Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To think there are way too many engagement farming threads on MN nowadays? s?

199 replies

MrMurphysComeuppance · 16/10/2026 15:37

Do you know what an engagement farming thread is, and what the classic signs are to spot one? If not then you are probably being taken in on a daily basis on this forum by 'posters' who are not genuine about problems and dilemmas that are not real.

The site is absolutely awash with them. It's been a big issue for the last year or so and it really is getting ridiculous now. These 'posters' often start threads that can run for days and days with pages of responses, but after the initial OP and maybe one or two quick follow up posts, the 'OP' is nowhere to be seen. And they are always (or almost always) a first time poster/brand new user name. Even if they have posted on one or two other threads that day (very rare and only done occasionally to make the account look more genuine) they never have a proper posting history. There is a very good reason for this, which I can explain if anyone is interested.

Now I've been here a really long time and I name change often these days, for privacy reasons, but there is NO WAY I name change for every single thread I start and NO WAY I use a new name each and every time for my one thread only, without ever engaging on anyone else's threads using that same user name. Who on earth has time for that? That's just not normal forum behaviour. And yet that is what is happening on here, multiple times a day, across several accounts that only exist to generate fake threads and therefore traffic.

I can spot them a mile off now, they are so formulaic and predictable, but it really irritates me that so many posters are so gullible and get caught up in these long debates, giving their time and advice where is no genuine OP at the heart of it. You are being taken for suckers.

I can give you a detailed breakdown of what to look for in a probable engagement farming thread (or rage bait as they are often called, although they are often not always designed to get people in a rage, often just to spark long conversations and polarise opinion on a subject.)

MN is full of actual, intelligent human beings who are more than capable of starting interesting conversations by themselves. Or at least it used to be. Do we really need people/bots creating accounts then name changing several times a day to churn out fake thread after fake thread just to keep the clicks coming? It has massively dumbed down the site and no-one seems to care. Certainly the people who run the site don't seem to care, and why would they, when key strokes and clicks mean ££££?

OP posts:
MrMurphysComeuppance · 24/10/2026 10:57

I've just started a thread in site stuff asking MNHQ to limit the number of name changes an account can have in a short time frame. That would go a really long way to solving this. It remains to be seen whether they are remotely motivated to deal with it.

OP posts:
Wistfultearia · 24/10/2026 13:06

MrMurphysComeuppance · 24/10/2026 10:57

I've just started a thread in site stuff asking MNHQ to limit the number of name changes an account can have in a short time frame. That would go a really long way to solving this. It remains to be seen whether they are remotely motivated to deal with it.

I get the impression that MNHQ are not bothered about this kind of thing.
Sorry if I've missed a previous post that is relevant to this, but why would limiting name changes help? Do you suspect that a small number of users keep name changing to create new threads, rather than creating a new login for each new thread?

Thecatspantaloons · 24/10/2026 16:18

Wistfultearia · 24/10/2026 13:06

I get the impression that MNHQ are not bothered about this kind of thing.
Sorry if I've missed a previous post that is relevant to this, but why would limiting name changes help? Do you suspect that a small number of users keep name changing to create new threads, rather than creating a new login for each new thread?

I've seen OP's name change in the middle of a thread, but not for reasons of pretending to be someone who agrees with them but because they obviously routinely have more than one account on the go and they accidentally fcked up and replied using the alternative account.

It's funny as fuck when it happens.

Wistfultearia · 24/10/2026 16:20

Thecatspantaloons · 24/10/2026 16:18

I've seen OP's name change in the middle of a thread, but not for reasons of pretending to be someone who agrees with them but because they obviously routinely have more than one account on the go and they accidentally fcked up and replied using the alternative account.

It's funny as fuck when it happens.

Ah, the old sock-puppetry technique , but by accident!

MrMurphysComeuppance · 24/10/2026 17:41

Wistfultearia · 24/10/2026 13:06

I get the impression that MNHQ are not bothered about this kind of thing.
Sorry if I've missed a previous post that is relevant to this, but why would limiting name changes help? Do you suspect that a small number of users keep name changing to create new threads, rather than creating a new login for each new thread?

Yes. I do. I think if your sole purpose is to create as many long running threads as possible because it's your job to, and it in some way benefits you or your organisation financially, then it's a lot easier to repeatedly name change under one MN registration than to keep re-registering multiple new accounts under multiple different emails each time. I'm sure both things happen, but it's obviously much less work to simply name change daily within the account you already have.

The issue is with the constant creation of new user names that are only ever used once to start one fake thread, then ditched. There is never any posting history outside of that one thread and once that thread had died, the name never gets used again. Understandable if it's obviously for privacy reasons on a very sensitive or identifying thread, but most of the time that simply isn't the case and the threads have all the signs of being AI written.

OP posts:
Aquasoap · 25/10/2026 12:12

Wistfultearia · 24/10/2026 16:20

Ah, the old sock-puppetry technique , but by accident!

I once nearly sock-puppeted myself on an old thread (I must have had a new account). I was delighted to find someone who shared my point of view!

nomas · 25/10/2026 12:26

MrMurphysComeuppance · 16/10/2026 19:37

Never tried to hide that they make up content and fake scenarios presented as real posters with real problems? Really? When? I've never seen them admit any such thing.

There is absolutely nothing wrong with MN creating content and coming up with ideas for discussion on their own forum providing they are open that it's them and not pretending to be genuine posters, making up fake problems in order to get posters' attention. Then it's just plain dishonest. How is that any different to actual trolling if the intention is to deceive?

Anyway, I am not saying categorically that it's MN doing it. But someone is certainly doing it.

I don’t think MNHQ are doing it.

But I think there is an issue with how some threads are started.

Like single issue posters. Posters who name change and who only post about Andy Burnham or immigrants or anti-Islam posts. They have no interest in anything else which I find strange.

Wistfultearia · 25/10/2026 12:45

I wouldn't go so far as to say MN are creating threads, but I suspect they know that AI threads are being created possibly to train or test AI, or to push a political agenda, and do nothing about it.

Thecatspantaloons · 25/10/2026 13:16

nomas · 25/10/2026 12:26

I don’t think MNHQ are doing it.

But I think there is an issue with how some threads are started.

Like single issue posters. Posters who name change and who only post about Andy Burnham or immigrants or anti-Islam posts. They have no interest in anything else which I find strange.

This is precisely some of the disruption the government are warning us about - bad actors sowing discontent online. I have noticed more and more posters in agreement to what is being said. In real life too.

We are so cooked.

Rosegla55es · 25/10/2026 13:36

Thecatspantaloons · 25/10/2026 13:16

This is precisely some of the disruption the government are warning us about - bad actors sowing discontent online. I have noticed more and more posters in agreement to what is being said. In real life too.

We are so cooked.

MN are blatantly playing a part though- due to money. I complained this week re the mobility vehicles thread. You know the weekly let’s bash the disabled/ or whatever vulnerable group of choice type, the type that would have gone poof a few years back before they liked the money they make from advertising which relies on click numbers. Their answer was “it doesn’t break any of our talk guidelines”.Errrr don’t you set them? As such they are blatantly colluding for no other reason than money and I seriously think it’s time the government clamped down on forums doing this. It’s dispicable, leaving vulnerable groups out to dry as easy targets inciting hate whilst they rake in the cash. Whats particularly unpleasant about MN is they trade on being a safe supportive place for all mums when it absolutely isn’t.

bigsquid · 26/10/2026 13:42

Completely agree that mumsnet are playing their part. Mumsnet workers - listen up.

Contributing to the epistemic insecurity of our society is a DIRECT threat to democracy. And you doing this is what it looks like in practice. This is not a drill.

You should watch the Channel 4 programme about how easy it is to get people to become Nazi scapegoaters of others (while richly appreciating the irony given their ADHD programme).

This is what autocracies rely on, this is the threat, scapegoating the poor, the minoritised, the disabled, the immigrant - this is what the bad actors want us to do. It's happening now. And you are not on the right side of history if you provide a lovely welcoming space for it.

Moral injury is a thing that can happen to you when your job requires.you to do bad things. Honestly, letting these threads up is bad and harmful - and it's on you. Entirely on you.

By the by I shall be interested in what happens to the "Ive got 3 kids with SEN and I wfh taking the piss" thread today.

EasternStandard · 26/10/2026 14:03

nomas · 25/10/2026 12:26

I don’t think MNHQ are doing it.

But I think there is an issue with how some threads are started.

Like single issue posters. Posters who name change and who only post about Andy Burnham or immigrants or anti-Islam posts. They have no interest in anything else which I find strange.

But then you have posters who only respond on this.

Plus posters n/c as they get attacks from some and even AI scraping by a few invested enough to do that. So I don’t blame them.

BlackbirdSingingintheTrees · 26/10/2026 14:08

bigsquid · 26/10/2026 13:42

Completely agree that mumsnet are playing their part. Mumsnet workers - listen up.

Contributing to the epistemic insecurity of our society is a DIRECT threat to democracy. And you doing this is what it looks like in practice. This is not a drill.

You should watch the Channel 4 programme about how easy it is to get people to become Nazi scapegoaters of others (while richly appreciating the irony given their ADHD programme).

This is what autocracies rely on, this is the threat, scapegoating the poor, the minoritised, the disabled, the immigrant - this is what the bad actors want us to do. It's happening now. And you are not on the right side of history if you provide a lovely welcoming space for it.

Moral injury is a thing that can happen to you when your job requires.you to do bad things. Honestly, letting these threads up is bad and harmful - and it's on you. Entirely on you.

By the by I shall be interested in what happens to the "Ive got 3 kids with SEN and I wfh taking the piss" thread today.

Agree with this. Also with the point above that going "oh but we're just a platform" is incongruent with the whole "making parents' lives easier" thing.

Also, it's even more problematic when posts on here are actively mined, synthesised and sold as genuine by Mumsnet, for money or as part of the political process (e.g. presented at select committees).

Mossyfox · 26/10/2026 14:10

I haven't seen any posts about farming.

Rosegla55es · 26/10/2026 14:14

BlackbirdSingingintheTrees · 26/10/2026 14:08

Agree with this. Also with the point above that going "oh but we're just a platform" is incongruent with the whole "making parents' lives easier" thing.

Also, it's even more problematic when posts on here are actively mined, synthesised and sold as genuine by Mumsnet, for money or as part of the political process (e.g. presented at select committees).

Absolutely this.

Rosegla55es · 26/10/2026 14:15

bigsquid · 26/10/2026 13:42

Completely agree that mumsnet are playing their part. Mumsnet workers - listen up.

Contributing to the epistemic insecurity of our society is a DIRECT threat to democracy. And you doing this is what it looks like in practice. This is not a drill.

You should watch the Channel 4 programme about how easy it is to get people to become Nazi scapegoaters of others (while richly appreciating the irony given their ADHD programme).

This is what autocracies rely on, this is the threat, scapegoating the poor, the minoritised, the disabled, the immigrant - this is what the bad actors want us to do. It's happening now. And you are not on the right side of history if you provide a lovely welcoming space for it.

Moral injury is a thing that can happen to you when your job requires.you to do bad things. Honestly, letting these threads up is bad and harmful - and it's on you. Entirely on you.

By the by I shall be interested in what happens to the "Ive got 3 kids with SEN and I wfh taking the piss" thread today.

And this!

Thecatspantaloons · 26/10/2026 14:38

bigsquid · 26/10/2026 13:42

Completely agree that mumsnet are playing their part. Mumsnet workers - listen up.

Contributing to the epistemic insecurity of our society is a DIRECT threat to democracy. And you doing this is what it looks like in practice. This is not a drill.

You should watch the Channel 4 programme about how easy it is to get people to become Nazi scapegoaters of others (while richly appreciating the irony given their ADHD programme).

This is what autocracies rely on, this is the threat, scapegoating the poor, the minoritised, the disabled, the immigrant - this is what the bad actors want us to do. It's happening now. And you are not on the right side of history if you provide a lovely welcoming space for it.

Moral injury is a thing that can happen to you when your job requires.you to do bad things. Honestly, letting these threads up is bad and harmful - and it's on you. Entirely on you.

By the by I shall be interested in what happens to the "Ive got 3 kids with SEN and I wfh taking the piss" thread today.

That last one you were referring to is at almost 11 pages deep and because it has all the ingredients 3 sen kids, shithouse husband, WFH piss taking and a partridge in a pear tree, it's attracting both the earnest and the angry posters from all the realms 🫣.

Gingerbreadlattetoppingsontheside · 26/10/2026 14:49

You know you have a choice whether to engage with a thread or not. So do other people. Does the OP intention matter if people are posting and therefore for whatever reason getting something out of the post?

You can also choose to only post on sections of Mumsnet you are interested in.

The Mumsnet's changed/dumbed down threads have been around.on the forums as long as I can remember. Seriously in the twenty(?!?)-ish years ive been on mumsnet theories that matter most have changed but the character of the forum really hasn't much. Except the poster hero worship, thankfully that has died a death somewhat.

Gingerbreadlattetoppingsontheside · 26/10/2026 14:50

Oh and people who pride themselves on troll hunting are so often wrong

Fakeplasticchimneyswhy · 26/10/2026 15:08

Totally agree, OP. And I knew exactly what you meant by engagement farming - I thought most regular users of SM would have by now but it appears not.

WhatNoRaisins · 28/10/2026 07:31

Saw another one today posting a dilemma about a family member. I replied because I've had similar concerns for my parents but the follow up posts don't sound like they're coming from a human if that makes sense.

MrMurphysComeuppance · 29/10/2026 10:46

daisychain01 · 24/10/2026 10:23

The motivation is simply to keep the forum and the website as a whole as busy as possible.

but MNHQ has denied that they are doing this. So if that's true, what motivation does the average poster have to keep the website as a whole as busy as possible,

Well it isn't 'the average user' doing it, so the average user doesn't need the motivation.

It's most likely AI bots learning about how humans respond with empathy, anger etc to different situations. I've been down a few rabbit holes in the last few days learning about how/why this happens on forums and what can be done to stem it. It's fascinating and complex and actually quite terrifying. The motivations are varied, depending on who is behind it.

It's not easy to stamp it out altogether and let's be honest, plenty of forums are not actually motivated to stamp it out altogether because in the short term at least, it appears to be good for business. It's good for their advertising revenue and their optics for any future investment or sale for the board to look busy, even if half the threads are made up.

But that's short sighted and damaging for forums in the long term to allow this to proliferate unchecked. Once most humans who use forums cotton on to the fact that they are being duped/used and they aren't actually interacting with other forum users at all, just responding to wholesale bot threads, they lose respect for the forum, they lose confidence in the forum and they lose any sense of belonging to the forum 'community' because as it turns out, there isn't one. It's a sham.

Certain sites expect you to have contributed to a certain number of other people's threads before you are allowed to start your own threads. Or to register then wait for 24 hours before you can post at all, or have limited new name creations or a limited number of threads you can start in a day on one account, or you can see exactly how long a new account has been active for, etc.

There are several ways in which these bot accounts can have their wings clipped and their activities curtailed, but MNHQ has to want to do it and it's clear that they simply don't because of the short term benefits to them financially.

It could implement any number of fairly simple measures to make it much harder for their threads to proliferate, or at least much easier for us to spot them, but time and again they state the most ridiculous and nonsensical reasons for not doing so.

OP posts:
MrMurphysComeuppance · 29/10/2026 11:42

Aquasoap · 25/10/2026 12:12

I once nearly sock-puppeted myself on an old thread (I must have had a new account). I was delighted to find someone who shared my point of view!

I've done that too. I thought 'I love this woman, she's so sensible.' 😁

For those of us old enough to remember, there was once a thread on here many moons ago from a woman asking for people's experiences of a specific product (I think it was a baby buggy) because she was thinking of buying one.

About a year later she found herself heartily recommending the buggy to someone who was asking about it. She posted her review of the buggy then realised that she responding to herself on her own thread. 😂

OP posts:
Aquasoap · 31/10/2026 00:19

MrMurphysComeuppance · 29/10/2026 11:42

I've done that too. I thought 'I love this woman, she's so sensible.' 😁

For those of us old enough to remember, there was once a thread on here many moons ago from a woman asking for people's experiences of a specific product (I think it was a baby buggy) because she was thinking of buying one.

About a year later she found herself heartily recommending the buggy to someone who was asking about it. She posted her review of the buggy then realised that she responding to herself on her own thread. 😂

I love this!

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread