Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I don’t love my sister

85 replies

Fortunatelymaybe · 11/10/2026 20:52

AIBU? I have no real deep love or connection with my sister. I don’t hate her, I honestly just don’t care about her in any way. I understand that my even writing this post may suggest that I care in some way but I don’t. I suppose the reason for writing this is to feel that I’m not alone for having no real love for a sibling.

My sister and I have had a tumultuous relationship our whole lives, and that’s putting it lightly. Since as far back as I can remember she has had an evil streak and regularly hurt me physically, mentally and emotionally. She’s been my biggest bully from day 1. We were raised together in the same home until she moved out as a teenager.

As adults we have never spent longer than 2-3 months on speaking terms. We haven’t been in contact now for over 3 years. We are completely different people with generally opposing views on things. We live different lives and have differing priorities and I understand that this is normal in a lot of families. Where it becomes difficult is that she is rude and outspoken whereas I am introverted and prefer to distance myself from negativity. Anytime I am in her company she makes nasty comments about my looks, my life, my family and anything else you could imagine. She is also rude and nasty to my other siblings (all of whom I get along with perfectly well).

There has been a recent change in family dynamics (too much to get into) which has made me consider the relationships I have with my siblings and how much I truly value their presence and how lucky I am to have them. This is when I began to realise that I have no real love for my sister. The thought of never seeing or hearing from her again has absolutely no impact on me emotionally.

I always hear people say “she’s your sister, you love her deep down” I can honestly hand on my heart say that I do not love her. AIBU to feel this way? Should I have some form of affection for her because she’s family?

OP posts:
FancyPantsThatArentThatFancy · 12/10/2026 09:08

I think it’s more common than not to not have a great relationship with your siblings, especially after the parents have died and there’s no common “glue” to keep you connected.

My sister is dead now but I didn’t speak to her for 10 years before she died. My brother is a complete arsehole. He phones me randomly every 2 years or so and manages to get right up my nose in the process.

EndorsingPRActice · 12/10/2026 09:08

I'm the same with my DB. The only time I ever see my DB is a family event, usually for DM who is elderly. We've never fallen out as such but just don't want to be close. We are very different people. I have been quite close to my DSiS throughout life (I'm late 50s) until the last few years when she's got increasingly fretful and difficult to spend time with as nothing is ever right, she's a bit older than me and since retiring has got more and more insular. I am still making an effort with DSis as I feel a bit sorry for her, but just am not bothered about making a relationship with DB.

OurChristmasMiracle · 12/10/2026 09:08

Me and my sister have not spoken since before our mum died. The last time I saw her was my mums funeral and I didn’t even speak to her at the funeral. I haven’t spoke to her since and have no intentions to

motherhoodisntfortheweak · 12/10/2026 09:32

Same with my half sister we lived in the same house for 5 years I had to move to my dads when my mum passed she and her mother looked down on me and treated me badly just like cindirella . Shared a bedroom but never spoke. We live in different continents now no contact and I do not care.

Dithercats · 12/10/2026 09:35

How do you manage when a parent dies?

I have thought that when mum dies I will just have to let my sister get on with planning the funeral and have no input. I have told my mum this and it doesn't mean I love her any less but I cant manage with any fallout so happy to let her take charge...and me & the other siblings will likely go along with it.

Monty36 · 12/10/2026 09:56

Not enough is done to understand sibling relationships. And why they fall apart.

Sibling alienation is a thing that is getting attention. When one sibling encourages other siblings to turn against another. Chilling, but very real.

I don’t know enough about genetics but I read somewhere that it is possible to have siblings you are barely related to you genetically. Rare but true. Whether that is a factor. The genes you inherit.

Mostly though I think sibling relationships fall down due to poor parenting.
Where siblings have not been raised to trust, love and respect each other. Where a competitive element for approval and praise exists. Where perhaps one child is ‘the’ child. With parents who themselves were raised in dysfunctional households, where bullying, nastiness, or favouritism was apparent and replicate the behaviours with their own families.

A hard cycle to undo. And when adult children are so very different from one another and the ‘glue’ vanishes hard to retain any sense of together. If respect and love and acceptance of any differences between siblings were established earlier on in life then it would not need to be so. Without that behaviour established, then relationships do tend to fade.

I think too, if you do not share day to day, or live close to each other then it is harder to maintain a close relationship. All the close families I have ever known all live close by, see each other regularly and are each others friends as well as family.

BoredZelda · 12/10/2026 10:03

I love my sister, but my brother is simply someone I shared a house with as a child. It’s taken me a long time to recognise I don’t have to put up with his shit.

Barney16 · 12/10/2026 10:04

My DH had two siblings that I think, most of the time, he forgot existed. He used to say they brought nothing positive to his life and he had very little contact. I think it's ok not to get on with a sibling, just because they are family doesn't make them nice people.

UnwillingAdvocate · 12/10/2026 10:08

I think we live by unwritten rules that family members are supposed to be close but that’s just not the reality for many. I always thought that I knew where I stood with my sister until she made it clear my feelings were not a priority to her. Now I feel very little. The relationship I thought we had was never real.

whyohwhyohwhyohwhyohwhyohwhy · 12/10/2026 10:10

Granville82 · 12/10/2026 06:15

Sorry to hear that. Do you have children? Children would ignite such a fire of love inside.

Oh yes I love my 2 kids madly. Never expected to feel like that due to general indifference to most people.

Granville82 · 12/10/2026 10:20

whyohwhyohwhyohwhyohwhyohwhy · 12/10/2026 10:10

Oh yes I love my 2 kids madly. Never expected to feel like that due to general indifference to most people.

I'm so happy for you! Me too :) although I also felt love for other family members. Once you have kids though, everything else is a prelude in a way.

yellowrosesontable · 12/10/2026 11:33

I love my sister however we are estranged, she didn’t even speak to me at all recent funeral. She makes life harder when dealing with emergencies involved elderly frail parents, really unhelpful and even blocked me at the worst possible time with one critical emergency.

It’s her that is difficult, everyone and I mean everyone struggles with her, our parents really don’t have my back, as they are scared to say anything positive about me in case she cuts them off.

the general consensus is that we should/must love our siblings but the reality is very different. OP don’t feel bad about how you feel, live your life in love

TheeNotoriousPIG · 12/10/2026 11:34

I don't have a relationship with my brother. We might have grown up in the same house, but we have just three things in common... the same parents, the same eye colour, and a love of 80's music. He was one of the cool kids at school; I was at the opposite end of the social spectrum- and imagine trying to live in the same house with that situation. We only started getting on slightly better when he moved out (i.e. we could have polite, stilted conversations, like you'd have with a stranger). The only time I ever see, or speak to, him is at occasional whole-family events. If we weren't related, we wouldn't care to know each other, because we are two very different people.

It bothers our mother that we are not close. She has tried to guilt me into making more of an effort, but I haven't liked him since primary school, we live 100 miles apart, we rarely speak at family events, and we're unlikely to speak the rest of the time... so, yes, it's fine to not like your siblings!

LindorDoubleChoc · 12/10/2026 11:38

No sane person would expect you to love your sister given your shared history, the bullying and her unpleasant personality.

So if there really is anyone on the planet who thinks you do love your sister actually, or should love her - you can safely ignore them and forget about their opinion because it is stupid.

Violetplus4 · 12/10/2026 11:45

I feel like this about several members of my family. I don’t hate them, I just don’t feel anything for them.

Spendysis · 12/10/2026 12:12

I had a really close relationship with my dsis but we are now nc due to her financial abuse of our elderly dm who due to dsis making it incredibly difficult to see dm I am also nc with

dsis has caused so much hurt and damage within our family and to many relationships as family friends have believed her lies so are nc with me despite that i dont think i hate her i wont have anything to do with her and i hope the truth comes out. She has been suspended by opg and they have involved court of protection so while I don’t particularly want anything bad to happen to her she needs to face the consequences of her actions

whereismybike · 12/10/2026 12:15

I think the notion that you must love your family simply because you are related is wrong and can be very harmful. I've had it said to me many times as I have had no contact with one sibling and very limited contact with the other for many years. Sometimes it's said by people with have good relationships with their siblings and I think can't understand how different my experience is. Other times it's said by family members as a way to try push me to 'be nice', take the blame for the breakdown in the relationships and put up with behaviour that I wouldn't tolerate from anyone else.

