Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you buy a house with a toilet in an open-plan room?

230 replies

lostinspace00 · Yesterday 15:30

Hope to find some sensible opinions here before I (possibly) waste loads of money (and so sorry i just posted this on an existing thread by mistake).

My house has a separate dining room and kitchen with a hallway between the two leading to a toilet. I want to knock the walls down to create one large room but keep the toilet as it’s very useful. To cover all bases:
1 no I can’t afford to put the toilet anywhere else it would make the job too expensive

  1. I want to keep the toilet (it’s a shower too) rather than get rid of it as it’s useful.

would you buy a house with a toilet in the middle of a big open plan room?

I’ve created some excellent architectural designs to show you what I mean (by excellent I mean a bit shit)

Thank you to anyone who can be bothered to respond

[image removed by MNHQ at OP's request]

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
IAmInTheHouseSidney · Today 09:38

WhosGotTheKeysToMyBimma · Today 09:29

Looking at that kitchen diner with horror

Where on earth would you put a table? There's 6 doors into that kitchen! You might be able to fit one of those 4 seat space saver Ikea ones where the chairs slot under the table but that's it

What a terrible design.

I think some developers take pride in the most stupid placement of their development as well as creation of most ridiculous spaces. Like the 2 bedrooms upstairs when there was no need to make the landing bigger and create awkward angles.... As well as what you mentioned.

Aluna · Today 09:47

The confusion about the regulations is that they have changed. It used to be the case that you could have a toilet off a kitchen area. Now if you have a wash basin + extractor can you can.

CrazyMidget · Today 09:52

nomas · Yesterday 16:15

True! I wonder if there will be a passage or if the front door opens into this room.

Maybe it’ll be a back passage! 🤣

Aluna · Today 10:29

MeandT · Yesterday 18:28

Where are the toilet flushings going in these 2 scenarios? Is the magic compost fairy spiriting them away every time?

Or are you suggesting OP jackhammers a 2ft trench across the middle of her dining room to connect to the existing soil pipe at 12 o'clock on the current floor plan?

This house looks like it's had enough half-arsed additions done to it in the first place (it looks a lot like the kitchen/diner space is an extension, and tackling the issue of changing the orientation of the staircase when that was done would have given several far more functional options on the floorplan at that stage. OP is trying to make the best of what she's (presumably) inherited layout wise. But running new utilities to reach the front door is unlikely to be a budget option!

Depends where the central soil pipe is - it may be connected to the back but I think it’s more likely to run down the side.

It’s not clear if the kitchen dining room is a (one storey?) extension in which case the soil pipe to that toilet may be a branch.

In any case a macerator and pump means you don’t need gravity drain pipes or major floor and concrete excavation.

ZombieZebra · Today 10:32

No way. Our kitchen has got a utility room with a door into it and then a downstairs loo off it. That’s fine in my opinion as the kitchen is quite large so you can’t hear anything. If it had been in the middle of the kitchen we wouldn’t have bought the house.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page