Please or to access all these features

AMA

I have two primary-aged children who are unable to attend school due to EBSA. AMA.

64 replies

MumofMaskers · 15/11/2026 16:59

I've been reading quite a few threads recently about emotionally based school avoidance (EBSA), and I've been struck by how many misconceptions there are about children who are unable to attend school and the families supporting them.

I have two young children, both autistic, who are currently unable to attend school. Both started out in mainstream education, and both experienced progressively greater difficulties despite extensive efforts to support their attendance.

Our lives have changed beyond recognition. I've had to give up my career, we're navigating a complicated SEND system, and we're trying to secure suitable education for both children.

I thought it might be useful to offer a perspective from someone living this reality, rather than another debate about whether parents are being too soft or children simply need to be made to attend.

I'm happy to answer genuine questions, including difficult ones, about what led to this situation, what we've tried, what everyday life looks like, and how it's affected our family. I don't claim to speak for every family experiencing EBSA, but I'm happy to share our experience. I especially wanted to talk about what it's like experiencing this with children at a younger age.

OP posts:
MumofMaskers · 15/11/2026 18:38

VioletsTale · 15/11/2026 18:20

What do you think would have helped/could have helped in a mainstream setting?

I think earlier recognition and intervention would have made the biggest difference, particularly for my eldest. By the time her difficulties were fully understood, she'd already experienced significant distress and autistic burnout, and I think we'd missed an opportunity to make mainstream education work for her.

Both children have significant sensory processing differences, difficulties with transitions and emotional regulation, and motor coordination difficulties. I think a much more individualised approach would have helped us understand what they were finding difficult and why. But of course I understand why this is so difficult in mainstream schools before an EHCP is in place.

In practical terms, things like a genuinely low-arousal environment, reduced sensory demands, predictable routines, flexibility around transitions, access to quiet spaces and trusted adults, and adjustments to the curriculum and expectations. Also, recognising that academic ability doesn't necessarily translate into an ability to cope with the school environment. My eldest is very academically capable, but that was sometimes part of the reason her difficulties were overlooked. Even for us at home, she told us for a long time she hated school and we were quite dismissive - don't be silly darling, you were made for school!

I also think there needed to be much greater recognition of masking. Both children could appear happy and engaged at school while experiencing enormous distress at home. I wish we'd spent less time focusing on whether they were managing to attend and more time asking whether attendance was sustainable and what it was costing them. Also, the support offered to children like this eventually is often described as 'if needed', eg access to a quiet space, which overlooks the fact that they will rarely speak up and ask for support. Again, I understand why this is so hard to implement in a busy classroom.

OP posts:
MumofMaskers · 15/11/2026 18:46

hibernatinghedgehog · 15/11/2026 18:27

If DS likes practical learning best, there are loads of subscription boxes you could look at as well as or instead of Spectrum Space boxes. For example, you could look at LCB Education boxes, SPIN Learning boxes, KiwiCo crates, Mel Science boxes, Little crafters boxes, mysteries in time, HelloMaker…

If you go to any home ed clubs with DD, have you come across any home ed groups that aren’t welcoming because you are still in the system and are pursuing EOTAS?

Fab - will definitely look into these, they both love science kits!

We only go to a few clubs now as honestly I tended to find we didn't really fit in - no one was unwelcoming as such and we were fully home ed for a few months, but maybe my heart wasn't in it. My daughter mainly goes to the clubs that focus on an activity so we haven't really met or spoken to too many other people, and if I do I don't go into too much detail. But most people are friendly.

OP posts:
MumofMaskers · 15/11/2026 18:53

KyleStar · 15/11/2026 18:33

Thanks for doing this, it's really helpful to read. We're still at the nursery stage with our three-year-old so we're a few years behind you, but the masking bit really struck a chord — we've started to notice how much harder evenings can be after a day of holding it together, and I hadn't really put a name to it until now.

Can I ask, with your eldest, what did the masking actually look like at home once the school day was over? And did the tummy aches ease off much once you took the pressure of mainstream away, or did that take a while? Really hope the EHCP fight gets you somewhere soon, it sounds exhausting on top of everything else.

