Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What’s the point in the NHS?

935 replies

younknow · 25/09/2026 23:20

I fell over at work today. My ankle was immediately black and blue and swollen, so I hobbled off to urgent care in a taxi.

I waited for four hours, I was x-rayed and told there were no breaks and a severe sprain. The doctor told me I’ve likely torn ligaments in my ankle and will be sore for three months.

I asked what sort of follow up would be given and she all but laughed at me, saying that I could get myself a support on Amazon if I wanted. I said I couldn’t even weight bear and she said I could also pick up crutches if needed. She then said I could refer to physio but “ChatGPT would give me a plan”. I asked if I’d be scanned to find out how badly damaged it is and she said there was no chance.

What is the point? Genuinely, what are we paying for when even things like this are being directed to Amazon and A.I?! I can’t believe it.

I remember 15 years ago my mum tore ligaments in her ankle and she was scanned the same day it happened, put in a boot and on crutches for six weeks, had a course of physio and consultations with an orthopaedic surgeon to discuss a plan if it didn’t improve.

What’s going on?!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
NullaEffugium · 28/10/2026 16:18

C8H10N4O2 · 28/10/2026 16:06

No it isn't. Its the spending choices of trusts who actively and repeatedly made shitty procurement choices and eg chose to "invent their own wheels" rather than participate in shared systems.

Those x-rays and scans could (and were recommended to) be made centrally available use standard storage and secure login protocols 20 years ago - in much the same way that countries such as Germany and Denmark and now pretty much everywhere in state backed European healthcare uses. Individual trusts insisted on building their own train sets which are not even consistent within a trust (which will often build more than one train set just because).

See also the billions spaffed up the wall on the longitudinal record due to regions and trusts simply insisting on having their own trainset rather than using the standard model or centrally shared models.

See also the insistence on using their own speshul email service when the entire world was moving to standardised models such as office 365 (which even a decade ago was compliant with data sovereignty rules) and which still struggle to match basic features any small business takes for granted.

None of these decisions were related to local variable needs or incidence of different health needs in different areas - they were due to petty bureaucrats making crap procurement decisions, not in the interest of patients and a lack of accountability.

Spending choices with no money are no choice at all. The countries you listed have on invested far more per capita and as a % of GDP into modernising their health systems and training & recruiting staff.

TheBoldPombear · 28/10/2026 16:26

I'm not saying you received stellar care (obviously you did not). But 'I should have been given a better service' is nowhere near 'what is the point of the NHS' For those of us who work many hours for free for the NHS, sacrificing so much, this is such a kick in the teeth.

NullaEffugium · 28/10/2026 16:32

@C8H10N4O2
The trusts did not insist on doing their own thing, the central government handed down unfunded mandates and told trusts to figure it out on their own with no increased budget for it and no centralised program office to procure, test and deploy these basic modernisations.

pinck · 28/10/2026 16:37

Right, so my own experiences aren't sufficient but yours are? Okay then ... I've lived in the US for the vast majority of my life and I know an awful lot of Americans who've had similar experiences to mine including people who've undergone cancer treatment, major surgeries, and treatment for serious illnesses. I'm not claiming the system is perfect, but positive experiences don't suddenly become irrelevant just because they don't fit your argument and no, I've never lived in the UK, nor would I want to. My husband is Irish, and I lived in Ireland for a year and a half and either of us would choose to move back there either . And lol, congratulations on living in seven states, I guess? I'm not entirely sure why you think that gives you some sort of special authority over the opinions of people who actually live here. But apparently seven states means your personal experiences count and mine don't.

C8H10N4O2 · 28/10/2026 16:37

NullaEffugium · 28/10/2026 16:32

@C8H10N4O2
The trusts did not insist on doing their own thing, the central government handed down unfunded mandates and told trusts to figure it out on their own with no increased budget for it and no centralised program office to procure, test and deploy these basic modernisations.

Edited

No, I was in the room where some of the insane decisions were made. There was no government mandate influencing these decisions, nor was cost the driving factor - building and running your own train set costs a fuck ton more than sharing a standard trainset with the rest of the NHS. Refusing to share the standard trainset made available to you costs more money not less.

