Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my husband should visit his brother

60 replies

ChickensAreTheAnswer · 02/06/2026 21:02

Ive been married 10 years. Together for 13. My husband has an brother. He was diagnosed with severe mental health in his 20s & disabilities quite young. He is very vulnerable. He was put in secure accommodation so has his own flat but carers visit once a day. The medication hes on mean he isnt the best at looking after himself. He lives a quiet life of TV, music, bus spotting and thats it. His parents visit weekly. He lives about an hour away from us.

Do people think it's odd he's never visited his brother. The rest of the family all do. He says there is no bad blood or trauma, he just doesnt want to visit him and "doesnt have anything to talk about with him.

He's see him at Xmas if the brother comes for Xmas dinner *so maybe 4 times in 13 yrs .. but apart from that - never.

Understandable? His own choice? Or a bit odd?

I've been really let down by my husband in recent years. I was v unwell last year in hospital and he disappeared. He left the hospital v quickly after birth of baby to get back to bed. And when kids are unwell or something bad happens, he basically disengages. It got me thinking about the brother situation and whether he is essentially a bit unable to deal with anything hard.

OP posts:
Dancingsquirrels · 03/11/2026 07:43

He's lazy and selfish

Bit surprised how many posters are suggesting it's totally fine for him to abandon his brother. I think that's terrible

PollyBell · 03/11/2026 08:06

If you want to leave him as he is a terrible husband and father go for it but his brother is his business don't you have enough issues to try and control this?

Pedant61 · 03/11/2026 08:11

Completely your husband's choice, OP, and nothing to do with you. Some family members just don't "click", so there's no reason to keep in touch.

rwalker · 03/11/2026 08:14

sounds like he lacks empathy and emotion
he’ll of spent his childhood being in the background and his brother would of dominated everything and this has moulded him into who he is
children with SEN siblings a look ways miss out in childhood physically and emotionally it’s a case of there alright and there left to there own devices

Iclyn · 03/11/2026 08:17

My dh has siblings he never talks to , there wasn't any falling out etc they just don't bother with each other .
I think it's a case of out of sight , out of mind .
They don't send cards at Christmas or birthdays and don't text .

IsawwhatIsaw · 03/11/2026 08:20

BruFord · 02/06/2026 21:52

What you're describing is a pattern of selfish behavior towards other people. If it was only that he didn't want to see his brother, fair enough, but it sounds as if he's inattentive to you and your children as well. I wouldn't be happy with a partner like that tbh.

Yes it’s a pattern of selfishness. He isn’t caring.
and you clearly can’t rely on him. That would concern me .

Francestein · 03/11/2026 08:26

Time to stop “doing” for his family. No more reminders, cards, presents. That’s all his. No more sharing calendars, photos, etc. No more cooking and preparing anything for him on behalf of his family. If they’re coming for dinner, ask him what he’s cooking.
If his family asks you, refer them to him.
If I had been left dangling at his family’s house by myself, I would have picked up the keys and gone home.
This man has forgotten that you are a person.

5128gap · 03/11/2026 08:28

The answers in your second paragraph. Your husband is a fair weather only companion. Happy enough to be around people when the going is easy, but no appetite for it when it's hard work or less pleasant.
No one loves it when the people in their lives aren't on top form, but mostly we get on with it as part of the wider experience of being in relationships with them. Some people like your husband can't or won't.
As a stand alone, not visiting his brother could be justifiable for many reasons. Coupled with his behaviour when you were ill, it's not great.

CloveRinse · 03/11/2026 09:29

Nofeckingway · 03/06/2026 09:58

I married one like that selfish and self absorbed . He could play the nice guy to achieve what HE wanted which is why I married him . The reality that we were all in his satellite took awhile to realise . He wasn't nasty or unkind just inattentive and disengaged . I also had to remind him to call his family because otherwise he wouldn't bother . They were decent grandparents so I felt bad for them . No arguement he just couldn't be bothered . He also told me how tired he was after my son was born at 2am .

I completely understand what you mean.

Mine went home after DD1 birth at 2:28am by EMCS - slept and returned at like 4pm and told me he had Nando’s for lunch! I’d been nil by mouth for over 48 hours and he didn’t bring me ANYTHING! I was so close to chewing my own arm off with hunger. Selfish man!

However mine got nasty in the end. Now ex.

CloveRinse · 03/11/2026 09:37

5128gap · 03/11/2026 08:28

The answers in your second paragraph. Your husband is a fair weather only companion. Happy enough to be around people when the going is easy, but no appetite for it when it's hard work or less pleasant.
No one loves it when the people in their lives aren't on top form, but mostly we get on with it as part of the wider experience of being in relationships with them. Some people like your husband can't or won't.
As a stand alone, not visiting his brother could be justifiable for many reasons. Coupled with his behaviour when you were ill, it's not great.

Agree

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread