Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask my son to change rooms with his stepsister?

262 replies

Lollylucyclark101 · 29/10/2026 15:31

So, been together with my now husband, for 10 years. Our children were roughly 8 and 3 when we met.

When we moved in together after a year, we moved into a new 3 bed house. We had the master bedroom, my son the other bedroom and my stepdaughter had the box room. The reasons behind that choice what that my son was with me 💯 of the time (had no contact with his dad) and we had stepdaughter every weekend.

We moved house in April this year to another 3 bed house and stepdaughter has again got the smallest room, (bed and set of drawers, is all we can fit in there) basically for the same reasons….. BUT she’s nearly 14 now and does spend the majority of the school holidays with us and not with mom.

My son is 19, has a job and a gf and since we moved in has spend the majority of his time at his girlfriends or work, meaning his larger bedroom (double bed, wardrobe, desk) is unused….. sometimes for weeks at a time.

Now, I’m trying to be fair. My son will always have a home with us, but as he’s not here the majority of the time I think he needs to move into the smaller room. This would mean him getting rid of his desk….. his wardrobe isn’t really used for cloths, and he would have to downsize to a single ottoman bed (which we will buy)…. But he is dead against it….. he pays board, so thinks that gives him the choice (we have said we would lower the amount, which isn’t much anyway!…. And I’m not interested in people commenting on this!). Son says that he will be home more to make sure his room is used as it should be. Weekdays here and weekends at his girlfriends.

I genuinely don’t know what to do. I don’t want my son to feel pushed out, but do think stepdaughter should have the bigger room….. but if he falls out with his gf he would be back here full time, and his stepsister would only be here weekends and part of the holidays.

My husband thinks that his daughter should have the bigger room and obviously, stepdaughter does too.

what would you do in this situation? our house is odd, so we don’t have a spare downstairs room (like we did in our old house), and our bedroom isn’t much bigger than my sons, the only people that can stay in the smaller room bedroom is one of the kids.

Thank you for any suggestions or advice.

OP posts:
Isobel201 · 29/10/2026 17:36

I think your step-daughter could use your son's bedroom when he's not there, then on the odd night he does stay, perhaps she moves temporarily into the box room again? I think that's the fairest way of doing it. That way she does have use of a desk 99% of the time. She can always move some stuff if she doesn't want him looking at it.

JenRummy · 29/10/2026 17:37

Why not just say it’s going to be reviewed again end January? You can’t kick your son out if he starts using it more. SD will just need to accept that.

JenRummy · 29/10/2026 17:37

Isobel201 · 29/10/2026 17:36

I think your step-daughter could use your son's bedroom when he's not there, then on the odd night he does stay, perhaps she moves temporarily into the box room again? I think that's the fairest way of doing it. That way she does have use of a desk 99% of the time. She can always move some stuff if she doesn't want him looking at it.

Edited

Terrible idea and likely to lead to more discontent and conflict.

MrsBananaman · 29/10/2026 17:39

Isobel201 · 29/10/2026 17:36

I think your step-daughter could use your son's bedroom when he's not there, then on the odd night he does stay, perhaps she moves temporarily into the box room again? I think that's the fairest way of doing it. That way she does have use of a desk 99% of the time. She can always move some stuff if she doesn't want him looking at it.

Edited

I cannot imagine a 14 year old girl being comfortable in a 19 year old boy’s bedroom!

anyolddinosaur · 29/10/2026 17:41

Is the small bedroom big enough for a high sleeper bed? Your daughter would then have a desk to study and your son could keep his room. He should be paying more than £50 a month so tell him he can continue with the box room at £50 a month or pay something more for the larger room - maybe £200 month which is still a lot less than renting a room himself assuming you still feed him and let him do his washing.

oviraptor21 · 29/10/2026 17:41

PinkyFlamingo · 29/10/2026 15:41

You can't take his room from him, his relationship could break up at any time.

This.
Way to tell him he's not wanted too.

My DS is 26 and lives in a box room in our house. He's fine. If you don't have a big bedroom you just learn to live in what you have. If you want to be practical about it, give her some extra storage in another room.

Whenisitsummer · 29/10/2026 17:42

He's 19 and has only been with the gf for 9 months . I wouldn't personally view that as him having moved out. Step daughter's main home is with her mum, where I'm sure she has a larger space.
So the rooms would be staying as they are if it was my house.

oviraptor21 · 29/10/2026 17:44

Lollylucyclark101 · 29/10/2026 16:22

Whilst I agree, he wasn’t spending weeks on end with his girlfriend when we moved in April. In the last month he’s slept here once.

Apologies - seen your update so deleted me comment.

Cyclingmummy1 · 29/10/2026 17:46

Teenagerantruns · 29/10/2026 15:51

I wouldleave it as it is. Presumably SD has a room.at home?
A lot might change in a year so wait another year and then reconsider

Yes, it's a box room while her SB's (double) room is mainly empty.

The swap should have been done with the house move.

Hopefulsalmon · 29/10/2026 17:50

I think he's being a bit selfish tbh - I'd just tell him he's moving room and it's not up for discussion. He's an adult so can sort out alternative accommodation if he doesn't like it.

OneHazelBird · 29/10/2026 17:51

It’s a difficult one but I’m assuming your DSD has a bedroom at her mums.

Therefore she has 2 bedrooms and doesn’t need to put all of her stuff in 1.

Your son only has 1 room snd therefore all of his belongings need to go in there.

So DS needs to stay in the bigger room.

