This is an interesting bit of research into the history of so called "Conversion Therapy" in the UK.
TLDR
- Historical Aversion Therapy Research and rare Christian Reparative Therapy (both targeting gay men and lesbians) have been bundled together with bog-standard Mainstream Exploratory Therapy and rebranded "Conversion Therapy" by trans activists in order to prevent children being protected from propulsion along a bio-medical pathway to major surgical bodily modification, sterilisation, castration, breast amputation, hormonal disruption, life-limiting iatrogenic damage, dependence on medical services, higher suicide risk and exclusion from mainstream psychological services due to psychotherapists, psychologists and psychiatrists being fearful of unjust criminalisation.
British mental healthcare responses to adult homosexuality and gender non-conforming children at the turn of the twenty-first century
David Pilgrim, 1 Aug 2023 in "History of Psychiatry: Madness, Science, Culture"
Abstract
The roots of the recent controversy about how mental health professionals should respond to gender non-conforming children are traced. To make historical sense, this paper distinguishes between epistemological (discursive) and ontological (non-discursive) aspects and describes their features, since 1970. This helps to clarify some of the confusions at the centre of the still heated debate about sexuality and gender identity today. In the concluding discussion, the philosophical resource of critical realism is used to interpret the historical narrative provided. It cautions against the anachronistic tendency to amalgamate the short-lived, and now defunct, experiment of aversion therapy for homosexuality with more recent defences of exploratory psychotherapy. The latter have challenged a different form of experimentation: the bio-medicalisation of gender non-conforming children.
Extracts
Aversion therapy c. 1970
To summarise, this phase from 1970 to 1980 reflected a dominant focus on homosexuality, not gender identity. Its target was research subjects and so it did not reflect routine clinical practice. Moreover, the patients (research or otherwise) were adults, not children.
After 1980
After 1980, clinically, homosexuality was now virtually absent as a target for intervention in mainstream mental health services. If there was any meaningful connotation of ‘conversion therapy’ (note not aversion therapy) at the time, it resided in socially conservative religious organisations. By contrast, the psychiatric gatekeeping of transsexual adults, of the sort noted above, continued. This raised an ambiguous semantic question, which is still pertinent: What is actually meant by ‘conversion therapy’?
In the 1990s, the emerging implications for transgender healthcare of patient-centredness, rather than older professional paternalism epitomised by the aversion therapists c.1970, were to become clear. Gay Liberation in the 1970s meant de-pathologisation, whereas transgender activism now was more ambivalent, with a demand some of the time for much more medicalisation and, controversially, that was proposed for pre-pubescent children.
The importance of the 1990s and afterwards
Alongside this problematisation of sexual orientation in childhood, came the wider shift to a focus in identity politics from sexuality to gender identity. This seemingly represented a progressive response to events such as the passing of the Section 28 bill, but it was being shaped by other forces, some of them quite conservative: neoliberalism as an economic regime and the atomised consumerism generated in its wake. That is, policies were driven by a focus on the reported experiences and expressed needs of individual customers. These were soon reflected in the New Public Management approach to state-run organisations, including the NHS in the UK. Patients became customers, and they were to be allotted consumer rights. Their views of services were to become a new defining criterion for quality assurance.
. . . in a healthcare context patient need was being defined less and less by objective criteria and evidence from epidemiology (showing recurrently that the poor were sick more often and died younger). Instead, it was about what patients said about themselves as individuals. This provided them with an ‘epistemological privilege’, not just to report, quite legitimately, their unique biographical perspective, but also, at its most aspirational, to determine whole service philosophies.
Elsewhere in the world, the controversy about affirmation versus cautious exploration had produced its career casualties. The one with the highest profile was the dismissal of clinical psychologist Ken Zucker from his role as manager of the Toronto gender identity service in Canada. The service was shut down in December 2015 after his dismissal. His case was dramatic (a dismissal and a service closure) but also noteworthy, given his reputation.
