It’s interesting to see the selective quoting elsewhere from Matthew Syed’s article about Brand. Weirdly this section is being completely ignored.
But there is a twist here, and why I believe this story illuminates so much about our times. When Brand perceived he was about to be exposed, he pivoted. He is a grotesque figure but also possesses a canny, Machiavellian intelligence. He could see a new group emerging, this time on the right, who had become blinkered in their own way — not by utopian ideology but the deranging dynamics of social media.
Did you notice who defended him once he became a rabid antivaxer and reactionary? That’s right: Tucker Carlson. Andrew Tate. Beverley Turner. People whose commitment to truth is subordinate to their commitment to tribe. And I believe this duality explains a great deal about the state of the western world. A civilisation whose rise (particularly in the Anglo-Saxon sphere) was constructed on evidence, due process, a suspicion of utopianism and the patient examination of facts, but which is now caught in a pincer movement between enemies of truth on both sides. The blinkered ideological left and the truth-fearing, science-hating, conspiratorial right.