Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be offended that SIL told me to return a gift I got for her?

335 replies

chicosmommy · 10/01/2024 19:50

I try to buy my Christmas gifts early in the year, during sales and times when there might be discounts.

I was in Harvey Nics in September and I spotted a gorgeous jumpsuit in SIL's size and in a brand that she loves and wears a lot. It was 50% off. I bought it for her and kept it until Christmas Day to give it to her as her gift.

When Christmas Day came around, she opened the gift, scrunched up her nose at it and said these exact words, "urgh. I wouldn't wear that. Can you return this and get me a voucher instead".

I just took it back, said very little and today, I went in to try get the value of the jumpsuit in a voucher. The store told me that because it was bought in September, it is too far back and they can't give me a voucher.

Clearly, I don't want SIL to know that I'm buying her gift on discount so I ended up buying a voucher for her for £150 & I'm stuck with the jumpsuit, which I'll have to ebay or put on Depop (doesn't fit me).

What are people's thoughts on this? Is it very rude not to accept a gift and if you don't like it, just exchange it yourself? Should you expect the buyer/gifter to exchange it for you?

OP posts:
TillyTrifle · 10/01/2024 22:50

Honestly I think YABU.

A jumpsuit is a very big risk even from a brand you know she likes. It’s a very marmite item. Sounds to me like you’re annoyed because you wanted her to think you spent about £150 (because presumably this is a normal established present amount in your family if that’s what you spent on the voucher), you thought you’d pulled a blinder by getting something much cheaper and are annoyed because you feel caught out? It’s bonkers to buy someone clothes without giving a gift receipt. Don’t buy sale crap that the person can’t return - if your budget is less than £150 then buy something costing that at full price (and include a gift receipt if it’s clothes!)

Spomsored · 10/01/2024 22:51

Is £150 what you actually spent or the price before it was discounted? Either way just keep the voucher for yourself. Tell your SiL that you bought it too long ago to return and offer it back to her. I'm sorry that what you thought was a great gift was so rudely received. Unless your SiL always gives you fabulous presents, I suggest you stop exchanging Christmas gifts.

Mirabai · 10/01/2024 22:53

Bainbridgemews · 10/01/2024 22:18

Which is exactly why many people don't buy sale items for presents, knowing they can't be returned it they're no good.

Exactly.

Legendairy · 10/01/2024 22:54

YABU for buying a jumpsuit for someone and not getting a gift receipt

She is BU for being so rude, she should have at least have the decency to say it didn't fit the next day or something and ask to exchange.

juicyfruitmtume · 10/01/2024 22:54

Just tell her they won't exchange it or give a refund because you've run out of time to take it back, as you buy things you like throughout the year.

She doesn't need to know if you got it reduced or not.

She should be the one who is embarrassed for her behaviour and not you!

Suggest she sells it on something like Depop or Vinted!

SauronsArsehole · 10/01/2024 22:59

Suck it up this time. Next year she gets. 3 for 2 boots beauty gift for £15

amispeakingintongues · 10/01/2024 23:00

She is insanely rude. I can't believe you spent £150 on a voucher after that behaviour. She wouldn't even get a card from me next year.

Did anyone else witness her being so rude to you? My toes are curling

MCOut · 10/01/2024 23:02

She’s so rude. I’d be so touched if my SIL even noticed which brands I favoured. You are far too nice, I wouldn’t have given her a voucher.

PlipPlopChoo · 10/01/2024 23:07

You should have asked our advice before buying a £150 voucher.

Buy her a very cheap present next year, the ungrateful little shit.

BungleandGeorge · 10/01/2024 23:07

Why don’t you want her to know that it was on discount? Why are you pretending it was £150?
on the surface yes she was rude but sometimes people are obsessed with getting things in the sale so that it appears they’ve spent much more than they have than actually getting a gift the other person would like.in which case you can see why someone might get a bit annoyed at always receiving unsuitable gifts that they can’t use. How much did she spend on you? In future I’d just buy something for your budget that is less personal than clothing or get something she can exchange. She will know how much you paid then though

Sj07 · 10/01/2024 23:14

Cheap box of chocolates next year. At most. Learn your lesson.

Bellavida99 · 10/01/2024 23:21

I think it’s really relevant to know what she got you. If she got you something you absolutely love worth at least £150 that’s fine but if not I don’t understand why you bought the voucher. And if you’re not 100% happy with your gift hand it back to her and say you’ve been thinking you’d actually prefer a voucher too please. Then agree never to bother with presents again or just small token gifts

Tuturkeykey · 10/01/2024 23:24

I can’t get my head around the concept of buying someone else a jumpsuit. It’s my idea of hell - ill fitting, impractical garment and you have to strip naked to have a wee. How does it work in public loos? My mind boggles.

Sorry OP, I think you were generous but you didn’t think this through.