It was absolutely bad procurement decisions made for poor reasons (and sometimes decidedly dodgy reasons).

Denmark and Germany were early adopters but as I said in my post - most countries now use the same model, including much poorer countries with less money than the NHS spends on IT.

Imdunfer · 28/10/2026 16:44

NullaEffugium · 28/10/2026 15:57

The inefficiencies are caused by lack of adequate funding into modern IT systems that share a patient dossier across all NHS sites. They cannot sort the nonsense using spit and elbow grease.

That would be funding into things like the brand new system that my opthalmologist told me 3 months ago had slowed him down and demonstrated slowing him down again this morning? The project management in the NHS is dire.

They put new windows into his unit recently. They removed the blackout blinds to install them. When he pointed out that opthalmologists need to be able to get the room completely dark, they said they would refit them. Then they couldn't, because they'd installed windows which have big sticky outy levers to open and close them and you can't roll a blind down over them.

For over three months he's had his windows blacked out by plastic sheet duck taped to the window frame.

My last update notes arrived on paper through the post marked "dictated and signed in absence to save time" - 4 weeks after my appointment. That letter went to a typing pool where it sat in a queue of other letters waiting to be typed up and was put in the post to me and my GP costing an absolute minimum of five quid, and that's being repeated all over the country. Other departments email me.

The actual management of the NHS is appalling.

And as long as the NHS goes on wasting money hand over fist like that it will never get its act together.

Imdunfer · 28/10/2026 16:51

NullaEffugium · 28/10/2026 16:32

@C8H10N4O2
The trusts did not insist on doing their own thing, the central government handed down unfunded mandates and told trusts to figure it out on their own with no increased budget for it and no centralised program office to procure, test and deploy these basic modernisations.

Edited

GPs are currently using about 4 systems between them and can choose their own, and NHS Trusts can, I am reading, also choose their own on a shared data structure. This use of more than one set of software results in far, far greater support costs across the NHS.

NullaEffugium · 28/10/2026 19:16

pinck · 28/10/2026 16:37

Right, so my own experiences aren't sufficient but yours are? Okay then ... I've lived in the US for the vast majority of my life and I know an awful lot of Americans who've had similar experiences to mine including people who've undergone cancer treatment, major surgeries, and treatment for serious illnesses. I'm not claiming the system is perfect, but positive experiences don't suddenly become irrelevant just because they don't fit your argument and no, I've never lived in the UK, nor would I want to. My husband is Irish, and I lived in Ireland for a year and a half and either of us would choose to move back there either . And lol, congratulations on living in seven states, I guess? I'm not entirely sure why you think that gives you some sort of special authority over the opinions of people who actually live here. But apparently seven states means your personal experiences count and mine don't.

It is not my experiences versus yours. It is research studies with facts and figures covering the entire population of the US vs yours & your families’ positive experiences.

Fwiw, all my experiences with US healthcare were fabulous because I had those gold plated federal employee health benefits. But our positive experiences do not trump the research done on how it is for all Americans.

The facts and figures are backed up by research reports which I linked. It is not my fault you refuse to acknowledge how many Americans are left to die outside your bubble of privilege. I was in the same bubble as you, but at least I am not in denial about the true human cost of the US healthcare system.

You have never lived in the UK or used the NHS but are all lol I can’t talk about my living in the US and using the US healthcare for 25 years (which could actually be longer than however long ‘most of your life’ is). I mentioned 7 states because access to and affordability of healthcare varies by state. You should know this as someone actually living in the US. Living in multiple states gave me more awareness into how the US healthcare system is not one consistent monolith from coast to coast or north to south.

NullaEffugium · 28/10/2026 19:25

Imdunfer · 28/10/2026 16:51

GPs are currently using about 4 systems between them and can choose their own, and NHS Trusts can, I am reading, also choose their own on a shared data structure. This use of more than one set of software results in far, far greater support costs across the NHS.

Yes that is because some Trusts collaborated and pooled resources.

