Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

Phones to be totally banned from school Sept2027

284 replies

Anneleesa · 10/11/2026 09:57

Two questions on this for the MN hive mind!

First - If you can’t have a phone in your bag AT ALL will that include dumb phones? Will all schools be obliged to provide pouches/lockers for kids whose parents want them to have a phone when travelling to and from school? There isn’t a phone box anywhere on dc’s route home from school.

Second - the last para mentions access to Vinted and eBay may be banned. Can anyone suggest why? I sort of understand eBay (the auction process can get addictive?) but why Vinted?

https://www.bbc.co.uk/phones to be banned from pupils bags under new rules

A secondary school aged girl and boy in uniform looking at the screen of a phone. The boy has school packpack on over his shoulders

Phones to be banned from pupils' bags or pockets under new rules

The government says it is strengthening its guidance for schools in England, which came into force in June.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c51kdk422w8jo

OP posts:
sittingonabeach · 11/11/2026 23:02

ShanghaiDiva · 11/11/2026 23:01

mobile phone detector wands are used where I work.

And in my local schools and instant suspension if one found

drspouse · 11/11/2026 23:35

An early twenties staff member at my work told me her school had signal blockers - we were visiting a school together for work and I was using my phone and she was surprised it worked. I don't know how common that is - I'm assuming it only blocks phone signals not WiFi and staff members can use WiFi for educational devices and for their own phones in the staff room.

WilliamTopazMcGonagallPoorPoetFromDundeeBeItTold · 12/11/2026 00:32

Needmorelego · 11/11/2026 19:09

This is one of my arguments. Public transport needs to have smartcards or contactless card payments instead of apps.
Many bus companies are happy to change back so school students don't need an app but they haven't been given enough time to sort it before the no phones in schools rule came in.
Once that's sorted then teens don't need an app to use public transport.
Other tickets can be printed off if needed.
So really older teens technically don't need a smart phone. They can just have a dumb phone.

Other tickets can be printed off if needed.

But most households don't have printers anymore; so as well as the extra admin task to have to remember and do, that's extra outlay for people having to buy printers, ink and paper for them... all to take a backwards step when a much more efficient, commonplace method exists, because other children haven't been parented or disciplined appropriately in the appropriate use of everyday tools.

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about this subject:

WilliamTopazMcGonagallPoorPoetFromDundeeBeItTold · 12/11/2026 00:42

Needmorelego · 11/11/2026 19:10

Why would the school buy them?
They don't pay for the uniforms and stationary that students are required to have.

Uniforms and stationery are standard everyday requirements for attending school. That's completely different from expecting people to pay money to limit themselves, predicated on the assumption of their not being able to be trusted.

I would see it as the equivalent of if the UK brought in the same law as they have in France, whereby all drivers have to carry a breathalyser in their cars at all times. I'm sure they're great if you are a drinker and you choose to buy one because you want to make absolutely certain that the booze you drank the previous night is no longer present in your system; but for those of us who are tee-total (including devout people whose faith forbids alcohol, and those with medical conditions that mean they must not drink), it's just another thing to be forced to pay for and carry with you because of other people's undisciplined and illegal behaviour, which is totally irrelevant to you, but which is nevertheless presumptuously ascribed to you as well.

Needmorelego · 12/11/2026 00:44

WilliamTopazMcGonagallPoorPoetFromDundeeBeItTold · 12/11/2026 00:32

Other tickets can be printed off if needed.

But most households don't have printers anymore; so as well as the extra admin task to have to remember and do, that's extra outlay for people having to buy printers, ink and paper for them... all to take a backwards step when a much more efficient, commonplace method exists, because other children haven't been parented or disciplined appropriately in the appropriate use of everyday tools.

Don't most children get taken to the cinema etc by their parents?
The parent can have the ticket to be scanned when dropping them off?

Needmorelego · 12/11/2026 00:51

WilliamTopazMcGonagallPoorPoetFromDundeeBeItTold · 12/11/2026 00:32

Other tickets can be printed off if needed.

