Which coat looks more attractive to you?

[HavanaLove]

www.next.co.uk/gl3476s15#r02272

or

www.riverisland.com/p/navy-high-shine-fitted-padded-jacket-735257

Thanks :)

If I had to choose, the next one. But not keen on either really.

@FAQs 😂😂😂😂

They both look cheap and tacky sorry.

Don't love this look but if I had to choose it would be the Next one

Are they waterproof?

Not a good look! I'm common as shit and far from stylish but these look like they should be paired with a tracksuit and hair in a high scrunchie with a fag hanging off a hand decorated with sovereign rings. Sorry

Eh?

@22:56mawof3soontobe

Sorry both a ghastly but if I had to pick them the one from Next

Theyre both a very poor imitation of the Moncler. Sorry.

Everyone and their granny will be wearing shiny black parkas this year OP.

Neither

The first one, but I really don't like the shiny-ness

They’re both horrible and cheap looking.

Hate the shininess. Looks cheap and probably aren't that warm.

River island one for sure!

They are both nasty.

I think this actually looks nicer......

www.next.co.uk/style/st386439#553781

They’re far too shiny, would be far nicer if they were Matt.

I’d look like a walking water tank in both of them.
Second bin bag looks the strongest

brilliant.

They're both awful sorry!!

Oh God no, don't do it !

Not a fan of either but the first one is better. Also I would only wear this is you are thin with a small midsection.

I love my coats, I have so, so many and the oldest one is 12 years old OP and still going strong - my point is, don’t buy a shiny one as you’ll regret it when they go out of fashion in a few months time - buy a coat that you can get out every winter and wear.... looks cheap shiny.

Both nasty & cheap looking, but the Next one is the least worst.

If you are considering wearing either of these I'd hope you are young, tall, very slender & confidently fashion forward. Otherwise it's not going to be a good look.