Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To consider a deferral for dc1 because it is unfair for her to be the youngest in her year while her little sister will be the oldest in her year?

402 replies

sunflowerdaisiesroses · 26/09/2023 10:42

Hello
I have two dcs, one born in 19/7/2020 and the other in 2/9/2022.
First dc is due to enter Reception in Sept 2024 at 4 +2 months due to state cut off, and the second will be due in Sept 2027 at 5 yo.

I feel like it is unfair for dc1 to be expected to act/ achieve at a level of 3 years ahead of dc2 when she is practically only 2 years older than dc2. Dc1 has ASD while dc2 is very likely NT, which adds to that.

I am considering a deferral for dc1 mainly because of this reason, which DH thinks is ridiculous.

Any ideas on whether I should defer dc1?

For some context both dcs are academically bright, but dc1 is really babyish compared to other 3 yo and dc2 seems more mature than other 1yo.

OP posts:
sunflowerdaisiesroses · 26/09/2023 12:51

Bear2014 · 26/09/2023 12:41

Nah - I have one January and one August child, it is what it is.

To be honest, if you equate age with ability I think being the oldest in the year is also problematic. The school have to keep the pace of learning manageable for all 30 children regardless of age or ability, so your September born, having done 2 years of preschool as opposed to 1, will then be covering some of the same ground yet again. They will need to use the TAs to help the ones who may be struggling to keep up so may not be able to stretch the more able ones. Of course the more able ones can be the youngest as age is just one factor.

The only reason we would have considered deferring would have been for obvious delays/SEN/if he had been born prematurely.

My dc1 has ASD

OP posts:
notafruit · 26/09/2023 12:52

I have 2 July babies, and the thought never crossed my mind. Initially it might seem like a good idea, but roll on a few years, and that child will be monumentally annoyed at you, when there are kids younger than them in the year above, going to high school/leaving school altogether.

One of my DC's had August born friends.
Academically, after a few weeks, it makes no difference when they were born. Delaying their start will probably only lead to 13 years of piss taking by other kids.
They won't thank you for it.

usernother · 26/09/2023 12:54

Mine were exactly the same OP. One a summer birth, one early September. I never considered deferring. The summer born was a bit behind at first but soon caught up. The September born wasn't always top of the class. They are all different OP. I agree with your husband, there is no reason to defer.

sunflowerdaisiesroses · 26/09/2023 12:55

notafruit · 26/09/2023 12:52

I have 2 July babies, and the thought never crossed my mind. Initially it might seem like a good idea, but roll on a few years, and that child will be monumentally annoyed at you, when there are kids younger than them in the year above, going to high school/leaving school altogether.

One of my DC's had August born friends.
Academically, after a few weeks, it makes no difference when they were born. Delaying their start will probably only lead to 13 years of piss taking by other kids.
They won't thank you for it.

Does "piss-taking" mean discriminated due to being a few months older than usual? That's never crossed my mind....

OP posts:
Lou670 · 26/09/2023 12:55

My daughters are adults now but I had this but the other way around. First born a September birthday and second born an August birthday. There was a difference between the two in terms of development and personal care. My September birthday was more than ready for school but my youngest did struggle a bit.

I decided against referring as noone else was and I was worried that if she started much later then friendships would have already been established. The first year is always difficult for all of them. It balances it out and they soon find their feet. As it turns out my youngest born academically and socially did better than her sister.

VyneVibes · 26/09/2023 12:57

All of the evidence shows that summer born children entering school with their normal cohort are at a disadvantage throughout their education.
Join the Flexible School Admission for Summer Borns group on Facebook for all of the info you will need.
We deferred our summer born daughter who has ASD. She has just started reception and is worlds away from the just turned 4 year old she was last year when she “should” have started school.

TaigaSno · 26/09/2023 12:58

My sister and I are both end of summer birthdays, so we were both the very youngest in our school year groups. She excelled academically and got top grades for everything, she even got her photo in the local paper for getting the top grades in the area. I didn't do anywhere near as well academically.
So birthday/age in year isn't necessarily the best judge. Nothing wrong with deferring your daughter but make the decision based on her and her needs, not on comparison to a sibling.
FWIW, my sister and I both have equally successful careers regardless of school achievement!