He had been the editor of the Archives of Sexual Behaviour since 2001 and was an acknowledged expert in the field. He was not opposed in principle to the Dutch model but he urged caution, in similar terms to the disaffected staff at the Tavistock Clinic (Zucker, Wood, Singh and Bradley, 2012). He argued for a plurality of approaches, applied judiciously from case to case, and the need for better quality research in the meantime. Transgender activists accused him of championing ‘conversion therapy’, which, by the turn of this century, had come to mean exploratory alternatives to affirmation. Their campaigning was successful when lobbying for Zucker’s sacking. (After an acknowledgement of false claims against him, Zucker’s former employers paid him compensation and damages, though he was not re-instated.) The cases of David Bell and Ken Zucker highlight the career implications for gender-critical clinicians in recent times.
Recent historical reflections and gender activism
Another relevant report that appeared around the same time (June 2022) was from the University of Birmingham, which published online and in full, a retrospective review of the work of Feldman and MacCulloch on aversion therapy. This was produced by psychologists and historians employed by the university, but it is not clear from the document how it emerged.
Its relevance relates to the sequencing of sections in the report. It begins with a health warning and the offer of help to anyone affected detrimentally as a result of targeted ‘conversion therapy’. This is followed by an apology from the vice-chancellor of the university about the work of Feldman and MacCulloch and then by the report from the employees about aversion therapy.
This report is important because the last and substantive part alludes specifically to the role of aversion therapy c.1970 and it is critical of ex-staff members Feldman and MacCulloch, noted earlier. However, it fails to distinguish clearly, for empirical and ethical consideration, adult research subjects from gender-confused children, who might be patients of mental health services today.
For example, it makes clear that its focus is on Feldman’s and MacCulloch’s work on aversion therapy with homosexual men, as their main empirical interest. However, it refers often to gender identity and conversion therapy, viz: ‘The focus of this report, as stated at the outset, is on research into and related to “conversion therapy” that was conducted and disseminated by members of staff at the University of Birmingham.’ Aversion therapy when used is not put in speech marks but conversion therapy is, raising a question about what is being alluded to specifically and operationalised c. 1970, and what is being connoted for rhetorical purposes in today’s context of transgender activism.
It is analytically questionable to group aversion therapy historically in relation to adults with exploratory therapy today with children. Of most importance throughout the report is the elision or amalgam of sexuality and gender identity, as a combined unwelcomed target of the umbrella term ‘conversion therapy’, which offers the reader a form of anachronistic reasoning. For example, the health warning placed at the start of the report says this (bearing in mind the report is substantively purportedly about aversion therapy for homosexuality 50 years previously):
Note: this report deals with activities aimed at changing gender identity and sexual orientation. It discusses psychological ‘treatments’ used in the past in sometimes graphic detail. Readers affected by this material may wish to make use of this dedicated resource: National Conversion Therapy Helpline If you are currently experiencing abuse aimed at changing, altering, or ‘curing’ your LGBT+ identity, or think this will happen to you if you come out, Galop’s Conversion Therapy Helpline is here for you. So-called conversion therapy can have a long-term impact on LGBT+ people. If this has happened to you in the past and you are still struggling with it, you can reach out to Galop’s support services. The helpline can provide a safe, confidential listening and information service to any LGBT+ person aged 13+. There are different ways to contact us. All of them are free: Phone 0800 1303335 Email [email protected] The helpline is open: Monday to Friday 10am – 4pm. Calls will last 40 minutes.
Note the privileging of gender identity at the opening of the report, even though it was not the main concern of the Feldman and McCulloch research, the purported focus of retrospective criticism from the employees of Birmingham University today.
In the previous paragraph cited, sexual orientation is privileged, suggesting that in the minds of many now (lay people and professionals) sexual orientation and gender identity are self-evidently alloyed, as the targets of ‘conversion therapy’. However, when and if they are thought of interchangeably, this is misleading. They are orthogonal concepts. Homosexuality is simply about same-sex attraction, whereas transgender individuals can report being gay, straight, bisexual or even asexual.