I can see that often siblings end up with love for one another, even if they are quite different people, having spent their formative years together and building that bond. But I think like in any other relationship, respect and love still has to develop and it's absolutely normal and fine not to love/respect someone who treats you and other people badly.

MellowCoralFinch · 12/10/2026 12:21

I feel the same about my brothers. One has children who I adore but I don't care about seeing him really. I can be in the same room as both and neither tries to talk to me so I don't bother now. One knew I had an x-ray last week as his friend said he saw me there and he never even asked if I'm OK and just went on about his friend's back issues. So I'm making no effort to care about him.

My mum excuses him because "he has children" like it's normal to stop giving a hoot about your other family when you have children.

Gotback · 12/10/2026 12:26

Everyone else in my family had just one bully, my dad. I had two, my dad & my sister. Only much later in life did cousins tell me "Your mum knew... we all knew..." but no-one said anything at the time or tried to address her behaviour. She always hated me yet she contacted me after a death in the family after 12 years of no contact. She expected me to be grateful & come running. I finally told her I didn't want or need her in my life. That was 10 years ago. Now she's just nothing to me. I forget she exists.

Spendysis · 12/10/2026 12:39

I don’t think I will be told when dm passes as dsis won’t want me at the funeral incase i tell my side of the story as to why we are nc. I wasn’t told when dm went into a care home so that will avoid any awkwardness I would like to go though opg have requested the council be appointed as deputy so hopefully they will deal with dm estate as i believe there has been a recent will change so I am probably no longer joint executive with dsis so won’t have be involved with that and dm house has already been cleared by dsis as it was rented out for a year and dsis is currently living there but i think the deputy will force it to be sold to pay care home fees

i have no intention of going to dsis funeral and i have never been down as her next of kin or executor of her will or a beneficiary of her estate that was due to go to my now adult dc as she is single and childless but she is also nc with them now.

so thankfully I can’t see any reason why I will have to communicate with her

Detailedakoda · 12/10/2026 12:59

People just presume that because you grew up with people and ‘are blood’ you should be best friends and love them… that’s just not the case for most! I’m not sure I love my sister, I definitely no longer like my sister, or who she has become, as a grown adult she is judgemental, horribly political and just generally quite miserable to be around.

Pedant61 · 12/10/2026 13:07

That's OK, OP. I'm sure there are lots of us who don't love one or more of our relations. Why should we? It always strikes me as odd that we are supposed to love people simply because of a biological connection. It's why I would generally prioritise friends, as they are the people we choose.

Thereweas · 12/10/2026 13:12

Same here. I have no emotional connection with any of my 3 siblings. Sometimes I'll read a statement by a sibling of a person who's been killed, and I can't relate to it at all, I just wouldn't feel upset if they died.

I've been nc for six years and it's quite liberating. I don't have the time or patience to spend my time or energy on people I don't care about.

PaperMachePanda · 12/10/2026 13:18

I have no emotional connection to any of my brothers. They're all weird.

I can sit in a room with one of them (my middle brother) just about but the other two are main characters in everyone else's life and if they're not the centre of everything then boy will you know about it. Urgh.

My youngest brother is the worst though as he's a vile human being who needs to be taken out the back and given what for. I don't say that lightly. He's done all sorts including chasing people with knives and convincing one of his gfs he had HIV and then AIDS and she had a breakdown and then he was like 'haha gotcha'. I haven't spoken to him in about 15 years and am in no rush to reconnect.

DramaAlpaca · 12/10/2026 13:18

I'm low contact with my sibling. We don't hate each other, I suppose we're just indifferent. We have nothing in common at all and very different lives. We can go a couple of years without speaking, and it's always me who instigates contact. After our very elderly parents die I wouldn't be surprised if we never see each other again. It's a shame, but we weren't brought up to be close and we never really got on even as children.