Thank you, and I'm glad it's helpful! I think masking is one of the most important things for parents and professionals to understand, particularly with children who appear to be coping well in nursery or school.

With my eldest, it wasn't always the stereotypical picture of a child coming home and having huge meltdowns. A lot of her distress was internalised. She became increasingly anxious, exhausted and emotionally fragile. She'd hold everything together at school, where she was well behaved, academically successful and apparently happy, but at home we'd see the toll it was taking on her.

The tummy aches were one of the earliest signs, starting back in reception. We didn't initially appreciate how significant they were. Over time, the anxiety became more pervasive, affecting things like bedtime, sleep and her ability to cope with everyday demands. Eventually she reached a point of quite severe autistic burnout, with shutdowns, withdrawal and periods where she struggled to communicate at all.

The tummy aches did improve once the pressure of attending school was removed, but it wasn't overnight. And although she's much happier and more settled at home now, the effects of what she's been through haven't simply disappeared. Her anxiety around school and anything that reminds her of those experiences is still significant.

One thing I wish I'd understood earlier is that masking isn't necessarily a conscious decision to hide difficulties. For some children, it's an almost automatic response to the demands and expectations of an environment, and they may not even recognise how overwhelmed they are until they're somewhere they feel safe.

I wouldn't assume that difficult evenings after nursery necessarily mean your child is heading towards EBSA, but I would absolutely pay attention to the pattern you're noticing. I think the most important lesson from our experience is not to wait until a child stops attending before taking seriously what their behaviour at home might be telling you.

And thank you for your kind words, I really hope we get somewhere soon too!

OP posts:
GeorgeandTimmy21 · 15/11/2026 21:31

Why don't you physically force them to go to school? I'm not saying you should, far from it, I'm just wondering if you are protecting their mental health, because the school recommended you keep them at home or other reasons?

I have a 12 year old who repeatedly says he hates school but appears to enjoy it while there. When I ask why, he gives a list of subjects he says he finds boring and that he misses me which has been an issue with him since he was in the nicu. We both struggled enormously with home learning during covid so I don't think that's going to be a solution. Do you have any advice?

Peclet · 15/11/2026 21:43

so many children now EBSA with Asperger type high functioning Austism?

adhd- often same presentation as trauma

very young babies in full time children care and fully institutionalised.

What’s at the root of this?

did you work full time and have babies in full time nursery? Both parents racking in 40/50 hour weeks? Parents who fail to meet basic needs at the very earliest years and their children have insecure/anxiety based attachments.

our childcare systems are wrong and the pressures on parents are out of control.

What’s your take?

MumofMaskers · 15/11/2026 21:52

GeorgeandTimmy21 · 15/11/2026 21:31

Why don't you physically force them to go to school? I'm not saying you should, far from it, I'm just wondering if you are protecting their mental health, because the school recommended you keep them at home or other reasons?

I have a 12 year old who repeatedly says he hates school but appears to enjoy it while there. When I ask why, he gives a list of subjects he says he finds boring and that he misses me which has been an issue with him since he was in the nicu. We both struggled enormously with home learning during covid so I don't think that's going to be a solution. Do you have any advice?

It's primarily about protecting their mental health, but neither child is at home just because we've decided school is too stressful. Both reached a point where they genuinely couldn't attend, despite extensive efforts and adjustments. My eldest experienced severe autistic burnout, and her EP has advised that returning to school isn't appropriate at present. Having professional input and evidence has helped with out decision making.

I wouldn't necessarily assume your son is heading towards EBSA, but I wouldn't dismiss his feelings just because he seems happy at school either. Are you seeing any other signs of distress at home? For us, it went well beyond not wanting to go - anxiety, physical symptoms, exhaustion and eventually difficulties coping with everyday life.

I'd try to explore what he finds difficult and what he means when he says he misses you, and work with school on any adjustments that might help.
The biggest thing I've learned is that* *being able to attend school isn't necessarily the same as coping with it. But equally, not every child who dislikes school is experiencing EBSA. It's about understanding what's going on for that individual child. Do you have any ideas what might be underlying, is there any SEN etc?

