Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Conversion therapy bill should not stop ‘healthy and challenging family conversations’ Children's tsar

472 replies

IwantToRetire · 12/11/2026 21:21

Dame Rachel de Souza told The Telegraph that the Government’s legislation to outlaw conversion therapy must not “impact healthy and challenging family conversations”.

Dame Rachel said that while she supported the aims of the bill, she was keen to see that it did not impinge on conversations within the family.

“I know young people face abuse and coercion because of their sexuality or gender, and I support the Government’s aim to ban harmful practices,” she said.

“This is complex and sensitive legislation, and for the bill to be effective, it is important it doesn’t impact healthy and challenging family conversations and aligns with existing measures in place to protect children from cruelty.”

Full article https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2026/11/12/trans-conversion-law-must-not-silence-parents-children/

And at https://archive.is/QWfdH

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
Perenelle · 13/11/2026 20:02

ScrollingLeaves · 13/11/2026 19:47

It's not that you can't disagree, you can. It's just that it would be illegal to not support them……….with their,

body dysphoria?
anorexia?
cannabis?
vaping?
underage sex?
phone use?
isolating tgemselves?
porn watching?

and on and on.

One could say disagreeing with our kids and challenging their opinions really is everyday business in parenting.

Shedmistress · 13/11/2026 21:09

Perenelle · 13/11/2026 20:02

One could say disagreeing with our kids and challenging their opinions really is everyday business in parenting.

It is actually the duty of parents to at least try and keep their kids on some sort of line.

BinTheConversionPracticesBill · 14/11/2026 11:02

Thehorticulturalhussie · 13/11/2026 18:21

Thank you for this, it explains a lot. I feel annoyed with myself that I hadn’t queried the history and terminology but I don’t think that I’m alone. Not an excuse.

It had been niggling at the back of my brain for a while that all this talk of people being given electric shocks and made to vomit sounded like what was called Aversion Therapy - not "Conversion Therapy" - so I was glad that I found that David Pilgrim paper :-)

To bring us right up to date, the latest trans activist smoke and mirrors strategy in language manipulation and logical equivocation aka "double speak" was in evidence on Thurs 12 Nov.

Parliament TV: 12 November 2026 - Draft Conversion Practices Bill - Oral evidence

Dr Igi Moon
Dr Alison Berner

https://parliamentlive.tv/event/index/17ffbee0-28a5-44c0-aed2-767cbf43f2e2

Previously, trans activists have maintained that "Exploratory Therapy" = "Gender Critical Therapy" = "Conversion Therapy".

(Note: "Gender Critical Therapy" does not exist and has never existed. It is just a bogey-man rhetorical device used by trans activists.)

However, in the Oral Evidence session on 12 Nov, Dr Igi Moon repeatedly hammered home a new mantra:

  • Affirmative Therapy - IS - Exploratory Therapy
because
  • Exploratory Therapy is Affirmative
Firstly, there are multiple meanings of "affirmation" in psychotherapy.
  • Igi Moon described a meaning of "affirmation" relevant to mainstream Exploratory Therapy in order to claim, correctly according to that meaning, that best practice Exploratory Therapy is "affirmative".
  • Moon used that argument to claim repeatedly that gender identity services characteristically offer Exploratory Therapy, ie that "Affirmative Therapy" = mainstream Exploratory Therapy.

Secondly, by implication, any other approach is not mainstream Exploratory Therapy . . . so it must be something else. The only other "something else" on the table is . . . Conversion Therapy.

This is the all too familiar trans activist tactic of employing the rhetorical trickery of equivocation aka "double speak".

It is an interesting side-step given that they have previously devoted much time and effort to dissing "Exploratory Therapy" as evil TERF secret code for "Conversion Therapy".

I spotted the rhetorical side-step and linguistic trickery but I am not a psychotherapist so I had to look up the multiple meanings of "affirmation".

