Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are the far left more dangerous than we realise

1000 replies

MabelsCatMabel · 24/10/2026 10:23

"The French president took to the airwaves on Sunday to condemn the rioters and blame far-Left agitators for hijacking what began weeks ago as a demonstration against poor conditions in schools."

He called for “calm and order” after a day of protests saw shops looted, cars set alight and public buildings burned to the ground. The collapse of the clock tower attached to Limoges city hall after it was gutted by a fire started by rioters on Saturday will become an abiding image of France’s nadir."

Are the far left more dangerous than we realise?

Far right is a known problem, but are we more ignorant to the far left and therefore tolerate that more?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
LuckyHazelFox · 24/10/2026 11:12

Great thread BTW @MabelsCatMabel

time4anothername · 24/10/2026 11:16

Far anything is dangerous. The more overwhelmed with fear and threat humans are, the more they are at risk of entrenching into a simplistic set of beliefs that does not demand complex thinking and executive function.
The way the internet and SM work is overwhelming people so that they end up in an entrenched position once overwhelmed. That type of psychological warfare never stopped from some countries in the 20th century, they were always getting into places they could but the internet has allowed them unprecedented access to all levels of population and all ages. Capitalists use it to sell you stuff, petty criminals use it to scam, nations use it to exert control. If you grew up in mainland Europe in the 60s and 70s you were well aware of left terrorist gangs too. Far left groups like Baader Meinhoff seemed to disappear once the USSR crumbled, no coincidence there of course ;-).

ScholesPanda · 24/10/2026 11:17

I think the number of people who feel the system is working for them and that they are receiving benefit from it, is clearly diminishing.

You say that Reform and Green parties are extreme, but the rise of anti-system parties is a symptom of this disaffection not a cause.

Also, there has long been violence on both the left and the right, especially on the continent- Red Brigades, Red Army Faction, Action Francaise, Japanese Red Army, Baader-Meinhof, AAA etc. It's not like any of this is new.

Try reading Doris Lessing's 'The Good Terrorist', which pretty much sums up what you're talking about and was written in 1985.

HotTiredDog · 24/10/2026 11:17

In my 4 decades of following UK & global politics, my main learning is that extremes of anything tend not to be good.

LuckyHazelFox · 24/10/2026 11:18

As an incidental point, Zia Yusuf is the real intelligent voice behind Reform. Farage is only the gatekeeper.

Raiderofthelostbattenburg · 24/10/2026 11:20

https://www.lemonde.fr/en/france/article/2026/10/24/after-deadly-attack-in-trappes-which-macron-called-racist-questions-remain-over-suspected-gunman-s-motives_6762637_7.html

A man is dead and five people, including a twelve year old child, are in hospital with gun shot wounds after an attack by a terrorist - who it is currently believed acted out of racism and islamophobia.

In that context, debating which kind of violent extremism is “worse” feels obscene. Extremism on the left and extremism on the right should be equally and loudly condemned. You can condemn one without minimising the other.

Anyone using the situation in France to push further divisiveness and polarisation, or to simplistically shift blame onto one group or another should have a long hard think about where it leads.

Client Challenge

https://www.lemonde.fr/en/france/article/2026/10/24/after-deadly-attack-in-trappes-which-macron-called-racist-questions-remain-over-suspected-gunman-s-motives_6762637_7.html

quantumbutterfly · 24/10/2026 11:25

Somersetbaker · 24/10/2026 11:05

Though Reform has many far right supporters. Farage is just a grifter who will support anything that allows him to trouser more money.

And that makes him different from so many of our other MPs because......

LuckyHazelFox · 24/10/2026 11:26

quantumbutterfly · 24/10/2026 11:25

And that makes him different from so many of our other MPs because......

Great point Quantum.

overnightangel · 24/10/2026 11:28

LuckyHazelFox · 24/10/2026 11:06

In amongst all this hard left v far right debate, there is one extreme that gets forgotten. So where do we place extreme Islamist rhetoric, as I'm assuming that's far right? Before the usual objectors latch onto what I've said, I reiterate the word "extreme".

And this is an interesting point.

