Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

I had a date with a guy I met off tinder and his arms were covered in self harm scars.

649 replies

Toffeeandfudge1 · 11/02/2024 01:41

So I’ve been talking to this man for afew weeks over WhatsApp now and he seemed really nice. We had lots in common such as love of dogs, music taste, read the same books and so on. We also have children of a similar age. Sounded too good to be true. So we met up tonight for the second time and went to Pizza Hut, and it was really hot in the restaurant so he took his hoodie off and I couldn’t help but notice his arms were covered in scars. They looked old but I was a little taken back as I don’t know anyone that this. I was trying not to look although I felt a little awkward. Am I being unreasonably judgemental or is this a red flag?

OP posts:
CommentNow · 11/02/2024 09:05

Self harm scars can be brutal. I am in my 40s and still have some horrible ones from when I was a teenager. I haven't self harmed for 20+ years, nor do I drink or cope with stress that way any more.

That's all it is, a coping mechanism. It doesnt mean someone is manipulative.

I live in fear of the day my kids ask me about it or cotton on what the marks are and weigh up whether to ask about them. They are deeply shameful. But there is nothing I can do about them.

Strangely whilst I'm ok with my own scars, I find them arresting on other people, especially the serious ones. Its uncomfortable to see something that looks so violent.

I dont judge you not wanting to take on someone brand new with mental health issues, I've been there, and its hard. But scars arent the full story or even a mental health issue, they are a snapshot of someones visible coping mechanism. Some people eat, starve, drink, get piercings and tattoos, go for a walk. And challenges and coping mechanisms change.

nomoremsniceperson · 11/02/2024 09:06

It can be shocking to see something like this for the first time.

However it's important to remember that many sensitive people experience puberty as traumatic and, as teens, aren't always good at finding decent coping mechanisms. This doesn't mean he hasn't since found a healthy way to deal with his problems.

In itself this is not a red flag. Red flags would be behaviour-based. Is he love-bombing you? Is he too intense? Jealous? Controlling? Erratic moods? Blowing hot and cold? That's what I'd look out for.

89redballoons · 11/02/2024 09:06

Cancer can go into remission, depending on the type of cancer, but it's still possible it will come back. People can definitely learn strategies and gain experiences that will prevent them from self harming again, even in times of stress. Nothing is guaranteed, in either case.

Wasbedeudetetdas · 11/02/2024 09:06

You probably do know someone 'like this' but don't actually realise it - it's more common than you might think however many people hide it very well.

With regard to the future, anyone can develop or be hiding MH issues, so it's a bit unfair to write him off straightaway - if he self-harmed in the past and then successfully managed to stop then he's probably been really strong and courageous.

Maybe he subtly revealed them to let you know, instead of bringing it up in an awkward conversation directly?

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 11/02/2024 09:06

It never ceases to amaze me that people are happy for others to choose who to date based on trivial physical/aesthetic preferences, but think that it's unacceptable to rule out dating partners on the basis of historical or current traits which could potentially have a huge effect on one's own life. It doesn't matter whether the trait/history is that person's fault or not, or whether there are mitigating circumstances.

When it comes to choosing who to start an intimate relationship with, you don't owe anyone a relationship, a date, or the benefit of the doubt. Literally any reason is a good enough reason not to date someone. Life is complicated enough without deliberately choosing a relationship that is likely to add more complication if that's not what you want.

4timesthefun · 11/02/2024 09:07

If I liked him, I’d probably be trying to find out more information about the when/why/how did the self-harming end. I think there is probably a difference between someone who self-harmed as a young teenager, compared with someone who self-harmed well into adulthood and has only stopped within the last couple of years.

I’ll be honest. I had a history of self-harm as a teen. Not just a couple of times, a full on history involving multiple emergency trips and stitches. I had terrible scarring. As I got to my late teens, I got to the point of being able to address the trauma and reasons behind it. I’ve had full revision surgery on the main areas of scarring now so no one can tell my history. My husband does know though, and good thing he didn’t write me off. Aside from the fact I have better and more stable mental health than almost anyone I know (precisely because I’ve dealt with my shit), I have a PhD, a well paid career, and haven’t had a day of mental health problems since becoming a parent 13 years ago. I have four children and they would have zero clue. The idea I’m not an ideal parent because 24 years ago I chronically self-harmed could be offensive to some. I just find it amusing and short-sighted.

That’s a long way of saying, you don’t have to write him off, but I’d be wanting more information.

hellsBells246 · 11/02/2024 09:08

I'm not sure if it was a good idea asking here. Posters have been amazingly judgemental - about hoodies, about Pizza Hut, about you - not helpful!

