Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

Labour isn't Working - Thread 44

431 replies

Nuthatch26 · 16/11/2026 17:40

A chat thread for those who don't like this Labour government. ☕️💙

The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money.

Previous thread
https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/_chat/5595388-labour-isnt-working-thread-43?utm_campaign=thread&utm_medium=share

Labour isn't Working - Thread 44
OP posts:
Thread gallery
18
Nuthatch26 · Yesterday 09:20

EasternStandard · Yesterday 09:05

Yep it’s too much. Depressing stuff. I was thinking that whilst running yesterday.

Same. Those years were so damaging to society and politics. It felt like we were finally moving on, but oh no, Andy needs a distraction from Labour's disastrous first 2.5 years. He knows he can't run on the economy at the next GE so Brexit will have to do.

"My view is that Brexit has been damaging, but I also believe that the last thing we should do is re-run those arguments".

Andy Burnham - Makerfield 2026.

OP posts:
Nuthatch26 · Yesterday 09:23

strawberrybubblegum · Yesterday 09:09

I think it makes perfect sense in the context of Leftist liberals who loathe British history and want to atone for our sins whilst blind to our historic strengths and huge contributions to the world.

They don't want us making our own rules. The generous interpretation is that they don't trust us.

They certainly don't believe in the UK having it's own vision, nor value our leadership in the world.

They want the UK back in our little square box as an obedient and biddable global citizen - no tall poppies here please! No ideas above our station as a former great power and still the world's 5th largest economy, the cradle of parliamentary democracy and modern human rights.

They don't really care where the rules come from: the EU or tin-pot dictator city mayor. So long as we follow them rather than create them and act in the world according to our own vision.

Edited

Spot on, as always 👏

I don't know how anyone can look at the EU's behaviour over the last decade and think they have our best interests at heart.

OP posts:
EasternStandard · Yesterday 09:38

Nuthatch26 · Yesterday 09:23

Spot on, as always 👏

I don't know how anyone can look at the EU's behaviour over the last decade and think they have our best interests at heart.

We’ve done well at a few things unencumbered by regulation. We should keep going with that.

The old lines resurfacing are depressing but also not as relevant today.

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about this subject:

Nuthatch26 · Yesterday 10:02

Yes, financial regulation and AI are growing the economy away from the EU. Young people haven't stopped working and studying in the EU since we left.

If Andrew Neil's figures are to be believed, this deal will have no impact on food prices. In fact they may actually rise as he thinks the EU deal may put our energy costs even higher.

OP posts:
SapphireCasino · Yesterday 10:12

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · Yesterday 08:29

To be honest I think you have to be pretty anti Europe to find Belgium Waffles sickening! :-) I love a Belgium waffle! Are you anti French Fries as well?

Brussels waffle is not the same as Belgian waffle.

(that actually sounds like something Poirot would say)

seriouslycanthisgetWORSE · Yesterday 10:15

What's depressing is that without any real power this man with 25 thousand votes is doing exactly what he wants and it seems we are totally powerless to stop him .
A liar and a gas lighter just like Putin.
Says he's not doing something ,laughs away suggestions and does it anyway.

seriouslycanthisgetWORSE · Yesterday 10:17

Did anyone see the article that mercedez Benz has stopped investing in Germany

justasking111 · Yesterday 10:23

The EU deal is Starmers, he was forever scuttling off to Brussels. Burnham just signed a piece of paper.

DenizenOfAisleOfShame · Yesterday 10:29

I’ve never hated the EU or thought that it’s out to get the UK in some sort of ‘perfidious Albion’ way (apart from the process of withdrawal, which was intended to be a lesson to other states thinking of leaving). Each EU country is just pursuing its own interests within the EU. That’s what Thatcher got right about EU negotiation.

What went wrong with the EU was the Commission and Court pursuing a non-state policy of domination over states’ interests. Veto rights are next in line for Commission opposition.

Even so, I wouldn’t have left when we did, but we did.

What Burnham is pursuing is a centre-left faith in the EU for its own sake - a deference to continental Europe because the centre-left can’t bear to think that British policy and practice - but mostly society - are better or no worse than others’. Orwell saw this in the British left before WWII (there was no EU then of course, and the left’s preferences were for European states and the USSR).

