Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

Phones to be totally banned from school Sept2027

284 replies

Anneleesa · 10/11/2026 09:57

Two questions on this for the MN hive mind!

First - If you can’t have a phone in your bag AT ALL will that include dumb phones? Will all schools be obliged to provide pouches/lockers for kids whose parents want them to have a phone when travelling to and from school? There isn’t a phone box anywhere on dc’s route home from school.

Second - the last para mentions access to Vinted and eBay may be banned. Can anyone suggest why? I sort of understand eBay (the auction process can get addictive?) but why Vinted?

https://www.bbc.co.uk/phones to be banned from pupils bags under new rules

A secondary school aged girl and boy in uniform looking at the screen of a phone. The boy has school packpack on over his shoulders

Phones to be banned from pupils' bags or pockets under new rules

The government says it is strengthening its guidance for schools in England, which came into force in June.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c51kdk422w8jo

OP posts:
Needmorelego · 10/11/2026 10:52

Justploddingonandon · 10/11/2026 10:44

Actually there are quite a lot of jobs that don't allow you to have personal phones on/near your person while working, they do normally provide lockers though. Apart from the cost of providing lockers, I suspect the other issue schools will have is some kids will see it as a challenge to break into them.
I'm curious to see what DS's school will do, as they currently are fine with phones turned off in a bag, and the head teacher has said he doesn't want to go stricter as it's a grammar school with a wider catchment than normal and lots of kids have their train/bus tickets on their phone.

Most jobs don't allow phones. That is true. Pretty much all jobs I would imagine.
But you are allowed other personal items in your bag that you don't use during the work day because they aren't relevant to your job. They just live in your bag.
Like your house keys, wallet, a paperback book, mp3 player, kindle, make up, crossword book, packet of sweets, water bottle, packet of cigarettes, emergency spare socks.....
A phone is a personal and useful object to own.
If you want to have one living in your bag then why shouldn't you?

estrogone · 10/11/2026 10:53

Needmorelego · 10/11/2026 10:52

Most jobs don't allow phones. That is true. Pretty much all jobs I would imagine.
But you are allowed other personal items in your bag that you don't use during the work day because they aren't relevant to your job. They just live in your bag.
Like your house keys, wallet, a paperback book, mp3 player, kindle, make up, crossword book, packet of sweets, water bottle, packet of cigarettes, emergency spare socks.....
A phone is a personal and useful object to own.
If you want to have one living in your bag then why shouldn't you?

Students are not adults.

GasPanic · 10/11/2026 10:54

There are technological solutions to this.

Phones that automatically switch themselves off during school hours.

Jammers etc.

Surely anyone determined to give their kid a phone because they want to ask Johnny what cake he wants during school hours is just going to give them two, a burner to put in the pouch and one to keep on them.

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about this subject:

bebedon · 10/11/2026 10:55

DDs school has always had this rule. Phones are collected in morning registration. They are put into a plastic box and taken to the school office. A child collects the box at end of school and phones are handed back out by form teacher. It’s not at all difficult or complicated and works very effectively.

Needmorelego · 10/11/2026 10:56

sittingonabeach · 10/11/2026 10:43

Why are you so against it? Maybe schools want to spend more time teaching than having to sort out issues with phones.

I assume most workplaces don’t have daily issues with employees doing Tik toks instead of working, bullying via phones, inappropriate use of phones in the toilets etc

I'm against the idea of banning having a switched off phone sat in the bottom of a bag.
A phone is a useful personal item to own.
Smart phones could be banned in schools but I see no problem in a basic "dumb" phone.

Needmorelego · 10/11/2026 10:57

estrogone · 10/11/2026 10:53

Students are not adults.

How do they learn to be adults......oh we teach them how.

WilliamTopazMcGonagallPoorPoetFromDundeeBeItTold · 10/11/2026 10:58

Needmorelego · 10/11/2026 10:23

It's getting ridiculous.
Can you imagine if adults were told they couldn't have phone (that they might simply want to use on their commute to and from work) in their bag/locker at work.
I would rather we (society) start teaching young people to be sensible around phones.

I agree. It's also a nasty generalisation that ALL tweens and teens can only abuse phones and are unable and/or unwilling to use them sensibly as the tool that they are. In fact, there are plenty of teens who can use phones responsibly, and plenty of adults who can't.

If there are 100 licensed drivers who live on Acacia Avenue, how many of them need to have been caught speeding before ALL of the residents automatically have their driving licences taken away - "because we know that people who live on Acacia Avenue can't be trusted to drive responsibly"?