ImCamembertTheBigCheese · 11/02/2024 09:08

What’s wrong with Pizza Hut and hoodies?

Nothing, just would not expect either on a first date.

HistoryBufff3 · 11/02/2024 09:09

In my personal experience, yes.

I met somebody who fits your description who seemed wonderful, albeit had clearly been through a troubled time. It emerged that he had a severe personality disorder and he abused me for 5 years. The self harm was something he weaponised to get what he wanted. I called the police on him for assault - he cut his arms. I wanted to leave him - he cut his arms. It was a truly disturbing time of my life.

I would like to think cases like this are in the minority and the vast majority of people who self harm would never hurt somebody else as they're doing it as a way of coping.

Just be careful and on alert for other red flags, in my case there were many but being so young I ignored them.

Bubble2024 · 11/02/2024 09:12

89redballoons · 11/02/2024 08:56

@Bubble2024 and some of the other posters here seem to believe that people can't recover from mental illness, whether it's addiction or self harm or whatever else. That's definitely not true - I and many of the other posters on this thread are living proof of that.

OP is totally within her rights not to trust her date that he's recovered or recovering. She isn't obliged to try and find out either. Especially since the guy just casually showed his scars, which were presumably quite noticeable, without saying anything.

If you grow up with a parent with ongoing mental health or addiction issues then I'm sure it's very difficult to believe that anyone could heal from the same issues and grow and be a better person. It is possible, though. It's also possible to teach and show your own children that healing and growth is possible, rather than trying to shield them forever from the fact that mental illness exists.

Mental illness and mental health issues are vastly different things. A bit of mild depression or anxiety is different from self harming and other.

i never said shield a child, teaching a child about mental health issues is not the same as setting the framework that mummy / daddy is not safe.

Donmeistersleepmachine · 11/02/2024 09:13

10ThousandSpoons · 11/02/2024 08:58

This guy has scars not active bleeding.

My ex had scars too, old ones, no active ones. I'm not saying everyone who self harms is the same or in the same place mentally because there's lots of avenues you can go down to end up at self harm. However, all it took was one argument and because it was so normal to him to cut when upset, even though he had been talking to his ex I had to drive to the woods, bring him home, tend to his massive cut ALL over his thigh done with a rusty can .. I would have thought before this his cutting was well in the past. Basically, from experience, I wouldn't be with someone who had previously been so mentally unstable they were cutting themselves enough to cover their arms. One or two yes. But not covered in them - purely because it's too much of a risk for in my mind to go through that again. I have terrible choices in men but I wouldn't go near somebody romantically who has self harmed before - I myself have been through lots of trauma and only once ever have a taken anything to my body to hurt myself. It was a butter knife and I brought myself to reality quite quickly. But mentally troubled enough to cover arms, I'll personally be passing, and that's from experience.

You're welcome to, as a stable or strong person who hasn't experienced somebody like that, ignore what I'm saying because you think I'm being harsh. I just find those who have used cutting therapeutically for a prolonged period are quite inclined to do it again if emotions are heightened or you threaten to leave or if the situation is very heavy. Which is a huge stress for somebody stable who wouldnt ever do such things.

Pickles2023 · 11/02/2024 09:15

Bubble2024 · 11/02/2024 09:05

Supporting others in a professional role is not the same as personal resilience.

I think dealing with death on a day by day basis. The trauma that entails and knowing one of these individuals personally and knowing what she deals with and how she copes i know she has more personal resilience then i know in most people and in myself...some people are less resilient and they don't have scars..

ArabellaScott · 11/02/2024 09:15

Sounded too good to be true.

This sentence worried me more than the scars, tbh. Anyway, seems you've decided you don't want to pursue the relationship.

All I was going to say is, always trust your gut. Nobody should ever try to persuade anyone into a relationship - you are always, always free to withdraw or end a relationshp just because you want to, for whatever reason.

Mariposistaaa · 11/02/2024 09:16

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 11/02/2024 08:28

It's an indicator that they once had mental health issues. It doesn't say anything at all about their current mental state.

You are right but I wouldn’t want the risk. What if he relapses. Has a very stressful time in the future? Redundancy, illness, bereavement? Do you want to be dealing with that? I wouldn’t if I had kids.

Dogdilemma2000 · 11/02/2024 09:17

Bubble2024 · 11/02/2024 09:12

Mental illness and mental health issues are vastly different things. A bit of mild depression or anxiety is different from self harming and other.

i never said shield a child, teaching a child about mental health issues is not the same as setting the framework that mummy / daddy is not safe.

Your posts totally contradict themselves and you are making no sense.

No one here is justifying self injury as a healthy coping mechanism. No one here is saying active major mental health issues are healthy to be around. No one is saying it’s ok for someone to be self injuring around children.

