Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

How does it feel to be Gender Critical?

745 replies

2021x · 12/11/2026 06:26

I was watching a compilation of Elmo dealing with the fact that everyone is treating Rocco like a living being rather than a rock- especially regarding the cookie!

I felt this is how it feels to be talking to people who wish to validate transgender ideology as a valid identity, or having a conversation about why males shouldn't compete in female categories...

Anyone else have examples of what it is like trying to engage with people who believe TRAs more than their own eyes?

OP posts:
caprioska · 13/11/2026 21:35

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 13/11/2026 21:27

Children above the age of puberty are generally prohibited from mixed-sex formal competition in sports where sex is relevant to performance or safety.

We routinely segregate sporting competitions by age and weight as well.

We practice this segregation at all levels, even Parkrun.

Your comments are not reflective of the reality of amateur competitive sport.

Perhaps if you followed the thread you would comprehend the example of children in sport was to illustrate how context & trade offs matter in balancing rights that sex isn't necessarily relevant to.

Your comments are not reflective of the reality of amateur competitive sport.

As I said most sport played particularly by children isn't at the elite level or for purely competitive reasons & is motivated by the benefits of participation. Context matters!

GriseldaandMike · 13/11/2026 21:42

caprioska · 13/11/2026 21:35

Perhaps if you followed the thread you would comprehend the example of children in sport was to illustrate how context & trade offs matter in balancing rights that sex isn't necessarily relevant to.

Your comments are not reflective of the reality of amateur competitive sport.

As I said most sport played particularly by children isn't at the elite level or for purely competitive reasons & is motivated by the benefits of participation. Context matters!

If not elite sports for women didn't exist elite women's sport wouldn't exist. Elite athletes start as non elite athletes. If girls and women know they can't win, they will not be safe and they could be sharing changing rooms/ showers with men then they won't do sport at grassroots levels.

solerolover · 13/11/2026 21:43

GaIadriel · 13/11/2026 21:27

I just don't want to shower with dudes.

Sorry to say, but your mind has been "infected by phallophobia" and you should re-educate yourself. I'm joking of course, but this phrase has been used in the past by TRAs when single sex spaces have been discussed on this forum.

OP, I never even knew "gender critical" was a term until the last few years, it never occurred to me that saying there are only two sexes, you can't change sex and that women and girls should not be forced to undress or toilet with members of the opposite sex was such a controversial take. And this is coming from someone who studied queer theory pretty extensively in an academic context, I always regarded it as nothing more than a thought experiment and still do.

TheHereticalOne · 13/11/2026 21:44

Being gender critical feels like being hectored for suggesting that women and girls should not be obliged put the wants of every Tom, Dick or Harry ahead of their own physical safety and needs (let alone their own wants).

Usually by people who lack the wit to realise that is the line they are taking.

nutmeg7 · 13/11/2026 21:48

solerolover · 13/11/2026 21:43

Sorry to say, but your mind has been "infected by phallophobia" and you should re-educate yourself. I'm joking of course, but this phrase has been used in the past by TRAs when single sex spaces have been discussed on this forum.

OP, I never even knew "gender critical" was a term until the last few years, it never occurred to me that saying there are only two sexes, you can't change sex and that women and girls should not be forced to undress or toilet with members of the opposite sex was such a controversial take. And this is coming from someone who studied queer theory pretty extensively in an academic context, I always regarded it as nothing more than a thought experiment and still do.

Exactly. Queer theory and post-modernism were ideas to explore as thought experiments, and some alternative ways of creating art, literature and music.

They were not intended to be used in science, medicine or as a basis for an alternative “reality” that has no grounding in facts.

OldCrone · 13/11/2026 21:50

GriseldaandMike · 13/11/2026 21:42

If not elite sports for women didn't exist elite women's sport wouldn't exist. Elite athletes start as non elite athletes. If girls and women know they can't win, they will not be safe and they could be sharing changing rooms/ showers with men then they won't do sport at grassroots levels.

I think that's actually what the misogynists want.

What are all these women doing playing sport when they should be barefoot and pregnant in the kitchen?

OldCrone · 13/11/2026 21:52

caprioska · 13/11/2026 21:16

The logical flaw here is averages say nothing about individuals nor does it say anything about how grading in sports works to mitigate physical advantages & risks that also occurs within a sex.

If any of this were a real problem mixed teams would cease to exist in practical reality but instead they continue to flourish for many reasons including a desire for parents to socialise their children with the opposite sex that's ironically completely lost on gender critical 'feminists'.

Most sport played isn't at the elite level & isn't just about 'winning' but is motivated by character building, social & health reasons. Sport teaches children valuable psychological skills that translate to real world personal & social benefits in their day to day lives that a reductionist 'winning' approach ignores.

I do wonder if people actually have parental experience commenting on this forum.

Edited

Have you ever considered why we have single sex sports in the first place?

caprioska · 13/11/2026 21:55

GriseldaandMike · 13/11/2026 21:42

If not elite sports for women didn't exist elite women's sport wouldn't exist. Elite athletes start as non elite athletes. If girls and women know they can't win, they will not be safe and they could be sharing changing rooms/ showers with men then they won't do sport at grassroots levels.

And yet elite sports for women & men continues to flourish despite the existence of mixed teams. Why? Because talent isn't something that mixed sports conceals. In fact a lot of these social teams encourage participation that would have never have occurred otherwise.

The real barrier to participation in women's sport is poverty that gets conveniently ignored in the stampede to scapegoat trans people.

The idea that unfairness in women's sports is championed by wealthy middle class & above individuals like Riley Gaines who wouldn’t even rate as a high school athlete if not for income inequality is particularly rich.

caprioska · 13/11/2026 21:57

OldCrone · 13/11/2026 21:52

Have you ever considered why we have single sex sports in the first place?

That's irrelevant to the point of context.

GriseldaandMike · 13/11/2026 22:02

caprioska · 13/11/2026 21:55

And yet elite sports for women & men continues to flourish despite the existence of mixed teams. Why? Because talent isn't something that mixed sports conceals. In fact a lot of these social teams encourage participation that would have never have occurred otherwise.

The real barrier to participation in women's sport is poverty that gets conveniently ignored in the stampede to scapegoat trans people.

The idea that unfairness in women's sports is championed by wealthy middle class & above individuals like Riley Gaines who wouldn’t even rate as a high school athlete if not for income inequality is particularly rich.

Bollocks apart from the last few years of madness meaning some men got to sneak into women's teams mixed teams aren't really a thing in most sport beyond early childhood because anyone with enough brain cells to huddle together for warmth knows that it is unsafe for women to play contact sports with men and that women are going to be the 'weak link' in mixed teams so they would just stuff them full of men anyway.

StealthTroublemaker · 13/11/2026 22:10

caprioska · 13/11/2026 21:57

That's irrelevant to the point of context.

I’ll just leave this here.l.

Cary Elwes GIF
caprioska · 13/11/2026 22:14

GriseldaandMike · 13/11/2026 22:02

Bollocks apart from the last few years of madness meaning some men got to sneak into women's teams mixed teams aren't really a thing in most sport beyond early childhood because anyone with enough brain cells to huddle together for warmth knows that it is unsafe for women to play contact sports with men and that women are going to be the 'weak link' in mixed teams so they would just stuff them full of men anyway.

You'e the one that implied mixed teams prevented women from competing in elite sports & now they aren't a "thing"? Make up your mind.

In any case the point is in some contexts sex is irrelevant to sport & other shared spaces.

StealthTroublemaker · 13/11/2026 22:20

caprioska · 13/11/2026 22:14

You'e the one that implied mixed teams prevented women from competing in elite sports & now they aren't a "thing"? Make up your mind.

In any case the point is in some contexts sex is irrelevant to sport & other shared spaces.

Well yes, show jumping, totally can be mixed sex. And cafes, totally mixed sex. Libraries, deffo mixed sex. Toilets changing rooms, hospital wards, boxing, running swimming etc, single sex. Sorted.

JanesLittleGirl · 13/11/2026 22:21

caprioska · 13/11/2026 21:35

Perhaps if you followed the thread you would comprehend the example of children in sport was to illustrate how context & trade offs matter in balancing rights that sex isn't necessarily relevant to.

Your comments are not reflective of the reality of amateur competitive sport.

As I said most sport played particularly by children isn't at the elite level or for purely competitive reasons & is motivated by the benefits of participation. Context matters!

Have you never met any boys aged over about 7 years old? Boys play sports to test themselves against their peers. They will move heaven and earth to win because that is the only thing that matters to them. They aren't interested in taking part, they are exclusively interested in winning.

I was a cox for a male rowing crew at uni. While I gave them a 2 stone advantage over a male cox, I was only accepted because I contributed to their wins by being as good a cox as they were rowers and used every trick in the book to get us over the line first.

RapidOnsetGenderCritic · 13/11/2026 22:21

BackToLurk · 12/11/2026 07:59

Using their correct name and pronouns isn’t enough though, is it? Everyone else is also expected to believe.

This is a point at which a religion can become abusive – when you are not permitted to express even any doubt.

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 13/11/2026 22:22

caprioska · 13/11/2026 21:35

Perhaps if you followed the thread you would comprehend the example of children in sport was to illustrate how context & trade offs matter in balancing rights that sex isn't necessarily relevant to.

Your comments are not reflective of the reality of amateur competitive sport.

As I said most sport played particularly by children isn't at the elite level or for purely competitive reasons & is motivated by the benefits of participation. Context matters!

Only you would claim that the common sense view that it's OK for six year olds to play mixed-sex futsal was some kind of "nuance" and try to claim rhetorical victory on that basis.

When we are talking about single-sex spaces in wider society, the "nuance" looks like "it's OK to share an office with men, but not a toilet or shower". Again, this is common sense.

Either it's OK for a space to be mixed-sex, or it's not. The reasons for saying "it's not" are simple and well-understood, and rooted in the knowledge of who can become pregnant and who can make others pregnant.

Likewise for sports, it's about how the impregnator class in aggregate are stronger than the impregnable class, taller, and heavier.

Segregation to protect women must be by sex, or it fails to work.

Myalternate · 13/11/2026 22:22

How does it feel to be Gender Critical?

Bloody marvellous 😇

GriseldaandMike · 13/11/2026 22:23

caprioska · 13/11/2026 22:14

You'e the one that implied mixed teams prevented women from competing in elite sports & now they aren't a "thing"? Make up your mind.

In any case the point is in some contexts sex is irrelevant to sport & other shared spaces.

No, I said letting men identify into women's sport would have a huge negative impact on women's sport (because it wouldn't be for women anymore).

caprioska · 13/11/2026 22:30

GriseldaandMike · 13/11/2026 22:23

No, I said letting men identify into women's sport would have a huge negative impact on women's sport (because it wouldn't be for women anymore).

"If not elite sports for women didn't exist elite women's sport wouldn't exist. Elite athletes start as non elite athletes. If girls and women know they can't win, they will not be safe and they could be sharing changing rooms/ showers with men then they won't do sport at grassroots levels."

This is your response to children in mixed teams that has no impact on elite sports so stop changing the subject to men's access.

In any case, history shows a minority group like trans women has no meaningful impact on the growth of women's elite sports for obvious reasons.

StealthTroublemaker · 13/11/2026 22:31

caprioska · 13/11/2026 22:30

"If not elite sports for women didn't exist elite women's sport wouldn't exist. Elite athletes start as non elite athletes. If girls and women know they can't win, they will not be safe and they could be sharing changing rooms/ showers with men then they won't do sport at grassroots levels."

This is your response to children in mixed teams that has no impact on elite sports so stop changing the subject to men's access.

In any case, history shows a minority group like trans women has no meaningful impact on the growth of women's elite sports for obvious reasons.

What obvious reasons would they be? Why are you so keen to make all sports mixed sex?

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 13/11/2026 22:32

caprioska · 13/11/2026 22:14

You'e the one that implied mixed teams prevented women from competing in elite sports & now they aren't a "thing"? Make up your mind.

In any case the point is in some contexts sex is irrelevant to sport & other shared spaces.

in some contexts sex is irrelevant

No one claimed it wasn't.

implied

Not stated. And not even implied excepy by creative and wilful misreading.

You're strawmanning.

Captain Obvious Thank You GIF
lcakethereforeIam · 13/11/2026 22:32

Remember the mixed sex rowing teams in the US? The female places had to be taken by actual woman. All other women's sports at the time were fair game for trans identifying men though, just not where men might be disadvantaged.

TheHereticalOne · 13/11/2026 22:32

Being gender critical feels like a fierce tug of war between

"I must not be so arrogant as to dismiss my opponent out of hand. Focus and really listen to this new proponent and try to sincerely understand where they are coming from."

and

"Is it an abuse of the finite time I have been granted on this earth to spend so much of it attempting to impose coherence of a fundamental lack of reasoning skills?"

caprioska · 13/11/2026 22:32

JanesLittleGirl · 13/11/2026 22:21

Have you never met any boys aged over about 7 years old? Boys play sports to test themselves against their peers. They will move heaven and earth to win because that is the only thing that matters to them. They aren't interested in taking part, they are exclusively interested in winning.

I was a cox for a male rowing crew at uni. While I gave them a 2 stone advantage over a male cox, I was only accepted because I contributed to their wins by being as good a cox as they were rowers and used every trick in the book to get us over the line first.

Direct from the 'inventors' of stereotype threat: Stereotypes r us.

😂

caprioska · 13/11/2026 22:33

StealthTroublemaker · 13/11/2026 22:31

What obvious reasons would they be? Why are you so keen to make all sports mixed sex?

Never said that.

Swipe left for the next trending thread