Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to expect my brother to compromise on a family holiday?

31 replies

GenerallyVeryUnreasonable · 05/09/2026 21:24

Sorry long story:

Myself and DD (4) have joined my Mum and Dad on a UK holiday. My brother and SIL have also joined. They are here for 4 days but we are returning after only 2 due to school on Monday for DD. Brother and SIL are younger than me and do not have children. I’m a single parent.

This morning me, dad and DD went for brunch. Invited SIL and brother but they fancied somewhere else they’d found on IG. All fine. Met after and took a walk along the coastal path and back. DD obviously tired by this point. Told her we’d be going to visit the gift shops and I’d buy her a momento and some sweets. We had also all planned to have fish and chips somewhere in this same town and visit a little beauty spot. So we’re in the town, it’s 4pm ish but we haven’t eaten since brunch and everyone needs a wee. We’re all a bit tired so I suggest we dive into a half decent pub for some food, drink and a wee. Spot a pub with some tables in the sunshine.

SIL pulls up reviews on her phone. They look fine. Brother says she doesn’t like the brewery operating it. We’re all standing at the edge of the road while brother looks at other places on google reviews. He says “it’s fine, you lot can go there but I’m not eating there”. Me, DD and dad cross the road and go to the pub. Brother and SIL continue on to their preferred place. I’m a bit annoyed because I don’t think it’s necessary to make such a big deal and it’s more about the people and the sunshine - lots to enjoy at an average pub. My mum is a bit worried and wanting us all to try and stay together. I don’t know what to do for the best so I say I’m going to take DD to the gift shop so I can fulfil my promise to her (after telling her prior that we may have to miss the shop because everyone is hungry and since we’re on a family holiday we have to compromise) and dad and mum go with brother and SIL.

We finish at the shop then go to catch them up on the way to the chosen pub. We all walk 15 minutes to find we are at another average pub. Brother is criticising the menu. I get annoyed and say that I thought we were just trying to have a quick dinner. That not every meal has to be perfect. I try to explain my frustration. He explodes - becomes hostile in tone. We get into a row. He threatened to storm off so I tell him to go then. He says mean things to me and I say mean things to him (that he centres himself and needs to grow up). Then he and SIL leave and go back to the holiday rental. I haven’t seen or spoken to him since and they’re both currently out on their own for the evening.

I think he has his head up his own arse, frankly, and is forgetting that we have a 4yo in tow. I think if he’s going to come on a family holiday then he should just accept that he has to go with the majority vote for most of the time - not every meal is going to be a gastronomic experience and if he wants that then him and his girlfriend should do their own thing right from the start. AIBU?

OP posts:
SpottyPyjama · 07/09/2026 17:43

I get annoyed and say that I thought we were just trying to have a quick dinner. That not every meal has to be perfect. I try to explain my frustration.

You started the row. Own it.

Everyone needs to compromise but that doesn’t mean the whole thing revolving around your child or people eating things they don’t want eat.

SwanUpmanship · 07/09/2026 18:07

Your brother was being tedious - criticising the menu in the pub he'd chosen in preference to the one you'd suggested. It wasn't a great idea for you to pull him up on it, though.

It sounds like you and your brother want different things from day trips, and your situations are different as you have a small child. I'd avoid trying to do things together in future and let him do his own thing.

Livpool · 07/09/2026 18:29

MrsTerryPratchett · 05/09/2026 22:13

When you have kids, you follow their needs. He doesn't have kids. So he follows his wants. No one is unreasonable but you think he is!

He sounds like an insufferable prick moaning about a brewery when people just want a quick bite to eat.

Silverbirchleaf · 07/09/2026 18:34

They should have gone with the flow for this meal, especially as you were only there for a short time, I hate the faffing around looking at Tripadvisor etc for reviews.

Cooshawn · 07/09/2026 19:04

I agree with your point that every meal doesn't have to be a gourmet delight.

But I disagree with a holiday having to centre around a child. I'd not be keen on having dinner at 4pm either.

Ultimately you're both being a bit out of order and I feel sorry for your parents.

blythet · 07/09/2026 19:15

ByTipsyShark · 05/09/2026 21:52

To be fair it’s his holiday too, you seem to want to call the shots the whole time. I wouldn’t want to eat in a crap pub just because!

Presumably him (or his wife) had picked the pub that was 15 mins away that he then subsequently snubbed

New posts on this thread. Refresh page