Please or to access all these features

AMA

I have two primary-aged children who are unable to attend school due to EBSA. AMA.

64 replies

MumofMaskers · 15/11/2026 16:59

I've been reading quite a few threads recently about emotionally based school avoidance (EBSA), and I've been struck by how many misconceptions there are about children who are unable to attend school and the families supporting them.

I have two young children, both autistic, who are currently unable to attend school. Both started out in mainstream education, and both experienced progressively greater difficulties despite extensive efforts to support their attendance.

Our lives have changed beyond recognition. I've had to give up my career, we're navigating a complicated SEND system, and we're trying to secure suitable education for both children.

I thought it might be useful to offer a perspective from someone living this reality, rather than another debate about whether parents are being too soft or children simply need to be made to attend.

I'm happy to answer genuine questions, including difficult ones, about what led to this situation, what we've tried, what everyday life looks like, and how it's affected our family. I don't claim to speak for every family experiencing EBSA, but I'm happy to share our experience. I especially wanted to talk about what it's like experiencing this with children at a younger age.

OP posts:
PinkFrogss · 17/11/2026 19:46

What do you think their lives will be like as adults - thinking post 16 education, jobs, relationships?

And what is your opinion on Milburn’s recommendations?

MumofMaskers · 17/11/2026 20:54

PinkFrogss · 17/11/2026 19:46

What do you think their lives will be like as adults - thinking post 16 education, jobs, relationships?

And what is your opinion on Milburn’s recommendations?

It's something I think about a lot, and worry about too. They're still only young, so it's incredibly difficult to predict what their lives will look like in another 10 or 20 years.

Both have considerable strengths and abilities, and I hope that with the right education and support they'll have opportunities to pursue further education, careers and fulfilling relationships. I suspect they'll need some support with aspects of adult life, especially my youngest but I don't know what that will look like yet. I want to nurture their strengths while gradually developing their confidence, resilience, practical skills and independence.

I'm also very conscious that the world they'll enter as adults will be quite different from ours, particularly with AI and changes to the labour market. There may be opportunities we can't even envisage yet.

On Milburn, I think the emphasis on earlier intervention, personalised support and joining up education, health and employment services raises some really important points. My experience is that we spend far too much time and money responding to crises that might have been prevented with appropriate support much earlier. This reflect things I experienced in my career as a Civil Servant too, so I'm often looking at decisions the LA takes re my kids with that lens.

I'm particularly interested in the proposals for more flexible pathways into further education, training and employment, rather than assuming one conventional route will work for everyone. I did quite a bit of work on post 16 routes and think there's so much potential for reform here.

I've also had to really open my eyes to the possibility of educational pathways looking very different - and that is absolutely ok. I had a traditional academic/university route as did my husband, but we can't assume that is what's best for our children.

OP posts:
DeafLeppard · 17/11/2026 21:19

Are your children happier out of school? Did the tummy aches and physical symptoms disappear?

GingerIsland · 17/11/2026 21:23

I’m interested if you or your husband are autistic and your experience of school/education/work?

How do you compare your experience to your children’s.

OrangeFlower14 · 17/11/2026 21:31

@MumofMaskers “I do think we need a much wider range of properly resourced educational settings, rather than expecting mainstream to accommodate everyone regardless of their needs.”

it’s strange, isn’t it, I only know what things were like in the 70s/80s because of an uncle who went to specialist school. It seems like there’s been a lot of maybe well intention stuff about children being catered for in the mainstream, but I just don’t know how realistic that is. When we talk to our friends about it and then we compare it to uncle and what his parents didn’t have to deal with at all…. It doesn’t make any sense.. I suppose they thought it saved money somewhere but did it, and it seems like it certainly hasn’t done children any good

MumofMaskers · 17/11/2026 21:37

DeafLeppard · 17/11/2026 21:19

Are your children happier out of school? Did the tummy aches and physical symptoms disappear?

Yes, although it's been a gradual process, and the children are at quite different stages.

