I agree. It's also a nasty generalisation that ALL tweens and teens can only abuse phones and are unable and/or unwilling to use them sensibly as the tool that they are. In fact, there are plenty of teens who can use phones responsibly, and plenty of adults who can't.
If there are 100 licensed drivers who live on Acacia Avenue, how many of them need to have been caught speeding before ALL of the residents automatically have their driving licences taken away - "because we know that people who live on Acacia Avenue can't be trusted to drive responsibly"?
I'd much prefer to see a very strict no-nonsense approach taken whereby all pupils are allowed phones, BUT it's made abundantly clear to them and to their parents that they will lose all allowances to have phones on site if they are caught abusing them once (or maybe twice) - possibly to be reviewed at the start of each term or year.
As well as not punishing innocent people for the wrongs of others, that would send a clear, simple message about good behaviour = standard privileges; bad behaviour = losing standard privileges.
I also hate the tacit anti-disabled people rhetoric, whereby children who rely on a phone app to monitor a serious disability and keep themselves alive and out of hospital are dismissed and othered (with statements saying 'ALL phones to be banned'); and they are made to feel like they're being done a massive favour, and not really keeping to the rules, in being allowed to keep them with them. Can you imagine the outcry if children who use wheelchairs were told that they should feel grateful that the school lets them use the lift, even though 'the government has banned lifts in schools, because children only mess around in them'?