OP posts:
MumofMaskers · 15/11/2026 21:57

Peclet · 15/11/2026 21:43

so many children now EBSA with Asperger type high functioning Austism?

adhd- often same presentation as trauma

very young babies in full time children care and fully institutionalised.

What’s at the root of this?

did you work full time and have babies in full time nursery? Both parents racking in 40/50 hour weeks? Parents who fail to meet basic needs at the very earliest years and their children have insecure/anxiety based attachments.

our childcare systems are wrong and the pressures on parents are out of control.

What’s your take?

I do think about this a lot and what has changed, so find the many threads on here debating it interesting, although don't think the parent blaming is helpful. So no, that wasn't our experience. Both children had and have very hands on parents (my husband works full time and pretty long hours though), I worked part time around 3 days per week for almost all their early years, and they were cared for by me or family rather than attending nursery.

I do sometimes wonder what impact Covid and lockdowns had during their formative years, although it's difficult to disentangle that from everything else. I'm sure this is the case for many children who were at different ages and stages when the lockdowns happened, as the impacts would have been so varied.

For us, genetics clearly plays a significant role. There's a strong family history of neurodivergence and school anxiety although I won't go into the details here.

I agree that the pressures on working parents and our childcare system deserve scrutiny, but I don't think it's helpful to conflate autism, ADHD, trauma and insecure attachment. They can share some characteristics, but they're not interchangeable, and autism isn't caused by parents failing to meet their children's emotional needs.

OP posts:
ChapmanFarm · 15/11/2026 22:23

Do you think the school anxiety experienced by other family members affects the wider perception of school?

They seem so young in Y1 for burnout etc descriptions. We're you aware of this at the time or are you applying what you know now to those situations?

Do you think you'll try school again at another point?

MumofMaskers · 15/11/2026 22:35

ChapmanFarm · 15/11/2026 22:23

Do you think the school anxiety experienced by other family members affects the wider perception of school?

They seem so young in Y1 for burnout etc descriptions. We're you aware of this at the time or are you applying what you know now to those situations?

Do you think you'll try school again at another point?

The family experience I mentioned isn't something the children would be aware of. Both my husband and I had a very good education, we have family members who work in schools, and it has always been something we've spoken about positively and valued highly. So I don't think negative family perceptions of school have played a role here.

I agree they're incredibly young to have experienced burnout, it has taken us by surprise. We didn't initially have the language to describe what was happening, but we absolutely recognised that something was seriously wrong. My eldest experienced profound changes in her behaviour and functioning, including shutdowns, withdrawal and difficulties communicating, and we sought medical help at the time. Our understanding of autistic burnout came later, as we learned more about her needs. I have learnt a lot more about it since.

And yes, we very much hope they'll both return to some form of school education that better suits their needs. My eldest's EP has recommended EOTAS for now, with the aim of a small specialist setting. For my youngest it's still early days, and we're keeping an open mind about whether mainstream might become possible with the right support. We've never wanted them to be out of school indefinitely. We want them to be able to access education in an environment where they're happy, safe and able to thrive.

OP posts:
Bananacrepewithnuts · 15/11/2026 22:43

Looking back do you wish you'd done anything differently?
X

MumofMaskers · 15/11/2026 22:53

Bananacrepewithnuts · 15/11/2026 22:43

Looking back do you wish you'd done anything differently?
X

This is a really difficult one, and something I've spent a lot of time thinking about.
I think the biggest thing is that I wish I'd trusted my instincts more, particularly when what we were seeing at home was so different from what school was reporting. I wish we'd pushed for specialist support earlier and been more confident in challenging professionals when things didn't feel right. But it's so hard to do that when you're constantly being told what you're seeing isn't true - you just end up doubting yourself all the time.

But I also try not to be too hard on myself. We were making decisions with the information and understanding we had at the time, often relying on reassurance from people we trusted to know more than we did.

Hindsight is a wonderful thing, but I couldn't have known then everything I know now. And I don't think it's fair to place all the responsibility on parents when there are professionals and systems that should be recognising these difficulties and helping families navigate them.

OP posts:
Cornishclio · 16/11/2026 00:14

Your experience mirrors my daughters with my two granddaughters. Both ASD and one is PDA. They have been out of school for 18 months for the youngest, 6 months the oldest. Both masked in school until they couldn’t any more. The youngest with PDA suffered a bad autistic burnout, severe withdrawal and emotional shutdown, not eating almost to the point of being hospitalised. She has an EHCP and is now thriving under EOTAS after a battle with the LA. My daughter had to give up her career too and is now going through the same struggles with her eldest to get an EHCP. It is tough.

Newsenmum · 16/11/2026 17:22

Hohofortherobbers · 15/11/2026 17:11

In the short film the teachers said the child was happy once at school and well liked, it seemed to be the getting her in that was the issue. What did your dc's teachers say they were like when in school.

Edited

It’s called masking

MumofMaskers · 16/11/2026 17:32

Cornishclio · 16/11/2026 00:14

Your experience mirrors my daughters with my two granddaughters. Both ASD and one is PDA. They have been out of school for 18 months for the youngest, 6 months the oldest. Both masked in school until they couldn’t any more. The youngest with PDA suffered a bad autistic burnout, severe withdrawal and emotional shutdown, not eating almost to the point of being hospitalised. She has an EHCP and is now thriving under EOTAS after a battle with the LA. My daughter had to give up her career too and is now going through the same struggles with her eldest to get an EHCP. It is tough.

I'm so sorry your daughter and granddaughters have been through this. It's heartbreaking how familiar these stories are, particularly the burnout and the enormous impact on the whole family. I'm really pleased to hear your youngest is thriving with EOTAS though, that gives me a lot of hope for my own daughter.

It's also so frustrating that your daughter is having to go through another battle for her eldest, having already fought so hard for her youngest. It shouldn't be this difficult to get children the support they need. I really hope things work out for them.

OP posts:
Barbie222 · 16/11/2026 17:54

Do you think your children will have the skills / resilience to work and live independently as adults? If so, what strategies will get them there? I don’t have neurodivergent children myself, but know many, and it’s something that I know many parents really worry about.

Happyindevon · 16/11/2026 17:58

To give the second school credit, they did try many adjustments, including soft starts, alternative entrances, trusted adults, quiet spaces, reduced timetables, movement breaks, changes to lunchtimes and playground arrangements, and very gradual attempts to increase attendance

We’re often told it’s the punitive education system that causes EBSA. So given the significant adjustments school made for them, can this actually be the case? Everyone I know with an EBSA child is offered similar support, yet we constantly hear about how punitive the school is and how that’s causing the avoidance.

Put simply.. can your kids just not cope with any kind of structured environment?

I think ‘emotional based work avoidance’ will be a diagnosis in 10 years because it does seem they’ll have the same problems there.

MumofMaskers · 16/11/2026 18:40

Barbie222 · 16/11/2026 17:54

Do you think your children will have the skills / resilience to work and live independently as adults? If so, what strategies will get them there? I don’t have neurodivergent children myself, but know many, and it’s something that I know many parents really worry about.

Yes, absolutely, it's something I worry about, although they're still so young that it's very difficult to predict what adulthood might look like for either of them.

I think what people sometimes don't appreciate is the very careful balance we're trying to strike as parents. We want to protect their mental health and avoid pushing them beyond what they can cope with (having seen what happens if a child is pushed too far) but equally we want them to develop resilience, confidence, life skills and receive an education that will enable them to work and live as independently as possible.

I don't believe resilience comes from repeatedly forcing children through experiences that overwhelm them. I think it comes from helping them feel safe, building their confidence and gradually extending what they're capable of, with the right support.

Both my children have strengths and abilities that I hope will serve them well in adulthood. I suspect they'll need some support with aspects of independent living, but what that looks like remains to be seen.

Ultimately, my aim isn't to protect them from every difficulty. It's to equip them to navigate difficulties successfully, without sacrificing their mental health in the process.

The whole word resilience feels loaded when talking about EBSA and neurodivergent children. It doesn't mean what a lot of people think it does.