This is from Grok:

Q. What does the term "affirmation" mean in relation to psychotherapeutic practice?

Activate Ambiguity Mode. List cited sources with links as References. Stick to evidence. Think step-by-step. Qualify uncertainties. Verify facts. Review for errors. No tribal framing
-----

The term “affirmation” (and related forms such as “affirmative therapy” or “affirmative practice”) is used in multiple, partially overlapping ways in psychotherapeutic literature and practice. It does not have a single fixed meaning; usage depends on theoretical orientation, clinical context, and specific authors or organizations. Below are the principal documented senses, drawn from professional sources.

1. Therapist communication skill recognizing client strengths or efforts

In Motivational Interviewing (MI) and related approaches, affirmations form one of the core OARS skills (Open questions, Affirmations, Reflections, Summaries). They are statements that notice, value, or appreciate a client’s strengths, efforts, values, accomplishments, persistence, or positive characteristics.

They are intended to be genuine, specific, and focused on the person rather than generic praise or evaluation. Examples from MI training materials include recognizing effort toward change or reframing partial progress in a strengths-based way. The aim is to support engagement, build self-efficacy, and strengthen the therapeutic alliance. Affirmations are distinguished from praise, which can position the clinician as judge.

This usage appears in deliberate-practice materials published by the American Psychological Association and standard MI resources.

2. Expression or observable aspect of unconditional positive regard

In person-centered (Rogerian) therapy and related humanistic approaches, affirmation is closely linked to Carl Rogers’ concept of unconditional positive regard—the warm acceptance or “prizing” of the client as a person without conditions of worth.

Some process-research literature groups therapist behaviors such as acceptance, nonpossessive warmth, support, and validation under the broader category of “therapist affirmation.” Affirmation here is treated as an observable manifestation of the underlying attitude of positive regard. It is not limited to positive statements; it includes a nonjudgmental stance toward the client’s experience.

Rogers’ original formulations emphasize caring for the client as a separate person and accepting aspects of their experience without selective evaluation.

3. Client self-affirmations / positive self-statements

In cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT), positive psychology, and some self-help-informed clinical work, “affirmations” refer to consciously chosen, present-tense declarative statements that clients repeat or write to challenge automatic negative thoughts, reinforce adaptive beliefs, or support self-efficacy.

These are client-generated or collaboratively crafted tools rather than primarily therapist utterances. Clinical descriptions stress that they work best when specific, realistic or evidence-linked, and tailored rather than generic. They appear as adjuncts within broader cognitive restructuring or coping-skills work.

4. Affirmative therapy / affirmative practice (sociocultural validation of identity)

The APA Dictionary of Psychology defines affirmative therapy as:
“a socioculturally informed intervention that provides validation and acceptance for clients and their communities, particularly in situations in which ethnic, gender, or sexual orientation diversity has been resisted or in which normal conditions (e.g., gay identity) have been pathologized. Emphasizing self- and cultural awareness, this therapy may be practiced as a distinct intervention or within the context of other psychotherapies.”

In practice descriptions, this approach treats the client’s sexual orientation or gender identity as non-pathological and focuses clinical attention on minority stress, stigma, discrimination, internalized negative beliefs, and related distress. It is frequently discussed in relation to LGBTQ+ clients and is sometimes distinguished from (though overlapping with) broader gender-affirming care that may include social or medical steps.

Related specialized frameworks (e.g., gender-affirmative models for transgender and gender-diverse clients) share the premise that gender variations are not disorders and that support for a client’s experienced gender can reduce distress arising from external rejection or incongruence.

5. Other specialized or less common usages

  • *Psychoanalytic writing*: Affirmative interventions have been described as communications that remove doubt about the reality of an experience and thereby help re-establish a sense of identity; they are treated as complementary to interpretation.
  • *Baars Institute “Affirmation Therapy”*: A distinct approach drawing on the work of Conrad Baars and Anna Terruwe that emphasizes the therapist’s affective presence to convey the client’s intrinsic goodness and worth; it is framed in terms of emotional strengthening and is not synonymous with the sociocultural affirmative therapies above.

Summary of ambiguity

  • When the term appears alone as “affirmation(s)” in general psychotherapy texts, it most often refers to the MI-style strength-focused statements or to aspects of positive regard/validation.
  • “Affirmative therapy” or “affirmative practice” more specifically denotes the sociocultural, identity-validating stance, especially regarding sexual orientation and gender.
  • Context (theoretical orientation, client population, and surrounding language) is required to disambiguate. Sources do not treat these meanings as mutually exclusive; an affirmative stance toward identity can incorporate Rogerian regard or MI skills, and vice versa.

Definitions above are drawn from dictionary entries, professional training materials, and peer-reviewed or organizational descriptions. They describe usage rather than adjudicate comparative efficacy, which varies by context and is outside the scope of a definitional account. Evidence quality and consensus strength differ across the listed senses.

References

Compare and contrast Exploratory Therapy and Affirmative Therapy.

Exploratory Therapy (often called Gender Exploratory Therapy or GET in this context) and Affirmative Therapy (or gender-affirmative approaches) are frequently contrasted in discussions of care for gender-related distress, particularly among children and adolescents. They represent different clinical emphases rather than fully discrete, mutually exclusive methods. Both claim to prioritise the client’s wellbeing, reject coercive change efforts (conversion practices), and take distress seriously. Key differences centre on starting assumptions about identity, the role of exploration versus validation, and the threshold for social or medical steps.

Core Definitions and Stance

Affirmative Therapy is a socioculturally informed approach that provides validation and acceptance of the client’s stated identity (including gender identity or sexual orientation), treating it as a non-pathological variation of human experience. Distress is primarily attributed to minority stress, stigma, discrimination, or external rejection rather than to the identity itself. Clinicians typically follow the client’s lead on gender, use preferred names and pronouns, support social transition where desired, and may facilitate pathways to medical interventions after assessment. The APA Dictionary of Psychology defines it as an intervention that validates clients and communities where diversity has been resisted or pathologised, emphasising self- and cultural awareness. It can be applied as a distinct stance or integrated into other therapies.

Exploratory Therapy emphasises open-ended, non-directive talk therapy to understand the origins, meaning, and context of gender distress or dysphoria. It does not presume that a stated identity is either mistaken or settled. Clinicians explore co-occurring factors (e.g., puberty-related discomfort, autism/neurodivergence, anxiety, depression, trauma, family dynamics, peer influences, sexuality, body image) alongside the gender presentation. Social affirmation and medical steps are approached cautiously and are not automatic; the process prioritises comprehensive assessment and is described by proponents as open to a range of outcomes (persistence, desistance, or continued uncertainty). It is positioned as a holistic, whole-person approach rather than identity-focused validation.

Key Points of Comparison Table (see screenshot)

Similarities

  • Both reject conversion practices that aim to force a change in sexual orientation or gender identity.
  • Both can incorporate curiosity, emotional processing, and support for the client’s dignity and safety.
  • Affirmative approaches often include identity exploration; exploratory approaches can include affirming the person’s inherent worth and protecting against bullying or rejection.
  • Both aim to alleviate distress. Some clinicians argue that high-quality psychotherapy inherently combines elements of both when free of ideological predetermination.

Points of Contrast and Contested Claims

The central practical difference is clinical orientation: affirmative approaches begin from acceptance of the reported identity and treat external factors as the main drivers of harm, while exploratory approaches begin from curiosity about the full picture and treat the identity claim itself as potentially multifactorial.

Proponents of affirmative care argue that withholding affirmation risks compounding stigma and isolation, and that exploration of “causes” can pathologise a valid identity. Critics of exploratory approaches (e.g., Ashley 2023) contend that mandatory exploration of “pathological roots,” combined with discouragement of affirmation, shares conceptual features with conversion practices and may delay needed care.

Proponents of exploratory care argue that compassion does not require treating an initial identity declaration as a settled diagnosis with a predetermined pathway, especially given developmental plasticity in youth and weak evidence for benefits (and potential harms) of early medical intervention. They note that comprehensive assessment was part of earlier protocols and that the current referral population is heterogeneous. The Cass Review (2024) highlighted the weak evidence base across interventions, recommended holistic assessment that includes mental health and neurodevelopmental screening, and positioned psychosocial support as central rather than routine medical pathways for most young people. It distinguished appropriate exploration from conversion practices.

Evidence quality is limited for both specific therapeutic models. Systematic reviews have found the research on psychosocial interventions, social transition, and endocrine treatments to be of low or very low certainty, with methodological shortcomings common. Outcomes over long timeframes remain poorly characterised.

Scope and Uncertainties

The contrast is most sharply drawn in relation to gender dysphoria/incongruence in children and adolescents. For adult sexual orientation, affirmative approaches are more widely established and less contested. Terminology itself is contested: some clinicians view “affirmative” and “exploratory” as false binaries that obscure ordinary therapeutic practice, while others treat them as meaningfully distinct clinical stances with different risk profiles.

Neither label is a standardised, manualised protocol with strong outcome data unique to it. Actual practice varies by clinician, setting, and jurisdiction. Claims about superiority often outpace the available evidence. Individualised assessment that considers developmental stage, co-occurring conditions, and the young person’s full context remains the point of greatest consensus across major reviews.

References

Conversion therapy bill should not stop ‘healthy and challenging family conversations’ Children's tsar
Luckydog7 · 14/11/2026 11:51

Transperson · 13/11/2026 11:04

Come on you know it's different.

Being trans is more than a pretend play that lasts a few hours.

The indicators that a child is 'trans' and that a child is gender non-conforming gay are indistinguishable.

How can you tell these two groups apart?

If my male child is gender non-conforming and someone...a peer, a teacher, a stranger on Mumsnet, tells them that means they are actually a girl. How is that NOT an attempt at conversion? Plus that path leads to medicalisation and irreversible damage potentially.

Most of my male blood relatives are gay. My youngest brother is only in his 20s and was at the coal face for this and speaks about nearly getting caught up in it. He wears his hair long and likes sparky earrings and that was enough for people to start pressuring him to 'come out' as trans.

He's very happily engaged to a lovely man now.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 14/11/2026 12:03

HannahinHampshire · 14/11/2026 11:54

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/2e44c23a649c0556
’trans law could send teachers to prison’

This is such an important intervention. The trans captured NEU who have danced to the transactivist tunes for years, speaking out against the bill! Pointing out that statutory safeguarding guidance instructs schools to ensure no mixed sex undressing, toilets etc while the appallingly written bill enables schools to be targeted for this:

"Law firm Irwin Mitchell said: “It could be argued that enforcing separate sex facilities in line with biological sex suppresses a child’s gender identity, and this amounts to the same thing as causing them not to have that gender identity or to believe they don’t have it.”
A pupil could also claim being barred caused “serious alarm or distress” that disrupted their daily life, it said."

It raises questions as to who drafted this and why the government fails to use even basic due diligence when trans demands are made.

MarcTheGenderSkeptic · 14/11/2026 12:10

Is there any way to leave a submission without downloading a Word document etc? Just a simple open box to type some text into?
Otherwise I won't be able to contribute.

Dozer · 14/11/2026 12:18

It’s the trans lobby that is seeking for children and young adults to undergo ‘conversion’. ‘Conversion’ accurately describes what happens, by psychological, social and medical intervention. Where there is poor evidence and risk of harm, it should be prevented.

important discussions about children and young adults’ health is not the ‘conversion’

Myotherusernamesafunnyone · 14/11/2026 16:22

Transperson · 13/11/2026 01:09

I'm glad the government is standing up for trans people, GC believes go against tolerance.

Educate yourself. Try listening to this as a good place to start. https://open.spotify.com/episode/0uNsrFvCO7XCbhFELfQn30?si=D0QH2juATySFiHKb3d6VTg&utm_source=copy-link

The Conversion Practices Bill: Necessary or Dangerously Deluded? Plus the Jury Trial U-Turn

Double Jeopardy - UK Law and Politics · Episode

https://open.spotify.com/episode/0uNsrFvCO7XCbhFELfQn30?si=D0QH2juATySFiHKb3d6VTg&utm_source=copy-link

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · 14/11/2026 17:44

Excellent comment under the Telegraph article (thanks @HannahinHampshire):

“ It is also feared that teachers who use the wrong pronouns could be reported to police…”.
Simply identify as having used the correct pronoun. Sorted.

