Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think Mumsnet enables our worst selves

34 replies

wordscanhurt · 24/07/2026 22:43

New account as I've closed mine and am just logging back to make this post. I joined mumsnet because I like AIBU and have seen some useful, funny and heartbreakingly sad threads. When I commented, I always tried to post non-judgemental, empathetic, genuinely helpful responses, bearing in mind that an actual human being would be reading them, that often got hearts and likes. But yesterday I was called cruel and toxic and this was the final straw. It hurt. You can dash off a shitty comment online, but someone is reading it in the real world.

Mumsnet masquerades as a caring support site, but algorithms always trend towards conflict and Mumsnet HQ would much prefer 500 comments ripping someone to shreds than a post with 30 thoughtful responses. I hate how people allow the worst of themselves online. People who don't know each other rushing to judgement to call others a bad parent or wife, or say that they've been stupid or cruel. It's horrible. You would never speak to people like this in real life, but revel in the cloak of anonymity to do it online. Well enough for me. I'm not logging on any more to find I've been called horrible things that I know I am not.

How can we expect our children to behave sensibly in an online world when a group of women delight in making assumptions and rushing to judgement on an hourly basis.

There will be tons of replies underneath this saying aibu is supposed to be robust, or assuming all sorts of things about me when you know literally nothing about me. I'm not staying around to read them.

This site is terrible for my wellbeing and I'm logging off for good.

OP posts:
Onlywayisrainham · 25/07/2026 00:15

I take your point, people who set out to be deliberately cruel are horrible. That said, what is the purpose of advice? If it’s just to make the poster feel better by affirming their views then yes, the comments are going to be welcomed but are they going to be always helpful? Sometimes parents are bad, sometimes not every marital conflict has a clear goody and bady. Sometimes the kindest thing you can do is to (respectfully) say unwelcome things.

WeAreNotOk · 25/07/2026 00:33

Don't stop being you're honest self. It's a forum, not everyone agrees and as you well know, the pile on is enormous. I've been on the bad end of it. So, I changed name and carried on.

CrypticClueless · 25/07/2026 00:38

How can we expect our children to behave sensibly in an online world when a group of women delight in making assumptions and rushing to judgement on an hourly basis.

This should be in the MN philosophy.

Tinks2026 · 25/07/2026 00:40

You can't control other people, so stop trying.

It's a very freeing choice to make.

kookieCrumbles · 25/07/2026 00:41

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

GarlicEverywhere · 25/07/2026 00:50

I joined mumsnet because I like AIBU

Then your use of this site became a self-fulfilling prophecy, didn't it? It's a massive resource that hosts much thoughtful, insightful, educational and supportive discussion. Out of all this, you chose to home in on people being unreasonable. YABU to complain about people BU in AIBU!

PollysKenwood · 25/07/2026 01:49

I like Mumsnet but I wouldn’t post about things that I’d feel vulnerable about in terms of responses. I wouldn’t do this on any discussion site but Mumsnet is the only one I post on. I know there are plenty of topics where I could cope with someone flicking the verbal Vs at my comments and others where I would bruise easily so I steer well clear of the latter. Ultimately, if it’s an unhelpful experience then there’s no point in engaging.

TeenToTwenties · 25/07/2026 02:10

GarlicEverywhere · 25/07/2026 00:50

I joined mumsnet because I like AIBU

Then your use of this site became a self-fulfilling prophecy, didn't it? It's a massive resource that hosts much thoughtful, insightful, educational and supportive discussion. Out of all this, you chose to home in on people being unreasonable. YABU to complain about people BU in AIBU!

I agree with this.

AIBU is a draw because it is often very direct and can be antagonistic.

If you had steered clear and gone to education, or mental health, or elderly parents or whatever you would find predominately gentle supportive threads.

Maybe consider name changing and venturing further it a special interest board.

gymavoidant2027 · Today 11:28

CrypticClueless · 25/07/2026 00:38

How can we expect our children to behave sensibly in an online world when a group of women delight in making assumptions and rushing to judgement on an hourly basis.

This should be in the MN philosophy.

I do think that some people enjoy tearing someone else apart online, especially when they’ve been triggered or have a chip on their shoulder about something in their own life.

LollipopLil · Today 11:34

I think name changing enables the worst.

People can say what they want to who they want, in the knowledge that tomorrow (or even 5 minutes later), they can slip back into their 'nice' name where everyone thinks they're lovely.

If people had to stick to the same name (and I DO understand why many can't), then everyone would know they're a dick and just avoid them.

So, they'd have to be a decent poster or put up with being completely ignored.

