Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are the far left more dangerous than we realise

1000 replies

MabelsCatMabel · 24/10/2026 10:23

"The French president took to the airwaves on Sunday to condemn the rioters and blame far-Left agitators for hijacking what began weeks ago as a demonstration against poor conditions in schools."

He called for “calm and order” after a day of protests saw shops looted, cars set alight and public buildings burned to the ground. The collapse of the clock tower attached to Limoges city hall after it was gutted by a fire started by rioters on Saturday will become an abiding image of France’s nadir."

Are the far left more dangerous than we realise?

Far right is a known problem, but are we more ignorant to the far left and therefore tolerate that more?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
Raiderofthelostbattenburg · 24/10/2026 11:42

MabelsCatMabel · 24/10/2026 11:28

Thank you.

All extremists is bad and again I repeat I agree with neither but one end appears to get a free pass.

All violence is wrong.

I don’t believe it is true, at all, that one side gets a free pass. I see moderate politicians and journalists calling out far left extremism
just as often as I see them calling out far right extremism.

In fact, it saddens me to say, I think I have actually seen louder condemnation of looting, than I have of a 12 year old being shot at with an automated weapon.

If anything, this idea that the far left get a “free pass” sounds to me like a line designed to distract and deliberately divide us.

OvertiredandConfused · 24/10/2026 11:43

JohnofWessex · 24/10/2026 10:30

Define the Far Left

Certainly in the UK I suggest that we should be far more worried about the Racist Right

The far left is racist as well - just look at large sections of the Green party now. Most people who vote for them would be horrified if they studied some elements of their policy in detail.

WarmHiker · 24/10/2026 11:45

The observations about the debt and spending are true. But the far left are the biggest proponents of the hedonistic spending the Europeans engage in. There was crazy stat like nearly half of France’s schools budget is spent on pensions. If that’s not crazy, then what is.

The left have only themselves to blame for the state of European countries. Why go rioting when other people’s money runs out and you can’t have a free ride any more.

Menopausalsourpuss · 24/10/2026 11:45

Far right as labelled by people in government and the media seems to include views that were centre/mainstream up to 10 years ago ,(ie worried about Islam, uncontrolled immigration, increased crime particularly rapes, thinking men can't become women etc) so I am proudly far right as are probably most people. It is the left who have gone to the extreme which is why some left women now work for the Telegraph etc. Most political assassinations over the past few years have been far left or Islamic and the vast majority of terrorism victims in the UK in the past 25 years were killed by Muslims.

TemperanceWest · 24/10/2026 11:46

LuckyHazelFox · 24/10/2026 11:34

No he's not. He's a highly articulate rational man. Your opinion as opposed to mine, of course. He sticks to facts.

Facts like references to the Great Replacement Theory? OK.

Scrambledomelette · 24/10/2026 11:46

TemperanceWest · 24/10/2026 11:29

Yusuf is a really poisonous piece of work. Utterly vile man.

This is exactly what I mean. There is no assessment of right or wrong, of where his politics is inaccurate or undeliverable, just a reflex to say he is bad. He is bad. And that is enough to highlight your place in the political matrix, signal to your tribe and to abject yourself from that difference. It is so incredibly, incredibly lazy. But it achieves the aim of moving the conversation to virtue.

It requires no work to explain, no opportunity to find points of agreement and disagreement in the grey, just another five second dash of keyboard slapping someone with the morally bad brush. No wonder the kids are not okay.

LuckyHazelFox · 24/10/2026 11:48

TemperanceWest · 24/10/2026 11:46

Facts like references to the Great Replacement Theory? OK.

No but as this is just going to turn into an immigration concern means you're racist point, I'm not going to waste my time.

LuckyHazelFox · 24/10/2026 11:51

Scrambledomelette · 24/10/2026 11:46

This is exactly what I mean. There is no assessment of right or wrong, of where his politics is inaccurate or undeliverable, just a reflex to say he is bad. He is bad. And that is enough to highlight your place in the political matrix, signal to your tribe and to abject yourself from that difference. It is so incredibly, incredibly lazy. But it achieves the aim of moving the conversation to virtue.

It requires no work to explain, no opportunity to find points of agreement and disagreement in the grey, just another five second dash of keyboard slapping someone with the morally bad brush. No wonder the kids are not okay.

Edited

Well said. I've yet to see anybody get the better of Yusuf, because he always comes highly prepared and has the intelligence to back up his rationale. He's almost as good as Douglas Murray but I'm biased because Murray walks on water.

EasternStandard · 24/10/2026 11:53

I agree with pp on the debt issue. Of course voters put pressure on and politicians so far have increased debt.

France now is in a bind. The peacefully protesting students sound like they do have a legitimate ask but the lack of funds means riots are layered on top which make the problem so much worse.

Riots mean high costs to fix, closed outlets today and debt servicing going up.

On the question in the op something like Polanski saying he didn’t believe in states sounds dangerously naive on what that would look like in practise.

Back to France, rousing lines from Mélenchon re 1968 is fuel to the fire, and the landscape looks pretty unstable.

Newbutoldfather · 24/10/2026 11:55

@WarmHiker ,

‘The left have only themselves to blame for the state of European countries. Why go rioting when other people’s money runs out and you can’t have a free ride any more.’

I am not sure that is true. I think debt has increased under both left and right wing governments. I think Thatcher is the last PM who actually paid back some debt, and she had the luxury of privatisations and North Sea oil.

The left wing often think that the state has a duty to pay for them, I agree. However the right wing like creative monetary policy and bailouts for the wealthy (bankers and companies during COVID. That monetary policy allows assets to grown but impoverishes people on a normal salary via inflation.

It is a popular trope that the left support the lazy and feckless, but all the growth in the economy has accrued to the top quartile (and especially the top 1%) whereas teachers and medics have got poorer in real terms since 2008.

EasternStandard · 24/10/2026 11:56

Newbutoldfather · 24/10/2026 10:58

@WarmHiker ,

I am not sure Reform are properly ‘far’ right, although they do have far right members.

I would say suspending ALL asylum claims for 5 years borders on racism. Although, in theory it applies to everyone, the majority who are affected won’t ‘look’ that British.

On this when Denmark or Sweden vastly reduce numbers is it ok?

Not aimed at you really, just generally on how hardline policies are seen as good or not.

Newrumpus · 24/10/2026 11:56

It is authoritarianism that is to be feared. Both right and left are capable of this. Left wing authoritarianism is perceived by some as being in the best interests of those who don’t know what is good for them. This is very dangerous in my opinion.

ClaredeBear · 24/10/2026 11:58

babyproblems · 24/10/2026 10:30

It’s also very obvious that those looting are nothing to do with the political spectrum, right or left, or connected with the protests and genuine political groups in France.

If anything, mentality wise they are likely right wing; probably soaking up the manosphere, listening / watching / being fed algorithms containing right wing content. But in reality I doubt they would even know what that was if you asked them.

I can’t understand why people
don't immediately see that this is what’s going on.

TopPocketFind · 24/10/2026 11:58

For those unaware of Reform's racism and sexism

ITV News undercover documentary

Silence from Reform other than a 'few bad apples'

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://youtu.be/mp4hV7MALTg?si=yYeUJqdPcjyNR-KY

IamnotSethRogan · 24/10/2026 11:59

For me it matters what they're trying to achieve. The left in France are rioting basically for rights for all and fairer outcomes. The right here have been tricked into thinking all their problems are because of immigrants.

I can't think of many instances in society where those in power handed extra rights to the disadvantaged that they haven't had to take by some sort of disruption.

AgeingMillennial · 24/10/2026 12:00

babyproblems · 24/10/2026 10:27

In 2026 where we have the biggest wealth inequality gap which is growing; billionaires who live in a different world to the rest of us and who use their money to influence global politics and live above the reach of the legal system; this is a stupid post.

The telegraph is absolute nonsense and part of the above system which is contributing in the great transfer of our wealth into the hands of the ultra wealthy.

But does that justify relentless graffiti, rioting and violence toward innocent individuals, including murder..? ‘But the right/capitalists’ isn’t a very convincing comeback.

MabelsCatMabel · 24/10/2026 12:04

overnightangel · 24/10/2026 11:28

And this is an interesting point.

However one thing the Islamists and far left have in common is that they despise women, and that’s been the case forever. How long that uneasy alliance will last in the Greens is a different matter (and I fully expect them to be the Muslim Party before long, they’re currently in the process of Trojan-horsing it at the moment).

Most left wing people are either too naive to realise they’re being used as “useful idiots” by Islam, or too scared of losing woke points to call it out. The cognitive dissonance within groups like “Queers for Palestine“ would be hilarious if it wasn’t so terrifying.

The label “hard right” is becoming as meaningless as “Islamophabia” or “transphobia”, it’s just a term applied by people who want to demonise anyone who opposes whichever dangerous ideology they support. Those on the left seem more concerned with saying “I’m left wing” as some sort of badge of honour than looking at each issue individually to weigh up its merits. They just go “oh, Owen Jones says that’s a left wing thing now so I’d best support that”.