What everyone is saying is it’s possible to heal and recover from the past, and be totally mentally healthy in the present despite having had issues 20/30 years ago.

MolkosTeenageAngst · 11/02/2024 09:18

Bubble2024 · 11/02/2024 08:51

So your friend doesn’t have a history of self harming then. They self harmed once. Not quite the same.

She has visible self harm scars on one arm. People who saw them would probably assume she had a history of self-harm and judge accordingly. When does self harming once/ twice/ a few times qualify as having a ‘history of self-harming?’ Self harm is a such a broad term to cover a range of behaviours with a range of causes, severities, occurrences etc. How do you judge when it is symptomatic of being a person who has low resilience, turns to poor coping strategies and would be a bad, unhealthy parent vs somebody who is free to wipe it from their history?

PaperDoIIs · 11/02/2024 09:19

What I find highly ironic is that for every thread where a woman has some doubts and niggles and she's told she's ignorant and awful and stupid and of course everything will be fine, there are a dozen more asking why women are dating men that at best, aren't ok.

This is why. Because we are told we're crazy and awful and judgemental. Because we are told to ignore our boundaries and inner voices. Because we are told to be kind and understanding and put time and effort in dating and getting to know a man that for whatever reason makes us uncomfortable.

And when it all goes wrong we all get high and mighty because of course she should've known and never dated him in the first place.

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 11/02/2024 09:19

You are right but I wouldn’t want the risk. What if he relapses. Has a very stressful time in the future? Redundancy, illness, bereavement? Do you want to be dealing with that? I wouldn’t if I had kids.

It's a pretty fucking offensive assumption that anyone who's ever self-harmed will automatically relapse just because they're stressed.

Passingthethyme · 11/02/2024 09:20

NewYearNewCalendar · 11/02/2024 08:22

As someone who self harmed at uni, yes absolutely many of the people around me were self harming using weed or alcohol (or other drugs). They didn’t cut themselves, I didn’t use drugs or drink excessively.

Kindly, smoking weed or drinking when you're in your early 20s isn't self harming, it's what most do to have fun. Obviously if you're saying people are doing this to excess to harm themselves or cover up some deep mental issues then that is something quite different and I would also be cautious of this. I'd also caution OP against someone with a drug or alcohol addiction

Bubble2024 · 11/02/2024 09:20

Dogdilemma2000 · 11/02/2024 09:17

Your posts totally contradict themselves and you are making no sense.

No one here is justifying self injury as a healthy coping mechanism. No one here is saying active major mental health issues are healthy to be around. No one is saying it’s ok for someone to be self injuring around children.

What everyone is saying is it’s possible to heal and recover from the past, and be totally mentally healthy in the present despite having had issues 20/30 years ago.

I haven’t contradicted myself at all. I’ve said I wouldn’t want someone with that kind of history as a father to my children or if I already had children involved in their life or my life.

And I consider history of those issues too great

where do you think I’ve contradicted myself?

Bubble2024 · 11/02/2024 09:20

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 11/02/2024 09:19

You are right but I wouldn’t want the risk. What if he relapses. Has a very stressful time in the future? Redundancy, illness, bereavement? Do you want to be dealing with that? I wouldn’t if I had kids.

It's a pretty fucking offensive assumption that anyone who's ever self-harmed will automatically relapse just because they're stressed.

It’s pretty naive to think there isn’t a risk of it.

Notalldogs23 · 11/02/2024 09:22

As you have a child, I think you shouldn't take this any further, she had to be your absolute priority.

For those criticising you for judging him for this, it was a first date, the whole point is to judge whether you want to see the person again, you don't need an ethics committee to decide if you're permitted to reject him.

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 11/02/2024 09:22

@PaperDoIIs people can have whatever boundaries they like - that's not really what's being disputed here.

But having boundaries doesn't mean you get to be rude and judgemental about other people in the way that's being displayed on here. Some of these comments are awful and incredibly offensive.

By all means don't date someone with a history of self-harm - that's absolutely fine - but what's not fine is saying that they can't be suitable parents, or saying they can't be trusted not to relapse, or that they'll definitely be manipulative in an argument and threaten to cut themselves with kitchen scissors.

Those are only a few of the nasty comments that have been made by various posters on here. Imagine your child struggled with their mental health and people were saying those things.

Parisiennes · 11/02/2024 09:23

A hoodie
Pizza Hut
Scars

Is that the best he can do- wear a hoodie and suggest Pizza Hut?

Hardly making an effort unless that's the norm for yours and his social circle.

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 11/02/2024 09:23

It’s pretty naive to think there isn’t a risk of it.

I'm not debating with you because your posts are downright unpleasant and offensive.