It’s a very middle-class, quailing, self-loathing prejudice. Which is why the LibDems and a lot of Labour are so besotted with the EU.

I do think Burnham’s approach to the EU will end in tears. The economic advantages may be real in some ways but are illusory and negative in others. Burnham’s being dishonest about this.

Nuthatch26 · Yesterday 11:20

Great piece by Fraser Nelson. A voice of sanity cutting through the noise. He's been good on the radio this morning too.

Brexit has not been as good as Leavers promised or as bad as Remainers warned but it certainly did succeed in distorting our politics for the best part of a decade. If Burnham wants to fight the next election offering more of the same, he may not find many takers.

https://www.thetimes.com/article/463affb7-3408-42b9-83f6-126c10ce5305?shareToken=aae342cce41628ffe149c30bbbd8d5a8

OP posts:
LuckyHazelFox · Yesterday 11:25

Nuthatch26 · Yesterday 11:20

Great piece by Fraser Nelson. A voice of sanity cutting through the noise. He's been good on the radio this morning too.

Brexit has not been as good as Leavers promised or as bad as Remainers warned but it certainly did succeed in distorting our politics for the best part of a decade. If Burnham wants to fight the next election offering more of the same, he may not find many takers.

https://www.thetimes.com/article/463affb7-3408-42b9-83f6-126c10ce5305?shareToken=aae342cce41628ffe149c30bbbd8d5a8

Brilliant argument, summing up what most of you have been saying. This is also in stark contrast to Starmer's position on reopening EU talks. Burnham's arrogance is shining through now. We see it.

seriouslycanthisgetWORSE · Yesterday 12:14

Burnhams supreme arrogance when we are facing unimaginable challenges not least around our young people who were asked to compete for jobs with millions of people when Blair fucked up and now many more again from the EU.
I think Burnham is worse than trump. At least trump was voted in.

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · Yesterday 12:17

LetMeButterYourParsnips · Yesterday 08:46

Looking at Labradors post from 08:26 the goodwill amnesty might already be over. 😄

That wasn't anti burnham it was just a factual consequence for a real world small business.

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · Yesterday 12:21

As it turns out after being through the detail it seems I have made the same mistake our cat loving friends have of focusing on the Burnham cherry picked spin on a superficial level without checking the consequences. The honey labelling is good but hidden in the detail it seems Burnham is defining honeybee colonies as animals so all that similar movement paper work is going to come into place for bees as there is for cattle, amoungst a raft of other requirements. It turns out Labour are no friend of the beekeeping industry.

EasternStandard · Yesterday 12:22

Nuthatch26 · Yesterday 11:20

Great piece by Fraser Nelson. A voice of sanity cutting through the noise. He's been good on the radio this morning too.

Brexit has not been as good as Leavers promised or as bad as Remainers warned but it certainly did succeed in distorting our politics for the best part of a decade. If Burnham wants to fight the next election offering more of the same, he may not find many takers.

https://www.thetimes.com/article/463affb7-3408-42b9-83f6-126c10ce5305?shareToken=aae342cce41628ffe149c30bbbd8d5a8

Thanks he was good on the radio the other day.

Just reading some threads it bugs me how down some are on what we are doing and can do out of the EU. We have good universities and innovation and it shows when regulation is dropped.

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · Yesterday 15:47

There seems to a quite a consensus that Burnham is deliberately stirring up the brexit vote to drive people to Reform to split the Conservative/Reform vote.

boyleslaw · Yesterday 16:02

If true, that is so cynical. AB showed us that he had worked hard on social media to project his image of a tolerant, caring educated, wise-guy. He wants us to believe his decency, openness and devotion to helping those who have missed out. ( eg. The rough sleepers he mentioned in his acceptance speech after he deposed KS ) I am beyond depressed if this it may all be spin and manipulation to out-manoeuvre Reform and the Conservatives. Can we trust any politicians any more ?

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · Yesterday 16:05

boyleslaw · Yesterday 16:02

If true, that is so cynical. AB showed us that he had worked hard on social media to project his image of a tolerant, caring educated, wise-guy. He wants us to believe his decency, openness and devotion to helping those who have missed out. ( eg. The rough sleepers he mentioned in his acceptance speech after he deposed KS ) I am beyond depressed if this it may all be spin and manipulation to out-manoeuvre Reform and the Conservatives. Can we trust any politicians any more ?

