Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

Labour isn't Working - Thread 44

431 replies

Nuthatch26 · 16/11/2026 17:40

A chat thread for those who don't like this Labour government. ☕️💙

The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money.

Previous thread
https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/_chat/5595388-labour-isnt-working-thread-43?utm_campaign=thread&utm_medium=share

Labour isn't Working - Thread 44
OP posts:
Thread gallery
18
seriouslycanthisgetWORSE · Today 09:27

Tony Blair has just been on BBC news ( a clip of an interview ) saying basically is it good to re join if the EU is moving the wrong way on ai and tech.)

EasternStandard · Today 09:29

seriouslycanthisgetWORSE · Today 09:27

Tony Blair has just been on BBC news ( a clip of an interview ) saying basically is it good to re join if the EU is moving the wrong way on ai and tech.)

He was lauded on here as the best until he diverged from current Labour, but yes he’s right to raise this.

strawberrybubblegum · Today 09:59

PatrickDuffysHat · Today 09:04

If Scottish unis have to offer zero fees to EU students the unis won’t cope. It’s the same position as pre-Brexit but their financial situation is much worse.

Any idea whether the deal would relate to EU nationality or residency?

There are quite a lot of EU dual nationals living in England...

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about this subject:

Nuthatch26 · Today 10:02

EasternStandard · Today 08:13

It was really calm and useful.

Musing today I think Burnham is in a corner now. His reset isn’t that great economically and a whole raft of people are about to get paperwork and regulations for dynamic alignment even though they don’t export to the EU.

And the relevant unions will realise they don’t get a parliamentary vote as per their statement they just have to adopt as the rules change.

And universities are talking about needing funds, St Andrews today flagging £12m per year. That will be multiplied across many.

100k movement will compete on jobs.

So he’ll be in the middle ground and people will say you didn’t get the mandate. The only way out of that is to push for re-join.

I’m not sure the appetite is there, but there’ll be heavy selling for it for the rest of the term, however long that is.

Thanks for this summary.

I worry that many people, who don't follow politics much, will just accept the soundbites coming from Labour without further scrutiny.
Reading some of the comments on mn, many already have.

OP posts:
Nuthatch26 · Today 10:06

DenizenOfAisleOfShame · Today 09:22

The more I read about the reactions among fixated Brexiteers and obsessed Europhiles about Burnham’s EU antics the more it looks depressingly like we’ll have all the old arguments, but on steroids.

The foam-flecked anti-EUers are gearing up. They just love the fight and cannot see beyond Clacton. And on the other side, the weird-eyed Remoaners are preparing to talk over everyone else. They can’t be reasoned with: they believe fervently that Europe is the holy land and is brimming with milk and honey.

Burnham is condemning the great majority of us to national political argument that is utterly tedious and fruitless.

Yes I feel the same. The arguments haven't even been updated to reflect 2026, not 2016.
We've already lost years to this.

OP posts:
Dinnerontheterrace · Today 10:15

ArthurFrampton · Today 09:13

I have read a few articles commenting on the fact that cutting the tuition fees for EU students is a pet project of the so called 'Euro elite' who populate the EU parliament. Many of their children attend or want to attend prestigious British universities, and while they can well afford the fees they are very keen to get them cut and have those tens of thousands (c. £28000 per annum) back in their pockets.

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2026/11/21/brussels-elite-pushing-for-uk-university-deal-save-cash/

"Brussels “elites” have been accused of making the EU reset deal conditional on lower university tuition fees so that they can “save themselves some cash” when sending their children to study in Britain.
Anand Menon, the director of UK in a Changing Europe, a pro-EU campaign group, and Labour MPs have criticised the Europeans’ attempt to “derail” the reset deal by demanding the lower fees.
Since Brexit, students from the EU – around 45,000 of whom enrol every year at UK universities – have paid international rates, which are thousands of pounds more than the fees paid by British undergraduates.
But Brussels is demanding that Andy Burnham cut the price for European students from £38,000 per year to the domestic rate of £9,970, with EU capitals threatening to delay ratification of the reset deal if a compromise cannot be found."

It’s simple really. Walk away from the deal.

