Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To consider a deferral for dc1 because it is unfair for her to be the youngest in her year while her little sister will be the oldest in her year?

402 replies

sunflowerdaisiesroses · 26/09/2023 10:42

Hello
I have two dcs, one born in 19/7/2020 and the other in 2/9/2022.
First dc is due to enter Reception in Sept 2024 at 4 +2 months due to state cut off, and the second will be due in Sept 2027 at 5 yo.

I feel like it is unfair for dc1 to be expected to act/ achieve at a level of 3 years ahead of dc2 when she is practically only 2 years older than dc2. Dc1 has ASD while dc2 is very likely NT, which adds to that.

I am considering a deferral for dc1 mainly because of this reason, which DH thinks is ridiculous.

Any ideas on whether I should defer dc1?

For some context both dcs are academically bright, but dc1 is really babyish compared to other 3 yo and dc2 seems more mature than other 1yo.

OP posts:
SpendingTooLongThinkingOfAUsername · 27/09/2023 07:09

I have 3 kids with summer birthdays and another 3 with birthdays earlier in the school year. It has made Zero difference when their birthdays are. DC6 (who also is 19/7!) is a whizz at maths and is outperforming targets despite being "young". DC5 is super sporty and excels in interschool sporting competitions despite being nearly a year younger than some other competitors. It's only a year, not a decade.

Rycbar · 27/09/2023 07:17

Hi, I’m a reception and nursery teacher. I’ve had aged retained children in my class before. Please do not do this because you think it’s ‘unfair’. Look at your DC1 - do you think they will struggle in reception in September? If yes then retain. Not all summer born babies struggle and I’ve had children in my class who were retained and it was actually the wrong decision for them. I’ve also had older children who struggles more than the summer borns. Forget about DC2 in this decision - make it based on DC1. You’re in danger of creating a self fulfilling prophecy, you’re already comparing them so if you continue doing this, DC1 will feel like it’s unfair! Treat them as individuals!

Covetthee · 27/09/2023 07:26

@Muthaofcats

I would ignore all the anecdotes that say ‘my august born started at 4 and now they are prime minister and a doctor and a lawyer etc’ and look at objective data instead . What do the studies say about suicide rates for summer borns, risk of severe bullying, chances of being mislabelled as SEN, chances of getting into a Russel group Uni? Etc etc

suicide rates!? Really? 🙄

The OP has asked for opinions, so she should ignore anyone who has had summer babies who haven’t struggled but instead just rely on pure data!? Does anyone really live their lives based on research data only?

whilst the data may always suggests otherwise, i know very few summer babies who have struggled i don’t understand why parents are allowed to have their opinion about this? why should she ignore this? She knows her child better than us so she should ultimately be able to decide if her child is ready.

sashh · 27/09/2023 07:32

If she was an only child what would you do?

My niece went to school at just passed her 4th birthday and was fine, so was one of my younger cousins.

Some children are ready for school others not so much.

LolaSmiles · 27/09/2023 07:34

Deferring won't mean DC starts a year late in Reception. They will go straight into Y1 having missed all that socialisation and practical learning in the last year of EYFS.
It does mean dropping a year and completing reception with the year below.

It means that a child who might be 4 years and 2 days at the start of reception, will instead be 5 years and 2 days at the start of reception.

Doyouthinktheyknow · 27/09/2023 07:40

It has to be what’s right for your dc1, try not to compare both your dc, they will be different and have different needs.

I have the opposite, dc1 was one of the oldest in their year, ds2 youngest. This was in the days before we had as much choice but it’s been fine. They have both excelled and found their path. Would have liked the option but mine are young adults now and it wasn’t really an option back then.

Whsts important is to meet their individual needs, life is not fair and their strengths will be different so avoid comparing.