OP posts:
MumofMaskers · 16/11/2026 18:49

Happyindevon · 16/11/2026 17:58

To give the second school credit, they did try many adjustments, including soft starts, alternative entrances, trusted adults, quiet spaces, reduced timetables, movement breaks, changes to lunchtimes and playground arrangements, and very gradual attempts to increase attendance

We’re often told it’s the punitive education system that causes EBSA. So given the significant adjustments school made for them, can this actually be the case? Everyone I know with an EBSA child is offered similar support, yet we constantly hear about how punitive the school is and how that’s causing the avoidance.

Put simply.. can your kids just not cope with any kind of structured environment?

I think ‘emotional based work avoidance’ will be a diagnosis in 10 years because it does seem they’ll have the same problems there.

I don't particularly subscribe to the narrative that EBSA is caused by punitive schools. That hasn't been our experience. Both my children were generally well behaved at school and weren't personally subjected to punitive disciplinary approaches.

I think the bigger issue is rigidity. Schools have to deliver a prescribed curriculum, manage large classes and meet numerous expectations and targets. Even with the best intentions, there's only so much flexibility they can offer to children with very different needs. It seems that this has increased in recent years (I am not an expert and haven't worked in the education system, but did work in education policy for a time).

And while our second school made adjustments, those didn't fundamentally change the sensory, social and emotional demands of being in a mainstream classroom - ultimately the environment still wasn't working for them.

As for structure, they can engage with structured activities and learning when the approach and environment are right. But many children with this profile do struggle with imposed structure, and sometimes this can ease as they move to adulthood and they have more autonomy and choice about how they live life, choose the kind of work they want to pursue etc. It's not easy though, especially of course if they've missed education.

On your point about employment, plenty of adults struggle with workplace environments too, including neurotypical adults. We recognise stress related illness and burnout in the workplace, and people can take sick leave or seek reasonable adjustments. I don't see why we should regard children struggling with an unsuitable environment as fundamentally different. Again, it comes back to the constraints of the education system.

Of course I want my children to develop the skills and resilience to work as adults. But I don't think repeatedly exposing them to environments they currently cannot cope with is necessarily the way to achieve that. It worries me all the time, but I can only take it day by day and meet them where they are now, and remind myself they are still young.

OP posts:
himapiyali · 17/11/2026 00:38

Bananacrepewithnuts · 15/11/2026 17:29

Do your children socialise with other children their own age? I think this is my worry for home ed children the isolation.
X

Part of this likely depends on the child’s needs/how much and what type of socialising they want and the opportunities you can give them. We’ve just started to home educate our highly social little girl. She spends many hours a day 5-6 days a week playing m/ doing activities with other children her age. I go to home Ed meet ups / activities (there are tons where we live) and I also arrange play dates with other home Ed children. She spends so much more time playing and socialising freely than she used to. Thankfully, I quite enjoy the social aspect too! But it takes a bit of effort and time to find what’s on offer

Apoplepsy · 17/11/2026 17:26

How do you see their post-school future? My DSs struggled through school and college but at 19 and 24 they have been NEETs for a long time now. (They don't claim benefits due to a smallish inheritance)

Arran2024 · 17/11/2026 17:43

My daughter is 27 now - has a job, lives with her boyfriend. She masked like mad at primary school. I moved her at the start of year 3 to an enormous, profressive junior school - she should have gone to a tiny old-fashioned CoE junior. Imo bigger schools are better able to support a wider range of pupils and there is less pressure on individual pupils to conform. They have more funding so can pay for things like emotional support workers and play time youth workers. And they have more staff turnover, so newer staff with less entrenched ideas

Just mentioning this as you may revisit mainstream for your son.

Btw I got her a then Statement for going to secondary school (she went to an independentspeech and language school). Junior school was able to meet her needs without one. She would have needed one if she had gone to the CoE school, as they wouldn't have had a clue how to handle her needs.

So much depends on the resources in the school to begin with imo. The additional support through an EHC cannot overcome an inappropriate setting.

MumofMaskers · 17/11/2026 18:57

Apoplepsy · 17/11/2026 17:26

How do you see their post-school future? My DSs struggled through school and college but at 19 and 24 they have been NEETs for a long time now. (They don't claim benefits due to a smallish inheritance)

It does worry me, yes, although I think most parents worry to some extent about what the future holds for their children. I'm sorry to hear your sons have had such a difficult time finding their way after education.