Bear2014 · 26/09/2023 12:59

Rather than automatically deferring I'd be looking into what school will be the best for ASD. They will be more likely to thrive in that setting than at nursery.

RampantIvy · 26/09/2023 13:01

You should base decisions about DD1 purely on her needs and not those if others e.g, you and DD2.
Unless you have an extremely good reason don't take her away from her peer group and force her into younger classes so the gap with her sister will be artificially 'narrowed'.

I agree with this.
How does deferral work when it comes to secondary school? Am I correct in thinking that all children get put in the same academic year according to age even if it means skipping a year?

@sunflowerdaisiesroses you need to do what is right for your child, not what you want for yourself.

For the record, DD is mid July born, but was ready to join reception at the right age. I think it helped that it was a small school with mixed year groups, so she had friends who were a few weeks younger than her but in the year below.

She excelled at school, smashed her SATS, GCSEs and A levels and achieved a first class STEM degree last year.

misslooloo · 26/09/2023 13:04

My daughter was born at the end of August and started school before the option of deferring was a thing. She started school still half-bald and a uniform that was slipping off her frame. I felt like I had been cheated out of time with her at home 🥲

Academically wasn’t an issue at all. She’s a bright girl has always been in the top half of her class. As a tween I could see the differences in maturity with some of her older friends and in many ways that really upset me. It was almost like she was being dragged into adolescence before she was emotionally ready. I do think staying at her primary school for an extra year would have been frustrating for her, however. She was definitely ready to move up schools when she did.

Now as she starts her GCSEs it has all smoothed out, and other than the feeling of being cheated out of more time with her, I wouldn’t change it.

There is no one-size-fits-all. Go with your gut x

Heronwatcher · 26/09/2023 13:08

I mean this all sounds a bit mad. So your DD is already on yr 1 maths and you still want to defer her? So by the time she eventually starts (in 2025?) she’ll be older than all of her classmates but also probably doing year 2/3 maths because you’ve taught her at home. And you think this will help her socially? She’ll be bored stiff in class and 15 months older than some of her classmates, I’m not sure that’s going to help her make friends (and it sounds like a recipe for bad behaviour in class if she’s over 2 years ahead of her peers). Plus what about the teacher!! If you do do it then you can’t then be that parent turning up at school complaining that your DC isn’t being challenged because you’ve kept her back a year.

Socially reception is a huge mix, some kids (usually those with older kids) are a bit more streetwise but like everyone there are friendship groups over a wide range of ages and interests. I don’t think being older is going to really help if she does have difficulties- especially if she’s bored in class too.

Crunchingleaf · 26/09/2023 13:09

Where I live there is more flexibility regarding starting school. My eldest was diagnosed with ASD at three. He was eligible to start school at 4 but I waited until he was 5.
I have no regrets he is not very mature for his age, his social skills were behind etc.
My eldest is a boy so even though he is in secondary school now he is still coping fine with the boys. Given your eldest is a girl I think it’s very important to point out that once girls hit puberty the complexities of female friendships get even higher. So even if primary school is fine for her she might find secondary school a massive jump for her. So for some children deferring for a year can be the best decision you can make for them.

I find the English attitude to deferring quite strange. My sister hated being youngest in her year and struggled on and off for years but when it came to starting her summer born child she did same thing, because she said he is bright. I think this is actually the crux of the problem people can be overly focused on academics are afraid that if they defer then the child is seen as not capable academically.

Regholdsworthswaterbed · 26/09/2023 13:09

VyneVibes · 26/09/2023 12:57

All of the evidence shows that summer born children entering school with their normal cohort are at a disadvantage throughout their education.
Join the Flexible School Admission for Summer Borns group on Facebook for all of the info you will need.
We deferred our summer born daughter who has ASD. She has just started reception and is worlds away from the just turned 4 year old she was last year when she “should” have started school.

It depends on the child. My summer born certainly isn't disadvantaged.

humpty74 · 26/09/2023 13:09

What does nursery think?

You lose your 15 or 30 nursery hours once they're old enough to go to school, so you might need to think about whether it's financially viable.

Some summer kids do benefit from deferral and some autumn ones from early entry. That said, if she prefers to play alone a more structured environment might suit her more than the free-flow type play they have in most nursery environments.

Does she have friends at nursery that will be going to school at the same time? Being left behind might be hard for her if she does and you do defer.

Lancasterel · 26/09/2023 13:09

I think the word “unfair” is a bit strange. My DS was born at the end of August, despite being due to September. He is one of the youngest in his year but doing fine. I don’t think of it as unfair, just luck of the draw I suppose, they’ve got to draw the line somewhere in the calendar.
My DD does think it’s unfair though that he’ll always have his birthday in the holidays, while she has to go to school on hers…

gogomoto · 26/09/2023 13:10

I'm an august birthday as is my brother, he struggled more than me though I was actually preemie (due in October!) I wouldn't have been happy to realise that my parents had held me back. I left home for university at just 18.

Hankunamatata · 26/09/2023 13:12

Iv two summer born and wish I had the option to defer at the time. Statistically they do so much better being eldest on the class and having more confidence. I'd advise any summer born to defer

Regholdsworthswaterbed · 26/09/2023 13:15

Hankunamatata · 26/09/2023 13:12

Iv two summer born and wish I had the option to defer at the time. Statistically they do so much better being eldest on the class and having more confidence. I'd advise any summer born to defer

What bollocks. Just because your children weren't ready it doesn't mean others aren't.

UrsulaBelle · 26/09/2023 13:19

Ignoring the fact you have a September born child, as it isn't relevant... You have a July born child with ASD. There is no better reason to defer. They will do much better socially in the year below, will be advantaged throughout their education for being a bit older. Will this make up for their disability? Perhaps, perhaps not, but why not do this if you have the opportunity? I have an October born DS with ASD, I didn't defer as it wasn't allowed back then without an EHCP/statement of SEN. In retrospect, even he as an October child would have benefitted with a little more maturity, even up until sixth form.

notafruit · 26/09/2023 13:25

sunflowerdaisiesroses · 26/09/2023 12:55

Does "piss-taking" mean discriminated due to being a few months older than usual? That's never crossed my mind....

Yes. Kids can be horrible, and if it becomes common knowledge (which it will) that Little Janet/John is actually older than a couple kids in the year above, (even if it is just by a few days) then they WILL become a target for some other kids. There's no reasonable way to explain "well, my mum thought I wasn't ready for school when I was 4, so deferred me for a year" for a kid.

Just image being that kid. Best leave them to get on with it. As many posters have pointed out, if will make absolutely no difference whatsoever when it gets to GCSE/A level stage. Except the kid will have escaped the shame of being kept down a year.

TheyWentToSeaInASieve · 26/09/2023 13:26

Two deferred boys in my son's secondary are the tallest in the year and, apparently, get teased for being left behind. You should be careful. Some children benefit but not all.

Also, in the nicest possible way, you need to lose the language of "fair/unfair" as that itself sounds a little immature. I am sure that is not how you mean to come across.

VyneVibes · 26/09/2023 13:30

Regholdsworthswaterbed · 26/09/2023 13:09

It depends on the child. My summer born certainly isn't disadvantaged.

Yes of course, and that’s great for your child. When looking at the overall data it is not the case.

VaguelySpecific · 26/09/2023 13:30

Like many others on this thread my eldest is one of the youngest in their year and my youngest is one of the oldest in their year.
My eldest was ready to go to primary school the year she was 'meant' to. She was getting bored at preschool and needed something more challenging. Yes, emotional maturity wise she is perhaps slightly behind the older kids in the class but only slightly and she gets the advantage of learning from older classmates examples. But that's my child, only you will be able to say if deferral is best for your child, either way the idea of fairness based on a siblings month of birth shouldn't come into it.

jannier · 26/09/2023 13:32

caban · 26/09/2023 11:02

If you defer your child goes into Reception age 5, so the oldest of the class, rather than skipping R and going into Y1 as the youngest.

Not in all schools so check.

Squirrelsbite · 26/09/2023 13:32

Being fair is giving both kids the same educational access , just because one will be the youngest or oldest does not mean that one will have a better start/outcome than the other. Just because they are young does not necessarily mean they will be at a disadvantage in relation to their siblings or peers you do what is right at the time for the individual child not because ‘ it’s not fair to be the youngest’

Swipe left for the next trending thread