Please or to access all these features

AMA

I attend a local Pagan Moot - AMA

59 replies

SorcererGaheris · 28/10/2026 00:13

I attend a local Pagan Moot.

If anyone has any questions, and is polite/respectful, I'll do my best to answer them.

OP posts:
Hornswaddler · 04/11/2026 14:35

BillieWiper · 04/11/2026 12:36

If you can do spells to get more money and get a better job, get a better relationship, improve your life in some way, why don't people capable of such things do those spells on everyone in the world who's in a war zone, or starving, or homeless?
Or show people in those positions how to do it?

Sorry I'm not trying to be disrespectful. It is a genuine question.

Could say the same about prayer.

BillieWiper · 04/11/2026 15:58

Hornswaddler · 04/11/2026 14:35

Could say the same about prayer.

Yes indeed you could.

I suppose I think of prayer as a positive thought. Whereas a spell sounds like something you do to actually try and make a specific thing happen. Like you're casting a spell 'on' someone. Whereas I feel if you pray you just pray 'for someone/something'?

To me anyway, as someone who did not grow up with any religion or spiritual belief.

Either way I'm hoping OP or someone might be able to give some kind of answer to my question.

NoSmilingNoWrinkles · 04/11/2026 17:45

Have you ever had a dark energy attach itself to you? Do you consider that you may be opening yourself up to this sort of thing by practicing magic?

AnderNuvvaFing · 04/11/2026 18:25

Are you a vegan or vegetarian? And is the book shop related to your beliefs? (rather than the local Waterstones).

Just wondering how many stereotypes are involved.

SorcererGaheris · 04/11/2026 23:38

TheBroonOneAndTheWhiteOne · 04/11/2026 12:23

Why do you give the word a capital M?
It isn't a proper noun.

@TheBroonOneAndTheWhiteOne

Because I capitalised the word 'Pagan', it looked more "symmetrical" to capitalise the M, but yes, it doesn't strictly need to be capitalised.

OP posts:
SorcererGaheris · 05/11/2026 00:12

BillieWiper · 04/11/2026 12:36

If you can do spells to get more money and get a better job, get a better relationship, improve your life in some way, why don't people capable of such things do those spells on everyone in the world who's in a war zone, or starving, or homeless?
Or show people in those positions how to do it?

Sorry I'm not trying to be disrespectful. It is a genuine question.

@BillieWiper

A few reasons:

It can be a considerable investment of time and effort to simply do magic for one's self and (sometimes) one's loved ones; doing it for multiples upon multiples of strangers (with whom we have no emotional connection or relationship) is an investment of labour that many are not prepared to make.

Another reason is that many - not all, but many - people are focused fully (or primarily) on themselves and their nearest and dearest. If they don't have, or feel, a personal connection to such people/causes, there isn't necessarily the motivation to do anything for them.

There are quite a few traditions of magic where doing such a thing would, in a practical sense, be more or less impossible. A number of magical traditions call for many spells to have what is called "personal concerns" of the target; the stronger the personal concern, the better (so a particularly strong one might be the hair or bodily fluid of an individual; a photograph is a reasonable one as well.) In a pinch, you could write someone's name on a piece of paper, but that's a weaker personal concern. It's not practically possible to get personal concerns from all these people in the world, many of whom live in other countries and are unknown to us.

I'm personally in agreement with Jason Miller when he describes magic as an influence, rather than a cause, and (generally) I think spells have a greater chance of being effective if the mundane circumstances aren't impossible (or exceptionally difficult) to surmount. To quote from Jason's book "The Element of Spellcrafting'

"When we get into Magical goals, the idea of influencing change rather than causing change is key. It shows us why spells that aim to divert a coming storm will work better than attempts to make it snow in July. One of these is an event that just needs a nudge, the other requires a drastic suspending of the laws of nature. Magic as an influence rather than a cause is why enchanting for a better job or to start a successful business is a good investment of time, while spells to win the Mega-Millions lottery are a fool's errand."

Or show people in those positions how to do it?

Teaching is a lot of work and it's not a skill that everyone has (nor is it something that everyone is interested in doing.) There are a number of people in the occult community who work as teachers of magic; this is their full-time profession - they hold classes, run courses, etc, as well as publish books. I'm not sure how accessible such things generally are to people in dire circumstances, though - David Rankine, for example, is currently running a course on Practical Grimoire Conjuration from the Ars Goetia, which will run on six consecutive Sundays online. But people who are homeless or in war zones may not necessarily be able to access the internet at the appropriate times and probably have more pressing things to spend their limited money on.

Such courses, classes and workshops are open to anyone who is interested and who is happy to pay for them. Some such teachers are the aforementioned Jason Miller, who runs the Strategic Sorcery website, Sara Mastros, BJ Swain, Mat Auryn. Clifford Hartleigh Low has recently launched a website which focuses on a specific tradition of Astrological Magic, which has a ton of essays (over 70 at last count) as well as other information, as he is one of the main movers in revitalising this particular tradition.

OP posts:
BillieWiper · 05/11/2026 12:35

SorcererGaheris · 05/11/2026 00:12

@BillieWiper

A few reasons:

It can be a considerable investment of time and effort to simply do magic for one's self and (sometimes) one's loved ones; doing it for multiples upon multiples of strangers (with whom we have no emotional connection or relationship) is an investment of labour that many are not prepared to make.

Another reason is that many - not all, but many - people are focused fully (or primarily) on themselves and their nearest and dearest. If they don't have, or feel, a personal connection to such people/causes, there isn't necessarily the motivation to do anything for them.

There are quite a few traditions of magic where doing such a thing would, in a practical sense, be more or less impossible. A number of magical traditions call for many spells to have what is called "personal concerns" of the target; the stronger the personal concern, the better (so a particularly strong one might be the hair or bodily fluid of an individual; a photograph is a reasonable one as well.) In a pinch, you could write someone's name on a piece of paper, but that's a weaker personal concern. It's not practically possible to get personal concerns from all these people in the world, many of whom live in other countries and are unknown to us.

I'm personally in agreement with Jason Miller when he describes magic as an influence, rather than a cause, and (generally) I think spells have a greater chance of being effective if the mundane circumstances aren't impossible (or exceptionally difficult) to surmount. To quote from Jason's book "The Element of Spellcrafting'

"When we get into Magical goals, the idea of influencing change rather than causing change is key. It shows us why spells that aim to divert a coming storm will work better than attempts to make it snow in July. One of these is an event that just needs a nudge, the other requires a drastic suspending of the laws of nature. Magic as an influence rather than a cause is why enchanting for a better job or to start a successful business is a good investment of time, while spells to win the Mega-Millions lottery are a fool's errand."

Or show people in those positions how to do it?

Teaching is a lot of work and it's not a skill that everyone has (nor is it something that everyone is interested in doing.) There are a number of people in the occult community who work as teachers of magic; this is their full-time profession - they hold classes, run courses, etc, as well as publish books. I'm not sure how accessible such things generally are to people in dire circumstances, though - David Rankine, for example, is currently running a course on Practical Grimoire Conjuration from the Ars Goetia, which will run on six consecutive Sundays online. But people who are homeless or in war zones may not necessarily be able to access the internet at the appropriate times and probably have more pressing things to spend their limited money on.

Such courses, classes and workshops are open to anyone who is interested and who is happy to pay for them. Some such teachers are the aforementioned Jason Miller, who runs the Strategic Sorcery website, Sara Mastros, BJ Swain, Mat Auryn. Clifford Hartleigh Low has recently launched a website which focuses on a specific tradition of Astrological Magic, which has a ton of essays (over 70 at last count) as well as other information, as he is one of the main movers in revitalising this particular tradition.

Thank you for your detailed response. That is very interesting. X

SorcererGaheris · 05/11/2026 13:07

NoSmilingNoWrinkles · 04/11/2026 17:45

Have you ever had a dark energy attach itself to you? Do you consider that you may be opening yourself up to this sort of thing by practicing magic?

@NoSmilingNoWrinkles

Have you ever had a dark energy attach itself to you?

Not that I'm aware of.

Do you consider that you may be opening yourself up to this sort of thing by practicing magic?

I do think that regularly practicing magic can draw the attention/engagement of some spirits that may not be particularly pleasant. There are risks, but also steps one can take to mitigate against them.

OP posts:
SorcererGaheris · 05/11/2026 13:09

AnderNuvvaFing · 04/11/2026 18:25

Are you a vegan or vegetarian? And is the book shop related to your beliefs? (rather than the local Waterstones).

Just wondering how many stereotypes are involved.

@AnderNuvvaFing

I am not a vegan and I am not a vegetarian.

And is the book shop related to your beliefs?

No, it isn't, although the idea of working in an occult bookshop (something like Watkins and Treadwells in London or Courtyard Books and Labyrinth Books in Glastonbury) is a pleasant one.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page