Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To think there are way too many engagement farming threads on MN nowadays? s?

199 replies

MrMurphysComeuppance · 16/10/2026 15:37

Do you know what an engagement farming thread is, and what the classic signs are to spot one? If not then you are probably being taken in on a daily basis on this forum by 'posters' who are not genuine about problems and dilemmas that are not real.

The site is absolutely awash with them. It's been a big issue for the last year or so and it really is getting ridiculous now. These 'posters' often start threads that can run for days and days with pages of responses, but after the initial OP and maybe one or two quick follow up posts, the 'OP' is nowhere to be seen. And they are always (or almost always) a first time poster/brand new user name. Even if they have posted on one or two other threads that day (very rare and only done occasionally to make the account look more genuine) they never have a proper posting history. There is a very good reason for this, which I can explain if anyone is interested.

Now I've been here a really long time and I name change often these days, for privacy reasons, but there is NO WAY I name change for every single thread I start and NO WAY I use a new name each and every time for my one thread only, without ever engaging on anyone else's threads using that same user name. Who on earth has time for that? That's just not normal forum behaviour. And yet that is what is happening on here, multiple times a day, across several accounts that only exist to generate fake threads and therefore traffic.

I can spot them a mile off now, they are so formulaic and predictable, but it really irritates me that so many posters are so gullible and get caught up in these long debates, giving their time and advice where is no genuine OP at the heart of it. You are being taken for suckers.

I can give you a detailed breakdown of what to look for in a probable engagement farming thread (or rage bait as they are often called, although they are often not always designed to get people in a rage, often just to spark long conversations and polarise opinion on a subject.)

MN is full of actual, intelligent human beings who are more than capable of starting interesting conversations by themselves. Or at least it used to be. Do we really need people/bots creating accounts then name changing several times a day to churn out fake thread after fake thread just to keep the clicks coming? It has massively dumbed down the site and no-one seems to care. Certainly the people who run the site don't seem to care, and why would they, when key strokes and clicks mean ££££?

OP posts:
Thecatspantaloons · 18/10/2026 20:47

MrMurphysComeuppance · 18/10/2026 18:42

I find most commonly to be MIL problems, a friend behaving badly, a colleague behaving badly, affairs, inheritance issues, weddings. All the usual stuff except that where there would usually be a fairly obvious solution, this can never be applied, for some complicated reason or other.

Or it's something very clearly designed to set the cat among the pigeons. I'd love to give a couple of current examples but I can't. I'd get suspended.

Edited

It's always the cat amongst the pigeons bit that alerts my hackles - and worse, when it comes in a drip feed and is the most crucial element to the story.

So you will get a lot of knee jerk opinions, then a lot of informed opinions , then you get a lot of informed opinioners telling the knee jerkers to read the OP updates and on and on it goes.
Tedious AF.

Rosegla55es · 19/10/2026 06:35

The ceasing of removing threads because “it’s not in the spirit of MN” interestingly seemed to stop when advertising and MN revenue massively increased. Now vulnerable groups can just suck it up.

flumpkeu · 19/10/2026 08:40

Another type of thread to add to the list of which I’ve seen 2 today, made up surveys to discuss, OP posts controversial survey result, encourages discussion and disappears. I find these highly suspect.

flumpkeu · 19/10/2026 09:06

If you want to see proof of engagement farming look up bigred26 posts. Tell me that’s not a bot or a person with an agenda.

Palmtreesinthegarden · 19/10/2026 09:09

I couldn’t imagine being bothered by this. I didn’t think anyone took MN that seriously

Cloudsaandcastles · 19/10/2026 09:14

flumpkeu · 19/10/2026 09:06

If you want to see proof of engagement farming look up bigred26 posts. Tell me that’s not a bot or a person with an agenda.

100%
There is always some influx of posts which have exactly same format at the time. It used to be different usernames though.

HorseandHeron · 19/10/2026 09:23

I agree OP. I have often thought they are AI trawling for emotionally rational responses to outlandish situations.

They are always along the lines: DH is really angry with me because I no longer want sex. I work an 80 hour week and my husband lies in bed all day, but I do all the childcare, cooking and cleaning and honestly, I am so tired. AIBU to not feel up to romance?

This triggers hundreds of LTB responses, and feminist advice to insist on fairly sharing the work load and some misguided oafs suggesting ways to pep up libido etc.

Another version is: My friend earns three million a year and I earn sixpence a week but she always expects us to split the bill equally when she has lobster and champagne and i have a glass of water and a bowl of gruel. AIBU? I don;t want to seem tight.

The posts are always about hideously, comically villainously unreasonable men and doormat saintly women. Or hideously selfish friends of people pleasers.

Another version is some useless fecker she met online who wants to move in with her and her DC/try weird fetish games after their first date of walking around a wet park on a cold day which she had her hair and nails done specially for, and travelled 150 miles to meet him there.

The posts are usually very long but clearly written, in true AI style.

I used to get sucked in but just ignore them now.

The best way to kill them is not to engage with them.

Thecatspantaloons · 19/10/2026 13:07

HorseandHeron · 19/10/2026 09:23

I agree OP. I have often thought they are AI trawling for emotionally rational responses to outlandish situations.

They are always along the lines: DH is really angry with me because I no longer want sex. I work an 80 hour week and my husband lies in bed all day, but I do all the childcare, cooking and cleaning and honestly, I am so tired. AIBU to not feel up to romance?

This triggers hundreds of LTB responses, and feminist advice to insist on fairly sharing the work load and some misguided oafs suggesting ways to pep up libido etc.

Another version is: My friend earns three million a year and I earn sixpence a week but she always expects us to split the bill equally when she has lobster and champagne and i have a glass of water and a bowl of gruel. AIBU? I don;t want to seem tight.

The posts are always about hideously, comically villainously unreasonable men and doormat saintly women. Or hideously selfish friends of people pleasers.

Another version is some useless fecker she met online who wants to move in with her and her DC/try weird fetish games after their first date of walking around a wet park on a cold day which she had her hair and nails done specially for, and travelled 150 miles to meet him there.

The posts are usually very long but clearly written, in true AI style.

I used to get sucked in but just ignore them now.

The best way to kill them is not to engage with them.

Those examples absolutely nail it - so outrageously over the top, and what's worse is the 25,000 earnest replies i hate them more than the OP, are we really that gullible .
If I'm in a humourous mood I'll simply post a popcorn emoji and sit back and enjoy.
If I'm annoyed which is a lot of the time, then my comment gets deleted .

Then I discovered dead internet theory and now I suspect many of those 25,000 replies are also bots .

bigsquid · 19/10/2026 13:10

BeckyAMumsnet · 17/10/2026 10:09

Hi all. Just wanted to address a few points here.

We completely understand the frustration with threads that don't appear genuine but we're not convinced 'engagement farming' is really a thing on Mumsnet in the way it is on other platforms. There's no creator economy rewarding people for going viral.

Just to be absolutely clear, MNHQ doesn't create fake threads or employ people or bots to manufacture discussions. The suggestion that we'd deliberately deceive users to boost advertising revenue simply isn't true. It would also be a pretty daft way to run a community that depends on people's trust.

We'd also caution against assuming that certain posting patterns are evidence of trolling. New usernames, dramatic threads and OPs who don't return are all perfectly normal features of pretty much every online community. The danger of treating suspicion as fact is that genuine posters end up being interrogated or accused of lying, which isn't particularly welcoming, especially for people looking for support.

Please do report anything you're concerned about. We take those reports seriously, but we'd ask people to remember that suspecting a thread isn't genuine and knowing it isn't genuine are two rather different things.

Thanks
MNHQ

I appreciate your points but it would be more convincing if you were to share what you do to ensure this is not happening, as well as reassuring words.

Do you, for example, actually check threads where the OP doesn't return and see whether they are repeat posters (as you have the under the hood records of all our name changes linked to our accounts)?

Do you have any automated system in place to flag up problematic posting behaviours?

Obviously you don't have to tell us what the systems are but it would be more plausible if you could share statistics with us from your management of the platform, so you are demonstrably handling this stuff.

Or, if this is just something you think is "probably no big deal" but haven't actually yet investigated, why don't you commit to a small review of this, now it has been brought to your attention? It's something that erodes our good faith. Since reading this thread I have found 4 threads I thought were "real" and now I'm not sure. I'd love to put it out of my mind and take your comments on trust, but there seems a valid hypothesis here that OP proposes, and now we need evidence either way.

There's all sorts of things you could add if this proves an issue, like a flag to our names, saying how long this account has been active or how many times the user has posted under any name (up to 10, up to 100, more than that, etc).

A "community built on trust" only works if you are actively demonstrating trustworthiness - and if it costs you some time and energy to do so.

CrystalSingerFan · 19/10/2026 14:48

MrMurphysComeuppance · 16/10/2026 15:37

Do you know what an engagement farming thread is, and what the classic signs are to spot one? If not then you are probably being taken in on a daily basis on this forum by 'posters' who are not genuine about problems and dilemmas that are not real.

The site is absolutely awash with them. It's been a big issue for the last year or so and it really is getting ridiculous now. These 'posters' often start threads that can run for days and days with pages of responses, but after the initial OP and maybe one or two quick follow up posts, the 'OP' is nowhere to be seen. And they are always (or almost always) a first time poster/brand new user name. Even if they have posted on one or two other threads that day (very rare and only done occasionally to make the account look more genuine) they never have a proper posting history. There is a very good reason for this, which I can explain if anyone is interested.

Now I've been here a really long time and I name change often these days, for privacy reasons, but there is NO WAY I name change for every single thread I start and NO WAY I use a new name each and every time for my one thread only, without ever engaging on anyone else's threads using that same user name. Who on earth has time for that? That's just not normal forum behaviour. And yet that is what is happening on here, multiple times a day, across several accounts that only exist to generate fake threads and therefore traffic.

I can spot them a mile off now, they are so formulaic and predictable, but it really irritates me that so many posters are so gullible and get caught up in these long debates, giving their time and advice where is no genuine OP at the heart of it. You are being taken for suckers.

I can give you a detailed breakdown of what to look for in a probable engagement farming thread (or rage bait as they are often called, although they are often not always designed to get people in a rage, often just to spark long conversations and polarise opinion on a subject.)

MN is full of actual, intelligent human beings who are more than capable of starting interesting conversations by themselves. Or at least it used to be. Do we really need people/bots creating accounts then name changing several times a day to churn out fake thread after fake thread just to keep the clicks coming? It has massively dumbed down the site and no-one seems to care. Certainly the people who run the site don't seem to care, and why would they, when key strokes and clicks mean ££££?

Well, I care. What's your view on the petting bunny rabbits thread? I haven't enjoyed a thread so much for ages.

MrMurphysComeuppance · 19/10/2026 16:34

HorseandHeron · 19/10/2026 09:23

I agree OP. I have often thought they are AI trawling for emotionally rational responses to outlandish situations.

They are always along the lines: DH is really angry with me because I no longer want sex. I work an 80 hour week and my husband lies in bed all day, but I do all the childcare, cooking and cleaning and honestly, I am so tired. AIBU to not feel up to romance?

This triggers hundreds of LTB responses, and feminist advice to insist on fairly sharing the work load and some misguided oafs suggesting ways to pep up libido etc.

Another version is: My friend earns three million a year and I earn sixpence a week but she always expects us to split the bill equally when she has lobster and champagne and i have a glass of water and a bowl of gruel. AIBU? I don;t want to seem tight.

The posts are always about hideously, comically villainously unreasonable men and doormat saintly women. Or hideously selfish friends of people pleasers.

Another version is some useless fecker she met online who wants to move in with her and her DC/try weird fetish games after their first date of walking around a wet park on a cold day which she had her hair and nails done specially for, and travelled 150 miles to meet him there.

The posts are usually very long but clearly written, in true AI style.

I used to get sucked in but just ignore them now.

The best way to kill them is not to engage with them.

Nail hit squarely on the head. I don't want to engage, and I don't really, beyond the odd pithy comment that hopefully alert others to the fact that it's a steaming pile of made up shit. I want other people to know what is happening and see these annoying threads for what they are, so they can stop engaging as well. 😂

I honestly can't imagine that any half intelligent (or even fairly dim and easily pleased) person would bother getting engrossed in these threads if they realised what was going on and could spot the patterns of an obvious fake thread. I think they just genuinely haven't twigged yet. I am doing a public information service here. 😁

OP posts:
MrMurphysComeuppance · 19/10/2026 16:39

CrystalSingerFan · 19/10/2026 14:48

Well, I care. What's your view on the petting bunny rabbits thread? I haven't enjoyed a thread so much for ages.

Haven't read it but just had a quick look and it looks genuine to me. A poster with lots of posting history on various threads under their belt. Lots of engagement with the responses on her own thread. Not just a dump and run job. Maybe a contentious subject for a thread but it doesn't scream AI BOT thread to me, no. It doesn't fit the pattern I notice over and over again.

OP posts:
CrystalSingerFan · 19/10/2026 17:00

MrMurphysComeuppance · 19/10/2026 16:39

Haven't read it but just had a quick look and it looks genuine to me. A poster with lots of posting history on various threads under their belt. Lots of engagement with the responses on her own thread. Not just a dump and run job. Maybe a contentious subject for a thread but it doesn't scream AI BOT thread to me, no. It doesn't fit the pattern I notice over and over again.

Edited

Pleased to hear that. Keep fighting the good fight.

MrMurphysComeuppance · 20/10/2026 09:44

usernumbernotfound · 17/10/2026 09:20

I completely agree with you OP and what I find particularly frustrating is when posters literally warn others that a post is obviously fake (due to the advanced search function) and then they get attacked for using that function as if they are the ones with the problem!

People then start to brag about how they never search posters names because they arent stalkers etc and I just think alrighty then, carry on posting on a completely fake, made up thread- you're only wasting your own damn time- and they do! pages and pages of comments and arguing about a scenario thats a complete fabrication!

I've actually been suspended and threatened with a banning for doing exactly that. I was made to promise not to do it directly on those threads any more. Hence why I am doing it on this thread instead, but I still have to be careful about referencing specific threads or posters.

OP posts:
MrMurphysComeuppance · 20/10/2026 10:12

flumpkeu · 19/10/2026 09:06

If you want to see proof of engagement farming look up bigred26 posts. Tell me that’s not a bot or a person with an agenda.

I've just come across that poster. I see exactly what you mean. However, I don't object to it because it's very clear what they are doing. They just want a variety of opinions of specific topics, a bit like the Jeremy Vine phone in on R2.

The format is 'This has come to everyone's attention today via the news/social media and is dividing opinion. What is your take on it?'

It's very obviously not just some regular poster who is using MN to distract herself while BFing on a wet Wednesday, but AT NO POINT does this poster lie or pretend to be someone they are not, with a dilemma or a problem that has been completely fabricated to reel people in. They also start many threads under the same user name because they have nothing to hide and no fake character arc to keep track of across several threads. This is the reason these posters only ever use a user name for one thread only. So they are not tripped up by their own lies and inconsistencies across the many, many threads they dump on the forum.

With bigred26 there is no intention to deceive, no lies and no-one's time is being wasted by giving their considered advice or well-meant sympathy to some person or bot who is doesn't give a shit about the replies, isn't even reading them and is simply performing a job of work.

That's the important difference to me. If MN wants or needs more content to keep things busy then it could easily enough just do that in a more overt way and people would still contribute, because it's an interesting chat and people like to be heard. Just like phoning up Jeremy Vine and having your say on whatever the topic of the day is.

I think if whoever is behind these 'one time poster' threads were to be more transparent and just change tack by presenting them as a WWYD in THIS HYPOTHETICAL SCENARIO topic, people would still engage and give their opinions just for the fun of it.

It's the cynical, blatant dishonesty I don't like. We are being taken for stupid.

OP posts:
MrMurphysComeuppance · 21/10/2026 17:26

bigsquid · 19/10/2026 13:10

I appreciate your points but it would be more convincing if you were to share what you do to ensure this is not happening, as well as reassuring words.

Do you, for example, actually check threads where the OP doesn't return and see whether they are repeat posters (as you have the under the hood records of all our name changes linked to our accounts)?

Do you have any automated system in place to flag up problematic posting behaviours?

Obviously you don't have to tell us what the systems are but it would be more plausible if you could share statistics with us from your management of the platform, so you are demonstrably handling this stuff.

Or, if this is just something you think is "probably no big deal" but haven't actually yet investigated, why don't you commit to a small review of this, now it has been brought to your attention? It's something that erodes our good faith. Since reading this thread I have found 4 threads I thought were "real" and now I'm not sure. I'd love to put it out of my mind and take your comments on trust, but there seems a valid hypothesis here that OP proposes, and now we need evidence either way.

There's all sorts of things you could add if this proves an issue, like a flag to our names, saying how long this account has been active or how many times the user has posted under any name (up to 10, up to 100, more than that, etc).

A "community built on trust" only works if you are actively demonstrating trustworthiness - and if it costs you some time and energy to do so.

Totally agree with all of that and have asked similar questions myself before. Unfortunately I think we are banging our heads against a brick wall here. As you say, there are so many things that could be done, but MNHQ has to have the motivation to want to do it. They simply don't. Make of that what you will.

OP posts:
Aquasoap · 22/10/2026 00:08

MrMurphysComeuppance · 16/10/2026 15:37

Do you know what an engagement farming thread is, and what the classic signs are to spot one? If not then you are probably being taken in on a daily basis on this forum by 'posters' who are not genuine about problems and dilemmas that are not real.

The site is absolutely awash with them. It's been a big issue for the last year or so and it really is getting ridiculous now. These 'posters' often start threads that can run for days and days with pages of responses, but after the initial OP and maybe one or two quick follow up posts, the 'OP' is nowhere to be seen. And they are always (or almost always) a first time poster/brand new user name. Even if they have posted on one or two other threads that day (very rare and only done occasionally to make the account look more genuine) they never have a proper posting history. There is a very good reason for this, which I can explain if anyone is interested.

Now I've been here a really long time and I name change often these days, for privacy reasons, but there is NO WAY I name change for every single thread I start and NO WAY I use a new name each and every time for my one thread only, without ever engaging on anyone else's threads using that same user name. Who on earth has time for that? That's just not normal forum behaviour. And yet that is what is happening on here, multiple times a day, across several accounts that only exist to generate fake threads and therefore traffic.

I can spot them a mile off now, they are so formulaic and predictable, but it really irritates me that so many posters are so gullible and get caught up in these long debates, giving their time and advice where is no genuine OP at the heart of it. You are being taken for suckers.

I can give you a detailed breakdown of what to look for in a probable engagement farming thread (or rage bait as they are often called, although they are often not always designed to get people in a rage, often just to spark long conversations and polarise opinion on a subject.)

MN is full of actual, intelligent human beings who are more than capable of starting interesting conversations by themselves. Or at least it used to be. Do we really need people/bots creating accounts then name changing several times a day to churn out fake thread after fake thread just to keep the clicks coming? It has massively dumbed down the site and no-one seems to care. Certainly the people who run the site don't seem to care, and why would they, when key strokes and clicks mean ££££?

Im not sure it is full of actual intelligent people anymore. Or at least, not enough to make enough money.

daisychain01 · 22/10/2026 06:53

With bigred26 there is no intention to deceive, no lies and no-one's time is being wasted by giving their considered advice or well-meant sympathy to some person or bot who is doesn't give a shit about the replies, isn't even reading them and is simply performing a job of work.

but what's the motivation behind posting all the threads, why do that?

To my mind the more people like that fill MN with a lot of unfiltered dross and slop it puts me off. As it is, I find myself clicking away from the majority of threads because they are either so far fetched I know they are AI generated or I don't feel the OP has any skin in the game about the situation they're posting about (and now MNHQ are bumping some of them that makes them even less appealing).

Aquasoap · 22/10/2026 09:27

Aquasoap · 22/10/2026 00:08

Im not sure it is full of actual intelligent people anymore. Or at least, not enough to make enough money.

That was so badly written, I think I've proved my own point!

MrMurphysComeuppance · 24/10/2026 09:12

Aquasoap · 22/10/2026 00:08

Im not sure it is full of actual intelligent people anymore. Or at least, not enough to make enough money.

I think you are right. Certainly judging by the number of people who say they really don't care if half the threads on here are made up, so long as they keep them entertained and anyone who disagrees is 'taking MN far too seriously.'

Where did all the intelligent, funny women on here go? I can't remember the last time anything on MN really made laugh. I think it was probably around 2018.

OP posts:
CatesandAle · 24/10/2026 09:41

Blarn · 16/10/2026 16:10

While I do agree, you are not going to get many people seeing past the fact you have called them suckers and that mn usesd to be full of intelligent people. Lots of people here are tired and just looking for ways to pass the time while a small child is asleep on them.

That’s an interesting take on why people often seem so angry on here.

MrMurphysComeuppance · 24/10/2026 09:53

daisychain01 · 22/10/2026 06:53

With bigred26 there is no intention to deceive, no lies and no-one's time is being wasted by giving their considered advice or well-meant sympathy to some person or bot who is doesn't give a shit about the replies, isn't even reading them and is simply performing a job of work.

but what's the motivation behind posting all the threads, why do that?

To my mind the more people like that fill MN with a lot of unfiltered dross and slop it puts me off. As it is, I find myself clicking away from the majority of threads because they are either so far fetched I know they are AI generated or I don't feel the OP has any skin in the game about the situation they're posting about (and now MNHQ are bumping some of them that makes them even less appealing).

I agree with you, but we've been told numerous times on this thread that we have to expect a certain amount of (corporately generated) deliberate thread placement purely to keep the forum busy and give people things to discuss. I understand that is always going to happen and it's unavoidable to an extent. I just really, really detest the dishonesty behind the wholesale generating of fake dilemmas and problems thing. At least with the bigred26 type threads you know what you are getting and it's harmless.

I also agree though, that the more of that sort of content there is, the less anyone half intelligent is inclined to engage properly full stop, so the need to manufacture engagement becomes a self fulfilling prophesy.

Perhaps it's just time for me to accept that this forum isn't what it used to be and I've well and truly outgrown it.

OP posts:
MrMurphysComeuppance · 24/10/2026 10:09

daisychain01 · 22/10/2026 06:53

With bigred26 there is no intention to deceive, no lies and no-one's time is being wasted by giving their considered advice or well-meant sympathy to some person or bot who is doesn't give a shit about the replies, isn't even reading them and is simply performing a job of work.

but what's the motivation behind posting all the threads, why do that?

To my mind the more people like that fill MN with a lot of unfiltered dross and slop it puts me off. As it is, I find myself clicking away from the majority of threads because they are either so far fetched I know they are AI generated or I don't feel the OP has any skin in the game about the situation they're posting about (and now MNHQ are bumping some of them that makes them even less appealing).

but what's the motivation behind posting all the threads, why do that?

The motivation is simply to keep the forum and the website as a whole as busy as possible. It could be to increase exposure to advertising or to make the site's visitor engagement figures more attractive to future advertisers or investors or potential buyers. Sometimes it could be someone completely unrelated to any of those things, but just carrying out their own research for whatever reason. Or AI itself, learning about how humans react and respond to different situations. All or any of those things.

OP posts:
daisychain01 · 24/10/2026 10:23

The motivation is simply to keep the forum and the website as a whole as busy as possible.

but MNHQ has denied that they are doing this. So if that's true, what motivation does the average poster have to keep the website as a whole as busy as possible,

Wistfultearia · 24/10/2026 10:24

I agree OP but it's not fair to say genuine posters who haven't noticed the pattern and drawn the same conclusion are gullible. Not everyone examines the threads with the same care. That's probably why it works.
What I wonder is whether real people think up the scenario and start the thread, or whether the threads are AI generated. They often seem to be based on another recent thread , either a similar situation with details changed, or a reverse.Almost certainly AI but who knows, maybe some people like getting the reaction.