Andy Burnham spent a year manipulating the Labour party to become Prime Minister. He is shrewd political calculator!

GasPanic · Yesterday 16:32

Brexit is a politicians graveyard.

Just look at how many political careers it has ended. The only one who appears to come out unscathed time after time is Farage, maybe he's been taking tips from Teflon Tony.

EasternStandard · Yesterday 16:34

GasPanic · Yesterday 16:32

Brexit is a politicians graveyard.

Just look at how many political careers it has ended. The only one who appears to come out unscathed time after time is Farage, maybe he's been taking tips from Teflon Tony.

It is a bit and and he does.

Maybe it’s because everything has a cost or downside even if there’s a benefit.

GasPanic · Yesterday 16:37

EasternStandard · Yesterday 16:34

It is a bit and and he does.

Maybe it’s because everything has a cost or downside even if there’s a benefit.

I think it is probably because it is a very polarising issue and it moves across (main) party politics.

For example there are lots of both remainers and Brexiters in both of the Tories and Labour.

Farage and maybe the Lib Dems escape because they are clear about what they stand for and there is no major division in their party about it.

Worrall20 · Yesterday 16:38

boyleslaw · Yesterday 16:02

If true, that is so cynical. AB showed us that he had worked hard on social media to project his image of a tolerant, caring educated, wise-guy. He wants us to believe his decency, openness and devotion to helping those who have missed out. ( eg. The rough sleepers he mentioned in his acceptance speech after he deposed KS ) I am beyond depressed if this it may all be spin and manipulation to out-manoeuvre Reform and the Conservatives. Can we trust any politicians any more ?

Burnham only cares about Burnham. The manipulation by him seems to be working with those on the left. The spin ie the rough sleepers, again bullshit, he promised the same in Manchester and homelessness went up. Burnham, unfortunately is the master of bullshit, though I am hoping that as he goes on more people will see him for what he is, especially business leaders. Most business’s in Manchester are already aware. Maggie Oliver is also not a big fan. Can guarantee that this deal he has reached with the EU will not benefit the U.K. in fact if he said it is raining I would have to go outside to check. Sadly I have no faith in him at all.

Dinnerontheterrace · Yesterday 16:58

I listened to Andrew Neil’s podcast about this. He calmly goes through the facts.

Burnham is either a liar or an idiot.

Both the Conservatives and Reform are somewhat muted in their responses. Never interrupt your enemy when he is making a mistake, huh?

DenizenOfAisleOfShame · Yesterday 17:19

Worrall20 · Yesterday 16:38

Burnham only cares about Burnham. The manipulation by him seems to be working with those on the left. The spin ie the rough sleepers, again bullshit, he promised the same in Manchester and homelessness went up. Burnham, unfortunately is the master of bullshit, though I am hoping that as he goes on more people will see him for what he is, especially business leaders. Most business’s in Manchester are already aware. Maggie Oliver is also not a big fan. Can guarantee that this deal he has reached with the EU will not benefit the U.K. in fact if he said it is raining I would have to go outside to check. Sadly I have no faith in him at all.

That’s the gist of Burnham, I agree.

He is a politician with nothing but concern for himself. He doesn’t care what he says and promises. If it suits him to say it, he’ll say it. AKA a bullshitter, as you say.

He has no plan. No vision. No guiding principles. All of his ‘policies’, whether comically small (like bus fares) or supposedly big (like devolution) are pure gimmickry. And he’s running away from anything that’s tough.

The Labour fans are all excited by a PM - unlike Starmer - who can gab. But they’re unwilling to admit that it’s all vacuous shite.

Ereshkigalangcleg · Yesterday 17:56

DenizenOfAisleOfShame · Yesterday 17:19

That’s the gist of Burnham, I agree.

He is a politician with nothing but concern for himself. He doesn’t care what he says and promises. If it suits him to say it, he’ll say it. AKA a bullshitter, as you say.

He has no plan. No vision. No guiding principles. All of his ‘policies’, whether comically small (like bus fares) or supposedly big (like devolution) are pure gimmickry. And he’s running away from anything that’s tough.

The Labour fans are all excited by a PM - unlike Starmer - who can gab. But they’re unwilling to admit that it’s all vacuous shite.

That’s exactly it.