With my eldest, the intensity and frequency of the tummy aches reduced dramatically once school was taken out of the equation. She seems much happier and healthier overall, and is finally gaining weight again after a long period of struggling. She barely ate at school, and the sheer amount of energy she was expending on masking and managing her anxiety was enormous.
She's still a very anxious child, and the tummy aches haven't disappeared completely. But the difference now is that we can usually identify what's triggering them, rather than school anxiety being this constant background noise affecting everything.

My youngest is still very much in autistic burnout, and his day to day functioning hasn't fully recovered. We're seeing some gradual improvements, but it's still very early days for him - he only stopped attending school quite recently.

So I wouldn't say removing school has magically resolved everything. But it has removed an enormous source of distress, and we're beginning to see what recovery looks like for each of them, and what they need longer term. I think it's important to recognise that recovery from prolonged burnout can take a very long time. I found this hard to get my head around as so much of the conversation around this is in older children but it can absolutely happen in younger children too if they've been in the wrong environment.

OP posts:
MumofMaskers · 17/11/2026 21:42

GingerIsland · 17/11/2026 21:23

I’m interested if you or your husband are autistic and your experience of school/education/work?

How do you compare your experience to your children’s.

Neither of us is formally diagnosed, but since the children's diagnoses we've recognised a lot of traits in ourselves and across the wider family, as is often the way! I strongly suspect I'm autistic, while my husband has recognised both autistic and ADHD traits in himself. Both children are AuDHD. I'm not currently pursuing an assessment, although I may do one day.

I did well academically at school, but had a really difficult time at secondary school socially and emotionally, including experiencing bullying. I went on to university and had a successful career, including senior roles in the Civil Service, but looking back I can recognise how much I was masking and the toll that took. I've experienced significant periods of burnout in adulthood, especially since having the children, and it's a regular feature now, probably with perimenopause approaching too.

I think there are some striking parallels with my children, particularly my daughter's tendency to internalise distress, mask her difficulties and appear to be coping when she really isn't. But there are important differences too. I managed to stay in education and follow a fairly conventional path, whereas both my children have reached a point where school has become completely inaccessible to them.

One thing this whole experience has made me reflect on is how easily academic achievement and outward success can disguise significant difficulties. I was a bright child who did well at school, so nobody was particularly concerned about how I was coping underneath it all. I fell apart a bit in my late teens and twenties.

I don't want my children to have to spend their lives pushing through distress just to appear to be functioning successfully. I want them to have the opportunities I had, but hopefully without paying quite such a high price for them. So much more I could say, but not here!

OP posts:
MumofMaskers · 17/11/2026 22:29

OrangeFlower14 · 17/11/2026 21:31

@MumofMaskers “I do think we need a much wider range of properly resourced educational settings, rather than expecting mainstream to accommodate everyone regardless of their needs.”

it’s strange, isn’t it, I only know what things were like in the 70s/80s because of an uncle who went to specialist school. It seems like there’s been a lot of maybe well intention stuff about children being catered for in the mainstream, but I just don’t know how realistic that is. When we talk to our friends about it and then we compare it to uncle and what his parents didn’t have to deal with at all…. It doesn’t make any sense.. I suppose they thought it saved money somewhere but did it, and it seems like it certainly hasn’t done children any good

I agree. I remember children going to specialist schools when I was younger, although I suspect they were often quite different from the sort of specialist provision my children would need.

I think there was a major shift towards mainstream inclusion from the 1980s onwards, which was well intentioned in many respects. But I wonder whether we ended up pursuing inclusion without properly investing in the staffing, training, resources and range of settings needed to make it work. And successive funding pressures have compounded that.

It's like there's a false choice between mainstream and specialist education, when surely the objective should be to provide the right environment for each child. Inclusion isn't meaningful if a child is physically present in a mainstream classroom but is unable to learn or becoming increasingly unwell.

And I do wonder about the economics of it all. How much are we really saving when children end up out of education, families are pushed into crisis and councils spend enormous sums fighting over provision that might have prevented those outcomes in the first place?

OP posts:
OrangeFlower14 · 17/11/2026 22:53

“Inclusion isn't meaningful if a child is physically present in a mainstream classroom but is unable to learn or becoming increasingly unwell”

exactly.

Arran2024 · 18/11/2026 09:48

MumofMaskers · 17/11/2026 19:01

Thank you, that's really interesting, and lovely to hear that your daughter is doing so well now.