Why does DSD want the bigger room?
Does she want a desk or something and why?

likelysuspect · 29/10/2026 17:52

Yes swap their rooms, its not like he is being made homeless, he still has a room but at his age, he's not socialising in his bedroom in the same way a teen girl is, hes not going to have his friends round eating doughnuts sat on the floor listening to mix tapes (or the modern equivalent). He doesnt sound there enough. Dont ask for any board if he's going to use that as some sort of argument.

OneHazelBird · 29/10/2026 17:56

Lollylucyclark101 · 29/10/2026 17:31

We would lower the amount. It’s only £50
a month anyway.

I don’t think he should be forced to move as I think it’s unfair that 1 child has 2 rooms and the other only has 1 room.

However, you could give him the option of continuing to pay board and remaining in the big room or paying nothing and going in the small room.

If he’s spending weeks at a time at his gfs house then he needs to be giving that money to her parents.

Skippinglightly · 29/10/2026 17:57

I would be so fed up if I was the gf’s mum!

Isobel201 · 29/10/2026 18:00

MrsBananaman · 29/10/2026 17:39

I cannot imagine a 14 year old girl being comfortable in a 19 year old boy’s bedroom!

Edited

except that its not really been "his bedroom", he has only slept in it once since April. I've chopped and changed rooms with my dad's ex wife's children, so perhaps I'm not as bothered, but it is essentially just a room with a bed and furniture at the end of the day. Its not as if he's been in there for years and made it his own.

SaySomethingMan · 29/10/2026 18:00

LowlandLucky · 29/10/2026 16:23

Neither of them are there every night but as your son is paying board he should keep his room.

That someone should not be your son…

OriginalUsername2 · 29/10/2026 18:00

NoisyViewer · 29/10/2026 16:02

The only thing that irks me with this is your son’s attitude. That he will come home even if he doesn’t want to just so he can keep his room and deny it your SD. That response alone would have me switching those rooms. If he had been more mature about it and had reluctantly agreed (in the spirit of fairness) and expressed what would happen if he split with his gf id have thought about it leaving it as it is. I would reduce his rent. If you’re still feeding, doing his washing and he’s bathing at yours I would take enough to cover those costs. But I don’t think you can see the better bedroom remain unused. Especially if it would be really appreciated by someone else

Agree with this. He seems bratty about it.

Plus even if he splits with his gf, he’ll still have a room.

Differentforgirls · 29/10/2026 18:03

Hopefulsalmon · 29/10/2026 17:50

I think he's being a bit selfish tbh - I'd just tell him he's moving room and it's not up for discussion. He's an adult so can sort out alternative accommodation if he doesn't like it.

He is her son.

TwinklyAmberSloth · 29/10/2026 18:06

Lollylucyclark101 · 29/10/2026 17:34

We rent. We don’t have a choice.

Do you have a garden? Could you get your DSD a garden pod that she can have as her personal space, then her box room to sleep in?

Its a bit mean of your son not to give up the bigger room if he is rarely there.

Rayqueen84 · 29/10/2026 18:07

So many seem to think 19 is a kid. He is an adult living mainly with his gf and working paying a pittance of £50 per month. I'm so glad for once someone like me who is advocating for all kids treating them the same.
In our household this happened 3 months ago, swapped bedrooms around no drama so olders got smaller since there mainly away and youngest got the bigger rooms. Your sons attitude is sad tho but hey your mum step up :)

Monvelo · 29/10/2026 18:07

I think given that he's said no, I would leave things as they are for 6 months or a year. He'll have time to get used to the idea. Things with the gf may have changed one way or another.

beAsensible1 · 29/10/2026 18:10

Lollylucyclark101 · 29/10/2026 17:31

We would lower the amount. It’s only £50
a month anyway.

£50? Well that’s negligible. Yes he needs to move. He’s had his turn

Ophy83 · 29/10/2026 18:15

Your stance on her staying over in the week is odd... why can't she get the bus home in the morning age 18? Loads of younger kids are getting buses and trains at that time to go to school (but also (though completely irrelevant to your post) - why does she have nothing to do all day? Is she looking for work/education?)

Your son probably feels a bit pushed out - you won't allow his gf to stay during the week so he stays at hers, and then you say because he is staying at hers he can't keep his room

Edited to remove the bit about him paying for his room as £50/month is basically nothing!

jacks11 · 29/10/2026 18:15

Lollylucyclark101 · 29/10/2026 15:50

No, I don’t think he will move out anytime soon. I would like him to save for a deposit for a house, so to stay as long as possible.

Hes been with his gf about 9 months and she lives with her parents and younger brother.

It’s so difficult, as I just want everyone happy, but do get where my stepdaughter is coming from. In the last month, he’s slept here once. She’s been here every weekend (Friday to Monday) and is with us now for the school holidays.

What if he and gf split up and he is home every night, vs your step-daughter being there 3 days plus holidays? Are you going to move her back into the smaller room to make it “fair” again? Do you think your step-daughter and your DH would agree to that? If not, I think you are going to have a hard time framing this as purely about giving the most space to the person who uses it the most. Or, you are setting yourself up for a real headache in the future if/when he splits up with current gf and is home more. I’d tread carefully here- what message are you sending him? How will this impact in his relationship with step-dad and step-sister?

I guess if you push this, you might need to be prepared for him to leave sooner than you would like. If you do it against his wishes, he will feel you’ve ignored his opinions. That may not bother you, of course, and it might be easier for you if he did choose to leave, though I’d guess you’d like it to be on good terms not because he felt pushed out.

Blondeshavemorefun · 29/10/2026 18:17

He pays £50a month - I would scrap that and move him to smaller room

is he paying rent at gf house as if he is there 28/31 days + then needs to

why has gf got a job. Did she leave college /6th form

and at 18 she is quite capable of getting a bus home at 7am. Ffs 11yr school kids do it