Persephonia1966 · 28/10/2026 19:43

pinck · 28/10/2026 15:14

I'm American, and lol, no, that's not even remotly how it works. I have several complicated health issues and have been hospitalized multiple times and I've never been “shipped out of the hospital” the second I woke up from surgery. You're clearly thinking of outpatient surgery, which I'm fairly certain the UK has too, although clearly you don't know the difference. The American healthcare system has plenty of legitimate problems without needing to invent new ones and having dealt with some pretty serious medical issues myself, I know where I'd rather receive healthcare and it's certainly not the UK.

Patient dumping absolutely is a real problem. It is particularly an issue for elderly patients. It's a different situation to outpatients/trying to get patients recovering at home rather than at hospital which done right is better for patient recovery and the hospital bed management.

The UK absolutely has a problem with older people "bed blocking" because they are technically well enough to leave hospital but don't have the support in place at home or a nursing place home. It's not great, but we don't have old people being literally dumped in the street.

But on the other hand less hospital owners in the UK can afford super yachts so swings and roundabouts.

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://youtu.be/TDv5-FzuEIY?is=cR7xn2RsHVtxZd1x

Imdunfer · 28/10/2026 19:51

NullaEffugium · 28/10/2026 19:25

Yes that is because some Trusts collaborated and pooled resources.

Multiple systems requiring different support are not the result of collaboration.

NullaEffugium · 28/10/2026 19:57

To add to @Persephonia1966 post on patient dumping in the US.

Patient dumping is the illegal or unethical premature discharge or transfer of patients due to economic reasons or inability to pay

Here is a list of the most recent OIG enforcement actions against hospitals convicted of patient dumping practices.
Sorted by date

U.S. Department of Health and Human Services Office of the Inspector General

Baptist Medical Center South Agreed to Pay $290,000 for Allegedly Violating Patient Dumping Statute by Failing to Provide Appropriate Medical Screening Examinations and Stabilizing Treatment

https://oig.hhs.gov/fraud/enforcement/baptist-medical-center-south-agreed-to-pay-290000-for-allegedly-violating-patient-dumping-statute-by-failing-to-provide-appropriate-medical-screening-examinations-and-stabilizing-treatment/

NullaEffugium · 28/10/2026 20:04

Imdunfer · 28/10/2026 19:51

Multiple systems requiring different support are not the result of collaboration.

In this case they absolutely are. When over 6,000 GP practices can choose between 4 systems, some collaboration had to happen to make that a reality. The problem is that the collaboration is ad hoc between trusts or countries (ie NHS Scotland), not at the national UK level.

If there were no collaboration or pooling of resources then 6,000+ GP practices would be using at least a few dozen different systems. These are not very complex systems and not terribly expensive. The waste is as you said, the wheel being invented more than once, in isolation so they are not compatible with each other.

Greenmouldycheese · 28/10/2026 20:21

They got both my babies here. They helped my kids when they were very ill. They saved my mams life when she had cancer. They give us appointments, tests, deal with broken bones.

They have their faults and i have had issues with them too, but the pros outweigh the cons by a landslide. For some things I go private, but to say there no point to the NHS is madness, especially for something as simple as a sprained ankle. A consultation alone is 250 without scans and tests.

Imdunfer · 28/10/2026 21:18

NullaEffugium · 28/10/2026 20:04

In this case they absolutely are. When over 6,000 GP practices can choose between 4 systems, some collaboration had to happen to make that a reality. The problem is that the collaboration is ad hoc between trusts or countries (ie NHS Scotland), not at the national UK level.

If there were no collaboration or pooling of resources then 6,000+ GP practices would be using at least a few dozen different systems. These are not very complex systems and not terribly expensive. The waste is as you said, the wheel being invented more than once, in isolation so they are not compatible with each other.

We are talking about the additional expense incurred in supporting four different systems.

That additional expense is not incurred as a result of collaboration! You are saying it could have been worse, that's not the point.

Somebody should have made an executive decision that all GP practices would use one system.

pinck · 28/10/2026 22:05

NullaEffugium · 28/10/2026 19:16

It is not my experiences versus yours. It is research studies with facts and figures covering the entire population of the US vs yours & your families’ positive experiences.

