Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

I had a date with a guy I met off tinder and his arms were covered in self harm scars.

649 replies

Toffeeandfudge1 · 11/02/2024 01:41

So I’ve been talking to this man for afew weeks over WhatsApp now and he seemed really nice. We had lots in common such as love of dogs, music taste, read the same books and so on. We also have children of a similar age. Sounded too good to be true. So we met up tonight for the second time and went to Pizza Hut, and it was really hot in the restaurant so he took his hoodie off and I couldn’t help but notice his arms were covered in scars. They looked old but I was a little taken back as I don’t know anyone that this. I was trying not to look although I felt a little awkward. Am I being unreasonably judgemental or is this a red flag?

OP posts:
BungleandGeorge · 11/02/2024 10:59

Well loads of people have/ had mental health issues OP. The number on antidepressants is shocking. Some people deal with it by self harm, some drinking, some obsessively exercising, some drugs, some disordered eating, some OCD, some have multiple affairs some don’t deal with it at all and take it out on those around them. They’re not in a minority and personally I find some of the others way worse than self harm. It is discrimination so I think you need to question yourself whether it’s based on fact or your assumptions. Some of the nicest, kindest and strongest people I know have had demons to fight.

Bubble2024 · 11/02/2024 11:00

MolkosTeenageAngst · 11/02/2024 10:54

How can you say that this poster shouldn’t project or make assumptions about impact when this is exactly what you’ve been doing for this entire thread regarding the impact having a parent who has self-harm scars would have on children?

You’ve said all children whose parents have self harmed will be ‘significanty disadvantaged’ and ‘negatively impacted’ despite having no quality evidence or research to back this up. It’s just your assumption and projections based on your own childhood experiences of having a parent with active mental health/ addiction issues. You don’t seem able to rationalise that somebody can have self harmed in their past but can be healthy and happy and stable now and that it doesn’t have to have a major impact on their children.

It’s evidenced - please feel free to produce evidence showing children aren’t impacted if you want to have this discussion.

Making decisions based on evidence and my own boundaries is not the same as making assumptions about who or what I am.

Toffeeandfudge1 · 11/02/2024 11:03

Definitely mulling over it this morning. Arghhh. I might see him again.

OP posts:
PaperDoIIs · 11/02/2024 11:04

BungleandGeorge · 11/02/2024 10:59

Well loads of people have/ had mental health issues OP. The number on antidepressants is shocking. Some people deal with it by self harm, some drinking, some obsessively exercising, some drugs, some disordered eating, some OCD, some have multiple affairs some don’t deal with it at all and take it out on those around them. They’re not in a minority and personally I find some of the others way worse than self harm. It is discrimination so I think you need to question yourself whether it’s based on fact or your assumptions. Some of the nicest, kindest and strongest people I know have had demons to fight.

It's discrimination to not want to date him? Seriously?

Throckmorton · 11/02/2024 11:05

Fucking hell there are some judgemental posts on here. 1 in 4 people will have mental health issues at some point in their lives. Fair enough if you don't want to date those people, but to make out that they are all manipulative, basically permanetly broken, and someone children should not be exposed to is breathtakingly bigoted and ignorant.

Kbroughton · 11/02/2024 11:07

As I posted before, I self harmed as a teenager. According to some this is a massive red flag. My ex husband did not self harm as a teenager. Which one of the two of us do you think, lied, manipulated and cheated through our marriage? Point is, you don't know at this stage. It's fine to not what to find out, but the black and white comments on this thread judging people is just depressing. No pun intended.

Toffeeandfudge1 · 11/02/2024 11:08

Bubble2024 · 11/02/2024 11:00

It’s evidenced - please feel free to produce evidence showing children aren’t impacted if you want to have this discussion.

Making decisions based on evidence and my own boundaries is not the same as making assumptions about who or what I am.

I believe the burden of proof is on the one making the claim. Seriously, stop going out of your way to make women feel like rubbish mothers. You don’t know any of these women and you are coming across as manipulative and vindictive. You don’t have to do it, so just stop with that bullshit.

