Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

Screen deaths that have stayed with you

546 replies

SteviesNicks · Yesterday 15:14

There are loads!
But from a discussion with my siblings (we watch the same things) a few of mine are from er - Lucy Knight, Dennis Gant, and Mark Greene of course.

Also PC Kirsten in Happy Valley.

And then there’s Catelyn Stark, Oberyn Martell and Shireen Baratheon in the Game of Thrones.

Which ones have had a visceral effect on you?

OP posts:
Sherrystrull · Yesterday 21:16

Scarecrow16 · Yesterday 15:23

Spooks 2002 where Lisa Faulkner's character had her head plunged into a deep fat fryer. Totally unexpected and horrific. Could have done with out the memory.

Came on the thread to say this. Happened out of the blue.

Also,
Shane in Home and Away
David in Home and Away
TP in Shortland Street

NotTerfNorCis · Yesterday 21:16

Buffy's mother in Buffy the Vampire Slayer. The numbing sense of shock was very well portrayed.

Holdinguphalfthesky · Yesterday 21:18

MyDenimKoala · Yesterday 21:16

I have still never been able to bring myself to watch Bambi!

Some of the Disney films were so awful. Not a death but the scene in Dumbo where his mum’s in elephant prison after defending him, and rocks him in her trunk… bringing tears to my eyes just writing it 😭
And Pinocchio still haunts my nightmares. Horrific.

Tulipvase · Yesterday 21:21

Too many posts to read but the man who was made to bite the pavement in American History X. Absolutely horrific.

MyDenimKoala · Yesterday 21:22

Holdinguphalfthesky · Yesterday 21:18

Some of the Disney films were so awful. Not a death but the scene in Dumbo where his mum’s in elephant prison after defending him, and rocks him in her trunk… bringing tears to my eyes just writing it 😭
And Pinocchio still haunts my nightmares. Horrific.

My brother had to be taken out of Pinocchio when Gepetto was sad and looking for him, inconsolable. I don’t really like Disney films because of the ones we had as kids!

38woman · Yesterday 21:22

Vera Duck worth. It was strange, I was crying so hard. Beautiful acting all round

blablablah · Yesterday 21:23

Wallace in The Wire
Jamie in Easteners
Omar in the Wire. That one got me for a good few days afterwards. 😭

MyDenimKoala · Yesterday 21:23

Sherrystrull · Yesterday 21:16

Came on the thread to say this. Happened out of the blue.

Also,
Shane in Home and Away
David in Home and Away
TP in Shortland Street

Ah, David in Home and Away! Such a brilliant and in retrospect totally dodgy storyline.

Holdinguphalfthesky · Yesterday 21:24

Daniel Blake in the eponymous film. Made it worse because my dad also had The Shipping Forecast theme (Sailing By) at his funeral. I was showing it to a classic sixth form sociology students, and I had to step outside for a moment.

Gonners · Yesterday 21:25

The accidental shooting by Vincent Vega (John Travolta) of Marvin (the actor's name escapes me) in the car in Pulp Fiction.

HurdyGurdy19 · Yesterday 21:29

Aiden Connor in Corrie

Matthew Cuthbert in Anne of Green Gables

Barbara in Call the Midwife

BeepBoopBeeeeep · Yesterday 21:30

Max and Suzannah’s children in Brookside. Matthew and Emily 😢

billycat321 · Yesterday 21:30

Pinocchio was horrific. The part where the donkeys were crated up to be sent to Siberia (?) just broke me .70 years later still upsets me to think of it

Carathelara · Yesterday 21:31

Big in SATC. I've watched it since it first came out in 1998 and I was 15. I grew up with the show and have watched it countless times.
I wasn't expecting it and was gobsmacked.

Also, although it wasn't on screen and he had died in real life, Marty Crane in the Frasier remake. Just so poignant.

Jen in Dawson's Creek also made me very sad and she acted it beautifully.

PuggyPuggyPuggy · Yesterday 21:31

I can't check all 19 pages. Has anyone said Hodor yet?

liftingprincess · Yesterday 21:32

Derek shepherd Greys Anatomy

VielleTruite · Yesterday 21:34

Holdinguphalfthesky · Yesterday 21:24

Daniel Blake in the eponymous film. Made it worse because my dad also had The Shipping Forecast theme (Sailing By) at his funeral. I was showing it to a classic sixth form sociology students, and I had to step outside for a moment.

I cried in the cinema at that - so unfair after all he'd been through with the horrible system. I was in the same situation at the time so completely empathised with the whole film. It was very accurate.

Timeforaswim2026 · Yesterday 21:35

The kids in the 1997 film ‘Jude’ . I hadn’t read the book so was a real shock

lance corporal Blake in the film ‘1917’ . Devastating

Kristen Scott Thomas in the English Patient. I thought she would get rescued.

Wheniswinenight · Yesterday 21:36

Shane in Home & Away. With the lovely song playing. I was heartbroken.

Biddybobsleigh · Yesterday 21:42

SteviesNicks · Yesterday 15:14

There are loads!
But from a discussion with my siblings (we watch the same things) a few of mine are from er - Lucy Knight, Dennis Gant, and Mark Greene of course.

Also PC Kirsten in Happy Valley.

And then there’s Catelyn Stark, Oberyn Martell and Shireen Baratheon in the Game of Thrones.

Which ones have had a visceral effect on you?

Villanelle in killing eve

HorseandHeron · Yesterday 21:44

Clearingaspace · Yesterday 15:27

Manchester by sea

That is the saddest film I have ever seen. Brilliant but almost unbearable.

VielleTruite · Yesterday 21:47

Jody the soldier killed by the IRA in The Crying Game
Oliver Reed at the end of Women in Love
Alex (played by Jeremy Irons) drowning in Love for Lydia
Bergerac's (the original) girlfriend played by Louise Jameson being murdered
Not exactly a death, but River Phoenix's character in Stand By Me fading into the distance and the narrator updating that he was stabbed to death as an adult. All the more sad because of River Phoenix's premature actual death.

Carinissima · Yesterday 21:48

Danaerys in got. Still upset

Pungifries · Yesterday 21:53

The Luther series that started with all the parents/ relatives watching their loved ones die.
can’t remember the details but I found it horrific

Sherrystrull · Yesterday 21:55

Meg in Home and Away. How could I have forgotten? Blake’s grief was horrific. Home and away had some hugely touching deaths the more I think about.

David, Shane, Meg, Bobby, Ailsa, Tom,