But most households don't have printers anymore; so as well as the extra admin task to have to remember and do, that's extra outlay for people having to buy printers, ink and paper for them... all to take a backwards step when a much more efficient, commonplace method exists, because other children haven't been parented or disciplined appropriately in the appropriate use of everyday tools.

I actually agree that online apps, tickets and codes etc are bloody useful and make life easier.
That's why I am actually against school banning phones.
We (society) need to better at teaching our children that smart phones are a really good useful item to own and to stop using them for the crap that is causing them to banned.

WilliamTopazMcGonagallPoorPoetFromDundeeBeItTold · 12/11/2026 01:02

Needmorelego · 12/11/2026 00:44

Don't most children get taken to the cinema etc by their parents?
The parent can have the ticket to be scanned when dropping them off?

Yes - but the majority of people will have the ticket on their phone (which can be forwarded on to the child's phone if necessary, if they're going unaccompanied), and they will hold up their phone for the ticket code to be scanned at the counter.

A phone is a portable computer and thus has largely replaced the need for many people to have a printer, like they used to need to print something off the computer that lived on their desk at home, if they had to take it somewhere with them.

Loads of people don't even carry cash anymore - or even bother with physical bank cards, and just use Apple/Google Pay in shops. Phones are the standard modern way of conducting all kinds of transactions and communications in 2026; it's such a retrograde step to deliberately move backwards - especially for the generation who will, most of all, instinctively use current methods for doing things.

I wonder how the teachers who are in favour of this - and indeed the politicians who have voted for it - would feel if they were told that they would have to queue up on pay day to receive an envelope with carefully-counted cash inside it, which they can 'simply' go to the bank to pay in. Yes, that's what we used to do as standard, and it would still work fine (although you might have quite a journey to find a bank branch now)... but the world has moved on since then, and uses modern, efficient methods to conduct our lives.

Needmorelego · 12/11/2026 01:05

WilliamTopazMcGonagallPoorPoetFromDundeeBeItTold · 12/11/2026 01:02

Yes - but the majority of people will have the ticket on their phone (which can be forwarded on to the child's phone if necessary, if they're going unaccompanied), and they will hold up their phone for the ticket code to be scanned at the counter.

A phone is a portable computer and thus has largely replaced the need for many people to have a printer, like they used to need to print something off the computer that lived on their desk at home, if they had to take it somewhere with them.

Loads of people don't even carry cash anymore - or even bother with physical bank cards, and just use Apple/Google Pay in shops. Phones are the standard modern way of conducting all kinds of transactions and communications in 2026; it's such a retrograde step to deliberately move backwards - especially for the generation who will, most of all, instinctively use current methods for doing things.

I wonder how the teachers who are in favour of this - and indeed the politicians who have voted for it - would feel if they were told that they would have to queue up on pay day to receive an envelope with carefully-counted cash inside it, which they can 'simply' go to the bank to pay in. Yes, that's what we used to do as standard, and it would still work fine (although you might have quite a journey to find a bank branch now)... but the world has moved on since then, and uses modern, efficient methods to conduct our lives.

Edited

As I said in my follow up post - I actually agree with you.
Smart phones are a fantastic and useful piece of technology and I think there needs to be a different solution instead of banning them from schools.

WilliamTopazMcGonagallPoorPoetFromDundeeBeItTold · 12/11/2026 01:13

Needmorelego · 12/11/2026 00:51

I actually agree that online apps, tickets and codes etc are bloody useful and make life easier.
That's why I am actually against school banning phones.
We (society) need to better at teaching our children that smart phones are a really good useful item to own and to stop using them for the crap that is causing them to banned.

I completely agree. I don't see why we have to see the only options as either to ban teenagers from having access to phones, to use as tools, communication - and even (appropriately) entertainment devices; or otherwise assume that they will use them only for bad things, completely inappropriately... and also that adults have no control (or sanctions, if need be) in this whatsoever.

