@Truinio
You mention witchcraft, tarot, and astrology which leads me to think you see paganism as a syncretic belief system
I don't see it that way. Paganism is not one single belief system, but a cover-all term for multiple different religions and traditions. Wicca, Druidry, Norse Paganism, Celtic Paganism, Hellenic Paganism, Kemetic Paganism, etc, etc.
Witchcraft, Tarot and astrology are not the same thing as paganism, though they are practices that many (but not all) pagans engage in and use as part of their practice. But there are pagans who do not use any of those things.
There is no single tradition, paganism is am umbrella term for a multiplicity of avenues.
My understanding however is that certain Pagan movements, such as Wicca, aim to be more unified
Quite a lot of individual pagan religions are unified systems in themselves.
Does mashing together multiple unrelated practices and belief systems undermine efforts for paganism to be taken seriously as a belief system?
Paganism in itself is not a 'belief system' - it's an umbrella term for multiple religions and systems.