OP posts:
Clarissaexplainsit · 11/02/2024 11:09

Plenty of people have suffered from mental health difficulties and go on to make good recoveries. I suppose you don't know if this was a one off episode or something that recurs from time to time. It would be a conversation to have early on, if only because rejecting him on this basis would be very painful and difficult if feelings were more engaged. Many people who struggle with their mental health from time to time hold down demanding jobs and are excellent partners and parents. I would certainly look at what he had managed to achieve in terms of stability within employment, relationships, parenting, friendships - but as a parent I would do that with anyone.

Mrsredlipstick · 11/02/2024 11:09

This is a very sad thread. My DD self harmed and has scars.
I would be fuming if someone judged her for historic mh issues. She is currently studying for a medical based degree.
And I am a high earner but I love a movie and pizza hut. A bit of kindness is worth more than a fancy restaurant. Plus you can have seconds!
Give the fellow a chance. He could have had a shit childhood. I did and it made me drink too much for twenty years.
Bio oil works if you want to reduce scars.

10ThousandSpoons · 11/02/2024 11:10

Toffeeandfudge1 · 11/02/2024 11:08

I believe the burden of proof is on the one making the claim. Seriously, stop going out of your way to make women feel like rubbish mothers. You don’t know any of these women and you are coming across as manipulative and vindictive. You don’t have to do it, so just stop with that bullshit.

I think you get it OP. It's not a red flag but it's a flag of "lets have a conversation and see what the situation is".

Trulyme · 11/02/2024 11:10

Toffeeandfudge1 · 11/02/2024 11:03

Definitely mulling over it this morning. Arghhh. I might see him again.

Why not just see him again and take it from there?

His scars may not even be from self harm or they may be very old.

Perhaps just carry on and if there is anything else that you think could be a red flag, then just end things.

I personally wouldn’t end things over just this.

Take some posters comments with a pinch of salt as they also have an issue with a hoodie and Pizza Hut, so I would ignore their advice.

ToRecordOnlyWater · 11/02/2024 11:11

He can’t help having the scars, and I’m sure he would rather be without them as you do get judged a lot on having them (in my job I’ve worked with a lot of people with extensive scarring from their youth they were desperate to cover as it still brings them shame, even though it shouldn’t). They feel the judgement every day when they wear shorts, or t-shirts. It’s not necessarily a red flag at all, and I’d be gutted if someone saw my SH scars and assumed I was unstable because of it. They were from a part of my life I hope to never return to many years ago and even if you haven’t self-harmed for many years the scars are always there to remind you. Also want to go against the poster(s) saying ‘what if he threatens to cut himself if you dump him’ and similar, most people who are mentally ill are not manipulative or abusive in this way and it’s quite offensive to imply as such.

Bubble2024 · 11/02/2024 11:13

Toffeeandfudge1 · 11/02/2024 11:08

I believe the burden of proof is on the one making the claim. Seriously, stop going out of your way to make women feel like rubbish mothers. You don’t know any of these women and you are coming across as manipulative and vindictive. You don’t have to do it, so just stop with that bullshit.

I did provide evidence that it impacts.

I NEVER said people who have self harmed shouldn’t have children. That’s their choice. But if they think it won’t impact that’s an issue. Knowing it will and mitigating that is fine but pretending it doesn’t matter. That is not fine and is an issue.

Manipulative?! What 😂

BungleandGeorge · 11/02/2024 11:15

@PaperDoIIs its discrimination to make assumptions based purely on the self harm yes, it practically the definition of discrimination. You can date who you want but if you’re making snap decisions based on ethnicity, disabilities, scars etc it’s discrimination and might be best to have a think about why
FWIW I couldn’t care less whether my parent had SH scars. What mattered was their parenting ability which is unaffected by scarring whatever the cause

Noshowlomo · 11/02/2024 11:19

Of course it’s not discrimination to not want to date anyone for ANYTHING.
“I don’t want to date you because you have self harm scars and I don’t know how to navigate that”

”you can’t say that, that’s discrimination against me”

Makes it make sense. Where do you go from there. Being accused of being discriminating for life because you’ve got boundaries and a type?

Bubble2024 · 11/02/2024 11:21

BungleandGeorge · 11/02/2024 11:15

@PaperDoIIs its discrimination to make assumptions based purely on the self harm yes, it practically the definition of discrimination. You can date who you want but if you’re making snap decisions based on ethnicity, disabilities, scars etc it’s discrimination and might be best to have a think about why
FWIW I couldn’t care less whether my parent had SH scars. What mattered was their parenting ability which is unaffected by scarring whatever the cause

Assuming that someone who has self harmed has self harmed is not remotely discriminatory.

4timesthefun · 11/02/2024 11:28

Bubble2024 · 11/02/2024 11:13

I did provide evidence that it impacts.

I NEVER said people who have self harmed shouldn’t have children. That’s their choice. But if they think it won’t impact that’s an issue. Knowing it will and mitigating that is fine but pretending it doesn’t matter. That is not fine and is an issue.

Manipulative?! What 😂

Parental mental health absolutely has an impact on child development. Agree 100%. However, you are very certain of your position that self-harm happening decades before giving birth will impact on children, even if there have been no additional mental health concerns. Can you please link the evidence of that? I’d actually genuinely like to know. I’m not completely convinced that my behaviour 24 years ago is negatively impacting my children’s own well-being and development. However, if there is evidence suggesting otherwise I’m keen to look at how I can mitigate that. Because I’ve had scar revision surgery, mine aren’t aware of my self-harm history. If there is evidence my behaviour as a teen is harmful, it might influence my approach when they are exposed to it with peers etc.

cerisepanther73 · 11/02/2024 11:36

@Mrsredlipstick

Hear hear well said totally agree with your good insightful emotionally intelligent post on here...

Often in our society in the past there wasn't the support and awareness of how traumas such as shit childhood ect, can impact people,
thankfully there is more awareness nowadays about this topical issue,
but still not enough good effective support out there,
Huge waiting lists for counselling and other effective therapies support out there,
and it's often expensive too..

Free or reasonable low cost good effective therapies are like gold dust out there in life,

But saying that maybe in some cases 🤔 if someone pays for therapy sessions it gives them more motivation and incentive to want to want to stick at that therapy and make the necessary changes strategies to improve themselves,
to heal from whatever trauma,

I know maybe a bit of controversial point of view point saying that,

Bubble2024 · 11/02/2024 11:37

4timesthefun · 11/02/2024 11:28

Parental mental health absolutely has an impact on child development. Agree 100%. However, you are very certain of your position that self-harm happening decades before giving birth will impact on children, even if there have been no additional mental health concerns. Can you please link the evidence of that? I’d actually genuinely like to know. I’m not completely convinced that my behaviour 24 years ago is negatively impacting my children’s own well-being and development. However, if there is evidence suggesting otherwise I’m keen to look at how I can mitigate that. Because I’ve had scar revision surgery, mine aren’t aware of my self-harm history. If there is evidence my behaviour as a teen is harmful, it might influence my approach when they are exposed to it with peers etc.

Why haven’t you told them?

MolkosTeenageAngst · 11/02/2024 11:50

Bubble2024 · 11/02/2024 11:13

I did provide evidence that it impacts.

I NEVER said people who have self harmed shouldn’t have children. That’s their choice. But if they think it won’t impact that’s an issue. Knowing it will and mitigating that is fine but pretending it doesn’t matter. That is not fine and is an issue.

Manipulative?! What 😂

Which post provided evidence? I’m sorry I just have missed it in what is now quite a long thread. Please could you point me to the evidence/ research that having a parent with self harm scars impacts children?

PaperDoIIs · 11/02/2024 11:55

BungleandGeorge · 11/02/2024 11:15

@PaperDoIIs its discrimination to make assumptions based purely on the self harm yes, it practically the definition of discrimination. You can date who you want but if you’re making snap decisions based on ethnicity, disabilities, scars etc it’s discrimination and might be best to have a think about why
FWIW I couldn’t care less whether my parent had SH scars. What mattered was their parenting ability which is unaffected by scarring whatever the cause

Absolute bullshit. Having preferences and boundaries isn't discrimination. No one has the right to date a specific person. It doesn't exist.

You're a predator's wet dream with that mentality.

Dogdilemma2000 · 11/02/2024 11:59

Bubble2024 · 11/02/2024 11:00

It’s evidenced - please feel free to produce evidence showing children aren’t impacted if you want to have this discussion.

Making decisions based on evidence and my own boundaries is not the same as making assumptions about who or what I am.

It’s not evidenced. You’ve quoted one study on twins on rates of suicidal ideation when one twin has committed suicide. Massive confirmation bias there with the people studied. No report on a parent’s effect on the child when the parent has resolved their mental health issues. The traumatic death of a sibling has a profound effect on any child’s mental health way above past mental health issues of a parent.

In short, you’ve no flipping clue what you’re talking about.

Bubble2024 · 11/02/2024 12:03

Dogdilemma2000 · 11/02/2024 11:59

It’s not evidenced. You’ve quoted one study on twins on rates of suicidal ideation when one twin has committed suicide. Massive confirmation bias there with the people studied. No report on a parent’s effect on the child when the parent has resolved their mental health issues. The traumatic death of a sibling has a profound effect on any child’s mental health way above past mental health issues of a parent.

In short, you’ve no flipping clue what you’re talking about.

Yes it is.

There are endless charities set up to support the impact of parental mental health issues on children.

It’s absolutely ludicrous to suggest that children won’t be impacted if parents have a history of or active mental health issues.

I want to say I’m shocked anyone would claim it doesn’t but in the world of mumsnet I am not.

4timesthefun · 11/02/2024 12:10

Bubble2024 · 11/02/2024 11:37

Why haven’t you told them?

It’s not quite age appropriate yet. The reason behind mine as a young teen was extremely severe sexual abuse and not knowing how to cope. It’s actually the ‘why’ that would hold me back, as I’m not sure there is any benefit to them knowing that part of my history during their own developmental years. It would feel disingenuous to tell them about the self-harming but then make up an underlying reason or just lie and say I had depression. I’ve had more than enough counselling that I COULD talk about the abuse with them. It doesn’t hold power over me now… But I bring myself back to the question of whether telling them about my childhood/teen abuse and subsequent teenage behaviour would bring any value or benefit to their lives. At this stage, the answer is no, I don’t see that information helping them.

Don’t get me wrong, I’m very open with the kids generally, and I did a locum stint in a prison a few years back, so we have had many age appropriate conversations about difficult topics. I don’t shield them from everything in life, but I’m happy to make the judgement call on this one for now. I’m hoping the research you have found on the long term impacts of adolescent behaviours on parenting could shed some light on whether or not to discuss it with the kids from an evidence based perspective.

UnimaginableWindBird · 11/02/2024 12:16

Bubble, posted a link earlier in the thread showing that there were genetic as well as environmental factors in people who reported thoughts of suicide and self-harm.

I don't dispute this - there are certainly a lot of heritable mental illnesses, and there is evidence that a tendency to self-harm does, itself, have a genetic component.

But most people aren't such eugenicists as only to want to have children with someone who is genetically perfect.

@Bubble2024, you come from a family with a history of alcohol misuse, which has a strong genetic component, and had children with an autistic partner, and while autism isn't a mental illness, autistic people are three times more likely to self-harm than neurotypical people. So I'm taking from that that you don't actually think that people who have children when they have a genetic link to self-harm are bad parents.

Or have I been misunderstanding you? From what you've said, I've got the impression that you see the scars as both an indicator of severe long-term mental illness, and as something inherently traumatic to children.

I genuinely don't think that my teenage self-harm has had any significant effect on my happy, healthy, flourishing teenagers. Other aspects of my life and personality have proved to be far greater challenges when raising them. You talked about a mother "taking a blade to herself" in a way that seemed really visceral, but that's not really how it ever was with my children. I have scars from self-harm and scars from minor accidents and injuries, and illnesses, and also patches of eczema, and by the time they were old enough to tell the difference they had years of stable care to make them feel secure. I had some conversations with DD as she was heading towards puberty about how I had experienced PMDD so that we could both keep an eye out for symptoms in case it affected her, too, but luckily she was fine.

Sorry if the thread has moved on and my post is no longer relevant - I've spent ages writing this, and had to order the groceries in the middle.

Swipe left for the next trending thread