I think the world of work is going to look very different by the time mine reach adulthood, particularly with AI and the pace of technological change. It'll be interesting to see what comes out of the Milburn review published today.

They're still very young, and I can already see that they both have considerable strengths and abilities. My daughter could do amazing things, with the right support. My hope is that we have time to nurture those, help them develop confidence, practical life skills and independence, and find educational pathways that work for them.

I don't know yet whether they'll be able to work and live entirely independently, or what support they might need as adults. But I really hope their difficulties accessing school now will define what they're capable of in 10 or 15 years.

OP posts:
MumofMaskers · 17/11/2026 19:01

Arran2024 · 17/11/2026 17:43

My daughter is 27 now - has a job, lives with her boyfriend. She masked like mad at primary school. I moved her at the start of year 3 to an enormous, profressive junior school - she should have gone to a tiny old-fashioned CoE junior. Imo bigger schools are better able to support a wider range of pupils and there is less pressure on individual pupils to conform. They have more funding so can pay for things like emotional support workers and play time youth workers. And they have more staff turnover, so newer staff with less entrenched ideas

Just mentioning this as you may revisit mainstream for your son.

Btw I got her a then Statement for going to secondary school (she went to an independentspeech and language school). Junior school was able to meet her needs without one. She would have needed one if she had gone to the CoE school, as they wouldn't have had a clue how to handle her needs.

So much depends on the resources in the school to begin with imo. The additional support through an EHC cannot overcome an inappropriate setting.

Thank you, that's really interesting, and lovely to hear that your daughter is doing so well now.

We actually moved our children from a larger primary to a much smaller village school, partly because we thought the quieter, more nurturing environment would suit them better. In some respects it did- the smaller school was more willing to work with us and try different approaches, although ultimately it couldn't meet their needs either. It lacked capacity and resources and had a very high level of need in the early years/KS1 cohort they were part of. Children that mask often aren't first priority in those circumstances.

Interestingly, the first, larger school had considerably more resources, including a dedicated pastoral team and a wider range of support staff. So theoretically there was much more help available. Unfortunately, our experience was that the school took a rather adversarial approach to our concerns and didn't recognise our children as needing that support, despite what we were reporting at home. All those resources are of limited use if a school doesn't acknowledge a child's difficulties in the first place.

So I completely agree that the individual school's culture and approach matter enormously, alongside its size and resources. It's certainly something we'll consider if we revisit mainstream for our youngest. And I agree that an EHCP can secure additional provision, but it can't necessarily make an unsuitable setting suitable.

OP posts:
OrangeFlower14 · 17/11/2026 19:24

Do you feel like councils waste money and then that money could have gone back into designated schools, we only know one couple in a similar situation but it feels like the previous system, a long time ago, I know, would have been better for so many kids

I don’t feel like the push to mainstream has helped

MumofMaskers · 17/11/2026 19:41

OrangeFlower14 · 17/11/2026 19:24

Do you feel like councils waste money and then that money could have gone back into designated schools, we only know one couple in a similar situation but it feels like the previous system, a long time ago, I know, would have been better for so many kids

I don’t feel like the push to mainstream has helped

Yes, definitely. One of the most frustrating aspects of our experience has been seeing how much money and resource goes into resisting support. We've had to commission independent assessments and pursue appeals to secure provision that should have been considered much earlier. The LA has also had to devote resources to defending those decisions.

There's also an enormous amount of money wasted on providing the wrong support. We've experienced this with alternative provision, where time and money have been spent arranging education that isn't appropriate for our children's needs and that they simply cannot access. Had the right provision been identified and commissioned in the first place, I suspect it would have been considerably more cost effective, as well as better for the children.

I think there's a strong argument that earlier intervention and investment in appropriate specialist provision would save money in the long run. Instead, children can deteriorate to the point where they need much more intensive and expensive support.

I do think we need a much wider range of properly resourced educational settings, rather than expecting mainstream to accommodate everyone regardless of their needs. What frustrates me most is that so much of this feels avoidable. We're spending enormous amounts of money managing the consequences of failing to meet children's needs early enough.

OP posts: