Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think Mumsnet enables our worst selves

37 replies

wordscanhurt · 24/07/2026 22:43

New account as I've closed mine and am just logging back to make this post. I joined mumsnet because I like AIBU and have seen some useful, funny and heartbreakingly sad threads. When I commented, I always tried to post non-judgemental, empathetic, genuinely helpful responses, bearing in mind that an actual human being would be reading them, that often got hearts and likes. But yesterday I was called cruel and toxic and this was the final straw. It hurt. You can dash off a shitty comment online, but someone is reading it in the real world.

Mumsnet masquerades as a caring support site, but algorithms always trend towards conflict and Mumsnet HQ would much prefer 500 comments ripping someone to shreds than a post with 30 thoughtful responses. I hate how people allow the worst of themselves online. People who don't know each other rushing to judgement to call others a bad parent or wife, or say that they've been stupid or cruel. It's horrible. You would never speak to people like this in real life, but revel in the cloak of anonymity to do it online. Well enough for me. I'm not logging on any more to find I've been called horrible things that I know I am not.

How can we expect our children to behave sensibly in an online world when a group of women delight in making assumptions and rushing to judgement on an hourly basis.

There will be tons of replies underneath this saying aibu is supposed to be robust, or assuming all sorts of things about me when you know literally nothing about me. I'm not staying around to read them.

This site is terrible for my wellbeing and I'm logging off for good.

OP posts:
MerryAquaKoala · 16/11/2026 12:28

CookerHat · 16/11/2026 12:23

I agree there are some absolute lunatics in here and some real horror bags where they can be really nasty and almost certainly wouldn’t say the stuff in real life.

I can understand tensions are high under certain circumstances and on certain threads etc where subjects are emotive, but I posted about whether I should rush back early from a paid break away with a fro to go to the funeral on an ex in law and a few posted were bat shit crazy about it. They were so invested and really nasty about how awful I am if I don’t go. That level of abuse for something that’s bares no difference to their lives is wild. 72% of the votes were YANBU so I felt justified not going and that’s why i posted as I wanted to get the general consensus but yeah some people went mental.

People are nuts and it’s trying to keep that in mind OP. It’s not you it’s them

I find the final % on AIBU is more accurate than the comments. As you say comments are often taken over by crazies with a bee in their bonnet..

NovemberMorn · 16/11/2026 12:36

I think OP has done the right thing walking away, especially from AIBU, which often attracts keyboard warriors masquerading as caring, adult women.

This forum is no better or worse than others I have been on; it has more posters and possibly more influence than most, but it can still be a viper pit when the meangirls gather.

MrsBennetsPoorNervesAreBack · 16/11/2026 12:44

Mumsnet is a business. It exists primarily to make money. We are all free to choose whether or not to engage.

There are certainly times when I feel that it's bad for my mental health. I hate seeing the racism, the misogyny and the ablism etc that people might not express so openly in real life. The disinformation and the increasing volume of AI generated content are annoying. And I'm regularly frustrated by the crapness and inconsistency of the moderation.

But ultimately, nobody is forcing me to post here. And if you're finding it too much, OP, then it's wise to delete your account.

MerryAquaKoala · 16/11/2026 12:49

People Are batshit though. All you had to do a few years ago was say sex is real and a whole load of posters would descend to tell you off in very nasty terms. Transphobic apparently. Thankfully they’ve calmed down about that now. Well some of them have. Being told to pipe down by the Supreme Court does that to people. 💫

Abitofalark · 16/11/2026 12:58

LollipopLil · 16/11/2026 11:50

Actually I'd realised this is a zombie thread from yet another OP, who decided to post and run immediately 🙄

Thanks for pointing out that it's a zombie. I hadn't realised. Unbelievable that someone thought it was a good idea to resurrect someone else's flounce thread.

FoodoftheDog · 16/11/2026 13:02

I’ve had a fair mix of supportive, robust and then downright rude posts over the years. Sometimes the support has been robust, so that is not back and white.

It has helped me to figure out what to take on board and what to ignore which I apply in real life too. There are plenty of people we need to tune out in real life too.

All in all I’ve found it a very helpful site.

WimpoleHat · 16/11/2026 13:07

I know what you mean - and sometimes people do seem to
delight in putting the boot in. But the beauty of it is that you do get genuinely honest responses which you realistically won’t even get from your best friends (who are likely to sugarcoat it to save your feelings). So I think you have to try and be thick skinned and zone out the people who are deliberately unpleasant and concentrate on the genuinely helpful replies.

HobgoblinNorFoulFiend · 16/11/2026 13:20

I find it useful for getting a robust response that challenges my own. My friends are too polite to take a strong alternative view and know me too well to not know what I’m thinking. But I also recognise that some posters are just being goady or contrary for giggles. So I take it all with a big pinch of salt, those who are “lovely” and “kind” as well as those who are not. Ultimately I don’t know them and they don’t know me so none of it matters in the real world.

JaneJeffer · 16/11/2026 13:25

Abitofalark · 16/11/2026 12:58

Thanks for pointing out that it's a zombie. I hadn't realised. Unbelievable that someone thought it was a good idea to resurrect someone else's flounce thread.

Traffic is traffic Grin

gymavoidant2027 · Yesterday 20:04

Abitofalark · 16/11/2026 12:58

Thanks for pointing out that it's a zombie. I hadn't realised. Unbelievable that someone thought it was a good idea to resurrect someone else's flounce thread.

Is not better replying to an existing thread, rather than creating a new one just to ask the same thing?

Thecatspantaloons · Yesterday 21:41

gymavoidant2027 · Yesterday 20:04

Is not better replying to an existing thread, rather than creating a new one just to ask the same thing?

I never thought about it like this, since there's always criticism about starting the millionth thread about the same tired topic done over and over again 🤔 .

gymavoidant2027 · Yesterday 21:45

Thecatspantaloons · Yesterday 21:41

I never thought about it like this, since there's always criticism about starting the millionth thread about the same tired topic done over and over again 🤔 .

Some things bear repeating I think…. 🙃

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread