Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to feel disappointed that my daughter has chosen a less prestigious college and a more practical degree?

424 replies

Idealist3 · 11/10/2026 20:44

My daughter is doing a degree in Business with Spanish and Italian, and she is very happy with her choice of college and course.

She had enough points to get into a more prestigious college and could have studied subjects such as humanities, communications or journalism. However, she was quite determined to do this particular course because she wanted something more practical and less theoretical. She also liked the industry links and the fact that there is a mandatory year abroad in Spain.

I completely understand her reasoning, and I have always wanted my children to make their own decisions about their lives. I don't want to be the kind of parent who tries to dictate what they should study or what career they should pursue.

However, if I'm honest, I feel disappointed, and I feel guilty about feeling that way.

My own degree was in Literature and Sociology at a good college, and I suppose I had hoped she might follow a more academic route. I value the intellectual side of a university education and had imagined her studying something along those lines at a more prestigious institution. I think I had an idea in my head of the sort of university experience I would have liked her to have.

Part of me worries that, given her academic ability, she could have challenged herself more and that she might be missing out on a richer university experience. I also wonder whether a degree from a more prestigious college might have opened up different opportunities for her in the future.

At the same time, I realise that she has thought about what she wants and has chosen a course that genuinely appeals to her. She isn't disappointed with her choice or wishing she had done something else. In fact, she's happy, which is what I should want for her.

I know that practical degrees can lead to good careers, and I can see the advantages of learning languages, spending a year abroad and having industry connections. I'm not suggesting that her course is a bad one, and I certainly don't want her to feel that I'm unhappy with her decision.

I think what I'm struggling with is that she has had the academic ability to pursue a different route but has actively chosen not to. Perhaps I had hoped she would value some of the things I valued about university.

I have always believed that my children should make their own choices, and I know it would be unfair to expect her to follow the path I took or to choose a degree based on prestige alone.

So, AIBU to feel disappointed, even though I respect her decision and am glad she's happy? Am I being too hung up on academic prestige and the kind of education I personally value? Or is it understandable to feel that she could have made more of her academic potential, even if she sees things differently?

I don't want to project my own expectations onto her, but I can't quite shake the feeling that I wish she'd chosen differently. I feel bad about that because, ultimately, it's her life and her decision.

I'd appreciate some honest perspectives, particularly from people whose children have chosen a different path from the one they might have hoped for them. How do you let go of your own expectations and feel genuinely happy for your child when their choices aren't quite what you imagined?

OP posts:
SingingShrews · 12/10/2026 09:18

Ilovemyfam · 12/10/2026 09:02

My thoughts too. I don’t believe this story.

She already explained that she is in Ireland. Here we often call University college. Trinity College for instance. 'Uni' isn't used here at all. If someone asked my ds what he is doing he would say he goes to college even though it is a university.

In the UK I think some kids go to 'college' after their gcses? Here you stay in secondary school until you are 18 then go on to college(but it's actually university).

Facecreamed · 12/10/2026 09:20

Ilovemyfam · 12/10/2026 09:02

My thoughts too. I don’t believe this story.

As many, many posters have pointed out, the OP is in Ireland, where ‘college’ is pretty much a synonym for ‘university’, in part because many of the universities have ‘college’ in their name because they are constituent colleges of the National University of Ireland (University College Cork, University College Dublin etc), and because the Technical Universities used to be called ‘Regional Technical Colleges’ before transitioning to autonomous, degree-awarding institutions in a gradual process which only finally finished in the last five years or so.

We don’t have sixth form colleges, other than a couple of private institutions that function roughly similarly and are mostly aimed at people repeating Leaving Cert. You stay at school all the way through to Leaving Cert (the equivalent of A levels.)

Therefore there’s no confusion with using the term ‘college’ to mean ‘institution of higher education’ exclusively.

BlueDillieDillie · 12/10/2026 09:21

The important thing is that she succeeds in the first degree, a First.

The languages will give her the entry to as much intellectual investigation in history or literature as she can cope with. Her Masters might just come round a bit later.

clary · 12/10/2026 09:22

As an aside, it is refreshing indeed to see so much support for business as a degree and a post-16 qual. So often on MN business, along with PE and media and a few others, is decried as being an easy A level or degree, an A level that RG unis are not interested in. I always protest against this (my DS took PE and easy it was not) – IMHO there are no easy or "doss" A levels or degrees.

Some will be more challenging for some YP than others; I would have struggled with a chemistry degree and DS2 would have been a non-starter at MFL. Flip those round and we were happy. That's why it's so important to take subjects where you will excel and you enjoy.

Anyway let's hear it for business! I'll link this thread next time I see it talked down on a HE/FE thread as not a real A level.