I'd much prefer to see a very strict no-nonsense approach taken whereby all pupils are allowed phones, BUT it's made abundantly clear to them and to their parents that they will lose all allowances to have phones on site if they are caught abusing them once (or maybe twice) - possibly to be reviewed at the start of each term or year.

As well as not punishing innocent people for the wrongs of others, that would send a clear, simple message about good behaviour = standard privileges; bad behaviour = losing standard privileges.

I also hate the tacit anti-disabled people rhetoric, whereby children who rely on a phone app to monitor a serious disability and keep themselves alive and out of hospital are dismissed and othered (with statements saying 'ALL phones to be banned'); and they are made to feel like they're being done a massive favour, and not really keeping to the rules, in being allowed to keep them with them. Can you imagine the outcry if children who use wheelchairs were told that they should feel grateful that the school lets them use the lift, even though 'the government has banned lifts in schools, because children only mess around in them'?

Needmorelego · 10/11/2026 11:01

Perhaps we should be looking at the bigger picture of why teens want to spend time making tiktoks during the school day (ie they're bored at school because the curriculum is terrible) or why bullying happens.
I would rather schools focused on things like that.

sittingonabeach · 10/11/2026 11:07

Needmorelego · 10/11/2026 10:57

How do they learn to be adults......oh we teach them how.

And that can be the parents' job. But as schools see on a daily basis many parents are failing in this regard

Mumof1andacat · 10/11/2026 11:09

My ds school use these yonda pouches. The pupils lock their phone in it at the beginning od the day and as they leave the building, the pupils hand over the pouches and the staff member unlocks them and hand over the pouche with phone in. Has been happening since yr 7. Ds is yr 9. Works well.

sittingonabeach · 10/11/2026 11:11

Needmorelego · 10/11/2026 11:01

Perhaps we should be looking at the bigger picture of why teens want to spend time making tiktoks during the school day (ie they're bored at school because the curriculum is terrible) or why bullying happens.
I would rather schools focused on things like that.

Do you work in a school?

JustAnotherWhinger · 10/11/2026 11:15

I’m torn on this one. I really hate how much phones take over, but school budgets shouldn’t have to stretch to pouches if they already have a good system. DS’s school have a policy that phones are confiscated if seen by a staff member and a parent has to collect it. It caused a storm when it first came in but it’s very very effective now.
They don’t need pouches or lockers when they have an effective system already.

The biggest issue here is that the bus passes for the school buses (and because we’re quite rural the vast majority of the kids get the buses) are on an app.

I’ll be mega pissed off if valuable school funds have to be spent on pouches because of the passes when their current system for phones works.

WilliamTopazMcGonagallPoorPoetFromDundeeBeItTold · 10/11/2026 11:16

Needmorelego · 10/11/2026 10:57

How do they learn to be adults......oh we teach them how.

There seem to be a lot of people who see a binary of 'children' and 'adults', with no recognition at all of the broad transitional stages whereby the former gradually learn and prepare to become the latter.

We understand this with most things - where we have to train, teach and guide youngsters through each stage; but when it comes to phones, we just want to pretend to them that they're irrelevant? Why would we want to take the lazy way out and deliberately deny our children the opportunity to learn this valuable life lesson for life in the 21st-Century? Are these the same parents who send children (able-bodied and with no SEN) to school in nappies, without ever thinking that it might have been a very good idea to prepare and toilet train them beforehand?

There's a campaign group that's been mentioned by the BBC, who are firmly anti smartphones in schools, who claim that they have 400 teachers and parents signed up in agreement. Maybe if parents did actually bother to parent, this would never have been an issue in the first place.

Smartphones are a standard part of life now, they aren't going away; and it's pointless being King Cnut trying to turn back the tide of them. Like so many things in life, it's up to the adults to parent, educate and guide children in making wise decisions about things that can both be used for good or abused for bad. You can use a car to take an elderly neighbour to their hospital appointments, or to do your family food shop, or to go to work, or to deliberately run somebody over - do we deduce from that that cars are bad things or good things (and you can apparently only choose one answer)?

Needmorelego · 10/11/2026 11:22

sittingonabeach · 10/11/2026 11:07

And that can be the parents' job. But as schools see on a daily basis many parents are failing in this regard

It's society's job.
Everyone's job.
Why do we even have schools if it's parents job to teach everything?

Babyboomtastic · 10/11/2026 11:39

Surely it should be up to individual schools. If a school has a policy of keeping them in the bag, out of sight etc, and it's working perfectly fine, they should be allowed to keep doing what is working for them.

I think it's the lazy way out to ban them, rather than teach kids how to use them in a moderated way.