Outright banning phones, so that they can't even be used at breaktimes, would be like the equivalent of banning sex education lessons, and all lessons about personal finances - and telling young people that it's not something that they need to know anything about, and that they can find out about it once they're adults - which will naturally be once they no longer have influential and supervisory adult authority figures in their lives who could have guided them wisely.

sittingonabeach · 12/11/2026 01:16

WilliamTopazMcGonagallPoorPoetFromDundeeBeItTold · 12/11/2026 01:13

I completely agree. I don't see why we have to see the only options as either to ban teenagers from having access to phones, to use as tools, communication - and even (appropriately) entertainment devices; or otherwise assume that they will use them only for bad things, completely inappropriately... and also that adults have no control (or sanctions, if need be) in this whatsoever.

Outright banning phones, so that they can't even be used at breaktimes, would be like the equivalent of banning sex education lessons, and all lessons about personal finances - and telling young people that it's not something that they need to know anything about, and that they can find out about it once they're adults - which will naturally be once they no longer have influential and supervisory adult authority figures in their lives who could have guided them wisely.

It’s not like the students can’t use phones outside school. What many schools have found is that students are interacting more (in a nice way) during break times etc when they don’t have access to phones

WilliamTopazMcGonagallPoorPoetFromDundeeBeItTold · 12/11/2026 01:25

Needmorelego · 12/11/2026 01:05

As I said in my follow up post - I actually agree with you.
Smart phones are a fantastic and useful piece of technology and I think there needs to be a different solution instead of banning them from schools.

Edited

Sorry, yes, I know we're on the same page! Even schools themselves recognise how useful phones are in education, hence them using apps for communicating so much information with the students with.

It's so dispiriting when people in authority lazily ignore and slap it all down with an all-encompassing banhammer, rather than do their jobs (as parents, teachers and political leaders) and address the problems of misuse amongst some students who need proper guidance and discipline in wise use, like with so many other things in life at their age.

sittingonabeach · 12/11/2026 01:43

And schools will be teaching how to use technology safely (as many parents fail to do so). As usual schools are picking up the pieces from shit parenting

Cliffhampton · 12/11/2026 03:40

AmyByTheTrain · 10/11/2026 10:42

I am so frustrated with the "no phones at school policy" that I just need a rant. First, they already are banned this year, but it seems the government thinks they didn't spell it out clearly enough, so they need to update the wording.

Since they already are banned, DS's school followed the statutory guidance by banning phones from the premises this year. That means students don't have them for their commutes, which is stupid.

Yes, I know, they'll live and make do and build resilience, blah blah blah.

Back in my day, there weren't mobile phones, but there were pay phones. The school had a phone by the entrance that we could use after school to call our parents if we needed a ride home. In a pinch, we knew that nearby shops would let us call home if we really needed to.

None of that exists anymore... BECAUSE EVERYONE HAS MOBILE PHONES!

Yes, schools can provide pouches or lockers or collect phones at the beginning or end of the day. But that all takes money or time that is better for schools to spend on LEARNING because they are SCHOOLS. (Even pouches that parents pay for still need the school to invest money in the unlocking stations, I think I have heard.)

At out school, the policy now mostly means the parents spend their late afternoons whatsapping each other saying their kids aren't home yet, and asking if anyone knows if there are activities going on.

If social media will be banned for kids, isn't that supposed to be the government protecting them anyway?

Prior to all this, our school used the "in bags switched off, never seen or heard" rule and it worked just fine.

Ok, rant over.

Ours too. It is frustrating at best. I also didn’t have a mobile at school, but school had a phone box plus there were some on the way home. Even with that, there were certainly times when having a phone would have helped in dodgy situations. It has pissed parents off no end, especially as it worked fine with off in bag! Why can’t a child carry a brick phone? Children aren’t going straight home. The number of parents picking children up from school has increased. E..g. Child x has an activity from 5-7, so instead of going home and leaving twenty minutes later, they stayed in the library until 4.30 and got the bus to activity.
It’s ironic that another child collects their sibling from an after school club (y5). Younger sibling is allowed a phone for the commute!
The school relies heavily on apps and screens for homework.
I think it is appalling that schools are allowed to ban phones on a commute.

Missey85 · 12/11/2026 05:43

Needmorelego · 11/11/2026 20:52

In cases like that the kid will probably buy an old dumb phone for a few quid from CEX and don't actually put a SIM card in it - because it's a decoy phone.
Their not going to use it - just stick it the pouch.

Your a idiot if you'll think that works 😂😂😂 schools know teens don't bother with those phones and they'll know it's not Thiers how are you explaining that? School knows your not suddenly downgrading their phone's

Missey85 · 12/11/2026 05:52

ShanghaiDiva · 11/11/2026 16:26

If you dcs don’t use their phone during school then what are the few spoiling for them?
i dont want to use my phone at a spa, I respect other people’s right not to be photographed or videoed without consent so I don’t care if my phone is in a yondr pouch in my locker or just in my locker-makes no difference to me.

Some of the parents on here are really proving why these laws are good 😂😂 they've let thier kids get addicted to phones and social media because it was easy for them now they'll have to actually parent and suffer the meltdowns they've caused 🤣

frozendaisy · 12/11/2026 06:13

It’s a ban on phones being on at all during school day.

How individual Heads implement this is up to them.

Can’t see what the problem is really.

Most Heads will understand the need/want of phones for pupils travelling alone to/from school.

Ours have always had these rules at secondary. Phones off during the school day.

That’s all this rule is.

Almost nothing will change for the vast majority of pupils.

TheDrsDocMartens · 12/11/2026 06:53

My kids school is large, covers a massive rural area (so reliance on transport/lifts) and has 3 different entrances to the grounds and is spread over a variety of different buildings. The infrastructure for pouches will be huge and money much better spent elsewhere.

I want to support the ban on phones but for some schools it’ll come with a large cost at the schools expense which seems unfair.

ShanghaiDiva · 12/11/2026 09:07

frozendaisy · 12/11/2026 06:13

It’s a ban on phones being on at all during school day.

How individual Heads implement this is up to them.

Can’t see what the problem is really.

Most Heads will understand the need/want of phones for pupils travelling alone to/from school.

Ours have always had these rules at secondary. Phones off during the school day.

That’s all this rule is.

Almost nothing will change for the vast majority of pupils.

Exactly!
pupils will be able to use phones to and from school for bus apps etc. Pupils who need a phone for health reasons will be able to access their phone as they do now. If you need to contact your child due to an emergency/crisis then phone the school and they will communicate to your child.

WilliamTopazMcGonagallPoorPoetFromDundeeBeItTold · 12/11/2026 10:43

sittingonabeach · 12/11/2026 01:43

And schools will be teaching how to use technology safely (as many parents fail to do so). As usual schools are picking up the pieces from shit parenting

Sadly schools have to do this a great deal. I'm certainly in favour of supporting parents and offering/strongly 'encouraging' (even compelling, in some cases) them to engage and receive guidance in areas where they and/or their children demonstrate that there's a real need in any particular area.

I just don't see how assuming by default that all parents are useless and ineffectual, and all young people are poorly disciplined and unable to ever make wise choices, helps anybody in the long term.

It can actually be a very powerful driver of behavioural change when people who do make bad choices see the privileges that are enjoyed by those who make good choices, but denied to them until they mend their ways - whether they arrive there through self-discipline or through seeking/receiving help.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 12/11/2026 11:05

I wonder if. those who keep insisting that "practically everyone" now uses phones, laptops or whatever ever stop to think of the disabled and elderly?
It's all sold as "progress", but to some this really isn't progress - it's exclusion

And that's before we get to how the hell people will cope if the endless cyber attacks shut down internet access or hacking wrecks the banking systems

Worth remembering, perhaps, when assuming that little gadget in the pocket can be used by all for everything

Thelessdeceived · 12/11/2026 16:59

AttitudeAdjuster · 10/11/2026 12:29

I'm really worried about it as my DD needs her phone with her in lessons as a reasonable adjustment and its going to mean she has to explain it every time, and likely to end up told off unfairly by the endless supply teachers they seem to have. It also makes her phone a target to steal if she's one of the rare few with one in school. Technology has moved on, teens should be encouraged to learn how to use phones safely not banned from using them at school. All their homework, revision, payments and timetables are through a phone app too so it's very mixed messages. They had a careers event in the school hall a few weeks ago and every stall had a QR code for college prospectuses and further information that none of the kids could access as they're not allowed to use phones in school.

