Which coat looks more attractive to you?

[HavanaLove]

www.next.co.uk/gl3476s15#r02272

or

www.riverisland.com/p/navy-high-shine-fitted-padded-jacket-735257

Thanks :)

First one for me

The one from Next.

They’re both awful sorry

I’d look like a walking water tank in both of them.

Both awful - sorry!

Not my cup of tea at all. Sorry.

Both look cheap and nasty. 80 quid you got to be joking!!

2nd one

I think they both look like bin bags. Sorry.

First one I think. They are very similar so not a lot in it. Would look awful on me but look nice on the models.

The style of first one is better but don't like the shiny-ness.

The first one is slightly less awful.

I like them both, but think the second one is a bit nicer.

Both awful. Puffy coats like that with the belt are really common to me.

And I say that as someone who's common as muck 😂

Sorry OP neither, its's that PVC look. It's dreadful

Oh dear - neither are my style.

But the work would be very boring if we all wore the same stuff.

Go with the cheaper one, they look very similar.

Blimy, I had no idea that S&M costs existed till I saw that next link!

Both pretty vile I’d say.

• coats

The first one is better. The different patterns on the second one remind me of my DS' dragon shoes. sorry that's probably not helpful

The first one would nice enough if it wasn't shiny (and if you're quite skinny. I don't think it would be very flattering unless you have a well defined waist)

The second one is just awful shiny or not.

Yeah both too shiny like bin bags.

The one from Next is marginally less hideous.

At £85 and £89 I wouldn't buy either.

Neither

Second bin bag looks the strongest