Much like walking into their local pub or NCT group.

gymavoidant2027 · Today 11:37

@LollipopLil I genuinely think that a lot of the nasty or just attacking, but unhelpful and non-constructive posts, stem from insecurity and people with huge chips on their shoulder.

OsfameronTanamoril · Today 11:38

Mumsnet is not AIBU. I have had lots of support on other forums.

SmokeyRidge · Today 11:40

Can't be fragile on this site or capitulate to the mob. My views are very contradictory to many and, although I'm open to shifting these with evidence etc, sarcastic, low IQ, bitter and jaded individuals are immediately disregarded. I take this approach IRL and this is the way on the forum. Sorry OP that you've been upset. Some of us do care but would definitely agree that you shouldn't be here if 'mean girls' upset you. Remember, most people like this are only brave online. They'd whimper IRL if challenged, intellectually, because there is no substance.

LollipopLil · Today 11:43

gymavoidant2027 · Today 11:37

@LollipopLil I genuinely think that a lot of the nasty or just attacking, but unhelpful and non-constructive posts, stem from insecurity and people with huge chips on their shoulder.

I agree but on other forums where they can't name change, they soon realise no-one's bothering to reply to them due to their behaviour.

gymavoidant2027 · Today 11:43

OsfameronTanamoril · Today 11:38

Mumsnet is not AIBU. I have had lots of support on other forums.

Mumsnet can be toxic in other forums, not just AIBU.

BusyGreySnail · Today 11:47

I would say 95% of the people on here are fine - although AIBU does invite a more "direct" response that some other forums/ groups. Some people I agree are unnecessarily rude and agressive and I don't see the need at all. It's like they get off on pointing out percieved mistakes or stupiditym or making others feel rubbish. I think that's, sadly, human nature though.

Thecatspantaloons · Today 11:49

People post on aibu because it draws a lot of traffic, so it stands to reason that it will attract literally anyone and everyone - not just gentle women and mums - this is an important distinction.

It also has a really bad or good reputation for being anti Trans for the protection of women and girls, so I firmly believe that people on the other side of this issue purposely come here to shit stir . You can call me paranoid, but I don't think a lot of people on here are posting in good faith and I definitely wouldn't post anything super personal or sensitive.

LollipopLil · Today 11:50

Actually I'd realised this is a zombie thread from yet another OP, who decided to post and run immediately 🙄

Thecatspantaloons · Today 11:53

LollipopLil · Today 11:50

Actually I'd realised this is a zombie thread from yet another OP, who decided to post and run immediately 🙄

How embarrassing 🫣 that's on me.

gymavoidant2027 · Today 11:54

@BusyGreySnail I think it’s human nature when people have chips on their shoulder, but not otherwise!

BusyGreySnail · Today 11:56

gymavoidant2027 · Today 11:54

@BusyGreySnail I think it’s human nature when people have chips on their shoulder, but not otherwise!

I just meant it's human nature that a small number of people are just not very nice.

gymavoidant2027 · Today 11:58

BusyGreySnail · Today 11:56

I just meant it's human nature that a small number of people are just not very nice.

That’s true, but there sometimes appears to be a higher proportion of not-very-nice people on Mumsnet than in the general population.

BusyGreySnail · Today 12:11

gymavoidant2027 · Today 11:58

That’s true, but there sometimes appears to be a higher proportion of not-very-nice people on Mumsnet than in the general population.

Anonymity brings that out in people I think

MerryAquaKoala · Today 12:12

Such a lovely / funny / helpful place a lot of the time. It can be awful. I’ve found a particular group of posters to be pretty nasty. They sort of ‘gang up’ on a poster that they decide is saying things they and their online gang vehemently disagree with. I’ve also noticed that this group have arranged to meet off line. Pretty sinister stuff. Or maybe they need friends. Which you know, is fair enough. People get lonely sometimes. Just dislike how unpleasant and vicious they are.

CookerHat · Today 12:23

I agree there are some absolute lunatics in here and some real horror bags where they can be really nasty and almost certainly wouldn’t say the stuff in real life.

I can understand tensions are high under certain circumstances and on certain threads etc where subjects are emotive, but I posted about whether I should rush back early from a paid break away with a fro to go to the funeral on an ex in law and a few posted were bat shit crazy about it. They were so invested and really nasty about how awful I am if I don’t go. That level of abuse for something that’s bares no difference to their lives is wild. 72% of the votes were YANBU so I felt justified not going and that’s why i posted as I wanted to get the general consensus but yeah some people went mental.

People are nuts and it’s trying to keep that in mind OP. It’s not you it’s them

Swipe left for the next trending thread