which of these coats for 12 year old girl?

[belleandbete]

Long story but I have to buy a coat for a 12 year old girl who doesn't have one. I have only boys and don't know any girls this age. if you have a daughter would she be into either of these coats, or is there a specific style/ . brand that would be popular with her? Thanks for the advice

www.gap.co.uk/gap/kids-coldcontrol-max-puffer/000479534.html?dwvar_000479534_color=000479534002&dwvar_000479534_fit=regular&cgid=Girls-NewArrivals-WinterMustHaves#mlink=EU_HP_VDN_G&clink=gap_20191024_hp_div_nav&start=1

www.gap.co.uk/gap/kids-wool-blend-peacoat/000520376.html?dwvar_000520376_color=000520376000&dwvar_000520376_fit=regular&cgid=Girls-NewArrivals-WinterMustHaves#mlink=EU_HP_VDN_G&clink=gap_20191024_hp_div_nav&start=1

My DSD wanted a puffer coat from river island. Their practical and lovely and warm! Reasonably priced and in fashion x

Is the first one waterproof?

I like this one (not sure if it is helpful) - please it's 50% off.

www.landsend.co.uk/Girls_Waterproof_Squall_Jacket/pp/P_40626.html?cgid=11411&dwvar_P__40626_sizeVariation=Big%20Kids%207-13%20Years