SapphireCasino · Today 10:20

you know how recollections vary, to misquote the late queen

I think it might have been 2016 where I really became completely detached from politics. That sums up my level of interest. I was annoyed how much parliamentary time got wasted on it at the time, and I still am and I never knew why Theresa May’s deal was rejected because I couldn’t really be bothered to find out to be honest.

So I suppose now all the important stuff will go to the back of the queue again and they’ll just waste time on this.

@strawberrybubblegum in what way are the EU going backwards on technology and AI?

strawberrybubblegum · Today 10:20

strawberrybubblegum · Today 09:59

Any idea whether the deal would relate to EU nationality or residency?

There are quite a lot of EU dual nationals living in England...

Ah, I just looked that up. Looks like residence within the UK would take priority over EU rules, and there would likely be a 3 year prior residency rule in the EU (ie not the UK).

It was apparently tested before Brexit.

EasternStandard · Today 10:49

Nuthatch26 · Today 10:02

Thanks for this summary.

I worry that many people, who don't follow politics much, will just accept the soundbites coming from Labour without further scrutiny.
Reading some of the comments on mn, many already have.

It's odd reading some posts as they seem so stuck in the last referendum period. Many don't notice or look at what's happening in the EU. The idea we're the disaster and other EU countries are out-pacing us or socially more stable isn't the case.

I suppose we'll have the argument from a 2026 pov and hopefully the update will get out there.

strawberrybubblegum · Today 10:54

SapphireCasino · Today 10:20

you know how recollections vary, to misquote the late queen

I think it might have been 2016 where I really became completely detached from politics. That sums up my level of interest. I was annoyed how much parliamentary time got wasted on it at the time, and I still am and I never knew why Theresa May’s deal was rejected because I couldn’t really be bothered to find out to be honest.

So I suppose now all the important stuff will go to the back of the queue again and they’ll just waste time on this.

@strawberrybubblegum in what way are the EU going backwards on technology and AI?

The EU is a lot more prescriptive than the UK on things like giving people notice of using AI, opt-out for automated decision making, and how the data is used.

UK companies already have to comply with those if they deal with the data of any EU citizen, but if they're UK only it's a bit lighter touch (although still regulated). That makes working with those countries more expensive/more limiting/less attractive, and if we take on those regulations for UK citizens then we will in turn be less attractive to others eg in the US. In the most extreme case, they might restrict our use of their models.

There's a huge race world wide to use AI to improve productivity, with the risk of whole industries being priced out and diminished. (It's more to do with the use of the AI models than with creating them - but obviously, access to models will be critical for that, hence the push for us to develop our own.)

As for the consequences, the AI revolution is a bit like the Industrial Revolution or the uptake of Internet connectivity between companies. We benefitted hugely from being innovators and early adopters in those - it's the kind of difference that sets a country's position in the world for generations.

So putting in place excessive regulations that stop private companies from investing and developing that AI capability is a bit like overly-regulating steel production in Victorian Britain. The innovation will take place elsewhere, and that's where the generations-long advantage will stay.

The other thing that could really scupper the UK with AI is access to electricity. But that's a separate problem.

The UK is actually very well positioned to lead on this. It plays exactly to our strengths: technical innovation, strong education, a flexible and rich private sector who are keen to invest where it will genuinely make a difference, a top flight financial and professional services sector. It's ours to lose... and tying ourselves to excessive regulations from the less innovative EU is one way to do that.

Dinnerontheterrace · Today 10:56

It will be interesting to see which side the higher education sector supports. They were strongly remain last time, but going back in would decimate them.

Assuming the government would step in with further subsidies is niave and risky. Public opinion on higher education is mixed at best. It used to be that everyone blamed the government for tuition fees, now people are muttering about a bloated sector.

EasternStandard · Today 10:58

strawberrybubblegum · Today 10:54

The EU is a lot more prescriptive than the UK on things like giving people notice of using AI, opt-out for automated decision making, and how the data is used.

UK companies already have to comply with those if they deal with the data of any EU citizen, but if they're UK only it's a bit lighter touch (although still regulated). That makes working with those countries more expensive/more limiting/less attractive, and if we take on those regulations for UK citizens then we will in turn be less attractive to others eg in the US. In the most extreme case, they might restrict our use of their models.

