Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the French students are out of control?

506 replies

ITVXsponsoredbyDominoes · 17/10/2026 19:53

Demonstrating against large class sizes is one thing.

Smashing up shop windows and looting goods is another.

Idiots. They are 14/15 and when they are arrested the French authorities will come down on them and their criminal records will stay with them forever. Where are the parents in all of this?

Woukd this happen in the UK?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
leperol · 19/10/2026 19:16

Well has Macron (or whoever in Government has hands on the purse strings) immediately stated unequivocally that millions and millions will be allocated to schools, colleges etc., that teacher pay will be improved, that curriculum and length of school days will be examined, that university entrance criteria/application will be simplified, that measures will be taken to support low income students to enter university. Etc. Has he/have they?

Because if they haven't yet, they should do so immediately like now. That would expose the rioters for what and who they are. I know I have simplified it, but that's what's needed right away IMO. They can get the money from somewhere. Close down the initial reason for protest, and show up the rest of the thugs.

I haven't thought this through obviously, and I am probably being very naive, but they should do something really big about it asap.

1dayatatime · 19/10/2026 19:29

Raiderofthelostbattenburg · 19/10/2026 19:06

What is happening is clearly horrendous, but the point is the Jewish Community Protection Service - whose job is keep the French Jewish community safe - have specifically asked that misinformation and speculation not be spread.

It is absolutely more painful and distressing for Jewish business owners if they have the added anxiety of being told their shops were deliberately targeted by anti semites. You’ll read in the article you link to, the members of the congregation are at pains to point out there was no anti semitic graffiti.

Fear mongering helps no one, least of all the Jewish community, who are scared enough as it is.

Edited

I totally agree that misinformation and speculation not be spread.

However a synagogue was ransacked- that is an evidenced fact.

To deny that this happened, refuse to mention it or claim that the rioters simply mistook it for a Louis Vuitton store would indeed be misinformation, denial of facts, speculation- probably with a dash of anti semitism thrown in.

Raiderofthelostbattenburg · 19/10/2026 19:42

supernaturalmilkshake · 19/10/2026 19:12

The attack on the synagogue has been reported in multiple places and there are videos of the looting aftermath. Even rioters know what a synagogue is and who worships in one. Do you really think there is no selectivity in a synagogue being targeted? That sounds incredibly naive to me. It's not like antisemitism in France is something new and unusual, Jews get targeted there often.

I posted in response to a poster who had compared the riots to Kristallnacht, letting them know that the Jewish Community Protection Service - whose job it is to keep the French Jewish Community safe - had warned against the spread of unverified claims about Jewish shops being specifically targeted.

Believe me, I am the last person to deny France’s anti semitic history: that is why I take the words of the SPCJ about not adding to the fears of an already terrified community.

Raiderofthelostbattenburg · 19/10/2026 19:47

1dayatatime · 19/10/2026 19:29

I totally agree that misinformation and speculation not be spread.

However a synagogue was ransacked- that is an evidenced fact.

To deny that this happened, refuse to mention it or claim that the rioters simply mistook it for a Louis Vuitton store would indeed be misinformation, denial of facts, speculation- probably with a dash of anti semitism thrown in.

Absolutely no one is denying how horrific it is for a synagogue to be ransacked - I posted in response to a poster who had compared the riots to Kristallnacht, letting them know that the Jewish Community Protection Service - whose job it is to keep the French Jewish Community safe - had warned against the spread of unverified claims about Jewish shops being specifically targeted. I personally believe it is important we take the words of the SPCJ about not adding to the fears of an already terrified community seriously.

PumpkinSeasonIsHere · 19/10/2026 20:06

1dayatatime · 19/10/2026 19:29

I totally agree that misinformation and speculation not be spread.

However a synagogue was ransacked- that is an evidenced fact.

To deny that this happened, refuse to mention it or claim that the rioters simply mistook it for a Louis Vuitton store would indeed be misinformation, denial of facts, speculation- probably with a dash of anti semitism thrown in.

The link posted by someone else above says: A synagogue committee member suggested the intruders may have been searching for money but questioned whether the synagogue had been deliberately targeted. The Torah scrolls were left untouched, and no antisemitic graffiti was reported.

It was posted by someone who was making the POINT that a synagogue had been ransacked.

I can’t believed we’re being accused of antisemitism for quoting the SPCJ.

You can choose not to believe it - I certainly don’t believe everything I read in the papers - but please don’t accuse people of things like naivete and racism based on alternative reports from reputable sources.

Whether Yahoo is a reputable source is open to debate but you can’t simultaneously claim that it is proof that a synagogue was ransacked while refusing to believe to report from a committee member in the same article.

1dayatatime · 19/10/2026 20:16

PumpkinSeasonIsHere · 19/10/2026 20:06

The link posted by someone else above says: A synagogue committee member suggested the intruders may have been searching for money but questioned whether the synagogue had been deliberately targeted. The Torah scrolls were left untouched, and no antisemitic graffiti was reported.

It was posted by someone who was making the POINT that a synagogue had been ransacked.

I can’t believed we’re being accused of antisemitism for quoting the SPCJ.

You can choose not to believe it - I certainly don’t believe everything I read in the papers - but please don’t accuse people of things like naivete and racism based on alternative reports from reputable sources.

Whether Yahoo is a reputable source is open to debate but you can’t simultaneously claim that it is proof that a synagogue was ransacked while refusing to believe to report from a committee member in the same article.

Returning to my first point below, I agree with the SPCJ that misinformation and speculation is not helpful.

Now to suggest that maybe the rioters simply ransacked a synagogue because they may have been searching for money is indeed misinformation and speculation. Or perhaps you think that the rioters simply and "innocently "mistook it for a Louis Vuitton store?

In addition the SPCJ comment was referring to attacks on Jewish owned businesses not synagogues.

Lastly I see you have tried the usual tactic of disputing the reputation of the news source (Yahoo) if it doesn't support your existing opinion.

PumpkinSeasonIsHere · 19/10/2026 20:26

1dayatatime · 19/10/2026 20:16

Returning to my first point below, I agree with the SPCJ that misinformation and speculation is not helpful.

Now to suggest that maybe the rioters simply ransacked a synagogue because they may have been searching for money is indeed misinformation and speculation. Or perhaps you think that the rioters simply and "innocently "mistook it for a Louis Vuitton store?

In addition the SPCJ comment was referring to attacks on Jewish owned businesses not synagogues.

Lastly I see you have tried the usual tactic of disputing the reputation of the news source (Yahoo) if it doesn't support your existing opinion.

I honestly don’t know what you’re on at me for. And the Yahoo article is a report saying that the synagogue was ransacked, AND that a member thought they might have been searching for money, ie two bob each way. So it is neither supporting or denying (in whole) anything that anyone here has said.

I’m at a loss to understand how you can think all of these things at once, and also why you suddenly believe that I’m denying antisemitism or I don’t even know what. Truly, find another outlet for your righteous anger.

ExcitableCat · 19/10/2026 21:25

millymollymoomoo · 19/10/2026 19:12

Not students
not protests
not french

let’s be clear- this is not about school funding

It might have started out that way but after 24 hrs, its definitely just rioting and a free for all unfortunately. People jumping on the bandwagon for the thrill of it all and some looted goods. Macron was at a Celine Dion concert on Friday and couldnt give a F

Anonanonay · 19/10/2026 23:39

Sausagenbacon · 19/10/2026 10:37

Has anyone read Submission? It was presient when it was published, 10 years ago, at the time of Charlie Hedbo, and is worth reading now

I've got a copy. Must get on and read it, but worried it's going to be very depressing.

Sausagenbacon · 20/10/2026 06:39

Actually it's not. It shows how an establishment (French intelligence in this case) folds and accepts an Islamic status quo without a murmer.

Jane3212 · 20/10/2026 06:43

blankcanvas3 · 17/10/2026 19:55

I do have to admire the French’s passion when it comes to anything they aren’t happy with though. Violence is never the answer, but they simply don’t take things lying down. We sit complaining about our ever increasing prices, our ever decreasing quality of public services but don’t do anything about it. Part of me just thinks, viva la revolucion. At least they’re doing something about it.

The thing is, the French protest so much that it arguably dilutes the importance of protests that happen when things are truly dire.

So many jobs have struck there recently, yes, there are problems but there is only so much money and although services are often better in France than here, they are at risk or a financial crash. They can't meet everyone's demands.

These students DO have serious problems, though, at least a lot of them do,and there MUST be improvement.

Violence is disgusting though, and a lot of bad actors are trying to hijack it.