Muthaofcats · 27/09/2023 07:41

Suicide rates, yes really! That might not matter to you but if you’ve ever experienced a loved one having mental health issues you will be much more conscious of your own children’s mental well being and doing all you can to protect them.

but I agree with you, everyone entitled to their opinion!

some like to decide based on feelings and anecdotes, some make decisions looking at data, some a combination of the two!

You will see from the satay that the majority who do delay their summer borns start are professional, high earning parents; much of that is that they have the privilege of being able to afford an extra year of childcare, and some of that is that professionals do tend to use data and evidence to back up decisions because that is likely what they were trained to do at the Russel group Uni they likely went to in order to have got the professional job 😂

I hope my children grow up to make informed decisions for their own lives too :)

Somuchgoo · 27/09/2023 07:58

I think people are being unfair on the comparison aspect. It sounds like the OPs first is a little delayed in some areas, and that was made much more obvious by her younger sibling.

People laughing/rolling their eyes at the OP because she's amazed at how her one year old reasons to books (when it's quite a typical age appropriate action) seem to have missed that this was a new thing for the OP as her firstborn didn't do this. Its a hard thing to realise that one of your children isn't the genius, it's just that the other one is delayed. I'm not sure her being mocked is fair.

Also, how are we over 300 posts in, and Pele are still saying 'oh it's not a good idea to go into year 1' when even a cursory glance at the thread would answer this.

MrsRaspberry · 27/09/2023 09:49

@ImInACage where am i spreading misinformation as fact? My comment stated "as far as I am aware" and where is it illegal to skip Reception year? Reception class is non compulsory for a start off so skipping it is not illegal. Hence why in my area if you defer your kids a year they begin their schooling from year 1 keeping in line with their school age group

jannier · 27/09/2023 10:07

Covetthee · 27/09/2023 06:36

Yes it does.

when you defer, you just defer their reception year to the following year. Otherwise there would be no need to defer if they will still have been in the same class at their older peers.

hence all the talk of being the oldest in the class rather than the youngest.

As a teacher has said in a previous post it depends on the school and borough you can't assume in my school you go straight to year 1.

Peaceandquietfinally · 27/09/2023 10:14

LaLaLouella · 26/09/2023 10:49

You should base decisions about DD1 purely on her needs and not those if others e.g, you and DD2.

Unless you have an extremely good reason don't take her away from her peer group and force her into younger classes so the gap with her sister will be artificially 'narrowed'.

This .

caban · 27/09/2023 10:34

jannier · 27/09/2023 10:07

As a teacher has said in a previous post it depends on the school and borough you can't assume in my school you go straight to year 1.

Schools/LAs are no longer allowed to have a blanket policy on this - they need to show it is in the particular child's best interest to go straight to Year 1.

SunshineCrescent · 27/09/2023 10:43

Mamma of a DS born on the 31/08 Here.
And a DD born in July. Also a summer baby myself so I feel your pain.

For ages I wished my son had been a September baby for no other reason then my own anxietys about him starting school.
I considered looking into starting him the year later, at the time he would have had to go into year 1 and miss reception which made my decision. Not sure what the situation is now.

However now retrospectivly I'm glad I diddnt he's thriving (always was) friendship groups in his class are amazing and as I take my anxiety to each parents evening I'm told you can't tell he's the youngest in the class.

I think if he had been behind of development milestones at 4 I may have had discussions with the schools about him starting later but as he wasn't I reluctantly let him start and we've not looked back

He was particularly tiered when starting school he use to fall asleep on the drive home but we got there.

DD July is actually over achieving and my consern about her starting and being a young one has eased she was a while different ball game

IndysMamaRex · 27/09/2023 11:09

Why would it matter? My son is one of the youngest in his class & I never even considered deferring. He’s one of the brightest in his class so I think it comes down to individuals not being months less in age. Kids need stimulation & to be around other kids that will teach the me more than delaying a year

Frosty1000 · 27/09/2023 11:20

Focus only on the summer born child and their needs, not your other one.

