Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask my son to change rooms with his stepsister?

262 replies

Lollylucyclark101 · 29/10/2026 15:31

So, been together with my now husband, for 10 years. Our children were roughly 8 and 3 when we met.

When we moved in together after a year, we moved into a new 3 bed house. We had the master bedroom, my son the other bedroom and my stepdaughter had the box room. The reasons behind that choice what that my son was with me 💯 of the time (had no contact with his dad) and we had stepdaughter every weekend.

We moved house in April this year to another 3 bed house and stepdaughter has again got the smallest room, (bed and set of drawers, is all we can fit in there) basically for the same reasons….. BUT she’s nearly 14 now and does spend the majority of the school holidays with us and not with mom.

My son is 19, has a job and a gf and since we moved in has spend the majority of his time at his girlfriends or work, meaning his larger bedroom (double bed, wardrobe, desk) is unused….. sometimes for weeks at a time.

Now, I’m trying to be fair. My son will always have a home with us, but as he’s not here the majority of the time I think he needs to move into the smaller room. This would mean him getting rid of his desk….. his wardrobe isn’t really used for cloths, and he would have to downsize to a single ottoman bed (which we will buy)…. But he is dead against it….. he pays board, so thinks that gives him the choice (we have said we would lower the amount, which isn’t much anyway!…. And I’m not interested in people commenting on this!). Son says that he will be home more to make sure his room is used as it should be. Weekdays here and weekends at his girlfriends.

I genuinely don’t know what to do. I don’t want my son to feel pushed out, but do think stepdaughter should have the bigger room….. but if he falls out with his gf he would be back here full time, and his stepsister would only be here weekends and part of the holidays.

My husband thinks that his daughter should have the bigger room and obviously, stepdaughter does too.

what would you do in this situation? our house is odd, so we don’t have a spare downstairs room (like we did in our old house), and our bedroom isn’t much bigger than my sons, the only people that can stay in the smaller room bedroom is one of the kids.

Thank you for any suggestions or advice.

OP posts:
CraftySeal · 29/10/2026 15:37

Do you think he'll move out any time soon? How long has he been with GF?

It's definitely a tricky one. It is still your son's only home where he pays to live...but if he's so often at his GF's in the evenings and weekends, I can see that it seems like a waste when your DSD is stuck in her tiny room.

PinkyFlamingo · 29/10/2026 15:41

You can't take his room from him, his relationship could break up at any time.

Lulaloo · 29/10/2026 15:45

We did this with our children. The boys switched over from the when eldest was 19 and youngest about to start secondary.
Daughter remained in middle sized room.🙄
He was more than happy to as out working all day and out and about as he could drive. At that age they don’t tend to have lots of belongings just lots of clothes and a bit of tech. Ask, I’m sure he’ll agree.

TRS20 · 29/10/2026 15:46

I would tell him it’s happening and he’s had the best deal for many years. It’s now her turn. Half the cost of his board if it makes you feel better and tell him he will
always have a home but the child who needs it most right now is getting the bigger room. It’s your house

Positivepositron · 29/10/2026 15:47

Lulaloo · 29/10/2026 15:45

We did this with our children. The boys switched over from the when eldest was 19 and youngest about to start secondary.
Daughter remained in middle sized room.🙄
He was more than happy to as out working all day and out and about as he could drive. At that age they don’t tend to have lots of belongings just lots of clothes and a bit of tech. Ask, I’m sure he’ll agree.

It's in the opening post that he doesn't want to swap

Lollylucyclark101 · 29/10/2026 15:50

CraftySeal · 29/10/2026 15:37

Do you think he'll move out any time soon? How long has he been with GF?

It's definitely a tricky one. It is still your son's only home where he pays to live...but if he's so often at his GF's in the evenings and weekends, I can see that it seems like a waste when your DSD is stuck in her tiny room.

Edited

No, I don’t think he will move out anytime soon. I would like him to save for a deposit for a house, so to stay as long as possible.

Hes been with his gf about 9 months and she lives with her parents and younger brother.

It’s so difficult, as I just want everyone happy, but do get where my stepdaughter is coming from. In the last month, he’s slept here once. She’s been here every weekend (Friday to Monday) and is with us now for the school holidays.

OP posts:
Fidgety31 · 29/10/2026 15:51

I would not take my sons bedroom and belongings off him just because he stays over at his girlfriends place .
what about when they split up and he wants to be at home ?
even worse that you are considering this when he pays rent !!

Teenagerantruns · 29/10/2026 15:51

I wouldleave it as it is. Presumably SD has a room.at home?
A lot might change in a year so wait another year and then reconsider

Credittocress · 29/10/2026 15:52

He doesn’t rule the house. Tell him he’s swapping and he can either help or you’ll move his stuff yourself

AutumnOakTree · 29/10/2026 15:52

Ds is still young, only 19, so your home is very much still his home. Getting rid of all his furniture is a step too far for him at the moment, and his new room would look and feel different as a result if you did change.

Does gf live at her parents house? If so, he visits her, rather than lives there.

How long has this situation been happening?

Maybe give a timeline and say that you’ll review it in July. Ie, end of school year.

Bitzee · 29/10/2026 15:53

It’s a fairly short relationship and he’s still a teen. It’s not exactly unlikely that they’ll break up. Not to mention he pays to rent that room. And assuming he’s taller than his stepsister, he may not fit comfortably in a single bed. I would leave it as is.

