Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Split families should have similar standards of living?

131 replies

kevinandgail · 11/10/2026 09:55

AIBU to think that split families should have similar standards of living. Not one household living hand to mouth and the other wearing designer clothes and flying business class.

OP posts:
Glowingup · 12/10/2026 09:37

What does that mean in practice though? That one person has to hand over a massive chunk of income to the other to ensure parity? My DH’s ex is able-bodied and there are no reasons why she can’t work but she’s on benefits and has been since they split. She was a low-ish earner when they met and my DH supported her but at the time she was at least training for a profession. However, she quit this as soon as they married and expected to be a kept woman (if she’d completed her training and got a job in the field she’d be on a decent salary now). She received a large lump sum on divorce seven years ago and instead of getting a job and then a mortgage and using the money to buy a flat or house, she blew it on living expenses and and was spending to the tune of 10k a month at one point. It went in about a year. She still hasn’t been able to hold down a job for more than a few months (she always quits because she doesn’t get on with her employers). There are no child care reasons for not working as it’s 50/50 shared care and the kids are older and in school. Meanwhile, DH has had various promotions and almost doubled his salary since the divorce. I think it’s totally fine for the kids to see that if you work hard and hold down a job, you do well and can have nice things. And if you piss money away, have no work ethic and expect to live off others, you end up in a shit financial situation that’s entirely of your own making.

EmailsaysOOO · 12/10/2026 09:38

Need some explanation..Who will be the judge of the fairness of the calculations ? I don't think it is workable. although of course I can see it's the source of many problems when it is clearly not in balance.

Paganpentacle · 12/10/2026 09:39

Who are you expecting to be responsible for this?
Step-parent no doubt 🙄

StickyToffeePuddingAndIceCream321 · 12/10/2026 09:41

By split families do you mean a divorcing couple with children? If so I heavily disagree. Once upon a time (prior to the the 1960's) women generally didn't work outside the home once children came along, they relied on the man to earn the money and they looked after the children/home. It is no longer the 1950's, it is the 2020's and women build careers and work, the sensible ones establish their careers and build a life for themselves BEFORE they have children. There is no need to stay at home to have children, there's childcare available and in many cases there is help to pay for this. So you have no excuse for ending up a poor single parent really, it's simply choice and piss poor planning that leads to one half of the couple living in poverty and the other having a decent lifestyle on divorce.

I have 3 children (about to have a 4th) I have a career and earn marginally more than my husband. We went to uni, established careers, bought a house before we had children. If I was to divorce I would be fine affording to live on my wage, because I have made sure I have an income and protected my own best interests, i have a better pension than my husband too. We would have very similar standards of living to one another if we did divorce (I'm not planning to!) and would share our children 50/50. I see this in a lot of my close friends cases where they have divorced, the woman is actually better off than the man in many cases as they are career women, they do 50/50 split with the children so there is no maintenance to pay and both see their children equally.

If you don't have a career or decent income to start with but marry "well" have children and can afford to not work whilst married, stilting any chance you will ever have of any career progression, that is your choice. You can't expect an ex-partner to keep you in the lifestyle you have become accustomed to, you are no longer his responsibility. It works both ways too, if a man marries well, the ex wife shouldn't have to prop him up so he can still enjoy the nice lifestyle. The only reason they ever had that lifestyle was because someone else was funding it, there's always the chance the gravy train will run out if you rely on someone else to fund you.

Conniebygaslight · 12/10/2026 09:41

No. They should have the same standard of love & care. The rest is just fluff

Collaborate · 12/10/2026 09:59

On divorce the courts take this in to account. Spouse maintenance can be ordered so that there is more of a balance in standard of living for the children in particular.

Where there isn't a marriage there is either child maintenance and/or settlement of property to provide a home for the children before they grow up.

Wecanbeheroes26 · 12/10/2026 10:04

How would you propose this equality happens?

JHound · 12/10/2026 10:06

mumumental · 12/10/2026 09:06

I have no idea. There must be a way, though, to make men more responsible for the children they created in their past lives. We all know that the cms doesn’t work.

But that’s a whole other point to whether the two households should have equal living standards. Even with CMS if there is a huge earning imbalance then different lifestyles are to be expected.

How could you force equality in this situation and how would that be fair? Especially in situations where a household is dual income vs. single income or where the high earner is not the one with the children.

LadIsInPain · 12/10/2026 10:08

kevinandgail · 11/10/2026 09:55

AIBU to think that split families should have similar standards of living. Not one household living hand to mouth and the other wearing designer clothes and flying business class.

Yeah, the parent who is failing to provide a good enough standard of living needs to really step up.

PollyBell · 12/10/2026 10:09

So if a man has less of a standard than the woman the woman should give him more money?

And how is the next woman going to be funded when she goes on to have a replacement family with him? Can he fund the same lifestyle for both?