Check LA rules as when I was in this position ours put them into yr 1 so defeated the object. I also wouldn't dismiss your child's ability, just because they've a July birthday doesn't mean they're a failure or going to struggle, far from it.

I've a July child and once I found out LA rules I just went with it, yes they're young but someone has to be, like someone has to be the eldest. But I've found schools support everyone equally and do not focus on birthday month as it's irrelevant.

Have faith in your child and they may surprise you.

crostini · 27/09/2023 11:22

I have a September born and an august born. Similar years to yours too, but other way around.
They're still too young to know what their personalities will be like and how well they'll adapt to school etc. case to case basis I think. See how they get in at pre school.

crostini · 27/09/2023 11:28

Also not everything has to be the same, in parenting two children.

There will be many ways in which you have given your second things that you didn't give your first.

floofbag · 27/09/2023 12:34

Don't they have to go into year 1 though and miss reception . You can't back class them with out a Sen ? And even then they align them again at secondary

For me it's also about friendship groups . If they start a year later this is already set although obvs thing change .

ChristopherTalken · 27/09/2023 13:02

floofbag · 27/09/2023 12:34

Don't they have to go into year 1 though and miss reception . You can't back class them with out a Sen ? And even then they align them again at secondary

For me it's also about friendship groups . If they start a year later this is already set although obvs thing change .

No, you can request that they start reception at CSA. There is Government guidance on summer born children being able to request that. It is extremely rare for children to miss reception.

Xsxjxmx · 27/09/2023 13:54

It being 'unfair' isn't a valid reason. If your child is behind academically because of their age or their ASD and you're worried they will struggle, then fair enough, but imagine writing on a deferral form I want to hold my child back a whole school year just because her siblings birthday makes her the eldest in her year, while this child will be one of the youngest. If you're in England they will point blank refuse that request with that reason.
But if it can be proved one more year at home/nursery will benefit the child then it may be accepted, not all deferrals are.
How would the child cope if they where suddenly moved forward a year by secondary school or of you loved primary, because that is entirely possible.

You need to think of how your child will cope at school and if it's best for them, not if you think it's fair on siblings because of birthdays and their place in their own year group, they won't even care!

Xsxjxmx · 27/09/2023 13:55

Not that rare for children to skip reception, I know of a handful of people who's child started year 1 because they did a deferral, with valid reasons unlike this

Rinoachicken · 27/09/2023 13:59

Reception is still EYFS, like nursery is - from the child’s perspective it’s still just ‘play’.

It’s just in a different location.

Underestimated4 · 27/09/2023 14:22

I think if anything you’re putting the child back a year. I’m a july child I’m in my 30s it’s not affected me cos I can’t remember being 4. Reception is all about play and making friends anyway.

NameChanged45678 · 27/09/2023 14:29

I have kids similar gaps and timings, but a few years on. DC2 has just turned 5 and started reception. TBC, its more frustrating seeing DC2, who we feel has been 'held back' as he was more than ready to start school last summer with his summer born nursery friends born a couple of months early. He's only just starting a formal phonics programme and he's already 5. DC1 could read well before he turned 5, having already had a year of formal schooling and phonics. DS2 is 5 and cant read, even though he's academically bright, we just haven't taught him. He was quite bored (teachers words) in final year of nursery and more than ready to start school. DC2 has been held back because he is a September born. I would never do it voluntarily, and for DC2 I think it would be better if he was surrounded by kids who are equivalent or better in terms of academic ability.

ChristopherTalken · 27/09/2023 14:43

Underestimated4 · 27/09/2023 14:22

I think if anything you’re putting the child back a year. I’m a july child I’m in my 30s it’s not affected me cos I can’t remember being 4. Reception is all about play and making friends anyway.

Its not just about reception though.

Will they be ready for Year 1 when they are age 4 and 1 day.

Will they be ready for exams when they are age 14 and 1 day etc etc etc.....

Swipe left for the next trending thread