Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

Screen deaths that have stayed with you

546 replies

SteviesNicks · Yesterday 15:14

There are loads!
But from a discussion with my siblings (we watch the same things) a few of mine are from er - Lucy Knight, Dennis Gant, and Mark Greene of course.

Also PC Kirsten in Happy Valley.

And then there’s Catelyn Stark, Oberyn Martell and Shireen Baratheon in the Game of Thrones.

Which ones have had a visceral effect on you?

OP posts:
Pudmyboy · Yesterday 21:56

Another vote for the Snowman, sobbed my heart out when I first saw it

AutumnOakTree · Yesterday 21:56

Scarecrow16 · Yesterday 15:23

Spooks 2002 where Lisa Faulkner's character had her head plunged into a deep fat fryer. Totally unexpected and horrific. Could have done with out the memory.

Yes, my first thought also.

MuthaHubbard · Yesterday 21:57

I, Daniel Blake broke my heart. Never been able to watch it again 😭

ClaredeBear · Yesterday 21:58

Billie in Eastenders. Patsy Palmer was phenomenal. I’ve not seen it for over 17 years but I won’t forget that.

MyRedQuoter · Yesterday 21:58

Sybil in Downton Abbey. I never watched a single further episode! I was so upset and furious.

Leo McGarry in The West Wing. Especially because John Spencer had really passed.

ithinkthereforeyouarewrong · Yesterday 22:00

MrsArcher23 · Yesterday 15:46

Nothing tops the Jon Voigt boxer character in The Champ, one Christmas night, with Ricky Schroeder begging him to wake up.

Don’t die champ don’t die

I roared my eyes out at that

Rockfordpeach · Yesterday 22:00

Agree with Mark Greene in ER, i cant listen to Over the Rainbow without thinking about him. Also Greg Pratt's death in ER.

Tony Wilton in Soldier, Soldier

AllTheToddlers · Yesterday 22:01

Neighbours, he was late teens or early twenties and a relative of toadfish. Can’t remember his name. But he’d had a brain aneurysm, and then was in a street party on the road and sat there and died and no one realised for a while and the camera panned out. Haunts me that one.

Clubbiscuit · Yesterday 22:02

Mike in Breaking Bad 😭😭😭

HornyHornersPinger · Yesterday 22:05

Agree with others already mentioned, Mark Greene ER, George Greys Anatomy, but going to throw 1 out from my all time favourite film - Ellie at the beginning of Disney's Up! ... Gets me every time but the rest ot that film is funny, lovely and feel-good

Up The Movie GIF
Lougle · Yesterday 22:06

SockGene · Yesterday 16:39

Thanks for reminding me 😭 Ironically, I never even watched the programme except that bloody episode (ex watched the whole thing and I decided that night to give it a watch 😕).

I wouldn't watch it after that. It got far too nasty.

WildFinch · Yesterday 22:07

Emma - One Day, the Netflix series. Sobbed.
Lots in Line of Duty left me open mouthed in shock
Mark Greene - ER
It's a Sin

Edit to add
Aiden in Corrie

This thread has reminded me of others too!

MsAmerica · Yesterday 22:10

Camille

Madrid21 · Yesterday 22:11

Mark Greene in ER, that episode still makes me cry.

Sherrystrull · Yesterday 22:13

Mark Greene in ER was awful. Also, I’m still hugely affected when Carter was stabbed and landed on the floor in the consultancy room and saw Lucy dying under the gurney.

Madrid21 · Yesterday 22:13

Also Barbara in call the midwife, so so sad

OldPodge · Yesterday 22:13

LaurieFairyCake · Yesterday 15:24

Glen in the Walking Dead. Refused to watch it after that.

Natasha Yar, Star Trek TNG

Same here. I stopped watching Walking Dead after that.

thenightsky · Yesterday 22:16

HurdyGurdy19 · Yesterday 21:29

Aiden Connor in Corrie

Matthew Cuthbert in Anne of Green Gables

Barbara in Call the Midwife

Oh yes. Aiden Connor in Corrie. When his dad went into the flat and read the note... don't go into the bathroom. He went into the bathroom and all you could hear was his dad crying... noooo, not my boy.. nooo Sad

lindyloo57 · Yesterday 22:17

Yes any animal death, I can't watch any David Attenborough programs for fare of seeing a animal suffering.

goldielockss · Yesterday 22:18

InSlovakiaTheCapitalOfCourseIsBratislava · Yesterday 15:49

The hedgehogs in the animals of farthing wood
Dont curl up dear

Came here to say this. I think about this way too often!

Ketryne · Yesterday 22:21

Beth in the 1994 Little Women. I saw it at the cinema at 4 years old and cried the whole way home. I still can’t see Claire Dane’s’ lip wobble without sobbing.

Said before but Sybil in Downton was a really shocker.

Sonya in neighbours (Toadie’s wife). I’d lost my mum to cancer a year or so before and Neighbours was a love we shared, so her death on the beach really got me. It was such a beautiful piece of wish fulfilment and nothing like the awful awful hospital death my mum had.

The dad in About Time. Same personal reason as above but very different as done in such a beautifully understated way.

Ketryne · Yesterday 22:23

AllTheToddlers · Yesterday 22:01

Neighbours, he was late teens or early twenties and a relative of toadfish. Can’t remember his name. But he’d had a brain aneurysm, and then was in a street party on the road and sat there and died and no one realised for a while and the camera panned out. Haunts me that one.

Was It Stingray? I think…

nomas · Yesterday 22:23

Idontjetwashthefucker · Yesterday 17:05

Vasily in Chernobyl...awful

That was really said. And his wife loved him so much she risked radiation exposure to be by his bedside all the time. And it was based on a real couple.

Alittlefrustrated · Yesterday 22:24

Stan Ogden, Coronation Street, 1984.
I was 15 and for some reason this has stayed with me - particularly when the episode ended with the camera zooming in on his glasses left just sitting beside his chair.

nomas · Yesterday 22:25

Sherrystrull · Yesterday 22:13

Mark Greene in ER was awful. Also, I’m still hugely affected when Carter was stabbed and landed on the floor in the consultancy room and saw Lucy dying under the gurney.

Yeah they did Lucy wrong.

Also the moral dilemma of her killer going free due to him being mentally unwell at the time,