BTW @MeetMeOnTheCorner "any grad can do comms"? Sadly or maybe thankfully that is certainly not true. As a former comms person I can confirm that I have seen a number of grads who really were not great at it (along with plenty that were).

Imdunfer · 12/10/2026 09:24

Honestly? You're an intellectual snob and you need to take a good hard look about what's included in Business Studies in the 21st century.

BobbleBear · 12/10/2026 09:36

So you wanted her to go to Trinity and she’s going somewhere else?

DH and I both worked in a prestigious UK University before retiring so I do understand your thought process but fundamentally disagree with it.

Honestly, things have moved on massively since you did your degree (AI has turned the world on its head), and it’s surely far more important to take account of those changes and adapt?

Remember that the Dinosaurs became extinct whilst the little chickens survived!

Iocanepowder · 12/10/2026 09:49

maxslice · 12/10/2026 01:25

They are not useless. You just don’t like them.

I actually studied Sociology at A level.

I would still argue they aren’t very useful in terms of currently ensuring a job after graduation.

Ilovemyfam · 12/10/2026 09:59

@Facecreamed
@SingingShrews

Thanks for the heads up. I have learned something today.

I am not in the UK either, but do tend to assume that all posters are. Also so many of the posts I read prompt a reaction of "surely can't be true" from me.

Probably I should just stop posting.

Sadcafe · 12/10/2026 10:01

Good for her, she’s thought about it and is doing what she wants rather than what you want, you can’t live your life through your daughter

Sartre · 12/10/2026 10:01

But she is studying humanities subjects so I don’t understand what your point is? MFL courses have been closing across the country due to low uptake for many years. Why do you think business studies with MFL is any less academic than, say, sociology?

Sartre · 12/10/2026 10:02

Iocanepowder · 12/10/2026 09:49

I actually studied Sociology at A level.

I would still argue they aren’t very useful in terms of currently ensuring a job after graduation.

In the current market very few degrees are useful in securing a career due to an overall decline in entry level roles. You could study law and struggle to get into a law firm, they’re offloading the junior jobs to their own AI systems.

Goditsmemargaret · 12/10/2026 10:04

Ok so what I'm guessing is you're from a very rural part of Ireland and the fact you went to Trinners always went down well with the neighbours. You are letting that cloud your judgment.

Your daughter has done her research and chosen appropriately. Be proud of her.

Fletchasketch · 12/10/2026 10:05

As someone who did a languages degree, I really never considered that it wasn't an academic choice. It has opened more doors for me professionally, given me more experiences, and made me more friends (including my partner) than I ever could have hoped. It was also genuinely enjoyable. It is my friends who did law degress who now find themselves in exhausting jobs they don't enjoy. This is purely anecdotal of course, but it does sound like your daughter has thought this through and that her choices are sound ones to be celebratred.

Facecreamed · 12/10/2026 10:09

Goditsmemargaret · 12/10/2026 10:04

Ok so what I'm guessing is you're from a very rural part of Ireland and the fact you went to Trinners always went down well with the neighbours. You are letting that cloud your judgment.

Your daughter has done her research and chosen appropriately. Be proud of her.

God, where I’m from, going to Trinity would have marked you as someone with serious notions. 😃

I mean, my mother was mortified at my much more run of the mill destination, and when I got an entrance scholarship that made it into the local paper (on a very slow news week), she could be heard anxiously informing the neighbours I was only going to college because I was ‘too lazy to go to work.’

BlueDillieDillie · 12/10/2026 10:09

Given how recent and dramatic the Jason Arday affair has been it seems strange that so many on here are still pretending that Sociology in it's many forms is of any worth to anyone.

Goditsmemargaret · 12/10/2026 10:17

Facecreamed · 12/10/2026 10:09

God, where I’m from, going to Trinity would have marked you as someone with serious notions. 😃

I mean, my mother was mortified at my much more run of the mill destination, and when I got an entrance scholarship that made it into the local paper (on a very slow news week), she could be heard anxiously informing the neighbours I was only going to college because I was ‘too lazy to go to work.’

That's reverse snobbery though and still feeding into the rhetoric that Trinity is 'the best'. It depends on the course.

Facecreamed · 12/10/2026 10:21

Goditsmemargaret · 12/10/2026 10:17

That's reverse snobbery though and still feeding into the rhetoric that Trinity is 'the best'. It depends on the course.

I think you’ve misunderstood my post.

eggandonion · 12/10/2026 10:55

I thought commerce at ucd was aspirational.

