Self harm is incredibly common. Given the rate of rise recorded between 2007 & 2014 in England (I assume Covid did for 2021’s survey) I’d be astonished if we weren’t now close to a third of women in the 16-24 age bracket having self-harmed (from the 1/4 in 2014); & a more dramatic rise from the 10% of men in that age bracket who’d self-harmed in 2014.
The Samaritans disagree about self-harm being manipulative behaviour btw. It shouldn’t be confused/conflated with threats to deliberate harm oneself if eg a relationship is ended - that absolutely is abusive behaviour; & frequently enacted by individuals with no history of self-harm &/or suicidal ideation.
Some people scar very badly & the scars do not fade. I have chickenpox scars from over 30 years ago; & I didn’t have chickenpox badly, I just scar badly. Chickenpox, cat scratches, a burn from Home Economics class… I have friends who self harmed & are very badly scarred; & friends who haven’t a mark on them now.
His scars are visible, unlike the vast majority of MH issues. The fact they’re scars not wounds suggests that he probably no longer engages in self-harm: it is also common to effectively “grow out of” using it as a coping strategy (albeit a negative one) as people gain agency, independence, & maturity.
Imagine you had to wear a label saying “had depression & had to take [name of medication]”. Would you want that to be what people judged you on? For it to be considered a “red flag”? He might not be right for you; & at some point, if you pursue a relationship, you’ll need to discuss his scars. But leaping to wild conclusions (& what’s worse, if he in fact fell through a window or whatever you’ll feel an absolute buckeejit for deciding the scars are self harm) & writing him off when you didn’t get a bad vibe even seems foolish, to say the least.