The risks of anachronistic reasoning and of adding gender identity to sexual orientation
The history traced so far in this paper shows that aversion therapy for adult homosexuality was not the same as the exploratory approach for gender non-conforming children. The early work of Benjamin on responding sympathetically to the expressed needs of adult transsexuals has more of a pertinent historical resonance. The rationale today of enabling gender non-conforming children to begin a pathway of biomedical transition to the opposite sex represents a form of mission creep beyond the specific concerns of responding to adult transsexualism. For this reason, any discussion today about what is meant to be ‘conversion therapy’ in relation to children should begin there, with the Benjamin rationale, and not with the aversion therapy literature about homosexuality.
A failure to recognise these different historical lineages has led to a confusing ‘mixing of apples and oranges’ in the Birmingham report, and other documents common today, which elide sexual orientation and gender identity. A recent example of the implication of this elision, and the stand-off it has afforded between transgender activists and their gender-critical opponents, is the modification of the Memorandum of Understanding on Conversion Therapy (MoU), mentioned for the purpose of legitimisation in the introduction in the Birmingham report quoted above.
The MoU was agreed initially in 2015 and alluded specifically to same-sex attraction. There was absolutely no evidence that the work of those such as Marks, Bancroft, Eysenck, Feldman and MacCulloch had left any legacy of clinical practices in mental health services in the UK. However, there was evidence of conversion practices being present in some conservative Christian groupings, at times known as ‘reparative therapy’.
. . . we do not know the prevalence of ‘so-called conversion therapy’ in the UK, how it might have changed over time or how it has been constituted in practical terms. We do know that all mainstream therapy organisations condemn it today, and the dominant problem is considered to be with religious fundamentalist organisations.
However, that non-contentious endorsement in 2015, with its singular focus on sexuality, changed two years later with a revised version of the MoU. The group editing the original document were pro-transgender activism and all the paragraphs of the Memorandum were modified pointedly to add ‘gender identity’ to ‘sexual orientation’. This seemingly small, but politically significant, semantic elision was noted above in relation to the Birmingham Report and its alloy phrasing, common now in documentation in public and private organisations.
Thus, the period between 2017 and the present has witnessed the tension between those supporting MoU 2015 and those supporting the second edition in 2017. Those supporting the latter and pushing strongly for a gender-identity focus for now control the MoU Campaign Against Conversion Therapy.
A critical realist discussion
The historical summary above, covering the period between the late 1960s and today, reports various changes in the arguments about what might constitute ‘conversion therapy’. In the discussion below, the philosophy of critical realism, which assumes that open human systems are in constant flux, will be used as a hermeneutic resource. What was the world like across those decades to account for the picture described? How did the events and disputes of relevance to the focus of this paper emerge?
(Best to read this part yourself if interested.)
Conclusion
I have outlined the clinical and ideological changes that have emerged since the late 1960s in response to adult homosexuality and gender non-conforming children. Those changes shifted the focus from adults to children on the one hand and sexuality to gender identity on the other.
Critical realism was then used as a resource to examine the implications of considering ontological realism and epistemological relativism for a fuller understanding of this complex topic. This offers a better understanding of social and historical complexity than the strong social constructivist claims from the postmodern turn, with its characteristic third-wave feminism and Queer Theory.
Our four-planar social being was also applied to emphasise complexity and flux, especially in the ways in which identity politics valorise relationality and unique personal experience, while backgrounding biological and socioeconomic determinism.
This critical realist account leaves the very notion of ‘conversion therapy’ as problematic. For now, it means different things to different factions, within our recent Zeitgeist of identity politics. For this reason, it is unwise to conflate, without reflection and anachronistically, aversion therapy for adult homosexuality (now defunct in mainstream mental health services) with cautious exploratory psychotherapy offered to gender non-conforming children today.
https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0957154X231181461
🚨 REMINDER
⏳ Deadline for Submissions of evidence to the Scrutiny Committee on the Conversion Practices Draft Bill is Monday 16 Nov at 5pm
How anyone can make a submission to the committee in 15 minutes
https://sex-matters.org/take-action/submit-evidence-to-the-conversion-practices-bill-committee
Conversion Practices Consultation Response Guide
Dennis Kavanagh