BinTheConversionPracticesBill · 15/11/2026 05:06

MarcTheGenderSkeptic · 14/11/2026 12:10

Is there any way to leave a submission without downloading a Word document etc? Just a simple open box to type some text into?
Otherwise I won't be able to contribute.

Both Dennis Kavanah and Sex Matters have said that you can send an email as an alternative to completing a Word doc and then uploading it to the Gov website.

It might be a good idea to include the specific Questions that you are answering and Sex Matters has some good guidance on which ones to choose:
https://sex-matters.org/take-action/submit-evidence-to-the-conversion-practices-bill-committee

What it says on the Gov website:

Help and support
If you need help submitting your evidence, contact the Draft Conversion Practices Bill (Joint Committee) by email at [email protected]

https://committees.parliament.uk/submission/4010/#/evidence/4010/call-for-evidence

Submit evidence to the Conversion Practices Bill committee

A parliamentary committee is scrutinising the draft Conversion Practices Bill, and it wants to hear from people the bill would affect. The deadline for

https://sex-matters.org/take-action/submit-evidence-to-the-conversion-practices-bill-committee/

Rightsraptor · 15/11/2026 10:01

Transperson · 13/11/2026 18:20

In my opinion a person should unconditionally love and emotionally support their child. It's not that you can't disagree, you can. It's just that it would be illegal to not support them.

You can have a conversation with them about long term consequences but you can't tell them "no, you are aren't that gender".

Edited

So I could disagree but must still 'support' which you haven't defined. Am I to say 'you're wrong child, you are a perfectly formed girl' but then have to buy her a breast binder & testosterone? No. Not happening.

She'd be supported by being shown life is not what is online but what all around us in the tangible world, the world where sex is important.

Reality vs fantasy - reality will win.

AstonCanKissMyArse · 15/11/2026 12:55

I'm always puzzled by how often TRAs refer to their therapist (so are clearly pro therapy in theory), then in the next breath insist that their transistion is off limits when it comes to said therapy.

Either you think exploring your issues, all of them, it's a good idea, or you don't. Picking and choosing which aspects of your life that you will/ won't discuss is a red light in itself to any good therapist (eg if you refuse to talk about your job/ marriage/ whatever, then its pretty clear that you do in fact have some kind of issue with your job/ marriage/ whatever).

If you're so confident in your trans identity (and not wedded to it for some ideological reason), why wouldn't you want to explore it? See where it came from and how it developed, how it serves you, how it doesn't serve you, what you hope for from the future, is that likely, etc etc).

If you explore it thoroughly and decide its still for you, great. If you explore it and realise that actually you're trying to fix some other aspect of your life and its become a useful distraction or whatever, that's also good information, surely? You can go forward with the the true facts.

Its almost as though they're afraid this 'innate aspect of their being' won't actually stand up to thoughtful scrutiny. Good therapy is supposed to be gently challenging.

I saw some posts on X where woman was in a relationship with a trans woman (no surgery) and she was outraged that her therapist wanted to explore that with her. But why not?

Anyone who essentially says 'I can't talk to you because you might change my mind' (looking at you, #nodebate) doesn't have a strong conviction or evidence base for their position in the first place.

And this is why children need to be taught to think critically and question everything.

My son (mid-late teens) has a friend in his friends group who has decided he's a woman. The boy has a trans identified sibling. The group accept him but also discuss it - one of the other lads asked him if it might not be confirmation bias, and might there be other reasons for his distress? They are smart kids. This Bill could criminalise that supportive conversation among friends.

Don't forget to submit a response to the government online. It can be a few sentences if that's all you want to say. You don't have to answer all the questions.

MarcTheGenderSkeptic · 15/11/2026 13:09

AstonCanKissMyArse · 15/11/2026 12:55

I'm always puzzled by how often TRAs refer to their therapist (so are clearly pro therapy in theory), then in the next breath insist that their transistion is off limits when it comes to said therapy.

Either you think exploring your issues, all of them, it's a good idea, or you don't. Picking and choosing which aspects of your life that you will/ won't discuss is a red light in itself to any good therapist (eg if you refuse to talk about your job/ marriage/ whatever, then its pretty clear that you do in fact have some kind of issue with your job/ marriage/ whatever).

If you're so confident in your trans identity (and not wedded to it for some ideological reason), why wouldn't you want to explore it? See where it came from and how it developed, how it serves you, how it doesn't serve you, what you hope for from the future, is that likely, etc etc).

If you explore it thoroughly and decide its still for you, great. If you explore it and realise that actually you're trying to fix some other aspect of your life and its become a useful distraction or whatever, that's also good information, surely? You can go forward with the the true facts.

Its almost as though they're afraid this 'innate aspect of their being' won't actually stand up to thoughtful scrutiny. Good therapy is supposed to be gently challenging.

I saw some posts on X where woman was in a relationship with a trans woman (no surgery) and she was outraged that her therapist wanted to explore that with her. But why not?

Anyone who essentially says 'I can't talk to you because you might change my mind' (looking at you, #nodebate) doesn't have a strong conviction or evidence base for their position in the first place.

And this is why children need to be taught to think critically and question everything.

My son (mid-late teens) has a friend in his friends group who has decided he's a woman. The boy has a trans identified sibling. The group accept him but also discuss it - one of the other lads asked him if it might not be confirmation bias, and might there be other reasons for his distress? They are smart kids. This Bill could criminalise that supportive conversation among friends.

Don't forget to submit a response to the government online. It can be a few sentences if that's all you want to say. You don't have to answer all the questions.

It's like NoDebate all over again.
NoDebate 1.0 were the dark days where absolutely no dissent or even curious questioning was allowed in public. We all recall that period, I'm most aware of it from 2015 when I went on SM and the crazy stories on trans came at me relentlessly.
Then, it was open season re cancel culture on anyone not professing fealty to the cult.
Now, it's NoDebate 2.0 that's planned, this Bill if it ever comes to the statute book. Now the cancel culture will be parents and siblings talking with trans IDing young family members, therapists and doctors discussing the psychological and physical health ramifications, teachers/priests/other third parties unable to talk thru educational and societal issues of transing.
They almost got away with NoDebate 1.0, they can't be allowed NoDebate 2.0, just imagine the only voices that won't be at risk of the law will be the TRA ones.
TERF Island needs one last slog to kick this madness into touch.

maximc · 15/11/2026 16:32

AstonCanKissMyArse · 15/11/2026 12:55

I'm always puzzled by how often TRAs refer to their therapist (so are clearly pro therapy in theory), then in the next breath insist that their transistion is off limits when it comes to said therapy.

Either you think exploring your issues, all of them, it's a good idea, or you don't. Picking and choosing which aspects of your life that you will/ won't discuss is a red light in itself to any good therapist (eg if you refuse to talk about your job/ marriage/ whatever, then its pretty clear that you do in fact have some kind of issue with your job/ marriage/ whatever).

If you're so confident in your trans identity (and not wedded to it for some ideological reason), why wouldn't you want to explore it? See where it came from and how it developed, how it serves you, how it doesn't serve you, what you hope for from the future, is that likely, etc etc).

If you explore it thoroughly and decide its still for you, great. If you explore it and realise that actually you're trying to fix some other aspect of your life and its become a useful distraction or whatever, that's also good information, surely? You can go forward with the the true facts.

Its almost as though they're afraid this 'innate aspect of their being' won't actually stand up to thoughtful scrutiny. Good therapy is supposed to be gently challenging.

I saw some posts on X where woman was in a relationship with a trans woman (no surgery) and she was outraged that her therapist wanted to explore that with her. But why not?

Anyone who essentially says 'I can't talk to you because you might change my mind' (looking at you, #nodebate) doesn't have a strong conviction or evidence base for their position in the first place.

And this is why children need to be taught to think critically and question everything.