AnonyMumAuDHD · 12/10/2026 10:56

Facecreamed · 12/10/2026 10:09

God, where I’m from, going to Trinity would have marked you as someone with serious notions. 😃

I mean, my mother was mortified at my much more run of the mill destination, and when I got an entrance scholarship that made it into the local paper (on a very slow news week), she could be heard anxiously informing the neighbours I was only going to college because I was ‘too lazy to go to work.’

When I was applying to uni in the 80/90s, the same was often said of people applying to Oxbridge from my background. “Ideas above their station’’, which was often applied to my going to uni at all.

I couldn’t help read your PP in an Irish accent and found myself thinking about the Maeve Binchy book (and film with Minnie Driver), Circle of Friends. May have to dig it out and re-read it now. :)

UhOhRatPoo · 12/10/2026 13:42

I find it kind of funny that the daughter is doing MFL and has clearly thought about how important it is to be able to communicate clearly with people from other countries, whereas Mum with her fancy sociology degree didn’t even stop to think that it might be relevant to explain Irish terminology when posting on a UK forum..

Also, those suggesting Business is a non-academic option- maybe you should tell Harvard their MBA is for dummies?

eggandonion · 12/10/2026 13:45

In fairness there are differences between the Scottish education system and the English and Welsh which cause confusion at times. Even UK isn't straightforward.

Runnermumof2 · 12/10/2026 17:47

Idealist3 · 11/10/2026 20:44

My daughter is doing a degree in Business with Spanish and Italian, and she is very happy with her choice of college and course.

She had enough points to get into a more prestigious college and could have studied subjects such as humanities, communications or journalism. However, she was quite determined to do this particular course because she wanted something more practical and less theoretical. She also liked the industry links and the fact that there is a mandatory year abroad in Spain.

I completely understand her reasoning, and I have always wanted my children to make their own decisions about their lives. I don't want to be the kind of parent who tries to dictate what they should study or what career they should pursue.

However, if I'm honest, I feel disappointed, and I feel guilty about feeling that way.

My own degree was in Literature and Sociology at a good college, and I suppose I had hoped she might follow a more academic route. I value the intellectual side of a university education and had imagined her studying something along those lines at a more prestigious institution. I think I had an idea in my head of the sort of university experience I would have liked her to have.

Part of me worries that, given her academic ability, she could have challenged herself more and that she might be missing out on a richer university experience. I also wonder whether a degree from a more prestigious college might have opened up different opportunities for her in the future.

At the same time, I realise that she has thought about what she wants and has chosen a course that genuinely appeals to her. She isn't disappointed with her choice or wishing she had done something else. In fact, she's happy, which is what I should want for her.

I know that practical degrees can lead to good careers, and I can see the advantages of learning languages, spending a year abroad and having industry connections. I'm not suggesting that her course is a bad one, and I certainly don't want her to feel that I'm unhappy with her decision.

I think what I'm struggling with is that she has had the academic ability to pursue a different route but has actively chosen not to. Perhaps I had hoped she would value some of the things I valued about university.

I have always believed that my children should make their own choices, and I know it would be unfair to expect her to follow the path I took or to choose a degree based on prestige alone.

So, AIBU to feel disappointed, even though I respect her decision and am glad she's happy? Am I being too hung up on academic prestige and the kind of education I personally value? Or is it understandable to feel that she could have made more of her academic potential, even if she sees things differently?

I don't want to project my own expectations onto her, but I can't quite shake the feeling that I wish she'd chosen differently. I feel bad about that because, ultimately, it's her life and her decision.

I'd appreciate some honest perspectives, particularly from people whose children have chosen a different path from the one they might have hoped for them. How do you let go of your own expectations and feel genuinely happy for your child when their choices aren't quite what you imagined?

Disappointed? She sounds fantastic! She's really thought it through and isnt wasting time on useless degrees. Get skills, get a great career, be happy. What does the institution that it was completed at make any kind of difference ? Other than bragging rights to your own friends, which people hate anyway.
Your daughter sounds great !

Thewhatsaboutit · 12/10/2026 17:53

I am confused about Journalism being an intellectual degree.

I studied a year of it at a Russell Group university before realising in that industry, it’s not what you know, it’s very much who you know. I switched to Law.

I’m still friendly with a lot of people from the course and barely any of them actually work in journalism or that industry at all.

blacksax · 12/10/2026 17:56

The only people interested in the prestige of these top universities are the people who went there themselves (and who may have developed a sense of superiority to everyone else as a result); and the parents of people studying there, so they can use it as some sort of social cachet.

Nobody else gives two hoots.

LinaLouLa · 12/10/2026 17:57

To be honest, I got bored reading the original post halfway through. You are being unreasonable. She has thought long and hard about her choice. If you were to force your choices on her she might have a miserable university experience. Only she should be able to make this decision as it is for her future.