Yes. I agree these terms are becoming meaningless.

Saying left was a badge of honour as if 'better' than others. Whereas right a slur.

Now I think both terms are probably meaningless and just extremists of any type is poor. Maybe time to ditch the right bad and left good that some believe in?

OP posts:
WarmHiker · 24/10/2026 12:04

Newbutoldfather · 24/10/2026 11:55

@WarmHiker ,

‘The left have only themselves to blame for the state of European countries. Why go rioting when other people’s money runs out and you can’t have a free ride any more.’

I am not sure that is true. I think debt has increased under both left and right wing governments. I think Thatcher is the last PM who actually paid back some debt, and she had the luxury of privatisations and North Sea oil.

The left wing often think that the state has a duty to pay for them, I agree. However the right wing like creative monetary policy and bailouts for the wealthy (bankers and companies during COVID. That monetary policy allows assets to grown but impoverishes people on a normal salary via inflation.

It is a popular trope that the left support the lazy and feckless, but all the growth in the economy has accrued to the top quartile (and especially the top 1%) whereas teachers and medics have got poorer in real terms since 2008.

True, so-called right wing governments have overseen some atrocious fiscal management.

JuliaBraverman · 24/10/2026 12:06

overnightangel · 24/10/2026 10:27

Of course they are.
-Trans ideology being dangerous to women and to children
-Advocating for unvetted immigration on a crazy scale
-The rise of anti-semitism as sponsored by the Greens
-Labelling anyone who doesn’t embrace extremist Islam doctrine as “far right”

Could not agree more

Norwaygirl · 24/10/2026 12:08

overnightangel · 24/10/2026 10:27

Of course they are.
-Trans ideology being dangerous to women and to children
-Advocating for unvetted immigration on a crazy scale
-The rise of anti-semitism as sponsored by the Greens
-Labelling anyone who doesn’t embrace extremist Islam doctrine as “far right”

Yes they are but they seem to be able to hide behind being morally superior and calling anyone who doesn't agree with them racist.

TempestTost · 24/10/2026 12:10

babyproblems · 24/10/2026 10:30

It’s also very obvious that those looting are nothing to do with the political spectrum, right or left, or connected with the protests and genuine political groups in France.

If anything, mentality wise they are likely right wing; probably soaking up the manosphere, listening / watching / being fed algorithms containing right wing content. But in reality I doubt they would even know what that was if you asked them.

No true Scotsman is bad enough here, but trying to paint incredibly violent people on the left as right wing is a new low.

Sure there are looters and such that take advantage. But look around. There are plenty of examples of violent left groups now.

The denial is really notable. Flipping Sally Rooney crying that she's being censored because she isn't allowed to fun and organization that smashes police officers with sledge hammers.

No one seriously denies violent skinheads are some kind of right wing group. But the people twisting themselves to say left wing violence is really right wing ...

TallSturdyGirls · 24/10/2026 12:13

Extremism of any sort is dangerous. Rationale debate. Compromise. Cross parry working is far better for achieving stability. Populism and voting around niche issues is always a bad idea.

LuckyHazelFox · 24/10/2026 12:14

MyKindHiker · 24/10/2026 11:37

Agree.

Though when talking about comparative threats we can also say that statistically (crimes committed so far, terrorist plots foiled) the far right currently present more of a threat. And are better funded and there are more of them. Therefore something I personally worry about more.

Not saying the far left are not also a threat.

This sums up the blindness of the left.

LakieLady · 24/10/2026 12:15

Was it the "far left" that kicked off the Southport riots?

Was it someone from the "far left" who recently took a knife and used it to slash a dinghy while a rescue worker was in it?

Is it someone from the "far left" who will soon be up before the beak in Oxford for 16 offences including threatening behaviour and assault?

Meanwhile, tens of thousands of the anti-racist left managed to have a perfectly peaceful demonstration in London earlier this, and thousands did the same in Brighton a few weeks ago. Far from attacking the far-right marchers, they got them safely kettled under a railway bridge.

And I think it's false equivalance to compare the UK left to events unfolding in France, where they are much more inclined to take to the streets. After all, even the farmers kick off in France, and in the UK they are generally a pretty conservative group.

placemats · 24/10/2026 12:16

TemperanceWest · 24/10/2026 11:46

Facts like references to the Great Replacement Theory? OK.

Shocking really that posters would support him. If that's the bar for being a "highly articulate rational man", then one can only conclude that intelligence isn't their USP.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.