Edited

Can I suggest that a workaround for your daughter might be a ‘phone pass’ to show cover/supply staff, similar to time-out and toilet passes? This would cut down the public discussions with staff who don’t know the details of her RA.

AmyByTheTrain · 12/11/2026 17:30

frozendaisy · 12/11/2026 06:13

It’s a ban on phones being on at all during school day.

How individual Heads implement this is up to them.

Can’t see what the problem is really.

Most Heads will understand the need/want of phones for pupils travelling alone to/from school.

Ours have always had these rules at secondary. Phones off during the school day.

That’s all this rule is.

Almost nothing will change for the vast majority of pupils.

No, the policy is that students must not be able to access their mobile phone throughout the school day.

The upcoming update is to "make clear that schools should go beyond ‘not seen, not heard’ - where phones may remain in pupils’ bags - and adopt whole-school strategies that keep phones out of use and inaccessible throughout the school day." (https://www.gov.uk/government/news/strengthened-guidance-to-take-the-next-leap-to-phone-free-schools)

Yes, it is up to individual Heads to decide how to implement it. However, without funding for pouches or lockers, or if they don't want to spend time handing phones in and out at the beginning and end of the day, some choose to ban students from having phones at school altogether.

That is what DS's school did this year in response to the government policy, with the consequence that students now cannot have mobile phones with them for their commute, because they have nowhere to store them before entering the school grounds.

Moonnstarz · 12/11/2026 21:39

AmyByTheTrain · 12/11/2026 17:30

No, the policy is that students must not be able to access their mobile phone throughout the school day.

The upcoming update is to "make clear that schools should go beyond ‘not seen, not heard’ - where phones may remain in pupils’ bags - and adopt whole-school strategies that keep phones out of use and inaccessible throughout the school day." (https://www.gov.uk/government/news/strengthened-guidance-to-take-the-next-leap-to-phone-free-schools)

Yes, it is up to individual Heads to decide how to implement it. However, without funding for pouches or lockers, or if they don't want to spend time handing phones in and out at the beginning and end of the day, some choose to ban students from having phones at school altogether.

That is what DS's school did this year in response to the government policy, with the consequence that students now cannot have mobile phones with them for their commute, because they have nowhere to store them before entering the school grounds.

I think very few schools though will take such a hard line due to parent backlash. One school tried this near me but lots of parents were up in arms over it so the school relented and they currently just keep them in bags, but I have heard they will bring in pouches form September.

I guess it depends on how dependent the school is on numbers. A school that is the only one within a certain distance is more likely to have confidence in sticking to a no phone at all rule as they know they are less at risk of parents/kids choosing an alternative school. Within a 10 minute walk from where I live there are 2 secondaries. The other side of town (10 mins drive) there is another. There are then 3 grammar schools within the area plus a couple of other secondaries that could be accessible if required. With falling roll numbers schools are desperate for people to attend, so having such a hard policy of not having phones on site at all is not likely to work in my area and schools will have to invest in the pouch schemes.

Lindy2 · 12/11/2026 21:54

I needed to message my 15 year old today that I was in A&E with someone and wasn't sure how long I would be. They needed to make their own way home and let themselves in.

Because they have a mobile phone in their bag it took them 10 seconds after school to know the situation and know what to do. No problem. All sorted and OK.

It would have been a lot more complicated if they didn't have a phone with them for me to message them on.

I have no problem with phones being away during school but when the lessons are over I want my child to be able to message me if needed and visa versa like today.

Missey85 · 12/11/2026 23:00

Lindy2 · 12/11/2026 21:54

I needed to message my 15 year old today that I was in A&E with someone and wasn't sure how long I would be. They needed to make their own way home and let themselves in.

Because they have a mobile phone in their bag it took them 10 seconds after school to know the situation and know what to do. No problem. All sorted and OK.

It would have been a lot more complicated if they didn't have a phone with them for me to message them on.

I have no problem with phones being away during school but when the lessons are over I want my child to be able to message me if needed and visa versa like today.

In that case you would just phone the school and they'd pass the msg on?

Swipe left for the next trending thread