There's a huge race world wide to use AI to improve productivity, with the risk of whole industries being priced out and diminished. (It's more to do with the use of the AI models than with creating them - but obviously, access to models will be critical for that, hence the push for us to develop our own.)

As for the consequences, the AI revolution is a bit like the Industrial Revolution or the uptake of Internet connectivity between companies. We benefitted hugely from being innovators and early adopters in those - it's the kind of difference that sets a country's position in the world for generations.

So putting in place excessive regulations that stop private companies from investing and developing that AI capability is a bit like overly-regulating steel production in Victorian Britain. The innovation will take place elsewhere, and that's where the generations-long advantage will stay.

The other thing that could really scupper the UK with AI is access to electricity. But that's a separate problem.

The UK is actually very well positioned to lead on this. It plays exactly to our strengths: technical innovation, strong education, a flexible and rich private sector who are keen to invest where it will genuinely make a difference, a top flight financial and professional services sector. It's ours to lose... and tying ourselves to excessive regulations from the less innovative EU is one way to do that.

Edited

Absolutely. And the EU is slow on changing regs, which doesn't work against the speed of AI advancement.

Blair is right so I'm glad someone has raised it. The trouble is getting this message across so we don't hamper ourselves unnecessarily.

seriouslycanthisgetWORSE · Today 11:08

Nuthatch26 · Today 10:02

Thanks for this summary.

I worry that many people, who don't follow politics much, will just accept the soundbites coming from Labour without further scrutiny.
Reading some of the comments on mn, many already have.

Agree

seriouslycanthisgetWORSE · Today 11:12

Burnhan seems personally motivated re his dad and social care and his wife has lived in the netherlands and Belgium so I wonder if again there is personal motivstion there rather than looking at the broader picture.

seriouslycanthisgetWORSE · Today 11:14

EasternStandard · Today 10:58

Absolutely. And the EU is slow on changing regs, which doesn't work against the speed of AI advancement.

Blair is right so I'm glad someone has raised it. The trouble is getting this message across so we don't hamper ourselves unnecessarily.

Yes how to get this message across to this gov one whose own policies have hobbled a generation of young people and whose own tsar and champion calls it out ,the response ...let's get hundreds of new yp over.

I just don't think they have capacity for anything it's so deeply concenring.

SapphireCasino · Today 11:31

@strawberrybubblegum thank you for that explanation - that’s really helpful.

I think some people want us to be part of the EU no matter what. To be honest if David Cameron had had more guts, I think he would have wanted to say “close call, the referendum is only advisory anyway” and used it as leverage to change some of the free movement stuff. But he didn’t - and here we are. I was actually quite surprised when he resigned in the morning because I felt like he was just running away from a mess that he decided to make.

MissConductUS · Today 11:34

strawberrybubblegum · Today 10:54

The EU is a lot more prescriptive than the UK on things like giving people notice of using AI, opt-out for automated decision making, and how the data is used.

UK companies already have to comply with those if they deal with the data of any EU citizen, but if they're UK only it's a bit lighter touch (although still regulated). That makes working with those countries more expensive/more limiting/less attractive, and if we take on those regulations for UK citizens then we will in turn be less attractive to others eg in the US. In the most extreme case, they might restrict our use of their models.

There's a huge race world wide to use AI to improve productivity, with the risk of whole industries being priced out and diminished. (It's more to do with the use of the AI models than with creating them - but obviously, access to models will be critical for that, hence the push for us to develop our own.)

As for the consequences, the AI revolution is a bit like the Industrial Revolution or the uptake of Internet connectivity between companies. We benefitted hugely from being innovators and early adopters in those - it's the kind of difference that sets a country's position in the world for generations.

So putting in place excessive regulations that stop private companies from investing and developing that AI capability is a bit like overly-regulating steel production in Victorian Britain. The innovation will take place elsewhere, and that's where the generations-long advantage will stay.

The other thing that could really scupper the UK with AI is access to electricity. But that's a separate problem.