We actually moved our children from a larger primary to a much smaller village school, partly because we thought the quieter, more nurturing environment would suit them better. In some respects it did- the smaller school was more willing to work with us and try different approaches, although ultimately it couldn't meet their needs either. It lacked capacity and resources and had a very high level of need in the early years/KS1 cohort they were part of. Children that mask often aren't first priority in those circumstances.

Interestingly, the first, larger school had considerably more resources, including a dedicated pastoral team and a wider range of support staff. So theoretically there was much more help available. Unfortunately, our experience was that the school took a rather adversarial approach to our concerns and didn't recognise our children as needing that support, despite what we were reporting at home. All those resources are of limited use if a school doesn't acknowledge a child's difficulties in the first place.

So I completely agree that the individual school's culture and approach matter enormously, alongside its size and resources. It's certainly something we'll consider if we revisit mainstream for our youngest. And I agree that an EHCP can secure additional provision, but it can't necessarily make an unsuitable setting suitable.

He will be on the radar at the next school, so the bigger school with better resources should help. You also get a wider range of children and possible friends.

Happyindevon · 18/11/2026 09:58

MumofMaskers · 17/11/2026 22:29

I agree. I remember children going to specialist schools when I was younger, although I suspect they were often quite different from the sort of specialist provision my children would need.

I think there was a major shift towards mainstream inclusion from the 1980s onwards, which was well intentioned in many respects. But I wonder whether we ended up pursuing inclusion without properly investing in the staffing, training, resources and range of settings needed to make it work. And successive funding pressures have compounded that.

It's like there's a false choice between mainstream and specialist education, when surely the objective should be to provide the right environment for each child. Inclusion isn't meaningful if a child is physically present in a mainstream classroom but is unable to learn or becoming increasingly unwell.

And I do wonder about the economics of it all. How much are we really saving when children end up out of education, families are pushed into crisis and councils spend enormous sums fighting over provision that might have prevented those outcomes in the first place?

How do you provide the right education for every individual child when it relies on economies of scale? Nobody wants to pay more tax towards this. They just don’t.

Arran2024 · 18/11/2026 10:13

Happyindevon · 18/11/2026 09:58

How do you provide the right education for every individual child when it relies on economies of scale? Nobody wants to pay more tax towards this. They just don’t.

My local authority has built new sen schools recently. This helps everyone. Children with sen don't need to be sent on long taxi journeys to expensive out of area private privision for one thing. Also, parents are forever complaining about disruptive children in mainstream classes on mumsnet - fact is, some children need a different environment where they can access the curriculum. If you build a sen school, you still have economies of scale, as lots of children can attend it without the 1 to 1 TA who is often needed to support them in mainstream.

MumofMaskers · 18/11/2026 10:22

Happyindevon · 18/11/2026 09:58

How do you provide the right education for every individual child when it relies on economies of scale? Nobody wants to pay more tax towards this. They just don’t.

No, not every child needs a bespoke educational setting. Of course economies of scale are important, but you can still achieve those within a much wider range of educational settings.

Also, is the money already in the system being spent effectively? Many would say no. Councils are spending considerable sums defending tribunal appeals, commissioning expensive emergency provision and responding to crises that might have been prevented through earlier intervention.

Then there are the wider costs to the NHS, social care, the economy when parents have to give up work, and potentially the longer-term costs when children reach adulthood without the education or skills they need to live independently.

I'd like to see a proper assessment of those costs against the cost of meeting children's needs earlier and more effectively.

OP posts:
Charlwood · 18/11/2026 16:42

The family suspected very early that grandson was autistic ( lining up toy cars, meltdown if one moved etc) and very anxious on leaving a
him at nursery. * At home after school having meltdowns and violent hitting Daddy etc. Now realise he was masking. School said he was an ideal pupil until Year3 when he had a teacher who themselves was autistic and recognised all the classic signs. Only then did we feel justified in getting him diagnosed which we had to pay for after waiting years ( CAHMS are useless! Anything different eg sports day at school he suffers stomach aches and won't go

  • much much more than the normal behaviour of toddlers which would be expected
New posts on this thread. Refresh page