Bubble, posted a link earlier in the thread showing that there were genetic as well as environmental factors in people who reported thoughts of suicide and self-harm.
I don't dispute this - there are certainly a lot of heritable mental illnesses, and there is evidence that a tendency to self-harm does, itself, have a genetic component.
But most people aren't such eugenicists as only to want to have children with someone who is genetically perfect.
@Bubble2024, you come from a family with a history of alcohol misuse, which has a strong genetic component, and had children with an autistic partner, and while autism isn't a mental illness, autistic people are three times more likely to self-harm than neurotypical people. So I'm taking from that that you don't actually think that people who have children when they have a genetic link to self-harm are bad parents.
Or have I been misunderstanding you? From what you've said, I've got the impression that you see the scars as both an indicator of severe long-term mental illness, and as something inherently traumatic to children.
I genuinely don't think that my teenage self-harm has had any significant effect on my happy, healthy, flourishing teenagers. Other aspects of my life and personality have proved to be far greater challenges when raising them. You talked about a mother "taking a blade to herself" in a way that seemed really visceral, but that's not really how it ever was with my children. I have scars from self-harm and scars from minor accidents and injuries, and illnesses, and also patches of eczema, and by the time they were old enough to tell the difference they had years of stable care to make them feel secure. I had some conversations with DD as she was heading towards puberty about how I had experienced PMDD so that we could both keep an eye out for symptoms in case it affected her, too, but luckily she was fine.
Sorry if the thread has moved on and my post is no longer relevant - I've spent ages writing this, and had to order the groceries in the middle.