The UK is actually very well positioned to lead on this. It plays exactly to our strengths: technical innovation, strong education, a flexible and rich private sector who are keen to invest where it will genuinely make a difference, a top flight financial and professional services sector. It's ours to lose... and tying ourselves to excessive regulations from the less innovative EU is one way to do that.

Edited

There was a piece in the DT recently about Britain's failure to capitalize on opportunities to lead in AI and tech more broadly. One of the founders of Anthropic, who just became quite rich in their IPO last week, is a Brit who moved to the US for a better business environment.

Britain’s strange capacity for self-harm is holding it back - Anthropic’s blockbuster float shows what can happen when governments foster innovation rather than stifle it

I'm a Yank who leans conservative, and I've been on MN for about ten years. Is it okay if I join you all on this thread? I'm also ex-military, if that helps.

Britain’s strange capacity for self-harm is holding it back

Anthropic’s blockbuster float shows what can happen when governments foster innovation rather than stifle it

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/86edc134b7482488

Dinnerontheterrace · Today 11:35

Welcome!

strawberrybubblegum · Today 11:37

I'm not sure people realise quite how innovative the UK is. Our universities are truly outstanding, and we have a fantastic ecosystem of innovation hubs and venture capital.

Our venture capital ecosystem is leagues ahead of the rest of Europe - nearly half of all European VC funding is in the UK - and we're only behind the US and China worldwide. We also succeed fantastically well at creating real return on that investment - better even than Silicon Valley.

Where we struggle is scaling. We lose a lot to the US at that stage. But actually, I think AI innovation will be wide and embedded, so perhaps with the investment widely spread that will be less of an issue.

And we're really bad at big infrastructure projects! That's why I think electricity is such a huge potential risk for us. Milliband definitely not helping there.

EasternStandard · Today 11:40

strawberrybubblegum · Today 11:37

I'm not sure people realise quite how innovative the UK is. Our universities are truly outstanding, and we have a fantastic ecosystem of innovation hubs and venture capital.

Our venture capital ecosystem is leagues ahead of the rest of Europe - nearly half of all European VC funding is in the UK - and we're only behind the US and China worldwide. We also succeed fantastically well at creating real return on that investment - better even than Silicon Valley.

Where we struggle is scaling. We lose a lot to the US at that stage. But actually, I think AI innovation will be wide and embedded, so perhaps with the investment widely spread that will be less of an issue.

And we're really bad at big infrastructure projects! That's why I think electricity is such a huge potential risk for us. Milliband definitely not helping there.

Totally agree. And with @MissConductUS (welcome btw!) that we sometimes lose out moving, but the initial talent and investment funding is really good.

Nuthatch26 · Today 11:44

You are more than welcome to join us @MissConductUS Smile

OP posts:
LuckyHazelFox · Today 12:06

MissConductUS · Today 11:34

There was a piece in the DT recently about Britain's failure to capitalize on opportunities to lead in AI and tech more broadly. One of the founders of Anthropic, who just became quite rich in their IPO last week, is a Brit who moved to the US for a better business environment.

Britain’s strange capacity for self-harm is holding it back - Anthropic’s blockbuster float shows what can happen when governments foster innovation rather than stifle it

I'm a Yank who leans conservative, and I've been on MN for about ten years. Is it okay if I join you all on this thread? I'm also ex-military, if that helps.

Welcome ❤️

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · Today 12:15

The impact on Labour on the labour market is really quite pronounced. Labour being elected instantly killed the upward trend and then Reeves budget pushed in into decline.

Imagine where we could have been if Sunak had won. On that protectory he was tracking on job creation we could have had an additional 1.2m people employed - all the NEETS and more

Labour isn't Working - Thread 44
Dinnerontheterrace · Today 12:16

Regarding talks on the EU, from Tim Shipman in the Spectator:

The EU ambushed the government, issued demands for money with menaces, proved a tougher nut to crack than ministers (jacked up to the eyeballs on hopium) had expected, we agreed to talks about talks and to work together towards things that are expensive and undesirable.

MissConductUS · Today 12:30

Thank you all for the warm welcome. I feel like I've finally found my tribe on MN, and hopefully a safe space from the anti-Americanism that I've encountered from time to time here over the years.