My son (mid-late teens) has a friend in his friends group who has decided he's a woman. The boy has a trans identified sibling. The group accept him but also discuss it - one of the other lads asked him if it might not be confirmation bias, and might there be other reasons for his distress? They are smart kids. This Bill could criminalise that supportive conversation among friends.

Don't forget to submit a response to the government online. It can be a few sentences if that's all you want to say. You don't have to answer all the questions.

I imagine much of the therapy is what US detransitioner Clementine Breen described, when she said her therapist started with, 'you're a boy & I'm so sorry the world doesn't see you like that,' & proceeded to tell Breen that all her problems were caused by transphobia.

HenriettaSwanLeavitt3 · 15/11/2026 17:23

ILikeDungs · 15/11/2026 11:47

Archive: https://archive.ph/EL268

IMissBunbury · 15/11/2026 17:32

The first job of parents is to keep their kids safe
The second job of parents is to equip their kids with the skills they need to look after themselves, because we won't always be there.
Being on your kid's side is not the same thing as agreeing with every choice they want to make, as their immaturity and lesser experience of the world means that they aren't always aware of the broader consequences of that choice. Emotional support sometimes means helping them deal with not getting what they want, especially when it conflicts with those first two requirements. It should not mean having to abandon your role in safeguarding them to avoid them having a meltdown, and wanting parents to be criminalised for maintaining that role shows a bizarre lack of proportion.

ScrollingLeaves · 15/11/2026 17:42

HenriettaSwanLeavitt3 · 15/11/2026 17:23

Thank you.

This is so true:

Jean - Louis de Lolme, an 18th-century Genevan political theorist, suggested that Britain’s ‘parliament can do everything but make a woman a man and a man a woman’. It still can’t. But it can attempt to make pointing that out illegal.

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · 15/11/2026 18:12

ScrollingLeaves · 15/11/2026 17:42

Thank you.

This is so true:

Jean - Louis de Lolme, an 18th-century Genevan political theorist, suggested that Britain’s ‘parliament can do everything but make a woman a man and a man a woman’. It still can’t. But it can attempt to make pointing that out illegal.

Yes, the Bill is, at its core, nothing more sophisticated than criminalizing speech, which, aside for in certain circumstances which are already unlawful, I thought Britain had moved beyond. But censorship and authoritarianism keep rearing their ugly heads.

Transperson · 15/11/2026 19:32

BunnyBunbunbun · 13/11/2026 11:36

I totally accept that people who identify as trans are emotionally vulnerable and have a lot of distress and trauma. It's that distress that leads them to seeking solutions in the idea that something must be wrong with their body, that they can only gain control over their confused emotions if they start to control others and demand we go along with their play. That's why people who identify as trans, especially youth, should have access to good therapy to help them work through these issues, particularly if they want to go on drugs or have cosmetic surgery.

Are you suggesting that parents be jailed for rejecting the idea that their child is trans? Is that what you want from this bill?

As for gays, trans ideology is horrendous for us. I'm a lesbian. Stonewall - the backer of this ludicrous bill - has told me that if I refuse to date biological men who claim to identify as women then that makes me no better than a racist! That's the real conversion therapy - smearing lesbians as racists because we're only attracted to women! What's really crap is that the trans lobby is again exploiting the gay issue to get this anti-gay bill snuck through.

"Are you suggesting that parents be jailed for rejecting the idea that their child is trans? Is that what you want from this bill?"

Yes.

Transperson · 15/11/2026 19:34

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · 15/11/2026 18:12

Yes, the Bill is, at its core, nothing more sophisticated than criminalizing speech, which, aside for in certain circumstances which are already unlawful, I thought Britain had moved beyond. But censorship and authoritarianism keep rearing their ugly heads.

It's not really censorship or authoritarianism.

There are plenty of things you can't say in a tolerant society.

Perenelle · 15/11/2026 19:38

Disagreeing is not a hate crime in a tolerant society.

Transperson · 15/11/2026 19:41

Perenelle · 15/11/2026 19:38

Disagreeing is not a hate crime in a tolerant society.

When you reject Ur child healthcare it is.

Swipe left for the next trending thread