Fwiw, all my experiences with US healthcare were fabulous because I had those gold plated federal employee health benefits. But our positive experiences do not trump the research done on how it is for all Americans.

The facts and figures are backed up by research reports which I linked. It is not my fault you refuse to acknowledge how many Americans are left to die outside your bubble of privilege. I was in the same bubble as you, but at least I am not in denial about the true human cost of the US healthcare system.

You have never lived in the UK or used the NHS but are all lol I can’t talk about my living in the US and using the US healthcare for 25 years (which could actually be longer than however long ‘most of your life’ is). I mentioned 7 states because access to and affordability of healthcare varies by state. You should know this as someone actually living in the US. Living in multiple states gave me more awareness into how the US healthcare system is not one consistent monolith from coast to coast or north to south.

I'm not sure what's more impressive, your determination to argue against something I never said or your apparent inability to understand a fairly simple point. I never claimed the American healthcare system was perfect, that nobody struggles to access care, or that my experiences invalidate statistics. You've invented an entire argument for me and then spent several paragraphs congratulating yourself for winning it. And yes, I'm aware that healthcare varies by state. Believe it or not, you don't need to have lived in seven of them to figure that out. As for the NHS, my husband is Irish and has lived in Northern Ireland and so I'm quite familiar with its shortcomings of the NHS through people who've actually used it. I'm allowed to have an opinion about that too but apparently your personal experiences are valuable insight while mine are evidence of privilege and ignorance. Funny how that works. Anyway, I'm glad you've managed to turn a fairly straightforward disagreement into a lecture about how much more enlightened you are than everyone else. Truly groundbreaking stuff.

Velumental · 28/10/2026 22:23

younknow · 25/09/2026 23:31

Hey? A scan, a bandage and a pair of crutches would be £1000s?

Theres plenty that can be done for torn ligaments. This is another lie they’ve told us - that for some things we just have to put up with pain and long term consequences because “they can’t do anything”!

As someone with a chronic ankle instability the answer is you go home, you call your GP and you ask for referral to physio. Physio will give you a plan and check for.improvwmwmt. 90% of the physio information you can find online.

After doing all that I had deteriorating pain so THEN they scanned as was takingt po long to heal, that's when I found out all 3 lateral ligaments were fully torn. Now I'm likely to need surgery. If I need surgery this will be provided by the NHS as will follow up.

I've had.about 50 sprains, most just heal, twice I've had episodes like that. So roughly 96% of sprains heal themselves with basic care advice. Those that don't are dealt with as required.

You e had a minor.injury requiring zero drama. You want the drama, the NHS budget doesn't stretch to that

Persephonia1966 · 29/10/2026 02:08

pinck · 28/10/2026 22:05

I'm not sure what's more impressive, your determination to argue against something I never said or your apparent inability to understand a fairly simple point. I never claimed the American healthcare system was perfect, that nobody struggles to access care, or that my experiences invalidate statistics. You've invented an entire argument for me and then spent several paragraphs congratulating yourself for winning it. And yes, I'm aware that healthcare varies by state. Believe it or not, you don't need to have lived in seven of them to figure that out. As for the NHS, my husband is Irish and has lived in Northern Ireland and so I'm quite familiar with its shortcomings of the NHS through people who've actually used it. I'm allowed to have an opinion about that too but apparently your personal experiences are valuable insight while mine are evidence of privilege and ignorance. Funny how that works. Anyway, I'm glad you've managed to turn a fairly straightforward disagreement into a lecture about how much more enlightened you are than everyone else. Truly groundbreaking stuff.