Hairyfairy01 · 29/10/2026 15:57

I don’t think I would be dictated to. Your solution is the most obvious and fair to everyone, surely he can understand that?

aperolspritzbasicbitch · 29/10/2026 15:58

Well, he’s said he’s going to spend more time at home going forwards, so he’ll be there more than stepdaughter.

I think expecting him to lose storage space in furniture and move to a single bed is unfair too.

hindsight being 20/20 and all….this would have been better as something you thought about when you moved.

NoisyViewer · 29/10/2026 16:02

The only thing that irks me with this is your son’s attitude. That he will come home even if he doesn’t want to just so he can keep his room and deny it your SD. That response alone would have me switching those rooms. If he had been more mature about it and had reluctantly agreed (in the spirit of fairness) and expressed what would happen if he split with his gf id have thought about it leaving it as it is. I would reduce his rent. If you’re still feeding, doing his washing and he’s bathing at yours I would take enough to cover those costs. But I don’t think you can see the better bedroom remain unused. Especially if it would be really appreciated by someone else

NoisyViewer · 29/10/2026 16:05

AutumnOakTree · 29/10/2026 15:52

Ds is still young, only 19, so your home is very much still his home. Getting rid of all his furniture is a step too far for him at the moment, and his new room would look and feel different as a result if you did change.

Does gf live at her parents house? If so, he visits her, rather than lives there.

How long has this situation been happening?

Maybe give a timeline and say that you’ll review it in July. Ie, end of school year.

Edited

He has stayed at home once in a month. He is only coming home to stop him losing his bedroom. He isn’t being kicked out. However, his life is changing and he has to accept that changes also happen for others. He’s had the main room for years and that was fair at the time.

MCF86 · 29/10/2026 16:07

He's paying for that space at the rate you agreed. I don't think it is fair to change the goal posts. You don't want him to feel pushed out, but that's exactly what is happening!

Why did you move to a house with less available space? Was your step daughter not spending the holidays with you then?

MCF86 · 29/10/2026 16:09

NoisyViewer · 29/10/2026 16:05

He has stayed at home once in a month. He is only coming home to stop him losing his bedroom. He isn’t being kicked out. However, his life is changing and he has to accept that changes also happen for others. He’s had the main room for years and that was fair at the time.

If the situation was different enough in April that they agreed the rooms as they are, I don't think it's been long enough to assume him being out so much is a long term thing!

Feedingbirds · 29/10/2026 16:11

You will make him feel pushed out . Staying at a fairly new Gfs may well not last at that age .

Nor at all surprised your SD wants the room and is being supported by her Dad .
If your SD was moving in full time - I might think differently .

I would personally review in 6 and 12 months and see where things are at then .

Shteen · 29/10/2026 16:12

My feeling is it's maybe a bit early to do this. How about setting it in place for when he turns 21, or when she starts Y11 or something?

Moving a chunk of wall to even up the bedroom sizes might be a good investment if that is an option. And are you 100% that a double or small double won't fit even with super super planning and building in? Swapping from a 3ft to a 4ft bed in our box room sounded mad but has been absolutely transformational for my tallish son. Everything else in the room has been planned to the mm and it works very well. The property & DIY board here is fab and you'd probably get some really good ideas if you posted room dimensions on there. (Some of them might be wildly ambitious but you can ignore those ones.)

Yetanotherone12 · 29/10/2026 16:13

If you’re charging him board your acknowledging he is a contributing adult. He agreed based on the room offered, so no, I don’t think you can expect him to move.

even if he isn’t using it, he’s paying. Your stepdaughter isn’t using the room full time either, and she is not paying.

if you want to dictate rooms you need to stop charging board.

presumably the room will sit empty apart from 10 weeks or so in the holidays? That seems like a waste of the space as well.

IsItSnowing · 29/10/2026 16:14

Your step daughter should get the bigger room. We did this when my eldest went to uni - he was still coming back during the holidays but his younger brother was still there all the time. So we swapped them over. When the eldest moved back in and the youngest went to uni we swapped again. They were both perfectly reasonable about it thankfully and agreed it was fair. It's only reasonable to adjust as circumstances change.

Sahara123 · 29/10/2026 16:14

Lulaloo · 29/10/2026 15:45

We did this with our children. The boys switched over from the when eldest was 19 and youngest about to start secondary.
Daughter remained in middle sized room.🙄
He was more than happy to as out working all day and out and about as he could drive. At that age they don’t tend to have lots of belongings just lots of clothes and a bit of tech. Ask, I’m sure he’ll agree.

She did, he doesn’t agree!

Whyherewego · 29/10/2026 16:16

Stop him paying board. Then you can ask him to swap

Lollylucyclark101 · 29/10/2026 16:17

PinkyFlamingo · 29/10/2026 15:41

You can't take his room from him, his relationship could break up at any time.

He wouldn’t be without a room though.

OP posts:
NoisyViewer · 29/10/2026 16:18

MCF86 · 29/10/2026 16:09

If the situation was different enough in April that they agreed the rooms as they are, I don't think it's been long enough to assume him being out so much is a long term thing!

It’s a tough one. I think it’s his attitude of I’ll come home then. When he’s only doing it to keep the room. He isn’t being kicked out. He’s being treated in the manner they started out as. He got the room because he was fhere the majority of the time. It’s only fair that rule is applied to both children

Swipe left for the next trending thread