbook or on a marked mock paper that never makes it home in a form anyone can use.

So I'd like to know what it's like from your side. If your child is in Year 10 or 11, do you know which topics they're dropping marks on? If you do, how did you find out?

And for those whose teens have already done their GCSEs, what made the difference in the end?

To be upfront, I'm involved in building a GCSE revision site because of this, so I'm partly asking to understand how parents deal with it. No links. I just want to hear how it goes in real homes.

OP posts:
BerryTwister · 30/10/2026 12:45

RedPenAndTea · 30/10/2026 11:12

Thanks all, this has been useful. Sounds like most of you think it's on the student by Year 11, which is fair.

A different question for anyone who's paid for a tutor. How did the tutor find out what your child was struggling with at school? Did you email the school for mock results, did your child take their books and marked papers along, or did the tutor work it out over the first few sessions?

And would it help if your child, you and the tutor could all see the same marks and weak topics in one place, so nobody has to chase the school or dig out old papers? Or is that more monitoring than a teenager needs?

DS2 had tutors for maths and science GCSEs, and I didn't involve the school at all. The tutors asked DS which topics he struggled with, and he told them. They also went through exam papers with him, and were able to identify the areas that he needed help in. The impression I got was that experienced tutors like to make their own assessments of a pupil's ability, rather than hearing what other teachers have said.

As a parent I have always liked to be as involved in my kids' educations as possible, but I have to be realistic. There comes a point where you have to leave them to it. I provide a quiet area to work, a table, stationery, recommended text books, I attend parents evenings and arrange tutors if needed, and I've done a fair bit of nagging when exams are looming. But you can't control what actually goes into the brain of a teenager!

Newbutoldfather · 30/10/2026 13:00

@RedPenAndTea ,

‘Most of the time the information exists. It's sitting in a markbook or on a marked mock paper that never makes it home in a form anyone can use.’

Does this information really exist? I am dubious it has a lot of value.

For starters, the algebra question on a particular paper may have been a stinker, and the fraction question may have been trivial.

And then you have the AOs. Maybe the pupil is really strong on AO2 vs AO4, so again it’s not the topic.

It is such a multidimensional process. Schools love data, so they try to analyse exams, but I am not sure the statistics say much with any degree of confidence.

NorwegianForest · 30/10/2026 13:03

Hi OP, when my DC were studying for GCSE they used apps which tell them (after doing lots of practice questions) which areas are strong / weak based on their answers. I can't remember the names of the apps but I'm sure you can google to find them.

Octavia64 · 30/10/2026 13:08

Science apps for this include Tassomai

there are multiple maths offerings in this space including DrFrost maths and Sparx maths.

many schools recommend Duolingo for languages as it’s daily.

there’s also various flash card type sites like Quizlet.

3teens2cats · 30/10/2026 13:10

I expect this information to be shared with the student not their parents. My dc always had mock papers returned to them so they could look through and see where the marks were lost. Years 10 and 11 is time for teens to step up and start taking responsibility. Parents are responsible for encouragement and providing an environment at home which is conducive with revision. If dc wanted help I might go through a marked paper with them to help THEM to spot lost marks

Snorlaxo · 30/10/2026 13:12

Surely all students know which topics they are good at and which they find tricky?

Mine weren’t particularly organised but they knew that if a topic didn’t appear on paper 1 then it was a good idea to revise it for paper 2 and 3.

tomorrowfollowstoday · 30/10/2026 13:56

Snorlaxo · 30/10/2026 13:12

Surely all students know which topics they are good at and which they find tricky?

Mine weren’t particularly organised but they knew that if a topic didn’t appear on paper 1 then it was a good idea to revise it for paper 2 and 3.

Loads of students are not good at this at all.
One of the reasons private schools get good results is the amount of teacher support with this type of thing.
In state schools due to class sizes there isn't the exam support.
Parents who want to fill this gap need some info from school to do it. This is particularly useful if a child has any need for additional support.

Sirzy · 30/10/2026 14:02

Ds has just finished year 11. After every set of mocks there was a parents evening and information was given on what areas need more focus.

The school also offered a lot of after school sessions which focused on the areas where extra work was needed.

but I do agree that on the whole at GCSE age the young person needs to take on a lot of the responsibility for knowing where they need work!

Stompythedinosaur · 30/10/2026 14:13

Presumably parents who are actively involved will know though? I've gone through marked tests with dd1 and the school is very good at giving out topic lists which students can use to rate their confidence in, which helps to identify areas to focus on.

ThisCraftyAquaHedgehog · 31/10/2026 15:49

Please don't come up with yet more nonsensical paperwork to dump on teachers. The profession already spend more than enough time analysing every last detail of every last thing a child says or does in order to report all the nonsense to SLTs.

The children who don't care enough to do anything at all with the feedback they are given are not suddenly going to be 'student of the year' because the teacher told their parents specifically which history, maths, science, pe, etc objectives they weren't quite meeting.

And where would it stop?
Does the maths teacher need to be clear the child can multiply fractions, but struggles to add them? That they know all the tables facts, but can't quite get the linked division facts for the 7 times table though all other tables are fine?

No, the child is told. The child gets a paper with it clear on there what went wrong. The child can discuss with their parent if both want to.

Ohthatsabitshit · 31/10/2026 16:33

You seem to expect an extraordinary amount of input from parents. Teachers identify weakness and attempt to teach to deficits. Why would parents be involved in the minutiae of each subject to this degree? Madness.

BillieWiper · 31/10/2026 16:35

If they have the information what is the reason it doesn't get featured in the report?

NeverDropYourMooncup · 31/10/2026 16:43

If you actually had experience in the area, you'd know that this would involve creating hundreds of aspects, grade sets and marksheets for every subject that staff would then have to painstakingly complete every few weeks for every single student and then would need to be added to multiple report templates for all 1500-2000 kids.

ETA: and you'd have to then sort out an API to share that information (and make it work with multiple MIS and levels/modules) or expect somebody to create broadsheets, map the categories over and upload every few weeks.

JemimaTiggywinkles · 31/10/2026 18:06

We already do this. We put scores into our tracker which then tells parents what topics the child should work on and provides a link to a suitable revision website.

IdleGossip · 31/10/2026 18:50

This is the information you get at parents' evenings. "Your child is working at a B overall, but needs to work on algebra / french future tense / glaciation".

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread