OP, I really get where you're coming from. I too have largely given up on people who don't reply for months on end - sometimes longer. Meeting up once a year and having a catch-up is not enough for me.
But don't feel it's your personality that's the problem. I am sort of that show-stopping personality you talked about. I'm not bragging here - well, trying not to! - but I know I'm good company. I know I can make people laugh. I see people visibly having a good time when we're together. And guess what? It doesn't make any difference to whether they want to stay in touch.
I think the nature of friendship has changed. And yes, it's a lot to do with social media. But it's not to do with the young or their habits changing expectations. I'd say my generation - I'm in my 60s - are more affected by social media than my kids are. Me & DW are certainly on our phones more than them. They're in their 20s and 30s, they largely disdain social media - at least, the conventional Facebook/Instagram/Twitter/Snapchat end of things. Instead, they have tight friendship groups organized around Discord servers and computer gaming. They're spread across the country and meet up relatively seldom; maybe twice a year. But that doesn't seem to matter very much to them.
Whereas our idea of friendship - I'm guessing you're nearer my age than theirs? - is still based very much on face-to-face meetings. I may have hugely reduced my interaction with social media but it doesn't change the fact that if I'm not seeing someone, as far as I'm concerned we're not proper mates.
I would say that the people I would like to see more of as friends fall into two categories:
-
What you might call "webfriends" People I do chat to fairly often, but entirely on text - usually WhatsApp - and
-
The real absentees who don't even answer texts.
Both categories are reluctant to meet up face to face. Yes, people are busy. But weren't we always? Some of my best times, friendship-wise, were when my kids were primary school age, and we would meet up on weekday evenings and drink too much, talk lots, laugh, stay up far too late, given we all had work in the morning. Yes, there were big personalities involved in all that, certainly more "show-stopping" than mine. But I genuinely don't think that was the point.
The point was, our kids had brought us together, but they also kept us together. They were hanging out with their friends and playing, and so we parents hung out and played too. But those adults - who you would expect would become lifelong friends because of all your shared experiences together, and your knowledge of each other's families - have now, on the whole, moved away. And are now either webfriends or absentees.
For some reason, we've become very insular. I suspect what people are scared of these days is obligation. I genuinely don't know where this has come from. In that tight friendship group, based around school, we could have asked each other to babysit every other night, but we didn't. So what are people scared of now? That, if we meet, I'll ask them to come over and help me dig the garden? Build an outhouse? Bleed the brakes on the car?
It's possible that we're all just too comfy in our own homes. It's simply nicer, after a hard day, or on a weekend, to hole up in front of the telly, scroll through MN and eat snacks. Rather than making the effort to brush up, go out & drink expensive coffee or beer in a noisy place (why are they always so noisy? - because the owners think they're adding "atmosphere" fgs) with someone who might ask a favour; make demands on time that already seems so short. And so, being webfriends suits us just fine, a bit like what @WhatNoRaisins said. There's very little effort involved. You can share a few jokes and feel that you're not completely friendless for a very low outlay in terms of time, trouble & expense.
Zuckerberg was wrong. The internet doesn't bring us closer together, it isolates us. The streets, which always seemed so full of people when I was young, are now empty, save for fleets of delivery vans bringing us parcels, stuff we've ordered on the web.
OP, I know this is cold comfort, but don't go thinking it's you. There are massive societal forces at work here. It's not you; it's them.