JHound · 12/10/2026 10:15

StickyToffeePuddingAndIceCream321 · 12/10/2026 09:41

By split families do you mean a divorcing couple with children? If so I heavily disagree. Once upon a time (prior to the the 1960's) women generally didn't work outside the home once children came along, they relied on the man to earn the money and they looked after the children/home. It is no longer the 1950's, it is the 2020's and women build careers and work, the sensible ones establish their careers and build a life for themselves BEFORE they have children. There is no need to stay at home to have children, there's childcare available and in many cases there is help to pay for this. So you have no excuse for ending up a poor single parent really, it's simply choice and piss poor planning that leads to one half of the couple living in poverty and the other having a decent lifestyle on divorce.

I have 3 children (about to have a 4th) I have a career and earn marginally more than my husband. We went to uni, established careers, bought a house before we had children. If I was to divorce I would be fine affording to live on my wage, because I have made sure I have an income and protected my own best interests, i have a better pension than my husband too. We would have very similar standards of living to one another if we did divorce (I'm not planning to!) and would share our children 50/50. I see this in a lot of my close friends cases where they have divorced, the woman is actually better off than the man in many cases as they are career women, they do 50/50 split with the children so there is no maintenance to pay and both see their children equally.

If you don't have a career or decent income to start with but marry "well" have children and can afford to not work whilst married, stilting any chance you will ever have of any career progression, that is your choice. You can't expect an ex-partner to keep you in the lifestyle you have become accustomed to, you are no longer his responsibility. It works both ways too, if a man marries well, the ex wife shouldn't have to prop him up so he can still enjoy the nice lifestyle. The only reason they ever had that lifestyle was because someone else was funding it, there's always the chance the gravy train will run out if you rely on someone else to fund you.

Agree with almost all this except where the couple made a joint decision that for the best for their family one party would be home focused and the other paid work focused. Not everybody wants strangers to be the main carer for their children in the early years.

I don’t think this should mean on divorce the unpaid worker has exactly the same lifestyle as pre divorce and they should not expect to have to work. But it’s always painted as one person making the decision unilaterally and often it’s a joint one.

99bottlesofkombucha · 12/10/2026 11:19

FunPartyIdeas · 12/10/2026 08:43

@99bottlesofkombucha Unreasonable for one parent not to work and use the "childcare" excuse whilst the other works ft.
I have worked from the age of 16 all of my life and have been a single parent to two young children over that time period.
Of course it was my joint responsibility to put a roof over heads and food in bellies.
We need to stop relying on men!

I have 3 dc and work full time, and always have except for maternity leave. If my dh left and didn’t do his share of parenting, I’d be able to support my dc, but I’d resent him with very good reason. These two things are not mutually exclusive. Also, if I had a less senior role and couldn’t afford the childcare and support that we have and have the flex I do, then I couldn’t work the hours I do, so my husband leaving would cut back my working options. Even not having him doing the pick up etc as he does would put a lot of pressure on me and cut my capability to work. You can have a good job, support your dc and still be restricted compared to a man who acts and spends like he’s child free because he doesn’t need to pay for sports and music and food and clothes and after hours care and extra sports equipment and extra competition fees all day long.

FunPartyIdeas · 12/10/2026 11:39

@99bottlesofkombucha But in that instance, maintenance would be payable?

itsadlibitum · 12/10/2026 11:45

These posts always make me think of the SAHP threads where women insist that the do the childcare and their husbands bread wins and it’s a partnerships and just wonderful. Except when it’s no longer a partnership and wonderful, because what happens then? I guess they then start threads arguing that they should have the same lifestyle and continue being funded by their ex.

anyway, the children should always be provided for, but once the divorce is finalised and assets divided equitably it’s not the responsibility of one adult to financially provided for another just because they were once married and had children together.

99bottlesofkombucha · 12/10/2026 11:52

FunPartyIdeas · 12/10/2026 11:39

@99bottlesofkombucha But in that instance, maintenance would be payable?

sure. But when does maintenance cover anywhere near the lifestyle of the kids with parents who have the same income but who are actively parenting? He has to pay one plane flight for a holiday, the mum has to cover the family and get 2 rooms. The extra paying someone to pick up your kids from school so they can take them to training because you can’t skip out of work 3 afternoons a week and keep your management job. Of buying the quality pre made meals to feed your kids healthily while you’re in evening meetings and there’s no other parent to handle those nights. Of paying for the skills courses everyone else’s kids do so they can make the competitive teams. Of trying to dial into meetings inthe early morning while driving to drop off. Let’s not pretend there’s any fairness here when separated dads don’t take responsibility, whether the mum works or not.

FunPartyIdeas · 12/10/2026 12:39

@itsadlibitum Totally agree. Hence why I never took the risk of giving up work to be a SAHM. And I thank God every day I was wise enough not to!
@99bottlesofkombucha Those things you describe are luxuries though? Plane holidays and skills courses are luxuries for sure.

99bottlesofkombucha · 12/10/2026 12:51

FunPartyIdeas · 12/10/2026 12:39

@itsadlibitum Totally agree. Hence why I never took the risk of giving up work to be a SAHM. And I thank God every day I was wise enough not to!
@99bottlesofkombucha Those things you describe are luxuries though? Plane holidays and skills courses are luxuries for sure.