MagnoliaParks · 10/11/2026 11:42

Needmorelego · 10/11/2026 10:23

It's getting ridiculous.
Can you imagine if adults were told they couldn't have phone (that they might simply want to use on their commute to and from work) in their bag/locker at work.
I would rather we (society) start teaching young people to be sensible around phones.

Can you imagine if adults were told they were too immature to have sex and it was illegal, even in the privacy of their own home?!

There are plenty of things we accept that children shouldn’t do because it is not safe or healthy for them but adults can do freely. Unfettered smartphone use should be in their category.

Polstea · 10/11/2026 11:49

I have a dc in primary school and quite a few of the local secondary schools have phone bans with pouches. I'm curious to know how it's implemented in practice though - I know that if I were a schoolgirl and were determined to keep a phone with me, I'd hide it on my person (eg down my bra or in a pocket on cycling shorts worn under a skirt) and then check it in the toilets. Surely they can't be doing body checks like that for each pupil so some of them must be getting through. Plus I have backpacks with 6 or 7 zipped sections and they never all get searched when I visit places that do a bag search (by dedicated security staff), and I can't imagine it would be done thoroughly by staff at a school. If a pupil doesn't bring a phone to hand in (and leave it at home), would they get a more thorough check because staff wouldn't believe they don't have one? If they hand in a phone, would staff still do bag searches in case they have a second handset in a bag (what if they have 3)?

Although I'm a bit skeptical about how much it can be policed, I do support the ban. I definitely focus better in places that have a phone ban or when I can't get a signal (though I will sometimes come out to a build up of messages that I haven't been able to respond to and sometimes am too late to respond to). I think having access to a phone during the journey wouldn't be essential for my dcs as we are looking at fairly local schools (close enough to walk or catch a bus if the trains get delayed) but it would be more of an issue for dcs who go to school miles away with only one transport option.

BirdLandedonmyHead · 10/11/2026 11:50

This year DDs school has gone for really ramped up punishments (including a patent having to collect the phone at an alloted time).

But some are still using them in lessons. Or filming other pupils. Or hiding in the toilets with them. And the time the teachers spend realing with it is time away from teaching.

I find the governments interference OTT but understand ir is a massive problem.

Redbags · 10/11/2026 11:52

Needmorelego · 10/11/2026 10:23

It's getting ridiculous.
Can you imagine if adults were told they couldn't have phone (that they might simply want to use on their commute to and from work) in their bag/locker at work.
I would rather we (society) start teaching young people to be sensible around phones.

Can you imagine if adults were told where to be all day, where they should be all day, what time to be home, when to go to bed, what to eat, what they can't watch on TV.....get the gist?

sittingonabeach · 10/11/2026 11:54

Some schools will have introduced wands as well, so can checks bags for any hidden phones.

The secondary schools local to me introduced pouches this year. They also now treat phones on school site as prohibited item, so if one is found not locked in a pouch it could lead to a suspension (whereas previously it might have been a detention to start with)

Needmorelego · 10/11/2026 11:55

MagnoliaParks · 10/11/2026 11:42

Can you imagine if adults were told they were too immature to have sex and it was illegal, even in the privacy of their own home?!

There are plenty of things we accept that children shouldn’t do because it is not safe or healthy for them but adults can do freely. Unfettered smartphone use should be in their category.

I'm fine with smartphones not being allowed in schools.

Needmorelego · 10/11/2026 11:57

Redbags · 10/11/2026 11:52

Can you imagine if adults were told where to be all day, where they should be all day, what time to be home, when to go to bed, what to eat, what they can't watch on TV.....get the gist?

Your point?

EducatingArti · 10/11/2026 11:59

Needmorelego · 10/11/2026 11:01

Perhaps we should be looking at the bigger picture of why teens want to spend time making tiktoks during the school day (ie they're bored at school because the curriculum is terrible) or why bullying happens.
I would rather schools focused on things like that.

But schools will have more time to focus on all sorts of things if the teachers aren't continually having to police the " Keep your phone switched off in your bag" rule.

RaggedRocks · 10/11/2026 12:00

Redbags · 10/11/2026 11:52

Can you imagine if adults were told where to be all day, where they should be all day, what time to be home, when to go to bed, what to eat, what they can't watch on TV.....get the gist?

Prison is like that.

Needmorelego · 10/11/2026 12:02

EducatingArti · 10/11/2026 11:59

But schools will have more time to focus on all sorts of things if the teachers aren't continually having to police the " Keep your phone switched off in your bag" rule.

Well if it's taught right from age 4 in Reception that personal items stay in your bag and not used during the school day then by secondary school it shouldn't be an issue.