Please or to access all these features

AMA

I'm Jewish & went to the West Bank to help the olive harvest AMA

101 replies

Echobelly · 28/10/2026 11:35

I got back at the weekend from a week-long trip organised by a consortium of Jewish and Israeli charities and voluntary organisations. We spent 5 days in the West Bank assisting Palestinian farmers with their olive harvest, so AMA, I guess!

OP posts:
Pansykavalier · 29/10/2026 18:17

AshtonGardens · 29/10/2026 08:34

Thank you for posting this. I remember the Louis Theroux documentary about illegal settlers touched on the olive harvest, so it is encouraging to hear of these initiatives making a real difference at ground level, as clearly no change is coming from the top any time soon.

It would be great if Louis Theroux could do a follow-up to his documentary about the illegal settlers - similar to the one he did about that horrible anti-gay Baptist church in the US.

bellinisurge · 30/10/2026 08:00

How do you think Israel should have responded to Oct 7 2023

JohnofWessex · 30/10/2026 08:09

bellinisurge · 30/10/2026 08:00

How do you think Israel should have responded to Oct 7 2023

I understand that a lot of the women who were killed were raped first however no attempt was made to gather evidence (why?)

Had this been done and them made public it would have made things very difficult for Hamas as the Muslim world would have been very unhappy with this.

In the same way the Muslim world was horrified by 9/11 but the Americans then wrecked any support they might get by their behaviour.

Fixesplease · 30/10/2026 08:13

I felt the need to reply to this.

There are many innocent people on BOTH sides of the conflict, many, people who just want to live their lives in peace and certainly do not support terrorist attacks nor illegal settlements.

People like yourself serve as a healthy reminder of that fact.
I applaud you.

Echobelly · 30/10/2026 08:39

bellinisurge · 30/10/2026 08:00

How do you think Israel should have responded to Oct 7 2023

Well someone was sure to ask this

Im no military strategist, so I can't really say. But if they wanted revenge a month of that kind of bombardment would have been enough, hell, a week, and maybe they could maybe have gone in with a ground attack to retrieve the hostages? More costly in military lives but might have retained some moral upper hand and global support. I don't expect them to have politely have gone into negotiations, but there was no 'need' to bomb Gaza into ruins and severely curtail food and supply. That is collective punishment against people who aren't even allowed an army.

OP posts:
Matzochist · 30/10/2026 08:41

Echobelly · 29/10/2026 13:41

As Jews we shouldn't be seen as responsible for Israel's actions but I still feel this stuff is important, especially as the media only seems to foreground Jewish voices that excites express fear of Palestinians and even sometimes of solidarity with them. I find that incredibly frustrating!

But the only way forward is to know one another as human beings. Israel does everything it can, as do some forces in Palestine, to prevent that happening unfortunately.

But the only way forward is to know one another as human beings. I completely agree with this. There are many grassroots initiatives within Israel and the West Bank set up to do just this.

I do think we need to be careful about the language we use. I would instead say 'some forces in Israel and some forces in Palestine do everything they can to prevent that happening'.

Echobelly · 30/10/2026 09:03

Matzochist · 30/10/2026 08:41

But the only way forward is to know one another as human beings. I completely agree with this. There are many grassroots initiatives within Israel and the West Bank set up to do just this.

I do think we need to be careful about the language we use. I would instead say 'some forces in Israel and some forces in Palestine do everything they can to prevent that happening'.

Yes, totally fair point!

OP posts:
bellinisurge · 30/10/2026 12:01

Echobelly · 30/10/2026 08:39

Well someone was sure to ask this

Im no military strategist, so I can't really say. But if they wanted revenge a month of that kind of bombardment would have been enough, hell, a week, and maybe they could maybe have gone in with a ground attack to retrieve the hostages? More costly in military lives but might have retained some moral upper hand and global support. I don't expect them to have politely have gone into negotiations, but there was no 'need' to bomb Gaza into ruins and severely curtail food and supply. That is collective punishment against people who aren't even allowed an army.

The problem with a quick ground attack to retrieve the hostages was that the hostages weren’t all in one place. And most were hidden among the civilian population. There is no report of any civilians giving comfort or support to the hostages.
While it is true that there is no Palestinian Authority army, there seems to be an endless supply of combatants under an Islamofascist regime.
Any dissent is brutally crushed by Hamas so it is unsurprising that there is so little now and was zero civilian assistance to hostages. But even under the Nazis in Germany there was some.
Surely the international goal should be Free Palestine from Hamas not “be a bit nicer, Israel”

Echobelly · 30/10/2026 12:17

Well exactly, but they haven't done that. They have collectively punished every man, woman and child in Gaza. Which will simply create another traumatised generation where more people will hate Israel and never accept any compromise and go on to fight for Hamas or whoever succeeds them. Israel didn't have to be 'nicer' to Hamas, but the extent of its savage cruelty towards the people of Gaza was unnecessary and has led to the world to turn its back on Israel.

Aside from America (and to some extent Germany) who are enabling it - and not out of supporting Jews in the case of America, but connected, many people believe, to influential Christian Nationalists in the Trump regime who genuinely believe all us Jews need to go to Israel and die or convert to bring about the return of the Messiah. Yes, it's that bonkers! I don't know how powerful or influential they really are in the scheme of things, but it's scary if they are.

www.pbs.org/newshour/show/why-american-evangelical-christians-have-deep-ties-to-supporting-israel

OP posts:
JacknDiane · 30/10/2026 12:34

bellinisurge · 30/10/2026 12:01

The problem with a quick ground attack to retrieve the hostages was that the hostages weren’t all in one place. And most were hidden among the civilian population. There is no report of any civilians giving comfort or support to the hostages.
While it is true that there is no Palestinian Authority army, there seems to be an endless supply of combatants under an Islamofascist regime.
Any dissent is brutally crushed by Hamas so it is unsurprising that there is so little now and was zero civilian assistance to hostages. But even under the Nazis in Germany there was some.
Surely the international goal should be Free Palestine from Hamas not “be a bit nicer, Israel”

This post comparing the Nazis in Germany would have screams of Holocaust Inversion if posted by someone sympathetic to the Palestinians.

Martymcfly24 · 30/10/2026 12:52

bellinisurge · 30/10/2026 12:01

The problem with a quick ground attack to retrieve the hostages was that the hostages weren’t all in one place. And most were hidden among the civilian population. There is no report of any civilians giving comfort or support to the hostages.
While it is true that there is no Palestinian Authority army, there seems to be an endless supply of combatants under an Islamofascist regime.
Any dissent is brutally crushed by Hamas so it is unsurprising that there is so little now and was zero civilian assistance to hostages. But even under the Nazis in Germany there was some.
Surely the international goal should be Free Palestine from Hamas not “be a bit nicer, Israel”

Think this is very unfair to post on OP's thread
She is a Jewish woman who has gone to the West Bank (not Gaza where Hamas are) to support the olive farmers that are being besieged by settlers. Something very few could argue is a good thing.

LivingDeadGirlUK · 30/10/2026 13:18

I just wanted to say this was such a lovely thing to do OP, and brave too.

Coldcafeeveryday · 30/10/2026 13:22

I'm just wondering if a lot of settlers are from different countries in particular the USA? Have you seen the Louis Theroux documentary about it? Do you think this is reflective of what you've seen or heard?

Do you get into conversations with other Jews who are of the stance that Palestine is the enemy? What do you say to them?

Echobelly · 30/10/2026 13:36

Coldcafeeveryday · 30/10/2026 13:22

I'm just wondering if a lot of settlers are from different countries in particular the USA? Have you seen the Louis Theroux documentary about it? Do you think this is reflective of what you've seen or heard?

Do you get into conversations with other Jews who are of the stance that Palestine is the enemy? What do you say to them?

Quite a lot of Settlers do seem to come over from the States - to me that's one of the most egregious things, to come over from elsewhere explicitly to be a Settler. I haven't seen the Theroux documentary - it just makes me sooo angry to watch this people I don't think I can bear it!

I haven't had face to face conversations with Jews who feel enmity to Palestinians, though I have online. The main line I take is that I don't think it can be right to punish all of them and that Israel has no real future if it sets itself on the eradication/ethnic cleansing from the land of Palestinian people. My maternal grandfather's family were almost all murdered by the Nazis; to me what Israel is doing betrays their memories and those of all the Nazis victims.

We have neighbours, not Israeli by birth, but citizens, who we like very much but their daughter (same age as our oldest) has just joined the IDF with their full support. Which we find totally incomprehensible - I suppose they find our views the same but we still seem to get along OK! I wouldn't want to 'blacklist' friends or family because they support Israel and think it's important to keep talking.

OP posts:
gullgal · 30/10/2026 14:11

Fantastic well done.

Summerhillsquare · 30/10/2026 14:46

Brava!

Just popping by to say people can support by buying Zeytoun olive oil from Palestine, usually in fair trade shops and churches, if they want help the harvest from afar. It's v good quality.

Echobelly · 30/10/2026 14:56

Yes, it's a shame Zaytoun don't seem to do their candied almonds anymore, because those were bloody amazing!

OP posts:
MissyB1 · 30/10/2026 16:29

Summerhillsquare · 30/10/2026 14:46

Brava!

Just popping by to say people can support by buying Zeytoun olive oil from Palestine, usually in fair trade shops and churches, if they want help the harvest from afar. It's v good quality.

Thank you I will look for this.

JacknDiane · 30/10/2026 16:41

@Echobelly, thank you. You have restored my faith in humanity over this issue. I was chased away from mn by a very pro Israeli very vocal poster. And anything I wrote was smeared as antisemitic. I voiced almost exactly the same thoughts as yourself and I was hounded off mn. So to read of your actions and your beliefs is just so refreshing.
People are hurting on both sides and we need dialogue. Things must change but change seems to not be in the leaders interest. Its just profoundly depressing all round.

dairydebris · 30/10/2026 16:50

JacknDiane · 30/10/2026 12:34

This post comparing the Nazis in Germany would have screams of Holocaust Inversion if posted by someone sympathetic to the Palestinians.

No, because that poster did not attempt to make equivalence between any Jewish people and Nazis. The poster was commenting that German civilians showed resistance under the Nazis. Just look it up if you don't understand it.

JacknDiane · 30/10/2026 16:56

dairydebris · 30/10/2026 16:50

No, because that poster did not attempt to make equivalence between any Jewish people and Nazis. The poster was commenting that German civilians showed resistance under the Nazis. Just look it up if you don't understand it.

I dont need to look it up, I stand by what I said. Anyone mentioning the Holocaust on this board in relation to what happened in Palestine was hounded by certain posters. The context hardly mattered.
But this is not the place for more arguments.
This is a wonderful thread to celebrate what @Echobelly achieved.

JacknDiane · 30/10/2026 16:58

By this board I meant CITME, not AMA .

Craftycorvid · 30/10/2026 17:24

Bloody good show, OP. You have brightened my day and helped sustain my faith in humans.

Echobelly · 30/10/2026 18:05

Well there were many other people, and this week there is a whole other group of volunteers out there, as there will be for the two subsequent weeks.

OP posts:
herecomestheairfryer · 30/10/2026 18:19

Echobelly · 30/10/2026 13:36

Quite a lot of Settlers do seem to come over from the States - to me that's one of the most egregious things, to come over from elsewhere explicitly to be a Settler. I haven't seen the Theroux documentary - it just makes me sooo angry to watch this people I don't think I can bear it!

I haven't had face to face conversations with Jews who feel enmity to Palestinians, though I have online. The main line I take is that I don't think it can be right to punish all of them and that Israel has no real future if it sets itself on the eradication/ethnic cleansing from the land of Palestinian people. My maternal grandfather's family were almost all murdered by the Nazis; to me what Israel is doing betrays their memories and those of all the Nazis victims.

We have neighbours, not Israeli by birth, but citizens, who we like very much but their daughter (same age as our oldest) has just joined the IDF with their full support. Which we find totally incomprehensible - I suppose they find our views the same but we still seem to get along OK! I wouldn't want to 'blacklist' friends or family because they support Israel and think it's important to keep talking.

I don't think it can be right to punish all of them

Why would they need to be punished in the first place? It's crazy that a people who have been displaced, murdered, maimed for life, had land/livelihoods confiscated, been geographically imprisoned, denied medical treatment and many more, to be seen as the perpetrators? How come Israel are seen as the victims? I know you've said this, but I'm asking more generally. It's like people saying Israel had the right to fight back after October 7th, but Israel have been the terrorists since the country was formed. Israel have killed more children in Gaza in the last several years than any other world conflict combined.

Edit I've reread your post and I'm not sure if you are saying the above quote with regards to Palestinians or the Jews in Israel, but my point still stands in general as I've heard this many times

Swipe left for the next trending thread