Sure they are. But why should a dad get them and all the dads friends kids get them and all the dads kids friends get them, when his own kids could but his wife can’t sustain that level of extras and the income required for it on top of the parenting? My kids wouldn’t make it into the sporting teams they want to without the extra training everyone does, they would have to opt out of the comps that involve flights. That would just really unfair on them when the single reason they can’t do it is their dad doesn’t care enough about them. The whole op is about standard of livings and in many cases no amount of get off your butt you lazy woman and get a job he doesn’t have to provide for you now he’s not married to you can actually account for covering the full parenting load, which creates a massive lifestyle gap on its own. So she’s entirely correct in her op.

no I don’t think separated women should never have to work because they’re mums. But I think there’s often a lifestyle gap even if they work and parent themselves 25/7 until they drop, because they have a far far bigger work load and cost load. And a lot of people on this thread are ignoring that.

itsadlibitum · 12/10/2026 13:03

99bottlesofkombucha · 12/10/2026 12:51

Sure they are. But why should a dad get them and all the dads friends kids get them and all the dads kids friends get them, when his own kids could but his wife can’t sustain that level of extras and the income required for it on top of the parenting? My kids wouldn’t make it into the sporting teams they want to without the extra training everyone does, they would have to opt out of the comps that involve flights. That would just really unfair on them when the single reason they can’t do it is their dad doesn’t care enough about them. The whole op is about standard of livings and in many cases no amount of get off your butt you lazy woman and get a job he doesn’t have to provide for you now he’s not married to you can actually account for covering the full parenting load, which creates a massive lifestyle gap on its own. So she’s entirely correct in her op.

no I don’t think separated women should never have to work because they’re mums. But I think there’s often a lifestyle gap even if they work and parent themselves 25/7 until they drop, because they have a far far bigger work load and cost load. And a lot of people on this thread are ignoring that.

These mums aren’t typically fighting to get less time with their children though? At least that’s not what I see.

strictlybusinessuntildecember · 12/10/2026 13:28

Well no

my ex husband is a useless ingrate who was never going to amount to anything career wise so why should divorce make him better off than if he had never met me

MaroonCrimsonScarlet · 12/10/2026 15:12

itsadlibitum · 12/10/2026 11:45

These posts always make me think of the SAHP threads where women insist that the do the childcare and their husbands bread wins and it’s a partnerships and just wonderful. Except when it’s no longer a partnership and wonderful, because what happens then? I guess they then start threads arguing that they should have the same lifestyle and continue being funded by their ex.

anyway, the children should always be provided for, but once the divorce is finalised and assets divided equitably it’s not the responsibility of one adult to financially provided for another just because they were once married and had children together.

Agree. To be fair I’ve seen working women with this level of entitlement too. The only valid argument in the case of a SAHP is if being home has allowed the other parent to further their career eg being childcare whilst the other is doing extra hours or working away or abroad.

jacks11 · 12/10/2026 15:56

At the point of divorce, fair split of assets is correct. Thereafter, appropriate child maintenance should be paid, unless custody is 50:50. And that is it, both parents get a fair share of your shared marital assets and then it’s up to each person to stand on their own two feet. What happens after that point is the responsibility of each individual, excepting child maintenance.

You can’t have one partner continuously expecting their life to be funded by their ex-partner, or to have living standards improve on the back of their ex-partners success/hard work/ inheritance/their new partners income.

It’s just not right or appropriate, once financial settlement is done, it’s done. The only thing that should change is child maintenance payments, if applicable. That’s the only fair way to manage things. For instance, what if one parent enters a new relationship and has more children, making their budget tighter, whilst the other parent doesn’t have any more children and so has more disposable income. Why should the latter pay more to make lifestyles equal, when the choices of their ex-partner are the cause of the widening disparity in household lifestyle? Or if one parent’s new partner is well paid or independently wealthy- why should that lead to a financial benefit to an ex-partner (possibly a significant benefit, if lifestyles have to be roughly equal)? Or, over time one partners career progresses or they start a new business which has nothing to do with their ex-partner, and their income rises. Other than child maintenance increase, no I don’t think an ex-husband or wife is entitled to a significant additional proportion so his or her lifestyle is similar.

itsadlibitum · 12/10/2026 16:30

Also where does it end? 15 years post divorce one of them wins the lottery, should they have to give half so their distant ex can enjoy the same life style?

AnnoyedAsAllHeck · 12/10/2026 19:31

kevinandgail · 11/10/2026 09:55

AIBU to think that split families should have similar standards of living. Not one household living hand to mouth and the other wearing designer clothes and flying business class.

No I don't agree. One parent could sit around and do very little but because the other family unit has two working people that earn good money, they should subsidise the other lazy parent? Nope.
Life isn't always fair and households are not always equal. That's just life.

Nellodee · 12/10/2026 21:30

I’m divided on this. Often a woman’s unpaid labour allows a man to concentrate on their career whilst the woman’s career stagnates. Stay at home mums need to be very careful.

Bananacrepewithnuts · 12/10/2026 22:08

That will never happen.
X

Swipe left for the next trending thread