Please or to access all these features

AMA

I'm Jewish & went to the West Bank to help the olive harvest AMA

101 replies

Echobelly · 28/10/2026 11:35

I got back at the weekend from a week-long trip organised by a consortium of Jewish and Israeli charities and voluntary organisations. We spent 5 days in the West Bank assisting Palestinian farmers with their olive harvest, so AMA, I guess!

OP posts:
Echobelly · 30/10/2026 18:53

herecomestheairfryer · 30/10/2026 18:19

I don't think it can be right to punish all of them

Why would they need to be punished in the first place? It's crazy that a people who have been displaced, murdered, maimed for life, had land/livelihoods confiscated, been geographically imprisoned, denied medical treatment and many more, to be seen as the perpetrators? How come Israel are seen as the victims? I know you've said this, but I'm asking more generally. It's like people saying Israel had the right to fight back after October 7th, but Israel have been the terrorists since the country was formed. Israel have killed more children in Gaza in the last several years than any other world conflict combined.

Edit I've reread your post and I'm not sure if you are saying the above quote with regards to Palestinians or the Jews in Israel, but my point still stands in general as I've heard this many times

Edited

I'm saying it can't be right to collectively punish the Palestinians. I agree they are absolutely the victims in this, not the Israelis as a whole aside from the victims and hostages of October 7th. The families of several of whom begged the Israeli government to stop the indiscriminate killing.

OP posts:
bellinisurge · 31/10/2026 22:39

It is simply a matter of fact that not one hostage has mentioned an act of kindness or compassion. Happy to be corrected.
An obvious comparison is Nazi Germany - or Soviet Russia/Maoist China during the worst repression if you don’t want to mention Nazi Germany - and I’m pretty confident there were acts of kindness in those times.
The best thing that means is that Hamas has a complete stranglehold on every aspect of life in Gaza. The worst that it means is that no one would show kindness or compassion towards anyone- including the non-Jews they kidnapped.
It is a point worth making.

Isitmyluckyday · 31/10/2026 22:45

Do you mind me asking whereabouts you live and whether any Jewish friends objected to you joining this excellent project? Thanks.

CuteHANDBAG · 31/10/2026 23:29

Who paid for the flights. Did most people only go for one week? Wouldn’t it be more economical to go for longer? How many days did you actually manage to harvest the olives? I can see the reasoning about having extra people and it being safer but it seems an expensive way to help. I had no idea that people did this! It’s an interesting AMA

Friendlygingercat · 01/11/2026 01:01

Why dignify these people by calling them settlers when in fact they are squatters?

PrincessFiorimonde · 01/11/2026 01:25

Very interesting thread, OP. Thank you.

Pansykavalier · 01/11/2026 07:10

Friendlygingercat · 01/11/2026 01:01

Why dignify these people by calling them settlers when in fact they are squatters?

I think ‘terrorists’ seems most appropriate, given that they terrorise the indigenous population…

Lench · 01/11/2026 08:28

Very interesting thread, OP. Thank you for starting it.

Thank you to the poster who mentioned Zaytoun. I’ve ordered Olive oil, soap and some almonds (I didn’t see candied but there were caramelised and smoked).

Echobelly · 01/11/2026 08:40

Isitmyluckyday · 31/10/2026 22:45

Do you mind me asking whereabouts you live and whether any Jewish friends objected to you joining this excellent project? Thanks.

I'm in North London. Most of my friends aren't Jewish and most that are are sympathetic to solidarity with Palestinians, so no one has expressed disapproval.

@CuteHANDBAG - costs to join and flights were paid by participants. The group have advice on fundraising for anyone who couldn't afford it but I could so I paid myself. It cost about £2000 altogether with flights. But it did cover meals etc so we didn't have to spend much at all while there.

I think one week at a time is for a few reasons - makes it easier for people to do it, increases the chance of having more people as any intake might experience deportations (as we very nearly did) or banning from areas of the West Bank (as happened to some of the organisers), so if that happens you have fresh people who can do it next week.

We managed 5 days of harvesting as planned - basically in the morning each day with talks or activities in the afternoon.

OP posts:
Isitmyluckyday · 01/11/2026 08:46

CuteHANDBAG · 31/10/2026 23:29

Who paid for the flights. Did most people only go for one week? Wouldn’t it be more economical to go for longer? How many days did you actually manage to harvest the olives? I can see the reasoning about having extra people and it being safer but it seems an expensive way to help. I had no idea that people did this! It’s an interesting AMA

It is an expensive way to help and donating all the money involved instead of going, might have been hugely beneficial . But I guess the point was for Jewish people in other communities to show their solidarity with Palestinians and briefly to share a little of the danger they live in, which is beyond price.
OP will correct me if I have misunderstood this.

Pansykavalier · 01/11/2026 08:47

Isitmyluckyday · 01/11/2026 08:46

It is an expensive way to help and donating all the money involved instead of going, might have been hugely beneficial . But I guess the point was for Jewish people in other communities to show their solidarity with Palestinians and briefly to share a little of the danger they live in, which is beyond price.
OP will correct me if I have misunderstood this.

This is how I see it.

Solidarity is priceless.

JohnofWessex · 01/11/2026 09:11

Isitmyluckyday · 01/11/2026 08:46

It is an expensive way to help and donating all the money involved instead of going, might have been hugely beneficial . But I guess the point was for Jewish people in other communities to show their solidarity with Palestinians and briefly to share a little of the danger they live in, which is beyond price.
OP will correct me if I have misunderstood this.

I think also that it gives a message to the Settlers, the IDF & the wider Israeli population that there are Jews who are opposed to what they are doing.

Isitmyluckyday · 01/11/2026 09:13

JohnofWessex · 01/11/2026 09:11

I think also that it gives a message to the Settlers, the IDF & the wider Israeli population that there are Jews who are opposed to what they are doing.

Absolutely, so important.

Cricketduckout · 01/11/2026 09:21

I really admire you for putting yourself in harm’s way to help families in such a deeply impactful way.
Can I ask:
Are you a parent? If so, what did you tell your children?
What specifically turned your mind to do this? Had you been thinking about it for awhile or did it all happen to fall into place?

RainyDayCoffee · 01/11/2026 09:47

Bravo OP! Am really inspired.

Echobelly · 01/11/2026 10:09

@Isitmyluckyday - the point is the money for the trip (other than flights) did go into the local communities of the West Bank; to the hotels, restaurants and home stay hosts, which was another thing I liked about it. I think the organising people did it on a voluntary basis, with some funding from progressive charities like the New Israel Fund to help it happen.

@Cricketduckout - yes, I have a 15 year old and an 18 year old, they both supported it. In fact part of the reason I am going is that 18yo is applying to do a 4-week protective presence stretch next summer and I wanted to kind of test the water myself. Still blimmin' terrified for them, but I can't stop them! It's a much more dangerous task than ours given the longer stretch and it involves being in small groups with families in danger of being harassed out of their homes in more isolated areas.

I've been on some of the Palestine solidarity marches and other related events within the Jewish community in the last few years. I chose to do this because I have talked the talk about Palestine, and I wanted to walk to the walk, so when someone on our synagogue 'peacenik' whatsapp shared the link, I applied and paid the deposit before I could change my mind.

OP posts:
Isitmyluckyday · 01/11/2026 13:37

Echobelly · 01/11/2026 10:09

@Isitmyluckyday - the point is the money for the trip (other than flights) did go into the local communities of the West Bank; to the hotels, restaurants and home stay hosts, which was another thing I liked about it. I think the organising people did it on a voluntary basis, with some funding from progressive charities like the New Israel Fund to help it happen.

@Cricketduckout - yes, I have a 15 year old and an 18 year old, they both supported it. In fact part of the reason I am going is that 18yo is applying to do a 4-week protective presence stretch next summer and I wanted to kind of test the water myself. Still blimmin' terrified for them, but I can't stop them! It's a much more dangerous task than ours given the longer stretch and it involves being in small groups with families in danger of being harassed out of their homes in more isolated areas.

I've been on some of the Palestine solidarity marches and other related events within the Jewish community in the last few years. I chose to do this because I have talked the talk about Palestine, and I wanted to walk to the walk, so when someone on our synagogue 'peacenik' whatsapp shared the link, I applied and paid the deposit before I could change my mind.

Good point. You must have boosted the local economy a lot.

Echobelly · 01/11/2026 14:25

I asked what was good to buy to support the community - I was told local embroidery was good as it's a typical Palestinian craft. One of the party took us to the house of a lovely lady who basically had a shop in her front room of items made by local women - people bought bags, scarves, cushion covers etc. I bought a Palestinian flag make-up bag for my oldest as I knew they'd love that.

The economy is in a dire state as Israel revoked the work visa of up to 150,000 Palestinians who worked in Israel after October 7th, and this included our amazing host, he hasn't been able to find work since.

By the way, if anyone is wanting to follow social media accounts of Jewish and Israeli organisations supporting Palestinians, look for Protect the Harvest, Standing Together, Truah, Rabbis for Ceasefire, Yesh Din and Rabbis for Human Rights. They're mostly on FB, Instagram or X I think.

OP posts:
JacknDiane · 01/11/2026 22:18

bellinisurge · 31/10/2026 22:39

It is simply a matter of fact that not one hostage has mentioned an act of kindness or compassion. Happy to be corrected.
An obvious comparison is Nazi Germany - or Soviet Russia/Maoist China during the worst repression if you don’t want to mention Nazi Germany - and I’m pretty confident there were acts of kindness in those times.
The best thing that means is that Hamas has a complete stranglehold on every aspect of life in Gaza. The worst that it means is that no one would show kindness or compassion towards anyone- including the non-Jews they kidnapped.
It is a point worth making.

Wasn't there an elderly lady taken hostage who shook the kidnappers hands when she was realised? She was very brave.

MissyB1 · 02/11/2026 07:12

JacknDiane · 01/11/2026 22:18

Wasn't there an elderly lady taken hostage who shook the kidnappers hands when she was realised? She was very brave.

Yes I remember her, it was on the news. There were a couple of hostages who said they were treated with dignity and respect.

Noluthando · 02/11/2026 07:13

I don't have a question but this gives me hope for humanity.

MissyB1 · 02/11/2026 07:26

Noluthando · 02/11/2026 07:13

I don't have a question but this gives me hope for humanity.

Yes amongst all the horrific treatment we see dished out to Palestinian people, it’s good to remember there are many many people trying to help and support them. And in particular it’s important to remember the Jewish organisations providing support and help, even when they risk negativity or even being shunned by others in their communities. It should give us hope.

Echobelly · 02/11/2026 08:33

It frustrates me that the British media only tends to give voice to Jews expressing disapproval or fear of support for Palestine. It definitely can and does take the form of antisemitism sometimes, but for the most part this isn't the case. But the media framing tends to make it look like Jews in general don't tolerate sympathy for Palestinians, which isn't true, even for most Jews who are supportive of Israel on a number of levels.

OP posts:
gullgal · 02/11/2026 09:00

There are so many horrible threads on here it's nice to read a positive one

dairydebris · 02/11/2026 10:46

MissyB1 · 02/11/2026 07:12

Yes I remember her, it was on the news. There were a couple of hostages who said they were treated with dignity and respect.

This was Yocheved Lifschitz. She shook a Hamas soldier's hand. This is testament to the woman's grace and strength rather than the fact that she was treated with dignity and respect. In fact she was beaten with sticks and said she went through hell.

The 'treated with dignity and respect' bs comes from a random X account and has been debunked by factcheck.org. link below.

Please don't spread misinformation.

https://www.factcheck.org/2023/12/post-misrepresents-condition-of-israeli-hostages-released-by-hamas/

Post Misrepresents Condition of Israeli Hostages Released by Hamas - FactCheck.org

More than 100 hostages taken by Hamas during its Oct. 7 attack on Israel have been released through a negotiated swap for 240 Palestinians held in Israeli prisons. A post on social media misleadingly claims the freed Israelis "look like people finishin...

https://www.factcheck.org/2023/12/post-misrepresents-condition-of-israeli-hostages-released-by-hamas/

Swipe left for the next trending thread