You argued that because you had never been "shipped out of hospital" that it wasn't a thing that happened and that the other postet must be talking about out patient surgery. It's great that you had good personal experiences of hospital treatment but you ignored the very long list of cases she provided of patients being literally shipped out of hospital to double down. No system is perfect, I have had hospital treatment in the Netherlands and Germany and they all have their downsides. But it is hard to think of another developed country where ill elderly people are literally left on the side of the road like oversized rubbish. America is quite unique for that. Just because you have not experienced it doesn't mean it doesn't happen. That's all people are trying to say.

pinck · 29/10/2026 03:12

Persephonia1966 · 29/10/2026 02:08

You argued that because you had never been "shipped out of hospital" that it wasn't a thing that happened and that the other postet must be talking about out patient surgery. It's great that you had good personal experiences of hospital treatment but you ignored the very long list of cases she provided of patients being literally shipped out of hospital to double down. No system is perfect, I have had hospital treatment in the Netherlands and Germany and they all have their downsides. But it is hard to think of another developed country where ill elderly people are literally left on the side of the road like oversized rubbish. America is quite unique for that. Just because you have not experienced it doesn't mean it doesn't happen. That's all people are trying to say.

Right, because the NHS is apparently such a shining example of healthcare that we should just overlook people waiting HOURS for ambulances, struggling to get appointments and being treated (or not treated) in hospital corridors but then you find a handful of horrific cases in America and suddenly they're representative of the entire healthcare system. And lol, you're talking about elderly people being literally left on the side of the road like garbage as though this is some routine occurrence across America. Come on now. I'm not denying that hospital dumping has happened, but there's a pretty significant difference between isolated cases and something that's remotely representative of the average patient's experience. Funny how context matters when we're criticizing the NHS but apparently goes straight out the window when we're talking about the US.

And lol, why are you awake at 2 a.m. arguing with me anyway? Don't you have a job to go to tomorrow, or is lecturing Americans about their own healthcare system a full-time occupation?

malificent7 · 29/10/2026 06:26

The point is you got an expensive xray and diagnosis and was told to look after it. All free at the point of entry.
They are probably too busy saving lives to hold your hand much after that.
I know...I used to do xray in A and E. Absolutely flat out. Loved it though.

malificent7 · 29/10/2026 06:29

In xray you prioritise your ?Strokes, heart failure, resus patients, very ill children 1st...of which there are many.

Laurmolonlabe · 29/10/2026 09:41

I don't know why you are expecting a detailed breakdown of the damage from scan when there is no other treatment recommended than what you have had- the NHS works on need, you have had what you needed, the treatment recommendation could easily have changed in 15 years.
The point of the NHS is that everyone gets what they need , being a drama queen doesn't make your need greater.

pinck · 29/10/2026 13:44

malificent7 · 29/10/2026 06:29

In xray you prioritise your ?Strokes, heart failure, resus patients, very ill children 1st...of which there are many.

I'm a little confused by this list. I had a (scad) heart attack myself recently and subsequently needed an angiogram and CT scan to assess my coronary arteries so obviously cardiac patients can need imaging but I'm not sure what use an ex ray would be. Strokes generally require urgent CT scans too so are you referring specifically to ordinary X-rays or to the radiology department as a whole cause those aren't quite the same thing. Also, nobody is disputing that critically ill patients should take priority.

pinck · 29/10/2026 13:54

Laurmolonlabe · 29/10/2026 09:41

I don't know why you are expecting a detailed breakdown of the damage from scan when there is no other treatment recommended than what you have had- the NHS works on need, you have had what you needed, the treatment recommendation could easily have changed in 15 years.
The point of the NHS is that everyone gets what they need , being a drama queen doesn't make your need greater.

Exactly. She was told she has a sprain, but somehow that’s not enough. What kind of detailed breakdown is she expecting from an X-ray when ligament damage usually doesn't even show up on one?

I actually broke my ankle four weeks ago and had follow-up X-rays on Monday. The fracture line still looks essentially the same because soft callus and early healing don't show up on a standard scan—there’s only so much an image can reveal.

Asking questions is great, but demanding an elaborate explanation for damage an X-ray physically cannot display is ridiculous. What does she want the doctor to do?

NeverDropYourMooncup · 29/10/2026 15:35

BIossomtoes · 28/10/2026 15:56

I bet those 190,000 people would have preferred healthcare in the UK.

And definitely the 120k with type 1 diabetes that are uninsured (and pretty much all the others that are having to pay for things like prescriptions, supplies, monitoring, treatment for complications - that are less likely when somebody isn't forced to ration their medication - that are all absolutely free in the UK).