Xmasbaby11 · 10/01/2024 23:26

Yes she was rude, but it’s risky buying someone clothes, let alone in a sale, expensive AND months past it can be returned.

Sorry but yabu. You made a bad decision and it’s quite right that you had to deal with it since she couldn’t have. You gave her too much money though.

Singingseals · 10/01/2024 23:32

She was very rude, but yes, the mind boggles at buying someone a jumpsuit. Unless she’s a serial jumpsuit wearer it’s a really odd gift, sorry op! And maybe her rudeness was just her being taken aback, I certainly would be if I received one in those circumstances.

Daffodilsandtuplips · 10/01/2024 23:36

She was rude.
£150.00 !
She’d have got a voucher for £50.00 from me and no more.
Remember this for next Christmas and do the same.., £50.00. Front it out and present it to her with aplomb and a big smile.

ReadingSoManyThreads · 10/01/2024 23:36

@chicosmommy she was extremely rude. I would not have bought her a £150 voucher instead. I would not buy for her ever again. Your husband can buy for his own ungrateful sister instead. Don't waste your time or energy shopping for her again.

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 10/01/2024 23:37

You bought someone a jumpsuit as a gift? Irrelevant that she wears clothing form that brand, I can my think of a single brand where I like EVERYTHING in their range. In fact some years I like nothing at all in their shops, and then the next year I like loads.

Your SIL was a little in the rude side but on balance you were worse.

If you want to pre buy, keep it generic!

heartbroken22 · 10/01/2024 23:38

Next time take the gift back and just keep it. Avoid wasting time going to the shops and returning. Don't bother gifting her anything.

Zingy123 · 10/01/2024 23:46

She was rude by saying what she said. However it's silly to have bought clothes she might not like and to have bought it so long ago it couldn't be exchanged.

RedToothBrush · 11/01/2024 00:10

£150 for a christmas present for a SIL??!

Jesus.

What was the point of the thread again, cos I can't get past that bit...

Frangipanyoul8r · 11/01/2024 00:13

It was a high risk gift that didn’t work out. She was rude but the likelihood of it fitting her and her liking it and wearing it were slim.

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 11/01/2024 00:14

Gardengirl108 · 10/01/2024 20:38

I gave a book to someone (an adult) as a birthday gift. She unwrapped it, told me she already had it and gave it back to me. I’m not usually lost for words, but I was that day. I never bought her another gift though.

I don't think that's rude. What did you expect her to do with it? It's a waste of money holding on to it. Giving it back gives you the option of reading it yourself, if you hadn't read it; returning it to the shop or passing it on to someone else.

Alloftheskies · 11/01/2024 00:20

A jumpsuit was a dangerous gift tbh... you don't know how it's going to fit and even if it's a brand she likes jumpsuits can be very marmite. It's a risky gift to spend so much money on.
That being said she was a bit rude...
However I do think it odd you gave her more back than you spent on it..
It seems a bit like you are more concerned about showing off how much an item is worth than whether it's actually wanted.
I'd have just told her unfortunately you couldn't return it.. or at most given her the amount it actually cost in the sale..

IHaveNeverLivedintheCastle · 11/01/2024 00:24

ManateeFair · 10/01/2024 20:49

If those were her exact words, then yes, she was rude.

However, I think plenty of people would rather someone didn’t waste their money on a gift that won’t get used, so I don’t think it was unreasonable of her to want to return it. The way she asked was rude (“I’m really sorry, I can totally see why you picked this out for me but I can’t see myself wearing this / it doesn’t fit - do you have the receipt? Then I can exchange it” would have been the politer thing to say).

But even if she’d been polite about it, that wouldn’t have changed the fact that you wouldn’t have been able to exchange it. Spending a large amount of money on an item of clothing for someone else, many months before Christmas - especially something like a jumpsuit where the fit has to be perfect for it to look good, and which a lot of women never wear - was a silly decision on your part. Particularly if you’re embarrassed to be caught out buying things in the sales and passing them off as full-price items. If I bought someone a gift in a sale, I wouldn’t try to hide that fact and then get pissed off if they found out.

Somewhere in a parallel Mumsnet universe there’s a thread that says “My SIL bought me a jumpsuit for Christmas. It’s by a brand I sometimes wear but I absolutely hate it - clothes are such a personal thing and I would never wear it. She didn’t enclose the receipt or tell me where it was from and I didn’t want her money to be wasted so I asked if maybe she could exchange it for a gift card. Turns out that she actually bought it half price in a sale and so long ago that it’s non-returnable. Fair enough, just one of those things. But now she’s angry at ME because she’s embarrassed at being caught out! AIBU to say it’s not my fault that she wanted to pass off a sale purchase from a year ago as a new full-price item, and that I couldn’t possibly have known that when I asked to swap it?!”

Indeed. There's always 2 sides to a story.

Swipe left for the next trending thread