However one thing the Islamists and far left have in common is that they despise women, and that’s been the case forever. How long that uneasy alliance will last in the Greens is a different matter (and I fully expect them to be the Muslim Party before long, they’re currently in the process of Trojan-horsing it at the moment).

Most left wing people are either too naive to realise they’re being used as “useful idiots” by Islam, or too scared of losing woke points to call it out. The cognitive dissonance within groups like “Queers for Palestine“ would be hilarious if it wasn’t so terrifying.

The label “hard right” is becoming as meaningless as “Islamophabia” or “transphobia”, it’s just a term applied by people who want to demonise anyone who opposes whichever dangerous ideology they support. Those on the left seem more concerned with saying “I’m left wing” as some sort of badge of honour than looking at each issue individually to weigh up its merits. They just go “oh, Owen Jones says that’s a left wing thing now so I’d best support that”.

MabelsCatMabel · 24/10/2026 11:28

Raiderofthelostbattenburg · 24/10/2026 11:20

https://www.lemonde.fr/en/france/article/2026/10/24/after-deadly-attack-in-trappes-which-macron-called-racist-questions-remain-over-suspected-gunman-s-motives_6762637_7.html

A man is dead and five people, including a twelve year old child, are in hospital with gun shot wounds after an attack by a terrorist - who it is currently believed acted out of racism and islamophobia.

In that context, debating which kind of violent extremism is “worse” feels obscene. Extremism on the left and extremism on the right should be equally and loudly condemned. You can condemn one without minimising the other.

Anyone using the situation in France to push further divisiveness and polarisation, or to simplistically shift blame onto one group or another should have a long hard think about where it leads.

Thank you.

All extremists is bad and again I repeat I agree with neither but one end appears to get a free pass.

All violence is wrong.

OP posts:
MabelsCatMabel · 24/10/2026 11:29

ScholesPanda · 24/10/2026 11:17

I think the number of people who feel the system is working for them and that they are receiving benefit from it, is clearly diminishing.

You say that Reform and Green parties are extreme, but the rise of anti-system parties is a symptom of this disaffection not a cause.

Also, there has long been violence on both the left and the right, especially on the continent- Red Brigades, Red Army Faction, Action Francaise, Japanese Red Army, Baader-Meinhof, AAA etc. It's not like any of this is new.

Try reading Doris Lessing's 'The Good Terrorist', which pretty much sums up what you're talking about and was written in 1985.

I'll read that. Thank you 😊

OP posts:
TemperanceWest · 24/10/2026 11:29

LuckyHazelFox · 24/10/2026 11:18

As an incidental point, Zia Yusuf is the real intelligent voice behind Reform. Farage is only the gatekeeper.

Yusuf is a really poisonous piece of work. Utterly vile man.

Tiredthismorning · 24/10/2026 11:31

The far anything are dangerous.

We should worry about extremists on the left and the right. The horseshoe theory of political ideology is correct, and the far left and far right are close on many things (NATO, Russia, Anti-Semitism, populism generally).

What's also dangerous is people using the far left as an excuse for the far right, or distracting from the dangers of the far right by going 'Ooh look, the far left are dangerous'.

Both are bad. Neither are good.

TemperanceWest · 24/10/2026 11:31

MabelsCatMabel · 24/10/2026 11:28

Thank you.

All extremists is bad and again I repeat I agree with neither but one end appears to get a free pass.

All violence is wrong.

Can you give an example of when violence from the far left has been given a "free pass"?

Tiredthismorning · 24/10/2026 11:31

TemperanceWest · 24/10/2026 11:29

Yusuf is a really poisonous piece of work. Utterly vile man.

Who almost all Reform supporters would deport in an instant because of the colour of his skin.

TemperanceWest · 24/10/2026 11:32

Raiderofthelostbattenburg · 24/10/2026 11:20

https://www.lemonde.fr/en/france/article/2026/10/24/after-deadly-attack-in-trappes-which-macron-called-racist-questions-remain-over-suspected-gunman-s-motives_6762637_7.html

A man is dead and five people, including a twelve year old child, are in hospital with gun shot wounds after an attack by a terrorist - who it is currently believed acted out of racism and islamophobia.

In that context, debating which kind of violent extremism is “worse” feels obscene. Extremism on the left and extremism on the right should be equally and loudly condemned. You can condemn one without minimising the other.

Anyone using the situation in France to push further divisiveness and polarisation, or to simplistically shift blame onto one group or another should have a long hard think about where it leads.

In that context, debating which kind of violent extremism is “worse” feels obscene. Extremism on the left and extremism on the right should be equally and loudly condemned. You can condemn one without minimising the other

Exactly this.

quantumbutterfly · 24/10/2026 11:33

OneNewLeader · 24/10/2026 11:07

In Paris it started as a political protest, young people wanting a better education, hardly radical. It then mutates as more people join with different grievances and then different motives. The Gilet Jaune’s have joined, traditionally older and more right leaning.

The loss of Limoges’ town hall is a tragedy, but it’s a thing, the loss of education and hope for young people is, IMHO more tragic.

So what did people do historically in times of great change? In the UK we had Luddites & swing rioters, we also had the Rochdale pioneers & the Tolpuddle martys.

Better to smash or to build do you think?

LuckyHazelFox · 24/10/2026 11:34

TemperanceWest · 24/10/2026 11:29

Yusuf is a really poisonous piece of work. Utterly vile man.

No he's not. He's a highly articulate rational man. Your opinion as opposed to mine, of course. He sticks to facts.

MyKindHiker · 24/10/2026 11:35

I’m not really sure how you define threat. Do you mean threat to public order or genuine threat like terrorism?

For public order there has been pretty equal amounts of disorder caused by left and right the last few years.

For terrorism the police do release stats of foiled terrorist attacks / plots. Most were islamist, followed by far right as a close second place and way down the list at 2% were leftist.

So there are stats out there to quantify the risk.

WarmHiker · 24/10/2026 11:37

TemperanceWest · 24/10/2026 11:29

Yusuf is a really poisonous piece of work. Utterly vile man.

How?

LuckyHazelFox · 24/10/2026 11:37

Tiredthismorning · 24/10/2026 11:31

Who almost all Reform supporters would deport in an instant because of the colour of his skin.

You've spoken to every Reform supporter have you? I forgot it's easier just to categorise a whole group which is something I thought the left objected to.

MyKindHiker · 24/10/2026 11:37

TemperanceWest · 24/10/2026 11:32

In that context, debating which kind of violent extremism is “worse” feels obscene. Extremism on the left and extremism on the right should be equally and loudly condemned. You can condemn one without minimising the other

Exactly this.

Agree.

Though when talking about comparative threats we can also say that statistically (crimes committed so far, terrorist plots foiled) the far right currently present more of a threat. And are better funded and there are more of them. Therefore something I personally worry about more.

Not saying the far left are not also a threat.

Newbutoldfather · 24/10/2026 11:38

The reality is that Western society has a massive debt problem. Every year more and more of the budget gets eaten up by repaying debt. In addition, we have expensive wars taking place. However, the population (especially true in places like France) still wants to live a relaxed life and retire in their early 60s. It’s totally unrealistic!

And then you get the political centre trying to fiddle around the edges with technocratic fixes, nearly all of which both merely delay the inevitable and increase wealth inequality.

So, you can see the appeal of more extreme politics, who are at least political. They set out choices and solutions (even if many wouldn’t work). A proper wealth tax on the truly wealthy might change public finances for the better, but it seems almost impossible to collect and also drives away wealth creators. It would have to be some kind of a global tax to work, and that has zero chance of happening.

ColdAsAWitches · 24/10/2026 11:41

I very much doubt it's far left or far right, it's a group that will take any opportunity to cause trouble and riot. We've seen it in Ireland and the Uk I. the last few years, it's young people going out and causing trouble under a pretence.

tartyflette · 24/10/2026 11:41

It’s an opinion piece from the Telegraph - what do you expect? The paper is certainly no friend of France and the French, especially under its current government.
Take it from whence it came.
I was in France in the spring and summer of 68, during ‘les évenements’ when rioting students were joined by the workers and a new revolution was ‘imminent.’
That didn’t happen either.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.