I think French police should also change: they are much more aggressive than here, use tear gas more routinely etc. France isn't necessarily more free than us, at least not in everything.

I'd also argue in some ways it's a more snobby society than us.

unsync · 20/10/2026 07:09

Our local Town Hall has just issued an arrêté. All minors are now on a curfew from 22.00 to 06.00 every Friday through Monday morning. This is in place every weekend, bank holiday and every day through the school holidays. They are not allowed out unless accompanied by an adult or legal guardian. It is In place throughout the whole commune and is in place until the end of January.

Anonanonay · 20/10/2026 23:18

Sausagenbacon · 20/10/2026 06:39

Actually it's not. It shows how an establishment (French intelligence in this case) folds and accepts an Islamic status quo without a murmer.

How is that not depressing? Given the state of things.

pinck · 20/10/2026 23:49

AlicePottery · 17/10/2026 21:41

I really think people are mixing everything up. The kids protesting about their schooling are NOT the ones who are looting and damaging things.

Exactly, like go ahead and organize some peaceful protests in the UK and I bet it wouldn't take long for your Islamist extremists or other opportunists to take advantage of the situation and start smashing things up or setting shit on fire, just saying.

Sausagenbacon · 21/10/2026 07:37

How is that not depressing? Given the state of things.
I was responding to a poster who said she hadn't read it because it sounded frightening. As far as I recall, the striking thing is about it that how easily the intelligensia accept the new status quo.
The whole story is presented in a very matter-of-fact way.
And, of course, it came out immediately before Charlie Hebdo

igglepiggll · 21/10/2026 09:11

“The kids protesting about their schooling are NOT the ones who are looting and damaging things”

This could be largely correct. My SIL is currently in Bordeaux. This is her take on it;
It started as protests over schooling however soon lots of other forces joined particularly the young not in employment. This then quickly turned into the “cost of living” riots and looting started. You also have the large section of the illegal male migrants who are also bottom of the socio economic ladder who are struggling and these people know how to do violence as they have had to fight it. They have no respect for historic buildings or French culture hence they go further than looting, they burn and destroy.

Whenever inflation is running high it is increasing the cost of goods and energy and so such riots erupt. It happened in London 2011, there was looting then also. However now we have unvetted illegal mostly male migrants to add to that bubbling pot too which adds a new dimension of utter disregard and destruction.

Open unvetted borders. This is where it leads to.

igglepiggll · 21/10/2026 09:14

Jane3212 · 20/10/2026 06:43

The thing is, the French protest so much that it arguably dilutes the importance of protests that happen when things are truly dire.

So many jobs have struck there recently, yes, there are problems but there is only so much money and although services are often better in France than here, they are at risk or a financial crash. They can't meet everyone's demands.

These students DO have serious problems, though, at least a lot of them do,and there MUST be improvement.

Violence is disgusting though, and a lot of bad actors are trying to hijack it.

I think French police should also change: they are much more aggressive than here, use tear gas more routinely etc. France isn't necessarily more free than us, at least not in everything.

I'd also argue in some ways it's a more snobby society than us.

What does it say about a society that has “a lot of bad actors”.

This is a society where cohesion is dying, where they have imported a large volume of criminals who do not respect French laws and values.

LuckyHazelFox · 21/10/2026 09:19

igglepiggll · 21/10/2026 09:11

“The kids protesting about their schooling are NOT the ones who are looting and damaging things”

This could be largely correct. My SIL is currently in Bordeaux. This is her take on it;
It started as protests over schooling however soon lots of other forces joined particularly the young not in employment. This then quickly turned into the “cost of living” riots and looting started. You also have the large section of the illegal male migrants who are also bottom of the socio economic ladder who are struggling and these people know how to do violence as they have had to fight it. They have no respect for historic buildings or French culture hence they go further than looting, they burn and destroy.

Whenever inflation is running high it is increasing the cost of goods and energy and so such riots erupt. It happened in London 2011, there was looting then also. However now we have unvetted illegal mostly male migrants to add to that bubbling pot too which adds a new dimension of utter disregard and destruction.

Open unvetted borders. This is where it leads to.

The immigrants have been described as setting up their own ghettos, where they've all been placed and forgotten about. If they've no ties to or respect for their host country, is it any wonder why we are seeing violence injected into the protests.

igglepiggll · 21/10/2026 09:22

LuckyHazelFox · 21/10/2026 09:19

The immigrants have been described as setting up their own ghettos, where they've all been placed and forgotten about. If they've no ties to or respect for their host country, is it any wonder why we are seeing violence injected into the protests.

What is society meant to do with a huge influx of male immigrants who can’t speak the language. Hug them and take them to your place of employment? How exactly would you integrate them?

CandidLurker · 21/10/2026 09:30

Immigrants to France mainly will speak the language as they come from countries where French is widely spoken like Algeria, former African colonies etc

Greenseawitch · 21/10/2026 09:55

Sausagenbacon · 19/10/2026 15:40

They aren’t students and they aren’t French.
The problem is that they are French. 2nd or 3rd generation Algerians

Why is it a problem?

France is a former colonial power and had no problem with imposing their rule Algeria, Morocco and Tunisia.

That comes with consequences, including people from this country immigrating to France when it relinquished control.

Their offsprings are French citizen and are in or have been through the French education system. It really is not hard to understand.

Stop making this an excuse to have a go at 'immigrants'.

If you look at the footage the majority of the people who demonstrated are white but the way and so are the leaders of the students movement.

Goldenbear · 21/10/2026 10:07

igglepiggll · 21/10/2026 09:11

“The kids protesting about their schooling are NOT the ones who are looting and damaging things”

This could be largely correct. My SIL is currently in Bordeaux. This is her take on it;
It started as protests over schooling however soon lots of other forces joined particularly the young not in employment. This then quickly turned into the “cost of living” riots and looting started. You also have the large section of the illegal male migrants who are also bottom of the socio economic ladder who are struggling and these people know how to do violence as they have had to fight it. They have no respect for historic buildings or French culture hence they go further than looting, they burn and destroy.

Whenever inflation is running high it is increasing the cost of goods and energy and so such riots erupt. It happened in London 2011, there was looting then also. However now we have unvetted illegal mostly male migrants to add to that bubbling pot too which adds a new dimension of utter disregard and destruction.

Open unvetted borders. This is where it leads to.

But it's not the first time France has seen this level of civil unrest, youth challenging the social-political set up, nothing to do with your interpretation.

PammyPrang · 21/10/2026 10:25

Goldenbear · 21/10/2026 10:07

But it's not the first time France has seen this level of civil unrest, youth challenging the social-political set up, nothing to do with your interpretation.

Really? Looting, arson, beating up shopkeepers? These actions are hardly erecting barricades and pulling up paving stones, are they?

I see Georgia Meloni has said that these crimes are nothing to do with politics. And legislation has been put through to fine the parents of rioters.

Goldenbear · 21/10/2026 10:48

PammyPrang · 21/10/2026 10:25

Really? Looting, arson, beating up shopkeepers? These actions are hardly erecting barricades and pulling up paving stones, are they?

I see Georgia Meloni has said that these crimes are nothing to do with politics. And legislation has been put through to fine the parents of rioters.

Oh right.

Utahthecat · 21/10/2026 13:38

They have caught the suspect who set fire to the town hall in Limoges - he's an ultra-leftist in his thirties known to police. Not a student, not an immigrant trying to get rid of legal documents or an islamist who hates French culture but a local guy.

Today Macron didn't specifically mention mumsnet ;) but we can see the trends. For those reading, rather than posting disinformation about a country they don't live in, when multiple French posters and their president says it's not about immigration, maybe give them the benefit of the doubt. There are a lot of bad faith posters here pushing a very specific agenda.

Macron slams 'stupid' comments about France riots by world leaders
.... 'There was foreign manipulation of information which led to unacceptable and even stupid comments by many, including foreign leaders,' the French president told reporters in Doha after a trip to the Gulf.

Macron said the leaders were taking aim at France in the context of upcoming elections in their countries and added that they had been influenced by fake videos generated by artificial intelligence (AI) about the riots. "There was foreign manipulation of information which led to unacceptable and even stupid comments by many, including foreign leaders,"

Macron emphasized he did not see "foreign interference" in what unfolded in France at the weekend. But he warned: "We saw images generated by AI which showed scenes that never took place in France. We had people who explained that we had been 'invaded by hordes of migrants and Islamists' – which is totally false."In these moments, you see who likes France and who does not"

https://www.lemonde.fr/en/france/article/2026/10/21/macron-slams-stupid-comments-about-france-riots-by-world-leaders_6760927_7.html

Swipe left for the next trending thread